Meta says will appeal ‘unlawful' EU fine
The EU fined Meta in April over its 'pay or consent' system because of how it said the company used personal data on Facebook and Instagram.
'This decision is both incorrect and unlawful, and we are appealing it,' Meta vice president Tim Lamb said in a blog post published on Wednesday.
The fine against Meta concerned its 'pay for privacy' system, which rights defenders have vehemently criticised in Europe after its introduction in November 2023.
It means users have to pay to avoid data collection, or agree to share their data with Facebook and Instagram to keep using the platforms for free.
The European Commission in April concluded Meta did not provide users with a less personalised but equivalent version of the platforms.
It also warned Meta faced potential daily penalties under the landmark Digital Markets Act (DMA) unless it complied with the law within 60 days.
That deadline ran out last week but the commission said on Wednesday that after receiving information from the company, it was assessing whether they are now complying.
Defending its system, Meta's Lamb pointed to an EU court ruling in 2023 that he said opened the way for subscriptions as a legally valid option.
'Yet the (April) decision ignores this ruling. Instead, it claims that the (top EU court's) crucial judgment is not relevant and incorrectly concludes that Meta's user choice does not comply with the DMA. This stance is perplexing,' he wrote. – AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
21 minutes ago
- The Star
Prabowo in Brussels to seal European Union deal amid US tariff threat
JAKARTA: With trade tensions between the United States and its partners on the rise, President Prabowo Subianto arrived in Brussels over the weekend in a bid to finalise Indonesia's most ambitious trade pact yet, the Indonesia-European Union Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (IEU-CEPA). The trip follows the completion of substantive negotiations between Jakarta and Brussels, with both sides now preparing to sign the deal in Jakarta later this year. Coordinating Economic Minister Airlangga Hartarto, speaking from Brussels, said that 'all issues have now been resolved' and called the deal 'a milestone' that could reshape Indonesia's trade orientation in an increasingly uncertain global environment. 'This is certainly a milestone amid the uncertainty between Indonesia and the EU. Our products can now enter Europe at zero tariffs,' Airlangga told reporters in a video interview issued in Jakarta on Sunday (July 13). He added that the agreement's final signing is expected in the third quarter of 2025, pending a formal announcement from the President. The IEU-CEPA spans 21 areas of cooperation, including trade in goods and services, investment, customs procedures, digital trade and sustainable growth. Key sectors like textiles, garments and fishery products are expected to benefit from reduced barriers. Prabowo's visit to Brussels officially begins on Sunday, and includes scheduled meetings with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President António Costa, as well as King Philippe of Belgium. Airlangga emphasised that 'shifting global geopolitics', a likely reference to Washington's protectionist tariff hikes, has made Europe a more attractive alternative for Indonesian exports. He also pointed to Indonesia's bid to join the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) as one reason why Brussels now views Jakarta as a 'like-minded' and strategic partner. Trade Minister Budi Santoso, also in Brussels, echoed that sentiment, saying that Indonesia had gained leverage during the final stretch of negotiations. 'When IEU-CEPA neared completion, the EU started to soften on things like the deforestation regulation,' he said. 'They too want to work with us going forward.' The visit of the high-level Indonesian delegation comes just weeks after the EU reclassified Indonesia as a 'standard-risk' country under its deforestation regulation (EUDR), which had long been a sticking point for EU-bound palm oil shipments from Indonesia, the world's largest producer and exporter of the commodity. Budi also noted that Europe presents a more sizable and potentially stable market amid growing uncertainty. 'EU imports are about US$6.6 trillion globally, compared to around $3.3 trillion for the US. If we can grow our exports to the EU, that's a strong alternative market for us,' he said in a separate video interview. The EU is currently Indonesia's fifth-largest trading partner, with bilateral trade reaching $30.1 billion in 2024. The CEPA deal, once ratified, is expected to boost Indonesian exports to the EU by up to 50 percent due to lower tariffs and non-tariff barriers and attract more investment in key sectors such as electric vehicles, semiconductors, renewable energy and palm oil processing. While full ratification may not occur before 2027, Indonesian businesses are already aligning with EU partners to prepare supply chains ahead of its entry into force. 'After Indonesia, countries like Malaysia and Thailand are lining up. We are now the front-runner in forging deeper cooperation [with Europe],' Airlangga said. The US tariff threats, pegged between 20-40 percent for countries in Southeast Asia, have prompted Asean economies to diversify trade partners and bolster their domestic supply chains. Of Asean's current 10 member states, only Vietnam has signed a deal with the US to mitigate the tariff threat. In an attempt to appease the region, US Secretary of State Mark Rubio argued last week that 'many of the countries in Southeast Asia are going to have tariff rates that are actually better than countries in other parts of the world,' news wires reported. In response to a question on the ongoing Indonesia-US negotiations, Airlangga claimed that the US had agreed to a 'pause' on imposing tariffs for the next three weeks to allow for the fine-tuning and completion of the tariff deal. - The Jakarta Post/ANN
Malaysian Reserve
2 hours ago
- Malaysian Reserve
EU delays tariffs on us goods despite 30% levy announced by Trump
BRUSSELS — The European Union will extend its suspension of tariffs on goods imported from the US until early August, despite Washington's decision to slap a 30 per cent levy on imports from the bloc, European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen said on Sunday, reported German news agency (dpa). 'The United States have sent us a letter with measures that would come into effect unless there is a negotiated solution,' she said. 'We will therefore also extend the suspension of our countermeasures till early August.' It comes after US President Donald Trump said on Saturday that he will impose 30 per cent tariffs on imports from the European Union starting August 1, despite ongoing negotiations to avert a trade war. In a letter sent to von der Leyen and posted on his platform Truth Social, he complained of the 'long-term, large and persistent' trade deficit the US has with the EU, accusing the 27-nation bloc of unfair trade policies and barriers. Trump wrote that his administration would drop the high tariff rate if 'the European Union, or countries within the EU, decide to build or manufacture within the United States'. Von der Leyen on Sunday stressed that the EU would not stand back and watch, saying her commission would continue to prepare further countermeasures in the coming weeks, adding: 'we are fully prepared.' Following Trump's letter, the EU could have imposed initial countertariffs in response to earlier US levies on steel and aluminium products from the bloc from Tuesday after the initial suspension expired. — BERNAMA-dpa
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
EU to keep US trade countermeasures on hold until August, says von der Leyen
FILE PHOTO: European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen looks on during a joint news conference with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and European Council President Antonio Costa, during an EU-Canada summit in Brussels, Belgium June 23, 2025. REUTERS/Gonzalo Fuentes/File Photo BRUSSELS (Reuters) -The EU will extend its suspension of countermeasures to U.S. tariffs until early August as it aims for a negotiated solution on trade with the United States, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said on Sunday. U.S. President Donald Trump escalated his global trade war on Saturday and threatened to impose a 30% tariff on imports from the European Union from Aug. 1, separate from sector-specific duties, despite months of intense talks. Announcing the extension of the halt on retaliatory measures, von der Leyen told reporters the bloc would "continue to prepare further countermeasures so we are fully prepared". A first package of countermeasures to U.S. tariffs on steel and aluminium that would hit 21 billion euros ($24.6 billion) in U.S. goods was suspended in April for 90 days to allow time for negotiations. The suspension had been due to expire on Monday. A second package has been in the works since May and would target 72 billion euros of U.S. goods, but these measures have not yet been made public and the final list requires approval by member states. Von der Leyen added that use of the EU's Anti-Coercion Instrument was not yet on the table. "The (anti-coercion) instrument is created for extraordinary situations, we are not there yet," she said. The instrument allows the bloc to retaliate against third countries that put economic pressure on EU members to change their policies. Possible retaliatory steps could include restricting EU market access to goods and services, and other economic measures related to areas including foreign direct investment, financial markets and export controls. ($1 = 0.8555 euros) (Reporting by Julia Payne and Charlotte Van Campenhout;Editing by Gareth Jones and Helen Popper)
