Lee Soo Man slammed for using SHINee Jonghyun's funeral footage in documentary: ‘Really hope his family sues them'
Billed as a deep dive into Lee Soo Man's influence on the global K-pop phenomenon, the documentary sets out to chart the rise of SM Entertainment and its founder's role in shaping the idol industry. The trailer featured interviews with various artists and insiders from the K-pop world who worked closely with SM Entertainment, painting a portrait of Lee as both a pioneer and a controversial figure. While the trailer touches on Lee's achievements, it also attempts to address criticism around the high-pressure culture of K-pop idols, referring to how Western media has often cast a critical eye on South Korean entertainment systems.
The backlash began almost immediately after viewers noticed the inclusion of footage from SHINee's Jonghyun's funeral — a deeply emotional and private moment for fans and those who loved him. Jonghyun, who died by suicide in 2017 after publicly discussing his struggles with mental health and the overwhelming pressure of idol life, remains a deeply respected and beloved figure within and beyond the K-pop community.
Therefore, for many, using this moment in a documentary about Lee Soo Man feels not only tone-deaf but exploitative. Fans and critics alike have accused the filmmakers of leveraging a painful tragedy to build sympathy for someone who had often been criticised for his role in shaping the very system that many say contributed to Jonghyun's mental health struggles.
On social media, fans called the choice 'disrespectful,' and 'dehumanising'. Some also questioned how Jonghyun's death, which symbolised the very emotional cost of the K-pop machine, could be used in a film that largely centres Lee Soo Man's legacy without directly addressing that cost from the perspective of those who lived it. Calls for a revision or removal of the footage continue to mount, with fans demanding more sensitivity and accountability when representing such a tragic moment. As of now, the documentary's production team has not responded to the growing criticism.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
16 minutes ago
- Time of India
In A PoP World, A Couple Sticks To Clay & Ethical Craftsmanship
Nagpur: With Plaster of Paris (PoP) idols back in circulation, traditional clay sculptors are facing an existential crisis. For Prashant and Nisha Mahurkar, a couple who has dedicated decades to crafting eco-friendly idols, the new reality is not just challenging, but disheartening. "We spend days, sometimes weeks, handcrafting an idol. Each piece is a tribute to the Bappa," says Prashant, gently brushing dust off a half-finished Ganesha in his modest Nagpur workshop. "But POP idols? They're mass-produced and sold in minutes. They're cheaper and that's hard to compete with." The return of POP, which is harmful to the environment and banned by several state pollution boards until recently, has tilted the scales further against traditional artisans. Mahurkar recently received a request for a 'Military Ganpati' , an idol of Lord Ganesha holding a rifle. "I asked them if we could replace the weapon with a Tiranga (Indian tricolour). They agreed. That's our job to preserve sanctity, not just sculpt forms. " His wife, Nisha, who handles the final finishing of the idols, echoes his sentiment. "Sometimes people come with the most bizarre demands. Once, a family brought a photo of Ganeshji styled after a cartoon character, holding an oversized modak. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo We knew their intention was to please their kids, but we felt the need to change certain aspects," she says. "We explained the importance of maintaining the deity's sanctity, suggested gentler modifications, and thankfully, they understood." But far more than quirky customer requests, what keeps the Mahurkars up at night is the mounting cost of keeping their craft alive. The couple finds it increasingly difficult to hire and retain daily wage workers. "We can't afford to pay unskilled help anymore," Nisha explains. "And it takes time to train them, this work isn't just about moulding clay. It requires a deep understanding of balance, drying, and layering." Prashant adds, "We spend more time training than actually creating. And yet, we have to meet deadlines." They admit that taking shortcuts could make the business more profitable. "We could switch to POP and fool customers. But how will we sleep at night?" he asks. "This isn't just a business. This is our legacy, our offering to God." In a world where mass production reigns, the Mahurkars' stand is both rare and courageous, a testament to devotion, ethics, and a dying art.
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
Chinese comedian's viral set on domestic abuse sparks authority intervention on gender based humor in China
TIL Creatives Fan Chunli, a sensation is a 50-year-old comedian from rural China Fan Chunli, a 50-year-old comedian from rural China, became a national sensation after her raw and candid stand-up performance detailing years of spousal abuse and her eventual escape resonated widely with audiences on the streaming platform iQiyi's show The King of Stand-up Comedy . Before comedy, Fan worked as a sanitation worker and had limited formal education, only attending school until junior high. Growing up in a traditional environment where women had few rights to inherit family property and were expected to marry early, Fan initially accepted these roles but later found family and marriage constricted her financial independence. During her set, Fan, performing under the stage name 'Fangzhuren,' shared her painful personal story that highlighted the pervasive issue of domestic violence in China. The performance moved many viewers to tears and earned a standing ovation, culminating in one of the most-liked comments wishing anger upon her abusive the viral popularity of Fan Chunli's set and other similar comedic performances that discuss gender-related issues have elicited a stern response from Chinese authorities, particularly in Zhejiang province. Provincial publicity officials issued a public warning on WeChat admonishing comedians to avoid provoking gender opposition for the sake of being funny. They condemned comedy that reduces complex gender dynamics into simplistic battles between men and women.'Criticism is obviously fine, but it should be… constructive rather than revolve around gender opposition for the sake of being funny,' read the WeChat article by authorities according to Hong Kong Free Press. It urged comedians to analyze phenomena like consumerism's impact on gender roles and to avoid outright antagonism between sexes. This crack down is part of a broader pattern of Chinese authorities suppressing independent feminist activism and rigorously policing content across comedy, music, and public discourse. Over the past decade, China has significantly curtailed feminist movements viewed by the state as influenced by 'malicious Western' ideas. Fan Chunli's story brought to light the taboo and sensitivity around topics like domestic violence and women's rights—issues largely brushed under the carpet in Chinese society and public reaction to Fan's set was overwhelmingly empathetic, reflecting a deeper awakening among Chinese women who question traditional patriarchal norms. However, the state's response signals a desire to control the narrative and limit the scope of gender debates to avoid social discord, emphasizing 'palatable' and state-sanctioned content rather than authentic lived comedians and cultural creators, the authorities' directive means navigating careful boundaries between raising awareness and provoking censorship. As one analysis pointed out, Fen Chunli's candidness struck a chord but also reminded marketers and artists that authenticity in China's content environment carries significant risks of backlash.
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
Ganpati mandals rejoice as HC permits idol immersion in sea
Mumbai: Ganpati mandals are relieved at Thursday's Bombay High Court order permitting PoP idols over 6 ft tall to be immersed in the sea. They had been wary of organising full fledged celebrations in the absence of proper permissions. Now that the curbs have been lifted they are going ahead full steam with their usual tall moortis, decoration and fundraising. Ankur Lad, spokesperson for Khetwadi Cha Vighnaharta of Girgaum, said artificial tanks were not suited to tall moortis. "PoP idols of 20-25 ft contain metal and iron rods and frames inside for support. In fact even clay idols of that height, like Girgaon Cha Raja, have wood inside. Such idols won't dissolve at all, because how deep can you make artificial ponds," he reasoned. Even as the tug of war over PoP was under way, some mandals voluntarily switched to eco-friendly raw material. Rajendra Sawant, secretary of the 77-year-old Ambedkar Nagar mandal in Worli, said, "Our 10 ft idol was usually made of PoP. But after the earlier ban and concerns over environment safety we used a clay idol. This year it is carved from tissue paper. The decision had to be made quickly as we were sceptical about waiting for the decision over PoP immersion. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Private Browsers That Keep You Safe vividtrendlab Undo " You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai Abhinay Hate of Kandivali Cha Vighnaharta said their idol is 14 ft tall. "We too were tense about the ban even though we immerse our idol in a pond in any case. But this time there is no confirmation yet for the protocol to be followed at the pond where we usually go. The HC order is a big relief, though." The prominent Chandanwadi Ganeshotsav mandal near Marine Lines hosts a 26 ft tall moorti. Secretary Prathamesh Sakpal said, "Thousands of Ganpati idols are immersed every year amid processions that include lakhs of people. It would be problematic if there was an interruption." In Andheri West, the Saat Bangla Cha Raja stands 22 ft tall. Vice president Amith Kadam said, "Immersion of tall idols beyond 6 ft would have been impossible to execute in artificial tanks. Thanks to the HC order we can now continue our preparations with ease." Santosh Narkar, newly elected chairman of Khetwadi Cha Raja in Girgaum said their idol is 31 ft tall. "Our moortikar Aniket Shevale has carved an outstanding idol this year."
