Why Used Tacoma Retains More Value Than a BMW
Over the past decade, detailed resale analyses from CarEdge and iSeeCars have peeled back the myths around depreciation, revealing a clear pattern: the models topping the charts aren't flashy coupes or high-tech sedans, but rugged trucks and SUVs built to last. These vehicles, backed by high-volume dealer and fleet demand, straightforward mechanical layouts and proven longevity, regularly return well over 60% of their original MSRP after five years. Below is the verified lineup of the best performers in five-year value retention.
All of these models substantially outperform the industry average (the blue line), which stands at 54.4% retention after five years. This means that, on average, flipping that on its head, the average new vehicle loses about 45.6% of its value in the same period.
Not all trucks and SUVs stand out for retaining their value. For example, while the Jeep Wrangler is often praised for holding its value, recent data is inconsistent: some sources report a 5-year depreciation as low as 10%, but others find it loses up to 55% of its value over five years, making its performance highly variable depending on model and market. Similarly, the Ford F-150, despite being America's best-selling truck, depreciates more than the segment average, with a typical 5-year depreciation of about 46.5% - leaving it below many of its competitors in terms of resale value. This underscores that popularity and high sales don't always translate into the best long-term value retention.
For context, the BMW 3 Series - a popular luxury sedan - retains only 48.6% of its value after five years, falling below the industry average. Mercedes? Brand average 50.7%. Cadillac? Brand average 48.9%. This highlights the exceptional performance of the top trucks and SUVs, which not only beat the average but also demonstrate the resilience of certain segments against depreciation.
Doing a deep dive into why this is so, why do these 5 trucks hold their value far better than a BMW, a brand renowned the world over for its retention, here is the secret code:
Rock-Solid Reliability & DurabilityToyota's body-on-frame engineering and proven powertrains rack up miles with minimal fuss, earning a reputation for trouble-free ownership and strong demand in the used-vehicle market.Lower Cost of OwnershipPickup parts and service for Tacomas and Tundras are mass-market staples-widely available and competitively priced-keeping maintenance bills down and resale values up.Fleet & Commercial DemandTradespeople, municipalities and rental fleets churn through pickups at high volumes. Those well-maintained, low-mileage ex-fleet Tacomas and 4Runners flood the used market-still commanding premium prices thanks to documented service histories.Proven SimplicityUnlike tech-dense luxury sedans, these trucks stick to mechanical basics and sturdy electronics. Fewer high-tech modules mean fewer post-warranty surprises-and gentler depreciation when the factory bumper-to-bumper coverage ends.Towing & Hauling VersatilityWhether it's a weekend boat launch, a landscaping trailer or a tailgate cooler, Tacomas and Tundras do double duty for work and play. That multi-use appeal outlives the fashion cycle of compact sedans.Iconic Brand LoyaltyToyota-truck buyers come back-again and again. Repeat customers know the resale auction lanes and dealer-trade-in premiums, reinforcing high retail values on every new-for-used transaction.
Don't mistake "truck" for "throwaway." If you want a ride that still sells for strong money five years down the road, put the 4Runner, Tacoma or Tundra at the top of your shopping list. Their bullet-proof reliability, simple mechanicals, fleet-proven histories and go-anywhere versatility combine to crush depreciation the way a Haul-Master trailer conquers a steep grade. In contrast, even prestige nameplates like the BMW 3 Series can't match that resale resilience. Shop your next truck with an eye on those value-drivers, and watch your investment outlast the head-turners and hold its worth where it counts.
Copyright 2025 The Arena Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
an hour ago
- Business Insider
Ford Stock (NYSE:F) Slides on New Sales Numbers
It is a dark day when shareholders in legacy automaker Ford (F) respond to word of improved sales with a sell-off of their own. Because even as Ford managed to bring in some substantial new sales for July, that was not enough to properly fire up shareholders. In fact, shares were down nearly 3% in Friday afternoon's trading. Elevate Your Investing Strategy: Take advantage of TipRanks Premium at 50% off! Unlock powerful investing tools, advanced data, and expert analyst insights to help you invest with confidence. The sales numbers were terrific. There really is no other way to put it. Ford sales were up around 9% higher than in July 2024, thanks mainly to the still-high popularity of gas-powered trucks and sport utility vehicles (SUVs). And the impressive July numbers added nicely to the solid numbers that have been seen throughout 2025 so far, up about 7% total. The first half of 2024 saw around 1.2 million trucks sold, while 2025's first half gave us over 1.3 million. Trucks represented about 60% of the numbers, while SUVs kicked in the remaining 40%. The biggest reason, according to Ford rep Said Deep, is that the combination of tariff panic buying and employee pricing discounts provided just the right environment for people to buy, and buy Ford. This is indeed good news, but it is also enough to make one wonder what Ford will do for an encore when the third and fourth quarters hit. We've Had This Model T Moment Before So remember yesterday, when we heard about the ' Model T Moment ' that Ford has in mind for August 11? It turns out, reports note, that this is not the first time that CEO Jim Farley has used that phrase. In fact, Ford had a 'Model T Moment' just three years ago, in 2022, when the Ford F-150 Lightning emerged. And that particular moment left some disappointed. Certainly, the electric pickup proved a welcome addition to the lineup, and a frequent buy. But it certainly was nowhere near the iconic status of the car that brought cars to everyday life. And considering that reports have already emerged to say that the newest 'Model T Moment' will be built around an electric car, some are already preparing for disappointment. Is Ford Stock a Good Buy Right Now? Turning to Wall Street, analysts have a Hold consensus rating on F stock based on two Buys, 11 Holds and three Sells assigned in the past three months, as indicated by the graphic below. After a 10.37% rally in its share price over the past year, the average F price target of $10.18 per share implies 5.61% downside risk.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
8 Popular Car Brands To Stay Away From in Retirement
Buying a car in retirement isn't just about style or performance; it's about long-term value and reliability. With a fixed income and fewer daily driving needs, retirees should prioritize vehicles that are affordable to maintain over time. Unfortunately, some popular car brands come with surprisingly high upkeep costs that can drain your savings. Consider This: Read Next: If you want to protect your budget and peace of mind, consider not just the cost of your new car, but also the cost to keep it running through your retirement. According to CarEdge, these are the top eight most expensive car brands to maintain along with some of their pricier 2025 models. Ram You might have favored certain makes and models in the past, but now that you've entered a new chapter in your life, it might be time to reevaluate. The industry average for maintenance costs for popular brands is $8,303, making Ram's over $20,000 estimate a steep bill to consider. Moreover, CarEdge found that there is a 68% chance that your Ram will need a major repair within 10 years, which is considerably worse — over 43% worse — than other auto manufacturers studied. Average 10-year maintenance costs for Ram models: $21,595 Ram 3500 10-year maintenance costs: $27,445 Ram 2500 10-year maintenance costs: $27,423 Ram 1500 10-year maintenance costs: $19,357 Jeep It's wise to research car maintenance costs, so you don't accidentally buy a new car that requires pricey upkeep that will eat into your fixed income and Social Security benefits. Jeeps are often on many mechanics' lists of car models to avoid due to their higher than average 10-year maintenance and repair costs. With a jeep, there is a 32% chance your vehicle will need a major repair within the first 10 years of ownership, whereas the industry average sits at a little over 24%. Here are a few of the pricier options to maintain: Average 10-year maintenance costs for Jeep models: $11,690 Jeep Gladiator 10-year maintenance costs: $12,679 Jeep Grand Wagoneer L/ Jeep Grand Wagoneer 10-year maintenance costs: $12,375/ $12,269 Jeep Wrangler 10-year maintenance costs: $11,664 Jeep Grand Cherokee 10-year maintenance costs: $11,217 Learn More: Chrysler When you are budgeting out your monthly expenses in retirement, you plan on gas and insurance costs for your car, but excessive maintenance may put you over what you have allotted. If you decide to purchase a Chrysler, you'll have to factor in maintenance costs that are $3,064 higher than the average. This is in addition to the 32% chance of your car needing a major repair. Here are a few specific models you may want to dodge in retirement: Average 10-year maintenance costs for Chrysler models: $11,367 Chrysler Pacifica 10-year maintenance costs: $11,520 Chrysler Voyager 10-year maintenance costs: $11,207 Dodge If you want to be both fiscally and frugally responsible as a retiree, make sure you don't invest in cars that will cost you more than just standard wear and tear on your wallet. The $11,352 average maintenance and repair cost for Dodge vehicles is $3,049 over the industry average, meaning retirees will have to account for that added expense when budgeting. Similar to the Chrysler and Jeep brands, Dodge also has a 32% chance of requiring a major repair within the first 10 years of owning the vehicle. Here are some 2025 Dodge models that can be expensive to upkeep: Average 10-year maintenance costs for Dodge models: $11,352 Dodge Durgango 10-year maintenance costs: $11,768 Dodge Hornet 10-year maintenance costs: $10,934 Ford Just because something is built Ford tough doesn't mean it won't be hard on your finances. The cost to maintain and repair your Ford over 10 years will run an average of $10,392, which is $2,089 over the average for popular brands overall. And the chance your vehicle will need a major repair during that time is approximately 7% worse than the standard. If you want to stretch your nest egg a bit further in retirement, you may want to consider alternative modes of transportation. Average 10-year maintenance costs for Ford models: $10,392 Ford F-150 to Ford F-450 10-year maintenance costs: $11,367 to $16,170 Ford Expedition 10-year maintenance costs: $10,302 Ford Bronco 10-year maintenance costs: $10,159 Ford Explorer 10-year maintenance costs: $9,766 Chevrolet Chevrolet is another popular car brand with a steeper than average 10-year maintenance and repair cost — $1,359 higher to be exact. With a 28% chance of your Chevy needing a major repair, which is 4% worse than other auto manufacturers studied, retirees may have to contend with costlier mechanic bills alongside their other necessary expenses. Average 10-year maintenance costs for Chevrolet models: $9,662 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 to Chevrolet Silverado 3500 10-year maintenance costs: $11,045 to $15,497 Chevrolet Colorado 10-year maintenance costs: $10,713 Chevrolet Suburban 10-year maintenance costs: $10,108 Chevrolet Tahoe 10-year maintenance costs: $10,029 GMC It may seem counterintuitive to expect the unexpected, but when it comes to car expenses, you may need more than your emergency savings to cover some of these maintenance costs. GMC models on average will cost retirees nearly $9,500 in maintenance and repairs over 10 years. Not only that, but GMC vehicles have a 28% chance of requiring a major repair. Average 10-year maintenance costs for GMC models: $9,467 GMC Sierra 1500 to GMC Sierra 3500 10-year maintenance costs: $10,002 to $14,014 GMC Canyon 10-year maintenance costs: $9,568 GMC Yukon XL 10-year maintenance costs: $9.373 Buick Buick may bill itself as exceptional by design, but that design could cost you with an average 10-year maintenance and repair cost that's $715 higher than the industry average. While this may not seem like a lot, every dollar counts if you're living with a fixed income. Add to that the 25% chance of your car needing a major repair, which is 1% worse than other manufacturers, and you might want to consider avoiding these models in your golden years. Average 10-year maintenance costs for Buick models: $9,018 Buick Enclave 10-year maintenance costs: $9,322 Buick Envision 10-year maintenance costs: $9,105 Buick Encore GX 10-year maintenance costs: $8,857 Editor's note: Data sourced via CarEdge, and is accurate as of Jul. 31, 2025. More From GOBankingRates How Much Money Is Needed To Be Considered Middle Class in Your State? This article originally appeared on 8 Popular Car Brands To Stay Away From in Retirement Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Report: Toyota Still Considering Smaller Unibody Truck for US
Report: Toyota Still Considering Smaller Unibody Truck for US originally appeared on Autoblog. Ford and Hyundai have succeeded in the compact truck segment — could Toyota be next? Small trucks have had a bumpy history in the States. However, lately, some automakers have found success with smaller-than-usual offerings, including Ford's Maverick and Hyundai's Santa Cruz, both of which are small pickups. The small truck segment could grow even more with the Bezos-backed Slate pickup, albeit its existence has become a lot more uncertain in the last few weeks as EV incentives go the way of Amelia Earhart. Then, we get to Toyota. Recent reports coming from Automotive News seem to indicate Toyota may still bring a tyke-sized truck to the US market, and it might not be the truck you expect it to be. View the 2 images of this gallery on the original article A smaller Toyota truck would not share much with existing Toyota truck offerings While the current Toyota truck lineup in the US features solely body-on-frame construction, the prospective addition to the family would likely be based on the RAV4. Automotive News reports that Toyota Motor North America is still 'studying' a compact unibody-based pickup for the US market. They also confirm that the Corolla-based and electrified truck that Toyota is selling in Brazil is decidedly 'too small' for the US. Disappearing incentives/rebates and tariffs are also likely contributing factors as to why we won't get that smaller pickup. View the 2 images of this gallery on the original article A truck built on the TNGA-K platform — which underpins the RAV4, Camry, Sienna, and others — means staying more than competitive with other small truck offerings. The Grand Highlander, a TNGA-K vehicle, can tow up to 5,000 pounds, which is 1,000 more than what the Maverick can muster. Considering even the three-row Grand Highlander is only two inches longer than the Maverick, the platform's size would be right on the money, too. Although at one point speculation pointed towards electrification, that plan — if there ever was one — is almost certainly scrapped in the face of loosening EPA regulations and dashed EV rebates. In the US, anyway, as Europe is a different story. Automotive News thinks 2028 would be the earliest we'd see the hypothetical truck. A new small truck fits Toyota's goals like a glove In related chats with Ted Ogawa, Toyota North America CEO, Automotive News uncovered additional pieces of the puzzle that might point towards a tinier truck alternative. 'When we talk about affordability, the key is the entry segment,' Ogawa says. 'So, in our lineup, that means Corolla and Corolla Cross.' That covers the small SUV and sedan segment; why not bring in an 'entry segment' truck to round things out? Another priority of Ogawa's — and, realistically, all automakers — is getting the most bang per buck at a platform level. 'Products must be refreshed, but the platform can be extended,' he tells AN. There's one last intimation we glean from the Ogawa interview. 'Toyota's basic policy is to build where we sell and buy where we build,' he starts. Later, we get a real-world example. 'In the case of the Corolla sedan, currently the internal-combustion version is built in Mississippi. But the hybrid is built in Japan, because that plant is more competitive for that product.' We can't imagine any market more ready to chomp at the bit for an affordable, small Toyota pickup than the US. The Slate hype — which may have, ultimately, been just that — was all the evidence we needed. View the 2 images of this gallery on the original article Final thoughts New Toyota truck rumors have persisted for years. Ford moved 48,041 Mavericks in just the second quarter of 2025. Arguably more importantly, a whopping 60% of Maverick buyers were new to the brand. Some of those customers inevitably migrated from Toyota, and that's got to hurt. We think the chances are high that Toyota wants to bring a competitor to the market. It's just a question of when, and whether or not 2028 will be too late. Report: Toyota Still Considering Smaller Unibody Truck for US first appeared on Autoblog on Aug 2, 2025 This story was originally reported by Autoblog on Aug 2, 2025, where it first appeared.
