logo
Vape bans: A response to R. Paneir Selvam — Hafiz Hassan

Vape bans: A response to R. Paneir Selvam — Hafiz Hassan

Malay Mail4 days ago
JULY 22 — I refer to R Paneir Selvam's 'Vape bans: A slippery slope for legal governance'.
The July 2024 decision of the High Court referred to by the learned writer was the decision in the case of Lee Bak Chui & Ors v Kerajaan Negeri Kedah Darul Aman & Ors [2024] 11 MLJ 556
In that case, the applicants were the pool betting agents and aggrieved by the decision of the first respondent, the State Government of Kedah on the decision that the premise licences for the activities of the gambling business would not be renewed in the State of Kedah ('the said decision').
All the applicants then received letters from the respective Municipal Councils stating that it was agreed that the Ministry of Finance to not consider the renewal of gambling licences for the State of Kedah for the year 2023 since the licence fell within the purview of the Ministry of Finance and it was agreed that the Kedah State local authority and police should take strict enforcement action should there be any licence holders still in operation after December 31, 2022.
The applicants were informed of the said decision and were also informed that legal action would be taken if businesses were still carried out on the premises.
In their applications for judicial review of the said decision, the applicants argued before the High Court that the said decision was, among others, illegal and that the respondents had breached the applicants' legitimate expectation as provided under written law — that is, as long as the pool betting agents were licensed under Section 5 of the Pool Betting Act 1967, the applicants would be able to peacefully carry on their trade and business.
The applicants alleged that the respondents had acted more than their authority. Thus the application for judicial review of the said decision.
The learned High Court judge, Mahazan Mat Taib, allowed the application, ruling, among others, that the said decision was contrary to Article 80(1) read with Article 74 and Item 4(l) of the Federal List of the Federal Constitution.
Articles 74, 80(1), Item 4(l) of the Federal List and Item 4 of the State List are reproduced below:
Article 74 — Subject matter of Federal and State laws
(1) Without prejudice to any power to make laws conferred on it by any other Article, Parliament may make laws with respect to any of the matters enumerated in the Federal List or the Concurrent List (that is to say, the First or Third List set out in the Ninth Schedule).
(2) Without prejudice to any power to make laws conferred on it by any other Article, the Legislature of a State may make laws with respect to any of the matters enumerated in the State List (that is to say, the Second List set out in the Ninth Schedule) or the Concurrent List.
(3) The power to make laws conferred by this Article is exercisable subject to any conditions or restrictions imposed with respect to any particular matter by this Constitution.
(4) Where general as well as specific expressions are used in describing any of the matter enumerated in the Lists set out in the Ninth Schedule the generality of the former shall not be taken to be limited by the latter.
Article 80 — Distribution of Executive powers
(1) Subject to the following provisions of this Article the executive authority of the Federation extends to all matters with respect to which Parliament may make laws, and the executive authority of a State to all matters with respect to which the Legislature of that State may make laws.
No smoking and no vaping warning displayed in food store in Puchong. — Picture by Choo Choy May .
Item 4(l) Federal List
Civil and criminal law and procedure and the administration of justice, including — (l) betting and lotteries.
Item 4 State List
Local government outside the Federal Territories of Kuala Lumpur, Labuan and Putrajaya, including — (a) Local administration; municipal corporations; local, town and rural board and other local authorities; local government services, local rates, local government elections; (b) Obnoxious trades and public nuisances in local authority areas.
After setting out the above provisions, the learned judge said:
'An important point to note is that the words 'with respect to' in Article 74 must be interpreted with extensive amplitude. The cardinal rule of interpretation is that the entries in the legislative lists are not to be read in a narrow or restricted sense and that each general word should be held to extend to all ancillary or subsidiary matters which can fairly and reasonably be said to be comprehended in it.
'The widest possible construction, according to the ordinary meaning of the words in the entry, must be put upon them. In construing the words in a constitutional document conferring legislative power the most liberal construction should be put upon the words so that the same may have effect in widest amplitude.
'It is also well settled that the phrase 'with respect to' appearing in Article 74(1) and (2) of the Federal Constitution — the provision conferring legislative power upon the Federal and State Governments respectively — is an expression of wide import. As observed by Latham CJ in Bank of New South Wales v The Commonwealth:
'A power to make laws 'with respect to' a specific subject is as wide a legislative power as can be created. No form of words has been suggested which would give a wider power. The power conferred upon a Parliament by such word ... is wide.'
'Another equally important point to note is that the function of the entries in the Legislative Lists in the Ninth Schedule is not to confer powers of legislation, but merely to demarcate the fields in which legislative bodies operate. As summarized by the Federal Court in Gin Poh Holdings Sdn Bhd (in voluntary liquidation) v The Government of the State of Penang, the principles applicable to the interpretation of entries in the legislative lists as follows:
(a) the entries in the legislative lists do not confer legislative power. Rather, they are broad heads or fields of legislation to demarcate the respective areas in which Parliament and the State Legislature may operate;
(b) the entries must be interpreted liberally with the widest amplitude, and not narrowly or restrictively. Each entry extends to all ancillary and subsidiary matters which can fairly and reasonably be said to be comprehended in it;
(c) the rule of widest construction does not permit an entry to be interpreted so as to include matters with no rational connection to it or to override or render meaningless another entry;
(d) in the event of apparent conflict or overlap between entries, the court should attempt to reconcile the entries by adopting a harmonious construction; and
(e) in interpreting a particular entry, the court should confine its decision to the concrete question arising from the case, without pronouncing a more exhaustive definition than is necessary.
Accordingly, the entries in the Legislative Lists — that is, the Federal List, State List and Concurrent List (List I, List II and List III respectively) — in the Ninth Schedule to the Federal Constitution are not to be read in a narrow or restricted sense and that each general word should be held to extend to all ancillary or subsidiary matters which can fairly and reasonably be said to be comprehended in it.
Moreover, in the event of apparent conflict or overlap between entries, the court should attempt to reconcile the entries by adopting a harmonious construction.
The rule of widest construction does not permit an entry to be interpreted so as to include matters with no rational connection to it or to override or render meaningless another entry.
So, even though the first respondent had the Executive authority on the matter of local authority in relation to the licensing of premises for gambling, the said decision (to cease the renewal of premise licence for gambling) in effect rendered Item 4(l) of the Federal List on betting and lotteries meaningless.
The legislative authority of the State cannot be extended to banning betting and lotteries under the subject matter of licensing of premises for gambling.
Otherwise, it would be including a matter which overrides or render meaningless the entry in Item 4(l) of the Federal List.
Pool betting and lotteries are matters under Item 4(l) of the Federal List and not under the State List.
Therefore, the court was duty bound to interfere, and the application for judicial review ought to be granted on the ground of illegality.
Now, it is humbly submitted that R Paneir Selvam fell into error by seemingly listing vape as a matter under the Federal List only.
It is not.
Vape should be a matter under public health, which is a matter under Item 14 of the Federal List as well as Item 7 of the Concurrent List. It is therefore a matter which the Legislature of a State has power to make laws by reason of Article 74(2) of the Federal Constitution.
In other words, the legislative authority of the State can be extended to the subject matter of licensing of premises to regulate the sale, advertising, and promotion of all smoking products, including e-cigarettes and vapes, with a focus on preventing access by individuals under 18.
This despite the federal law, the Control of Smoking Products for Public Health Act 2024 (Act 852) referred to by the learned writer.
The primary goal of Act 852 is to reduce and prevent the use of tobacco and vape products, particularly among minors, and to safeguard public health and the environment.
The explanatory notes of Act 852 in fact states that the enforcement of the Act is the responsibility of the Ministry of Health with support from local authorities. (Read the comments by Health Minister Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad here)
A short response to R. Paneir Selvam is this: vape bans do not stand on the same legal footing as pool betting and lottery bans.
*This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Malaysia's new US ambassador strengthens bilateral ties with Trump
Malaysia's new US ambassador strengthens bilateral ties with Trump

The Sun

time28 minutes ago

  • The Sun

Malaysia's new US ambassador strengthens bilateral ties with Trump

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia's new Ambassador to the United States, Tan Sri Muhammad Shahrul Ikram Yaakob, has reaffirmed his commitment to enhancing Malaysia-US relations during a credentials ceremony with President Donald J. Trump at the White House. The Embassy of Malaysia in Washington, D.C., confirmed in a Facebook post that Muhammad Shahrul Ikram presented his Letter of Credence to Trump on July 24, officially marking his appointment as Malaysia's 18th Ambassador to the US. During the ceremony, Muhammad Shahrul Ikram briefly exchanged pleasantries with Trump, expressing his dedication to deepening bilateral ties. He also thanked the US President for Secretary of State Marco Rubio's participation in the recent 48th ASEAN Foreign Ministers' Meeting held in Kuala Lumpur, which reinforced US engagement in the region. Malaysia-US relations have evolved over six decades into a broad partnership covering political, economic, defence, security, and educational cooperation. Muhammad Shahrul Ikram, a seasoned diplomat with over 35 years of service, previously served as Secretary-General of the Foreign Ministry. He holds a Bachelor of Science in Ecology from Universiti Malaya and completed Harvard Business School's Advanced Management Programme in 2009. His diplomatic career includes postings in Qatar, Austria, and as Malaysia's Permanent Representative to the UN in New York. He has also served in diplomatic missions in Vienna, Washington, D.C., and Beijing. - Bernama

Malaysian International Chamber of Commerce and Industry chairman vows closer collab with government
Malaysian International Chamber of Commerce and Industry chairman vows closer collab with government

Daily Express

time28 minutes ago

  • Daily Express

Malaysian International Chamber of Commerce and Industry chairman vows closer collab with government

Published on: Saturday, July 26, 2025 Published on: Sat, Jul 26, 2025 By: Lorena Binisol Text Size: Susan stressed the importance of engaging closely with members to better understand their challenges and to foster partnerships that drive growth. Kota Kinabalu: Newly elected Chairman of the Malaysian International Chamber of Commerce and Industry (MICCI) Sabah, Datuk Susan Chang, has pledged to strengthen collaboration with the government and relevant agencies to address the concerns of the business community and enhance Sabah's economic ecosystem. Speaking at the Executive Committee luncheon, which attended by Minister of Industrial Development and Entrepreneurship (MIDE), Datuk Phoong Jin Zhe and ministry Permanent Secretary Datuk Thomas Logijin, Susan reaffirmed MICCI's commitment to its advocacy role. She stressed the importance of engaging closely with members to better understand their challenges and to foster partnerships that drive growth. 'We will continue to provide timely economic insights, relevant business intelligence, and support initiatives that promote capacity building and market expansion,' she said. Susan added that MICCI Sabah is committed to strengthening partnerships and economic ties with member countries of the emerging Borneo Economic Community (BEC), comprising nine territories with a collective population of 24 million. Concurrently, she said to remain actively engaged in the Brunei-Indonesia-Malaysia-Philippines East ASEAN Growth Area (BIMP-EAGA), with a focus on empowering SMEs by facilitating seamless cross-border trade and driving regional market expansion. On a separate note, she announced that the 11th Sabah International Expo (SIE) will be held from 3rd to 6th September 2026. The Expo, a State Government-sanctioned event, will continue to serve as a key platform for trade and investment in the region. She also appealed for the continued support of the State Government, particularly from MIDE to ensure the success of the event. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia

Malaysia's New Ambassador To US Pledges Stronger Bilateral Relations
Malaysia's New Ambassador To US Pledges Stronger Bilateral Relations

Barnama

timean hour ago

  • Barnama

Malaysia's New Ambassador To US Pledges Stronger Bilateral Relations

KUALA LUMPUR, July 26 (Bernama) – Malaysia's new Ambassador to the United States (US), Tan Sri Muhammad Shahrul Ikram Yaakob, reaffirmed his commitment to further strengthening the Malaysia–US bilateral relationship during a credentials ceremony with President Donald J. Trump at the White House. In a Facebook post on Saturday, the Embassy of Malaysia in Washington, D.C. stated that Muhammad Shahrul Ikram presented his Letter of Credence to Trump during the Presentation of Credentials Ceremony at the White House on July 24. The ceremony officially marked him as the 18th Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of Malaysia to the United States. bootstrap slideshow 'During the ceremony, Muhammad Shahrul Ikram had the opportunity to briefly exchange warm pleasantries with Trump, conveying his commitment to further strengthen the Malaysia–United States bilateral relationship. 'He also thanked the President for Secretary of State Marco Rubio's participation in the recent 48th ASEAN Foreign Ministers' Meeting and Related Meetings, held in Kuala Lumpur from July 8 to 11, which further reaffirmed the US's commitment to the region as well as the deepening of the Malaysia–US Comprehensive Partnership,' the embassy stated. Over the past six decades since 1957, Malaysia-US's ties have grown into a multifaceted partnership encompassing political, economic, defence and security, educational, and people-to-people cooperation. Muhammad Shahrul Ikram is a former Secretary-General of the Foreign Ministry and a veteran diplomat with over 35 years of service. Born in Pahang, Muhammad Shahrul Ikram holds a Bachelor of Science (Honours) in Ecology from Universiti Malaya and completed the Advanced Management Programme at Harvard Business School in 2009. He began his career at the Foreign Ministry in 1988 as an Administrative and Diplomatic Officer.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store