Fact Check: Old video of Tharoor bashing Trump goes viral as his delegation visits US
In the video, Tharoor says that while he 'shouldn't be commenting on political leaders in foreign countries on their soil', his personal manner struck him as 'not entirely as agreeable or pleasant as one would like to see in a distinguished American political figure'. He says that he had met four or five US presidents — from both parties there — who had a certain 'political heft, statesman-like gravitas, and intellectual quality that I find woefully lacking in this gentleman'. India Today Fact Check found that while Tharoor was indeed talking about Trump, this video is from September 2024, when the MP was speaking at the Jaipur Literature Festival in New York.Our ProbeReverse-searching frames from the video led us to an Instagram post dated September 24, 2024. This makes it clear that this video long predates the all-party delegation visiting the Americas right now. advertisement View this post on Instagram A post shared by Asia Society Museum (@asiasociety)We then found the full talk on the YouTube channel of the Asia Society, an American organisation that focusses on educating the world about Asia. The video's description noted that this talk was from September 10, 2024, at the Jaipur Literature Festival in New York.It was also shared on the Asia Society's official website. At the event, India Today Group Chairman and Editor-in-Chief Aroon Purie spoke to Tharoor on various issues regarding Indian and American politics. The viral clip can be seen around the 12-minute-40-second mark, when Aroon Purie asks Shashi Tharoor, 'What do you think about Trump?' The day after the event, on September 11, 2024, the official accounts of the Jaipur Literature Festival, Asia Society, and Shashi Tharoor shared various photos from the talk on Instagram. View this post on Instagram A post shared by JLF International (@jlfinternational)It's noteworthy that at the time, the president of the US was Joe Biden.What did Tharoor say in the US now?On Saturday, May 24, Tharoor spoke at an interaction hosted by the Consulate General of India in New York for a select group of prominent members of the Indian-American community. There, he said that the time had come to set a "new bottom line" in India's dealings with Pakistan.advertisement"We have tried everything — international dossiers, complaints, everything has been tried," he said, adding that Pakistan had remained in denial, with "no convictions, no serious criminal prosecutions, and no genuine attempt to dismantle" its terror infrastructure.The full address can be seen below: Thus, it's clear that the viral clip of Shashi Tharoor taking a dig at Donald Trump is not recent and was made when Joe Biden was the US President.Must Watch
Want to send us something for verification? Please share it on our at 73 7000 7000 You can also send us an email at factcheck@intoday.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
3 minutes ago
- Mint
Japan Election: Severe blow to PM Shigeru Ishiba as ruling coalition loses upper house majority — what we know so far
Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba's future was unclear on Monday after his coalition lost its majority in the upper house in Sunday's elections, which saw strong gains by a right-wing populist party. It will mark the first time in the LDP's 70-year history that it leads a coalition that does not control either house, Japan's NHK media reported. Despite this, PM Ishiba indicated he intends to stay on in his role. Here's all you need to know about Japan Elections: As many as 248 members of the Upper House are elected for six-year terms. Elections are held every three years, with half of the seats up for grabs. This time, there are 124 seats plus one extra to fill a vacancy, Japanese media NHK reported. It said 75 seats will be decided based on electoral districts. The remaining 50 seats will be filled by people elected through proportional representation from across Japan. The ruling coalition needs a total of 125 seats for a majority. They already have 75 uncontested seats, but NHK projections suggest it may be difficult for the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) and Komeito to get the additional 50 needed. The cards are stacked against PM Ishiba, with all major opposition parties ruling out joining the Liberal Democratic Party and its partner Komeito in an expanded coalition. According to reports, Ishiba's LDP and coalition partner Komeito returned 47 seats, short of the 50 seats it needed to ensure a majority in the 248-seat upper chamber in an election. The main opposition Constitutional Democratic Party finished second with 22 seats. If the ruling bloc fails to get a majority, it would be the first time in the LDP's 70-year history for the party to lead a coalition that does not control either house of the Diet. The fringe far-right Sanseito party emerged as one of the biggest winners in Japan's upper house election on Sunday. It, however, won't join coalition for now. The party won 14 seats, up from one seat, giving it a significant presence in the upper house. It has only three seats in the more powerful lower house. "Sanseito has become the talk of the town, and particularly here in America, because of the whole populist and anti-foreign sentiment. It's more of a weakness of the LDP and Ishiba than anything else," said Joshua Walker, head of the U.S. non-profit Japan Society. Meanwhile, the leader of the opposition Sanseito party, Kamiya Sohei, said in an interview that he doesn't plan to join the ruling coalition at this point. He expressed concern that Sanseito's tiny size renders it liable to be crushed if it becomes part of the ruling bloc. The party broke into mainstream politics with its "Japanese First" campaign. It gained support with warnings of a "silent invasion" of immigrants, and pledges for tax cuts and welfare spending. It was born on YouTube in 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, spreading conspiracy theories about vaccinations and a cabal of global elites, Reuters reported. While the ballot does not directly determine whether Ishiba's minority government falls, it heaps pressure on the embattled leader, who also lost control of the more powerful lower house in October. That comes on top of its worst showing in 15 years in October's lower house election, a vote which has left Ishiba's administration vulnerable to no-confidence motions and calls from within his own party for leadership change. The result further weakens Ishiba's position just days before the country needs to negotiate a deal with the Trump administration to avert the imposition of punishing tariffs in its largest export market. If Ishiba goes, it was unclear who might step up as the LDP's 11th premier since 2000 now that the government needs opposition support in both chambers. 'Ishiba may be replaced by someone else, but it's not clear who will be the successor,' Hidehiro Yamamoto, politics and sociology professor at the University of Tsukuba, told Agence France-Presse. Speaking late on Sunday evening after exit polls closed, Ishiba told NHK he "solemnly" accepted the "harsh result". "We are engaged in extremely critical tariff negotiations with the United must never ruin these negotiations. It is only natural to devote our complete dedication and energy to realizing our national interests," he later told TV Tokyo. His statement came as Japan, the world's fourth largest economy, faces a deadline of August 1 to strike a trade deal with the US or face punishing tariffs in its largest export market. Asked whether he intended to stay on as prime minister and party leader, he said: 'That's right. It's a difficult situation, and we have to take it very humbly and seriously.' (With inputs from agencies)
News18
30 minutes ago
- News18
'He Is Not With Us': Congress Leader Over Shashi Tharoor's Stance On National Security
Last Updated: Senior Congress leader K Muraleedharan said that Shashi Tharoor will not be invited to any party events in Thiruvananthapuram unless he alters his stance on national security. Senior Congress leader K Muraleedharan has said his party colleague Shashi Tharoor will not be invited to any party programme in Thiruvananthapuram till he changes his stance on the national security issue. Muraleedharan's remark came as he responded to reporters on a question of Tharoor sticking to his stand on the issue of national security. A day earlier, Tharoor had said that the nation comes first and parties are the means of making the country better. Reacting to Tharoor's remark, Muraleedharan said that Tharoor, also a Congress Working Committee (CWC) member, was no longer considered as 'one of us". He added that the party's national leadership would decide what action would be required against the Congress MP. 'Till he (Tharoor) changes his stance, we will not invite him to any party programme held in Thiruvananthapuram. He is not with us, so there is no question of him boycotting an event," Muraleedharan said. Shashi Tharoor, was led one of the multi-party delegations to world capitals to put forth India's stance against terrorism, had said that a lot of people have been very critical of him because of his stand supporting the armed forces and the central government in connection with India's response to Pakistan in the form of 'Operation Sindoor'. 'But I will stand my ground, because I believe this is the right thing for the country," he had said at an event in Kochi on July 19. Tharoor had also said that when people like him call for cooperating with other parties in the interests of national security, their own parties feel that it's disloyal to them and that becomes a big problem. Earlier too, Muraleedharn had hit out at Tharoor over sharing of a survey suggesting he is United Democratic Front's most preferred choice for chief minister, saying 'he should first decide which party he belongs to". The senior Congress leader had also attacked Tharoor following his article criticising Indira Gandhi over the Emergency appearing in a Malayalam daily. Muraleedharan had urged the CWC member to choose a clear political path if he felt constrained within the Congress. view comments First Published: July 21, 2025, 07:01 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Time of India
31 minutes ago
- Time of India
We have especially identified 8 issues: Congress MP Pramod Tiwari ahead of Monsoon Session of Parliament
Congress MP Pramod Tiwari on Sunday gave an inside in the INDIA alliance meeting held on July 19, and said that the INDIA Alliance has finalised its strategy ahead of Monsoon Session of Parliament , which centres around the Pahalgam terror attack , Operation Sindoor , and statements made by US President Donald Trump . MP Tiwari, while talking to ANI, said, "Yesterday, a detailed discussion on formulating strategy for the upcoming session regarding the crisis in which the nation has been pushed into by the BJP-NDA Government . It was a joint effort held in a conducive environment. I am happy to tell you that keeping national interest as supreme, it has been decided against the BJP's activities that are weakening the country, its democracy and economy." Explore courses from Top Institutes in Select a Course Category Technology healthcare Artificial Intelligence Data Analytics Digital Marketing Data Science MCA Finance Public Policy Leadership Design Thinking CXO Product Management Data Science Operations Management Healthcare Degree Project Management Cybersecurity Management MBA PGDM Others others Skills you'll gain: Duration: 12 Weeks MIT xPRO CERT-MIT XPRO Building AI Prod India Starts on undefined Get Details MP Tiwari said that the US President Trump's statement about the five fighter jets being shot down is disturbing and added, "It has been decided to raise issues, the most important being the Pahalgam attack. To date, the traces of terrorists have not been found. Regarding Operation Sindoor, US President Donald Trump stated for the 24th time that he secured the ceasefire. A shocking statement was made that five fighter jets were shot down. The defence attache also said the same. CDS too said the same. This disturbs us." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Play War Thunder now for free War Thunder Play Now Undo He also mentioned that the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) happening in Bihar is killing democracy and said, "In Bihar, democracy is being murdered with SIR. The manner in which India has been isolated in its foreign policy is also an issue. Even now, heinous massacres are occurring - Israel is doing this in Gaza is also an issue. The issue is also about the oppression of SC, ST, women and minorities and crimes against them. We have especially identified 8 issues. We are confident that all 24 parties (in the INDIA Alliance) will support us; even the parties who are not a part of this will support us." The Monsoon Session of the Indian Parliament is scheduled to begin on July 21 and conclude on August 21. Live Events During the monsoon session of Parliament, the government plans to push its legislative agenda, which includes some new bills. The bills on the agenda of the government include Manipur Goods and Services Tax (Amendment) Bill of 2025, Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill of 2025, Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Bill 2025, the Indian Institutes of Management (Amendment) bill 2025, the Geoheritage Sites and Geo-relics (Preservation and Maintenance) bill 2025, the Mines and Mines (Development and Regulation) Amendment Bill 2025, the National Sports Governance Bill 2025 and the National Anti-Doping (Amendment) Bill 2025. The government's agenda also includes the Readjustment of Representation of Scheduled Tribes in Assembly Constituencies of the State of Goa Bill, 2024, the Merchant Shipping Bill, 2024, the Indian Ports Bill, 2025, and the Income Tax Bill, 2025. The monsoon session of Parliament will continue till August 21.
