Denis O'Brien says it is time to question ‘conduct' of corporate enforcement chief
Denis O'Brien
has criticised the State's business law watchdog over the years-long
Independent News & Media
(INM) investigation, saying the time had come to question the 'role and conduct' of
Corporate Enforcement Authority
(CEA) chief executive
Ian Drennan
.
Mr O'Brien was INM's main shareholder when it was rocked by turmoil over an unlawful breach of company data relating to 19 named individuals, among them journalists and former company officials, some of whom had come into conflict with him.
The disruption in INM, Ireland's largest newspaper business, led to its sale in 2019 to Belgian group Mediahuis. That deal crystallised a loss exceeding €450 million for Mr O'Brien on his INM investment.
Mr Drennan ran the CEA's predecessor, the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, when it asked the High Court in 2018 to send inspectors into the company.
READ MORE
In a statement, Mr O'Brien said: 'Mr Drennan's failure to engage in due process and interview all relevant parties before heading to the High Court in 2018 in undue and irrational haste calls into question his continued suitability for the position.
'Mr Drennan's conduct showed little respect for due process, proper procedures or basic objectivity. As a result, he inflicted and facilitated very significant reputational damage for several individuals over six years.'
[
Leslie Buckley questions way that corporate enforcer investigated INM saga
Opens in new window
]
Minister for Enterprise
Peter Burke
, who has political responsibility for the CEA, had no comment on Mr O'Brien's remarks, citing CEA independence of the Government in its work.
Asked whether Mr Burke had confidence in Mr Drennan, his department said: 'Yes. The Minister has confidence in Ian Drennan as the sole appointed member of the CEA.'
Mr O'Brien was responding to the CEA decision not to take enforcement action over the data breach. The decision was set out on Thursday in its 2024 annual report.
How the wealthy are buying up land to avoid inheritance tax
Listen |
22:03
That followed on from a report 12 months ago by court inspectors who found after a six-year investigation that INM affairs were not conducted in breach of the Companies Acts.
Still, inspectors Seán Gillane SC and UK solicitor Richard Fleck reported 'technical' breaches of the Data Protection Acts.
They also found inside information was disclosed to Mr O'Brien by Leslie Buckley, the long-time ally who represented his interests as INM chairman.
Mr O'Brien said: 'Mr Drennan took a deliberate decision not to engage with or interview several parties, including myself, who could have provided him with answers to his questions and saved the State and other parties in excess of €40 million.
'His failure to make any reference to this element of the debacle in the annual report speaks for itself.'
There was no response from Mr Drennan's office to Mr O'Brien's statement by the close of business on Friday evening.
Mr Buckley, the former INM chairman, had criticised Mr Drennan in similar terms on Thursday.
Responding on Friday to Mr Buckley, the CEA said: 'As detailed in the annual report, the application to the High Court in this case followed a lengthy investigation and, despite being robustly resisted by the company, satisfied the High Court that the evidential threshold necessary to warrant the appointment of court-appointed inspectors had been fully met and the court's jurisdiction engaged.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Joe Duffy rules himself out of presidential race
Recently retired RTÉ broadcaster Joe Duffy has said he will not be seeking a nomination to run in the forthcoming presidential election . In a post to his X account on Saturday afternoon, Mr Duffy 'wanted to make it absolutely clear' that he was 'not seeking a nomination from any politicians, local or national, for the office of @PresidentIRL'. The move followed speculation that the popular media personality might join the race following his departure from the national airwaves last month. The former Liveline host signed off his post by saying, 'I will not be adding anything further,' and tagging the main news agencies, including The Irish Times, which ran a story on Saturday speculating as to his potential participation, among others. READ MORE President Michael D Higgins will leave office on November 8th, 2025, and the election to replace him is expected to take place in late October. While no political party or group has formally selected a candidate, former EU commissioner Mairéad McGuinness and sitting MEP Seán Kelly are expected to seek nominations from Fine Gael. Taoiseach Micheál Martin has not said whether Fianna Fáil will select someone to run for the role, while the Social Democrats and People Before Profit-Solidarity have both spoken in favour of supporting a united left-wing candidate. [ Race for the Áras: Mike Ryan and Bertie Ahern among names circulating but parties wary of 'knee-jerk' selection Opens in new window ] In order to run for president in Ireland, a candidate must be an Irish citizen aged 35 or older. They must receive the support of at least 20 members of the Oireachtas or the backing of at least four local authorities. So far, lawyer Nick Delehanty; MMA fighter Conor McGregor, businessman Peter Casey; former junior minister Peter Power; MEP Seán Kelly; MEP Mairéad McGuinness; and former minister Mary Hanafin have indicated they intend to run.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Our cities are dying': Large turnout at Dublin housing demonstration
Large crowds gathered outside the Garden of Remembrance in Dublin city on Saturday afternoon as part of an all-island housing demonstration urging the Government to act on the crisis . Led by the Community Action Tenants Union (CATU), and backed by more than 80 other trade unions and organisations, protesters marched through the city centre towards Molesworth Street. Oisín Doyle (28) and Cian Lawler (25) – who both live at home with their parents – travelled from Co Carlow to take part. Reflecting on the difference between his own housing situation and that of his parents' generation, Mr Doyle said he 'would like to get back to a place where we can prioritise housing as a basic need and right for people and not something that's just for the rich'. READ MORE Catherine Dineen (25), Cian Lawler (25) and Oisin Doyle (28) attended Saturday's demonstration on housing in Dublin 'I was living up in Dublin with a friend for a while but had to move back because the rent was too expensive. My dad was a civil servant and owned a home at the age of 23 in Dublin. It was just a completely different world.' For Mr Lawler, owning a home in the future 'seems completely inaccessible'. 'I think it's disgraceful that we're viewed as a progressive and rich country but we have so many families homeless, so many people in direct provision, people in asylum that come here for a better life and are forced into these dire situations,' he said. 'All these vulture funds are allowed to come into this country and suck the life out of it. Our cities are dying.' Clare Fortune and Carmel Lyons at the protest. Photograph: PA Catherine Dineen (25) has been renting for the past seven years. 'It takes up more than half of my income every month and it's quite depressing to face into the future knowing that I probably won't be able to afford a house unless I work a corporate job that I don't really like,' she said. Traveller advocacy group Pavee Point was one of the organisations represented at Saturday's protest. Director Martin Collins describes Ireland's housing issues as 'a humanitarian crisis'. Participants in Saturday's housing protest in Dublin. Photograph: PA 'For the Traveller community, we've always had an accommodation crisis. We've been let down by this State over many, many decades. We are disproportionately represented in the homeless numbers.' Mr Collins said racism towards Travellers and Roma people poses an additional challenge in the search for housing. 'Many private landlords are not renting out to Travellers and Roma so the private sector is not even an option for us. The strategy and the response has to be more social and public housing. The Government and successive governments have failed in this regard.' [ Where will vital student housing come from? Opens in new window ] Stephen Curran (32), a member of CATU's housing demonstration subcommittee and communications officer for one of its north Dublin branches, grew up living in social housing in the suburb of Coolock. Now renting in Phibsborough, he said the housing crisis has 'forced people like myself into the private market'. 'The place I was renting when I was in college was about a quarter the cost of what I have now. The standard was so much better,' he said. 'Communities are developed when people can go somewhere and put roots down and that's why we need an eviction bam. That's why we need rents to be affordable.' Speakers from CATU's national branches emphasised what they see as the interconnectedness of social issues such as the housing crisis, discrimination against migrants and economic inequality.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Dark Laboratory: On Columbus, the Caribbean, and the Origins of the Climate Crisis – a trenchant account of colonialism
Dark Laboratory: On Columbus, The Caribbean and the Origins of the Climate Crisis Author : Tao Leigh Goffe ISBN-13 : 978-0-241-62855-3 Publisher : Hamish Hamilton Guideline Price : £22 Montserrat is the only country aside from Ireland to celebrate St Patrick's Day as a public holiday. It's not just a chance to go on the beer but recalls the African rebellion against Irish slavers which took place in 1768. The rebels deliberately chose the date for the uprising, knowing that the Irish overseers and planters would be getting drunk at Government House. Tao Leigh Goffe recounts this and many other stories of black and indigenous resistance to Caribbean slavery in this trenchant account of Caribbean colonialism. Goffe contends that race, labour and colonialism are absent from environmentalist debates and suggests the arrival of Christopher Columbus in the Caribbean in 1492 is not only the 'ground zero of colonial conquest', but the starting point for the modern-day climate crisis. Along the way, the author takes a deserved swipe at western multinationals operating in the Caribbean for damage wrought on black and indigenous communities in places such as Jamaica – while strangely defending Chinese companies for the same sins – arguing that it is the 'global majority' who must lead the ecological conversation. Only by interrogating the history of western scientific and anthropological inquiry in the region, Goffe adds, will a solution be found to the climate crisis. This leads her to decry archival research – European archives and natural history museums are described as 'evidence lockers full of crimes against humanity' and 'death cults of colonial worship'. READ MORE Goffe unashamedly argues from a subjective standpoint, drawing much on her own family's fascinating history, one which embraces not only the Caribbean, but also China, Hong Kong, Britain and the United States. This could have been the starting point of a more nuanced journey through those regions most affected by the climate crisis and an objective analysis of the environmental destruction wrought by European colonialism in the Americas. [ From the archive: Meeting islanders with Irish ancestry on Montserrat Opens in new window ] Instead, while positing interesting ideas about the impact of colonial thinking on the Caribbean environment, Goffe often fails to support them, preferring to spend time on academic bunfights. Archival research may be 'cold, unethical and extractive' but it's also how one finds the bodies.
