Second inquest into mother's death after losing benefits hears of debt concerns
Jodey Whiting, 42, from Stockton-on-Tees, had been asked to attend a work capability assessment before her payments were stopped, but had not been well enough to attend, her mother told the Teesside Coroner.
Family members found her in her flat in February 2017 and an initial inquest recorded a conclusion of suicide but it did not consider the impact of the Department for Work and Pensions' (DWP) decision.
Her mother Joy Dove fought a long legal battle for a second inquest, going all the way to the Court of Appeal.
She told the hearing at Teesside Magistrates' Court how her daughter, who was a mother of nine including two sets of twins, suffered from a curvature of the spine and was later diagnosed with a brain cyst.
An Independent Case Examiner (ICE) report into the decision to remove Ms Whiting's benefits found that a number of mistakes had been made, and her payments should not have been withdrawn.
Extracts from notes found alongside prescription drugs in her flat were read in court.
Bridget Dolan KC, coroner's counsel, said: 'She wrote about not being able to pay her bills and having no food.
'In some she wrote about feeling breathless and having back pain and trying to pay her bills and being in debt.'
Another note stated: 'I have had enough.'
In a pen portrait, Ms Dove said: 'Her death really impacted on me, and to learn from the ICE reports of the number of failures by the DWP was to play was a further deep shock that I have not recovered from.'
Her father Eric Whiting said in his tribute in court, how she was like the 'Pied Piper' as she always had children around her who adored her.
He added: 'She always saw the fun side of life until her health issues started.'
Ms Whiting had suffered from chronic pain, was dependent on opiates and had long-standing mental issues, the inquest heard.
Her mother agreed that Ms Whiting, who had six grandchildren, became increasingly housebound in the last years of her life.
She had a hospital stay in December 2016 after contracting pneumonia and that meant she missed letters about her benefits, saying she needed to be medically assessed.
Ms Dove said she reassured her daughter that she would help, telling the inquest: 'I said, don't you worry, we will write in and we will explain how you have been in hospital and you are still convalescing.'
But in January 2017 Ms Whiting was told she had missed the medical assessment.
And the following month, her mother said Ms Whiting received another letter saying she was fit to work.
Ms Dove told the inquest her daughter told her she could not breathe or walk out of her flat.
Ms Whiting received another letter from the DWP telling her that her benefits were being stopped, including her housing benefit and council tax.
Ms Dove said when she saw her daughter, two days before her death, she was 'shaking and crying' and had threatened to kill herself.
Ms Dove said she was sure that the stress of losing her benefits was the trigger for her to decide to take her own life.
'I know my daughter and I know it was (that),' she told the inquest.
'It was the fact she couldn't find a job, the worry of paying bills and being pushed out after being so vulnerable all those years and years.'
Questioned by Jesse Nicholls, for the family, Ms Dove added: 'I know for a fact it was the DWP that caused it.
'She was quite happy for me to go through and look after her.
'There's no way it was anything other than that.'
Two photographs of Ms Whiting were placed on the coroner's bench at the start of the hearing.
The inquest continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
16 minutes ago
- The Independent
Jury out in Wagner Group arson trial
Jurors have retired in the trial of a group of men accused of setting fire to a warehouse linked with Ukraine for the proscribed Wagner Group. Around £1 million of damage was caused in an arson attack on an industrial unit in Leyton, east London, last March 20, the Old Bailey has heard. The building was targeted because it was being used by a firm sending humanitarian aid and StarLink satellite equipment to Ukraine, it is alleged. The attack was orchestrated by Dylan Earl, 20, and Jake Reeves, 23, who have admitted aggravated arson on behalf of the Wagner Group and an offence under the National Security Act, jurors heard. It is alleged that they recruited a group of men to carry out the attack as part of a series of planned missions for the terrorist group. Paul English, 61, allegedly drove to the warehouse in his Kia Picanto with Jakeem Rose, 23, Nii Mensah, 23, and Ugnius Asmena, 20. Mensah and Rose were captured on CCTV and livestreamed video as they set the warehouse on fire before they made off, it is claimed. Asmena and Rose, from Croydon; Mensah, of Thornton Heath, south London; and English, of Roehampton, south-west London, have denied aggravated arson relating to the warehouse fire. Earl, of Elmesthorpe, Leicestershire, and Reeves, of Croydon, have additionally admitted plots to set fire to the Hide Restaurant and Hedonism Wines in Mayfair, west London, and kidnapping their owner on behalf of the Wagner Group, the court heard. Two other defendants, Ashton Evans, 20, from Newport, Gwent, and Dmirjus Paulauskas, 23, from Croydon, are each charged with two counts of failing to disclose information about terrorist acts, which they deny. At 3.30pm on Tuesday, Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb sent jurors out to start deliberating on verdicts.
The Independent
16 minutes ago
- The Independent
Children pay tribute to ‘devoted' mother killed in alleged assault
The children of a 'devoted' mother who died after she was allegedly attacked by a driver whose car overturned have paid tribute to her as 'a beautiful, vibrant soul'. Nila Patel, 56, died in hospital on June 26 following an incident in which she was injured in Aylestone Road, Leicester, two days earlier. Leicestershire Police said it received a call shortly after 5.30pm reporting that a white BMW 1 series had crashed near to the Voco hotel and Leicester Royal Infirmary on June 24 before the assault allegedly took place. Police said the provisional cause of Ms Patel's death has been given as a head injury. Ms Patel's son Jaidan Patel and her daughter Danika Patel released a tribute to their mother through police on Tuesday and said: 'We are heartbroken, but we want the world to know who our mum truly was – a beautiful, vibrant soul who deserved so much more. 'She was a devoted mother, a loyal friend, and an incredibly hard worker. 'At home and in her career, she gave everything she had – never complaining, always giving. 'She raised us with patience, love, and unwavering support, and our greatest wish was always to make her proud. 'We will miss her more than words can ever express. 'We didn't get the chance to say goodbye, and that pain is something we carry every day. But we will continue to speak her name with pride, honour her memory, and live by the values she taught us. 'Mum's story matters. Her life mattered. We ask that anyone who hears her story helps us keep her name and memory alive.' Police said 23-year-old Michael Chuwuemeka, of Dover Street, Leicester, has been charged with her murder and appeared via video-link at Leicester Crown Court, sitting in Loughborough, on Tuesday. The force said Chuwuemeka has also been charged with dangerous driving, possession with intent to supply class B drugs, attempted grievous bodily harm relating to an incident on Welford Road prior to the collision and assault of an emergency worker following an alleged assault on a police officer after his arrest. He has also been charged with causing actual bodily harm in connection with a separate victim in London in the early hours of June 24, police said.
The Independent
16 minutes ago
- The Independent
Man ‘dismembered couple, left some remains in freezer and took rest to bridge'
A man 'decapitated and dismembered' two men and left their heads in a freezer before travelling to the Clifton Suspension Bridge with other parts of their bodies, a court heard. Yostin Andres Mosquera, 35, is on trial for the murders of Albert Alfonso, 62, and Paul Longworth, 71, on July 8 last year in the flat the two shared in Scotts Road, Shepherd's Bush, west London. Mosquera is alleged to have repeatedly stabbed Mr Alfonso, who suffered injuries to his torso, face and neck, while Mr Longworth was attacked with a hammer to the back of his head and his 'skull shattered', Deanna Heer KC, prosecuting, told jurors at Woolwich Crown Court on Tuesday. Two days later, at about 11.30pm, a cyclist on Clifton Suspension Bridge in Bristol saw the defendant standing next to a 'large red suitcase', and thought he was a tourist so stopped to see if he was ok, and a few metres away from the defendant was a silver trunk, Ms Heer added. The defendant told the cyclist he was from Colombia and that the suitcases contained car parts. 'That was a lie,' Ms Heer said. 'In fact the suitcases contained the decapitated and dismembered bodies of Paul Longworth and Albert Alfonso, which the defendant had taken to Bristol from their home in London where they had been killed two days before.' Mr Alfonso and Mr Longworth's decapitated heads were found by police in a chest freezer in their flat, the court heard. Mosquera has admitted that he killed Mr Alfonso, and Ms Heer added 'the killing took place while he and Mr Alfonso were having sex and the sex and the killing were recorded on film'. Mosquera has admitted the manslaughter of Mr Alfonso, but denies both charges of murder, the jury was told. The defendant denies that he killed Mr Longworth at all, he blames Mr Alfonso for the killing of Mr Longworth, Ms Heer said. Ms Heer said: 'The prosecution case is that the defendant murdered both men, intending to kill them, and that his actions were planned, they were premeditated, and having killed them, the evidence demonstrates the defendant attempted to steal from them.' At the time of their deaths, Mr Alfonso and Mr Longworth lived together. Mr Alfonso worked as a swimming instructor at a gym and Mr Longworth was retired, used to work as a handyman and was a regular customer at his local pub, the prosecution said. Mr Alfonso 'liked extreme sex' which he videoed and posted online, she added. Jurors were told they will hear from a witness called James Smith, which is a pseudonym, who had known Mr Alfonso and Mr Longworth for about 18 years and by the time that they died he 'considered them to be close friends'. He regularly engaged in acts of sexual domination with Mr Alfonso for which he was paid and some of the encounters were posted online, Ms Heer said. Mr Smith's description of his early relationship is 'undoubtedly troubling', Ms Heer said, adding Mr Smith 'recalls getting drunk with Mr Alfonso only to be told the following morning that they had sex and Mr Alfonso had filmed it'. She said Mr Alfonso said he would not show anyone else as long as he agreed to do him sexual favours and Mr Smith agreed, then told Mr Alfonso in due course he was not into the sex so Mr Alfonso told him about sexual domination and Mr Smith agreed. Over time both Mr Alfonso and Mr Longworth became in Mr Smith's own description 'like family to him' and would spend time together doing other things, Ms Heer said. Mr Longworth had 'nothing to do with that side of Albert Alfonso's life, although he knew about it and, it seems, that he accepted it', the prosecution said. Mosquera is a Colombian national who was visiting Mr Alfonso at the time of the killings, and Ms Heer described the defendant as a 'pornographic performer'. James Smith was introduced to the defendant in October 2023 while the defendant was visiting Mr Alfonso and the UK. Mr Alfonso invited Mr Smith to join in one of the sex sessions between him and the defendant and Mr Smith agreed, the court heard. According to Mr Smith, the defendant 'seemed friendly' and told him that 'like him, he was also doing it for the money', the prosecution said. On July 8 last year, Mr Alfonso worked an early shift at the gym and it was while he was out that the prosecution say the defendant killed Mr Longworth, the court heard. The defendant brought a laptop with him when he came to the UK which was seized and examined by digital forensic specialists and they found the laptop has a fault in the way that it records time, Ms Heer said. The defendant allegedly accessed Facebook Marketplace 'looking for a freezer' and Google and Youtube searches were also conducted on the laptop in Spanish, which is the defendant's first language, using search terms such as 'where on the head is a knock fatal', the prosecution said. Mr Alfonso was killed at about 10.15pm in his own bedroom, the court heard. The footage shows the defendant ended the sexual encounter by 'repeatedly stabbing' Mr Alfonso and 'cutting his throat'. At one point, with Mr Alfonso facing away from him, the defendant 'pulls Mr Alfonso's head back by the chin, with the other hand picks up the knife and 'inserts it quite deliberately and quite precisely into Mr Alfonso's neck', then Mr Alfonso 'begins to struggle, but the defendant, younger, fitter and stronger, managed to overpower him and repeatedly stab him' and at one point asks 'do you like it', Ms Heer said. Ms Heer said: 'What is striking, the prosecution say, when you watch the footage, is just how calm and in control the defendant remains throughout. 'Indeed so unconcerned does he appear by what he's just done that as Mr Alfonso lies on the floor dead or dying the defendant starts to sing to himself and break into a dance at one point.' The jury was then shown clips of the video. The defendant then started using Mr Alfonso's computer and examination of the computer shows the defendant looking at banking information relating to Mr Alfonso and Mr Longworth before compiling a PowerPoint document of that information, the jury heard. The defendant tried to send £4,000 to his own account in Colombia, before going to a cashpoint and withdrawing money, Ms Heer said. Having allegedly killed Mr Alfonso and Mr Longworth, the prosecution said the defendant set about 'dismembering them' before 'transferring some of their remains to Bristol in an attempt, the prosecution say, to dispose of them at the Clifton Suspension Bridge'. On July 10 the defendant was driven to Bristol and was on the bridge when bridge staff 'noticed something appeared to be leaking from the red suitcase' and the defendant said it was oil, the staff shone their torches on the suitcases and the defendant began to walk away, saying he was going to get the other suitcase, but walked past it then broke into a run, the court heard. The defendant was arrested on July 13 at about 2.15am after being found sitting on a bench outside Bristol Temple Meads railway station, the jury was told. The defendant's case in relation to Mr Alfonso is he 'lost his self-control' in a way that 'reduces his responsibility from murder to a lesser offence of manslaughter'. The trial continues.
