New York sued by National Retail Federation over surveillance pricing law
The world's largest retail trade group said New York's Algorithmic Pricing Disclosure Act, which would take effect on July 8, violates many members' First Amendment free speech rights.
Governor Kathy Hochul signed the first-in-the-nation law in May, saying the practice of charging different prices based on customers' willingness to pay was "opaque," and prevented those customers from comparison shopping.
In its complaint filed in Manhattan federal court, the National Retail Federation objected to requiring members to affix "misleading and ominous" warnings to prices set by algorithms linked to customer data.
It said the law reflected "speculative fear" of price gouging, even though retailers use algorithms to offer promotions and reward customer loyalty, sometimes resulting in lower prices.
According to the complaint, the law violates the U.S. Constitution by compelling a broad range of retailers to express misleading "government-scripted opinion" without justification, or face potential civil fines of $1,000 per violation.
The only defendant is state Attorney General Letitia James, who enforces New York laws. Her office did not immediately respond to requests for comment after business hours. Hochul's office did not immediately respond to a similar request.
In January, a divided Federal Trade Commission issued a study on surveillance pricing, saying location data and online browsing histories could permit retailers to "target" individual consumers with different prices for the same products.
FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson, then a commissioner, dissented from issuing the study, saying it was rushed out three days before Donald Trump succeeded Joe Biden as U.S. president to meet a "nakedly political deadline."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Top New York establishment Dems still withhold Mamdani endorsements
[Source] Prominent New York Democrats have declined to endorse NYC mayoral nominee Zohran Mamdani even as they now defend him after President Donald Trump threatened to arrest the 33-year-old candidate over his immigration status. Uncertainties: Over a week after the Democratic primary, most party establishment figures remain reluctant to formally back Mamdani. Sources told the New York Post that Gov. Kathy Hochul 'can't endorse him' because 'that'll be the election' and 'she'll lose Long Island.' House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, who has represented Brooklyn since 2013, also declined an endorsement on Sunday, asking Mamdani to clarify his position on the phrase 'globalize the intifada,' which many believe is antisemitic. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, who has represented New York for more than 25 years, has similarly held back his endorsement, though he praised Mamdani for running an 'impressive campaign.' A unified response: Interestingly, the lack of support shifted when Trump began attacking Mamdani the day after the June 24 primary, calling him a '100% Communist Lunatic' and questioning his citizenship status. Mamdani — who was born to Indian parents in Uganda — was naturalized as an U.S. citizen in 2018. Hochul fired back on Tuesday, writing on X, 'I don't care if you're the President of the United States, if you threaten to unlawfully go after one of our neighbors, you're picking a fight with 20 million New Yorkers — starting with me.' Jeffries also defended Mamdani on Wednesday, writing, 'Stop lying about Assemblyman Mamdani. He is neither a communist nor a lunatic,' and criticizing the president's 'One Big Beautiful Bill.' Possible benefit? Democratic Rep. George Latimer, whose District 16 includes parts of the Bronx, told CNN that Mamdani's candidacy will be 'tough for front-liners because they're in districts that have a lot of Republicans' who will try to tie Democrats to his progressive image. However, Democratic strategist Joel Payne told The Hill that establishment resistance might actually benefit Mamdani. 'It probably helps that members of the establishment of the Democratic Party are not completely, wholly signed on to what he's all about because I think it just emphasizes his broader critique of the establishment,' Payne said. Trending on NextShark: This story is part of The Rebel Yellow Newsletter — a bold weekly newsletter from the creators of NextShark, reclaiming our stories and celebrating Asian American voices. Subscribe free to join the movement. If you love what we're building, consider becoming a paid member — your support helps us grow our team, investigate impactful stories, and uplift our community. Trending on NextShark: Subscribe here now! Download the NextShark App: Want to keep up to date on Asian American News? Download the NextShark App today!
CNBC
12 hours ago
- CNBC
New York sued by National Retail Federation over surveillance pricing law
New York state was sued on Wednesday by the National Retail Federation over a new law requiring retailers to tell customers when their personal data are being used to set prices, known as surveillance pricing. The world's largest retail trade group said New York's Algorithmic Pricing Disclosure Act, which would take effect on July 8, violates many members' First Amendment free speech rights. Governor Kathy Hochul signed the first-in-the-nation law in May, saying the practice of charging different prices based on customers' willingness to pay was "opaque," and prevented those customers from comparison shopping. In its complaint filed in Manhattan federal court, the National Retail Federation objected to requiring members to affix "misleading and ominous" warnings to prices set by algorithms linked to customer data. It said the law reflected "speculative fear" of price gouging, even though retailers use algorithms to offer promotions and reward customer loyalty, sometimes resulting in lower prices. According to the complaint, the law violates the U.S. Constitution by compelling a broad range of retailers to express misleading "government-scripted opinion" without justification, or face potential civil fines of $1,000 per violation. The only defendant is state Attorney General Letitia James, who enforces New York laws. Her office did not immediately respond to requests for comment after business hours. Hochul's office did not immediately respond to a similar request. In January, a divided Federal Trade Commission issued a study on surveillance pricing, saying location data and online browsing histories could permit retailers to "target" individual consumers with different prices for the same products. FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson, then a commissioner, dissented from issuing the study, saying it was rushed out three days before Donald Trump succeeded Joe Biden as U.S. president to meet a "nakedly political deadline."
Fox News
14 hours ago
- Fox News
Hochul aide accused of sexual harassment was focus of prior behavior probe: report
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul's top aide who was recently placed on leave over a sexual harassment allegation, reportedly had previous complaints filed against him which led to an investigation. Avi Small, Hochul's press secretary, was reportedly the subject of complaints for allegedly berating junior staff members, according to Politico. The outlet cited five people with direct knowledge of the probe who were granted anonymity due to the sensitive nature of the matter. According to Politico, the governor's human resources department and an outside law firm conducted the investigation. The people familiar with the matter who spoke with Politico said Small had a history of yelling at younger staff, making several employees afraid to work with him. Politico reported that four out of the five who spoke with the outlet said they witnessed Small chastising staffers over errors in press releases or if the governor's speaking engagements did not go as planned. The investigation into Small's treatment of junior staff did not result in a human resources violation, Politico reported, citing another person familiar with the outcome. That source reportedly told Politico that Hochul had inadvertently created a system in which allegations quickly led to serious probes that could tarnish a subject's reputation. Law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky reportedly conducted interviews with Hochul's staff regarding Small's conduct. According to Politico, which cited sources, staffers were worried when they learned an expansion of deputy secretaries' responsibilities would mean Small would work more closely with underlings. Politico reported that several staffers met with human resources after the conclusion of the 2024 investigation to ask about the lack of information on the probe's outcome. The staffers were reportedly encouraged not to discuss the allegations against Small. Additionally, multiple sources reportedly told Politico that there was information given to human resources about Small cornering a subordinate in a supply closet and questioning them. Small was recently placed on leave over an allegation that he inappropriately touched a staffer during an office retreat in Albany on June 16, according to reports. Multiple outlets said that the governor's office claimed action was taken against Small shortly after the complaint was filed. When Hochul took over for former Gov. Andrew Cuomo after he was ousted amid sexual harassment allegations in 2021, she vowed that "no one will ever describe my administration as a 'toxic work environment.'" Cuomo has denied any wrongdoing. In October 2021, according to a press release from Calcagni & Kanefsky, Hochul announced new initiatives aimed at tackling workplace bullying and discrimination. Hochul's office did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital's request for comment, which was submitted on July 4. Fox News Digital was also unable to get in contact with Small.
