
Patients would rather see a GP than pharmacists and nurses, study finds
The review of 33 existing studies, from the University of Southampton, also found patients often like to choose a specific doctor to maintain continuity of care.
Trust and confidence decreased when patients wanted to see a GP but were directed to a nurse or other health worker instead, it added.
The study noted people also wanted easier ways to book GP appointments, clearer phone options, shorter recorded messages, and simple online routes with quick responses.
It comes after the Government published its 10-year health plan which intends to massively increase use of the NHS App, as well as recruit more GPs.
An improved app will give patients more control over booking, moving and cancelling appointments, as well as quicker access to medics and other forms of care.
The new study, published in the British Journal of General Practice, suggested confidence and trust scores appeared to be lower when people wanted a face-to-face appointment and received a call instead.
The public also wanted clear details on the roles of different NHS workers, it found.
Lead author Helen Atherton, professor of primary care research, said: 'Patients want a deeper connection with their doctor's practice, better communication, and the choice to see the right professional in the best way for them.
'The NHS needs to better understand what people want so it can shape its services to work for patients.
'Ignoring these fundamental needs will only exacerbate the issues it currently faces.'
Writing in the journal, Prof Atherton and colleagues added: 'Patients wanted a nearby practice, with clean waiting rooms, easy appointment booking using simple systems and with short waiting times, and to be kept informed about the process.'
In particular, researchers found that, for medication reviews and long-term conditions, patients preferred seeing someone they were familiar with.
The research also suggested that, where a patient's condition was worsening, 69.5% of patients reported preferring to consult a GP than a pharmacist and 42.7% strongly agreed or agreed that they would prefer to consult with a GP rather than a pharmacist.
Professor Kamila Hawthorne, chair of the Royal College of GPs, said: 'It's really encouraging to see how much patients value the care, and continuity of care, their GP provides – there are some things that only a GP can do for their patients, but it's also important that patients don't feel somehow short-changed if they're offered an appointment with another member of our highly-skilled multi-disciplinary team.
'Not all patients need to see a GP. Procedures such as blood tests, routine management of non-complex long-term conditions, the monitoring of repeat prescriptions, or assessment of a painful joint, for example, can be carried out by some of the various other members of the team who now work in general practice, such as nursing staff, mental health professionals, clinical pharmacists and physiotherapists.
'This also alleviates workload on GPs, allowing us to spend time with those patients with complex health needs who really do need our expert medical attention.
'However, we know that even when working as part of multi-disciplinary teams, patients often struggle to access their GP when they need to – and we share their frustrations.
A GP writes a prescription in his practice room at the Temple Fortune Health Centre GP Practice near Golders Green, London (Anthony Devlin/PA)
'This is due to decades of under-funding of general practice and poor workforce planning, which has meant patient need for our care has escalated in recent years, while GP numbers have sadly not risen in step.
'We need thousands more GPs, and the recently published 10-Year health plan commits to providing these.
'We're now looking ahead to the revised long-term workforce plan, due later this year, to see how the Government plans to recruit more GPs and keep more GPs in the profession for longer – but also address some of the nonsensical issues GPs are reporting that they can't find appropriate employment upon qualification.'
Henry Gregg, chief executive of the National Pharmacy Association, said: 'It's not surprising that people want to see a GP when they go to a GP surgery but all our research and experience shows that people are very happy to visit a pharmacy if they can access treatment or advice quickly without having to wait to see a GP.
'Pharmacists are highly trained medical professionals who offer first-class care for a range of ailments quickly and conveniently and will send patients to a GP or hospital if needs be.
'Increasingly people will be able to pop into a community pharmacy and see a highly qualitied pharmacist for things like screening, check-ups, HRT, weight management or ongoing care without lengthy waits, freeing their NHS colleagues in hospitals and GPs to do more and offering patients the choice and convenience we all want to see.'
Royal College of Nursing chief nursing officer, Lynn Woolsey, said: 'Nursing staff are an integral part of any general practice delivering a range of services to patients.
'They lead public health clinics, run screening and vaccination programmes, support patients in the management of chronic disease and can diagnose and prescribe.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


North Wales Chronicle
13 minutes ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Half of Britons oppose fining supermarkets failing healthy food targets
Under a new Government plan to tackle obesity, announced last week, supermarkets could be fined if they do not sell healthier food. But a poll taken by YouGov following the announcement found the public seems not to support the move, with 52% of Britons saying they oppose fining supermarkets for not hitting Government targets to buy healthier food. One third (32%) are in favour of the plan. Conservative and Reform voters are particularly opposed to the idea, the poll suggests, with 68% and 71% respectively saying they are either 'somewhat' or 'strongly' against it, while 44% of Labour voters and 45% of Lib Dem voters are also against it. The 'healthy food standard' will apply to retailers and manufacturers in England as part of a 10-year strategy to cut diet-related diseases, the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) said. Initially developed by innovation agency Nesta, the policy introduces mandatory health targets for retailers while giving them flexibility in how to meet them, such as by tweaking recipes, running price promotions on healthier items, or redesigning store layouts. Supermarkets will be required to report sales data and those that fail to hit targets could face financial penalties, Nesta suggested. Nesta analysed 36 million supermarket transactions, finding an average shopping basket health score of 67 out of 100, and has set a target to raise this to 69. Its modelling shows that raising the score by just two points would cut obesity by around a fifth over three years, helping more than three million people to achieve a healthier weight. Announcing the policy, Health Secretary Wes Streeting said: 'If everyone who is overweight reduced their calorie intake by around 200 calories a day – the equivalent of a bottle of fizzy drink – obesity would be halved. 'This Government's ambition for kids today is for them to be part of the healthiest generation of children ever. That is within our grasp. With the smart steps we're taking today, we can give every child a healthy start to life. 'Our brilliant supermarkets already do so much work for our communities and are trying to make their stores healthier, and we want to work with them and other businesses to create a level playing field. 'Through our new healthy food standard, we will make the healthy choice the easy choice, because prevention is better than cure.' The Government aims to introduce mandatory reporting by the end of this parliament in 2029, with the standard to be achieved some way into the next. Ken Murphy, chief executive of Tesco, welcomed the announcement, while Simon Roberts, chief executive of Sainsbury's, called it an 'important and positive step forward in helping the nation to eat well'. YouGov surveyed 5,742 adults in Great Britain on July 4.


BBC News
31 minutes ago
- BBC News
Report highlights failings in Torbay SEND provision
An Ofsted inspection into special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) in Torbay has found widespread failings which should be addressed services are commissioned by the Torbay Local Area Partnership, made up of Torbay Council and NHS Devon Integrated Care report found too many children and young people with SEND waited an unacceptable time to have their needs accurately identified, assessed and Council said it was trying to tackle the problem with a pilot locality model which it hoped would see children receiving SEND provision sooner. Ofsted said that, since its last inspection in 2021, many long-standing issues had remained included waiting times for assessment and diagnosis, and the high proportion of children and young people with SEND being excluded from school. It said too many children and young people with SEND in Torbay had poor experiences due to lack of access to the right provision and support. Tommy, 7, who has autism, was receiving one-to-one support in school. His mother Rachel said this was withdrawn at the start of the latest academic year so she wais now forced to educate him at said: "We've gone from a situation in just a couple of weeks, really, where he was thriving, hitting all of his targets in excess actually, doing brilliantly and suddenly he's had to come out because he can't cope with just day-to-day aspects of the school life. "It's meant that our household has been turned upside down." The partnership said it was trying to tackle the problem by introducing a pilot scheme call a locality model which meant children received SEND provision, earlier in the Bye, lead member for children's services at Torbay Council, said he planned to visit South Gloucestershire which ran a similar said: "Schools [there] have access to support for children, or more support for children with special educational needs, particularly behavioural issues, particularly with speech, language and communication, right at the basics." "They don't need then to rely on getting an EHCP (Education, Health and Care Plan) or the fight that sometimes there seems to be over getting an EHCP and the delays." In a joint statement, Torbay Council and NHS Devon said: "We are committed to ongoing improvement across all SEND provision and will continue to work with parents, carers and practitioners to develop and strengthen it"


The Herald Scotland
36 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Half of Britons oppose fining supermarkets failing healthy food targets
But a poll taken by YouGov following the announcement found the public seems not to support the move, with 52% of Britons saying they oppose fining supermarkets for not hitting Government targets to buy healthier food. One third (32%) are in favour of the plan. Source: YouGov Conservative and Reform voters are particularly opposed to the idea, the poll suggests, with 68% and 71% respectively saying they are either 'somewhat' or 'strongly' against it, while 44% of Labour voters and 45% of Lib Dem voters are also against it. The 'healthy food standard' will apply to retailers and manufacturers in England as part of a 10-year strategy to cut diet-related diseases, the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) said. Initially developed by innovation agency Nesta, the policy introduces mandatory health targets for retailers while giving them flexibility in how to meet them, such as by tweaking recipes, running price promotions on healthier items, or redesigning store layouts. Supermarkets will be required to report sales data and those that fail to hit targets could face financial penalties, Nesta suggested. Health Secretary Wes Streeting said the Government's aim was for children today to be part of the healthiest generation of youngsters ever (Lucy North/PA) Nesta analysed 36 million supermarket transactions, finding an average shopping basket health score of 67 out of 100, and has set a target to raise this to 69. Its modelling shows that raising the score by just two points would cut obesity by around a fifth over three years, helping more than three million people to achieve a healthier weight. Announcing the policy, Health Secretary Wes Streeting said: 'If everyone who is overweight reduced their calorie intake by around 200 calories a day – the equivalent of a bottle of fizzy drink – obesity would be halved. 'This Government's ambition for kids today is for them to be part of the healthiest generation of children ever. That is within our grasp. With the smart steps we're taking today, we can give every child a healthy start to life. 'Our brilliant supermarkets already do so much work for our communities and are trying to make their stores healthier, and we want to work with them and other businesses to create a level playing field. 'Through our new healthy food standard, we will make the healthy choice the easy choice, because prevention is better than cure.' The Government aims to introduce mandatory reporting by the end of this parliament in 2029, with the standard to be achieved some way into the next. Ken Murphy, chief executive of Tesco, welcomed the announcement, while Simon Roberts, chief executive of Sainsbury's, called it an 'important and positive step forward in helping the nation to eat well'. YouGov surveyed 5,742 adults in Great Britain on July 4.