NSW Premier Chris Minns and Opposition Leader Mark Speakman slam anti-abortion activist Joanna Howe over misinformation, bullying claims
Mr Minns accused campaigner Dr Joanna Howe on Wednesday of spreading an 'enormous amount of misinformation' on social media, but noted he did not blame her for a rumour that consciences objectors would be compelled to perform abortions.
'It's whipped up a lot of good people in the community, believing that the reform changes, the legislative changes, are far more extensive than they are,' Mr Minns said.
'I think that there are genuine differences, particularly when you have a matter as sensitive as abortion.
'It's not helped by putting an enormous amount of misinformation.
'As for threatening politicians about what you will and won't do, well that's a matter for activists. But, generally speaking, Australian politicians, regardless of their background or ideology, react incredibly poorly to that kind of threat.'
Mr Speakman on Tuesday night accused Ms Howe, who is self-described as 'the lead advocate' against the bill, of 'brazen bullying' following an email in which she told the Liberal leader she would halt a campaign targeting Labor seats.
'Should Premier Minns vote for the bill and enable its passage, I will be leading a 20-month campaign across five marginal seats that are currently Labor-held but are also in socially conservative electorates,' Mr Speakman said Ms Howe said.
'However, if you choose to vote for the bill, I will be left with no other choice but to suspend my planned campaign against Labor in order to lead a public campaign aimed at
encouraging a grassroots opposition to you as Liberal leader.'
In response, Mr Speakman said he would 'not cave to brazen bullying like this nor to the Americanisation of NSW politics. I will vote according to my conscience and balance difficult and sensitive ethical, social, moral and medical concerns.
'I thank all constituents who have contacted me. I have carefully considered their sincere and varying views. I will therefore vote for the bill. I think that, on balance, the bill will make no material difference to the rate of abortion in NSW.
'It will not interfere with freedom of conscience and will probably lead to better, not worse, health outcomes for many pregnant women seeking abortions.'
Mr Speakman said some opposition to the bill was 'based on misinformation' and that 'the attacks on freedom of conscience and freedom of religion in the original bill have now been removed by successful amendments.'
The Liberal leader described the bill as a 'shadow of its former self' and could 'no longer be characterised as a 'radical Greens bill'', noting that there was 'no way I could have voted for the bill in its original form'.
Those views were somewhat reflected by Mr Minns on Wednesday.
The Premier told the media he would support the bill 'in its current incarnation'.
'I couldn't have supported the removal of conscientious objection, but it's not in the bill anymore,' he said.
The bill, introduced by upper house Greens MP Dr Amanda Cohn in February, would expand access to abortions by allowing nurse practitioners to supply medication to terminate pregnancies of up to nine weeks in gestation.
It will be voted on tonight in the NSW Legislative Assembly where, if passed, it will become law.
The vote comes after a raft of amendments, including the removal of provisions to empower the Health Minister to compel public health services to comply with directions to offer abortion services and would require practitioners who object to abortion to refer a patient to someone who will perform the abortion.
The bill has stirred fiery debate since it was tabled.
In a parliamentary debate last week, upper house Liberal MP Chris Rath compared abortion to the Nazi genocide of Jews, stating 'it is bizarre that abortion is increasingly being categorised as a human right to health care'.
Mr Rath later apologised for the statement.
In Facebook video on Wednesday, Ms Howe claimed Mr Speakman's speech had been leaked to the media 'because they think it will stop me from speaking', and vowed to publish the email to 'let you guys decide' if she was a 'bully'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
14 minutes ago
- West Australian
CEOs urged to grow China trade, despite coercion threat
Australia's peak business lobby has played down concerns over Chinese economic coercion, saying increased trade between the two nations is actively encouraged. Business Council of Australia chief executive Bran Black said business leaders should continue to pursue diversification as an "inherent good in and of itself" while also strengthening ties with China. Australia's economic reliance on China was exposed during the COVID-19 pandemic, when Beijing imposed restrictions across $20 billion worth of key exports over political grievances with Canberra. At the time, Australia pursued a policy of trade diversification, successfully making up much of the trade shortfall with increased exports to countries such as Japan, South Korea and India. But since a thaw in relations with Zhongnanhai following Labor's election victory in 2022, trade between Australia and China has rebounded. Speaking ahead of Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Beijing, Mr Black said the meeting would set the tone at a business-to-business level and send a signal that further engagement is welcome. But Australian CEOs should still be encouraged to diversify because it was good for business as well as managing risk. "So from our perspective, we say let's try and have the best possible relationship that we can with China. Let's try and make sure that we can establish trade opportunities that help jobs and businesses back home," he told reporters in Beijing. "But let's also concentrate on the engagements that we have overseas with countries like the United Arab Emirates, countries like India, countries like those in Southeast Asia." A risk remains that China could once again resort to economic penalties on Australia in retaliation for political disagreements. Speculation has emerged that Beijing could apply countermeasures if Canberra follows through on its plan to tear up a Chinese-owned company's lease of Darwin Port. An article by a Chinese state media-linked influencer suggested Beijing could restrict Australian imports, including iron ore trade valued at more than $100 billion, in response. Mr Black refused to say whether businesses were concerned about blowback from the Darwin Port decision, backing the government's right to make decisions regarding the national interest. In a press conference on Monday, Mr Albanese said he was not concerned about Chinese retaliation. "We had a very clear position that we want the port to go into Australian ownership," he told reporters in Shanghai. "We've been clear about it, we've been orderly about it, and we will go through that process."
Perth Now
16 minutes ago
- Perth Now
CEOs urged to grow China trade, despite coercion threat
Australia's peak business lobby has played down concerns over Chinese economic coercion, saying increased trade between the two nations is actively encouraged. Business Council of Australia chief executive Bran Black said business leaders should continue to pursue diversification as an "inherent good in and of itself" while also strengthening ties with China. Australia's economic reliance on China was exposed during the COVID-19 pandemic, when Beijing imposed restrictions across $20 billion worth of key exports over political grievances with Canberra. At the time, Australia pursued a policy of trade diversification, successfully making up much of the trade shortfall with increased exports to countries such as Japan, South Korea and India. But since a thaw in relations with Zhongnanhai following Labor's election victory in 2022, trade between Australia and China has rebounded. Speaking ahead of Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Beijing, Mr Black said the meeting would set the tone at a business-to-business level and send a signal that further engagement is welcome. But Australian CEOs should still be encouraged to diversify because it was good for business as well as managing risk. "So from our perspective, we say let's try and have the best possible relationship that we can with China. Let's try and make sure that we can establish trade opportunities that help jobs and businesses back home," he told reporters in Beijing. "But let's also concentrate on the engagements that we have overseas with countries like the United Arab Emirates, countries like India, countries like those in Southeast Asia." A risk remains that China could once again resort to economic penalties on Australia in retaliation for political disagreements. Speculation has emerged that Beijing could apply countermeasures if Canberra follows through on its plan to tear up a Chinese-owned company's lease of Darwin Port. An article by a Chinese state media-linked influencer suggested Beijing could restrict Australian imports, including iron ore trade valued at more than $100 billion, in response. Mr Black refused to say whether businesses were concerned about blowback from the Darwin Port decision, backing the government's right to make decisions regarding the national interest. In a press conference on Monday, Mr Albanese said he was not concerned about Chinese retaliation. "We had a very clear position that we want the port to go into Australian ownership," he told reporters in Shanghai. "We've been clear about it, we've been orderly about it, and we will go through that process."
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
Anthony Albanese praised in editorial in Chinese state media
Anthony Albanese has enjoyed a glowing editorial in a state-owned Chinese newspaper, which welcomed his 'friendly' approach to the nation on his six-day trip. The editorial in the China Daily, however, took a shot at previous prime minister Scott Morrison for not having clear 'judgment and understanding' of the country. Titled 'Common ground prevails over differences', the editorial was published in China Daily, an English-language news organisation owned by the Chinese Communist Party's Central Propaganda Department. The release of the editorial coincides with Mr Albanese's planned meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Beijing's Great Hall of the People. 'Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's ongoing visit to China is not only of significance for the bilateral and trade relations between the two countries, it also sends a message amid the changing global trade landscape,' the editorial started. 'Albanese's visit, which began on Saturday and will last until Friday, is notably long for a state leader, highlighting Australia's commitment to deepening ties and fostering stability amid the uncertain global landscape.' It continued on to highlight rising tensions with the US and makes a point of criticising former prime minister Scott Morrison. 'Albanese's visit shows that the Australian side has a clearer judgment and understanding of China than it had under the previous Scott Morrison government,' it said. Australia's relationship with the superpower soured under the Morrison government after Australia called for an investigation into the origins of Covid. Tariffs were placed on some of Australia's most significant exports to China, including coal, barley, copper and wine. The editorial noted that tension but praised the 'positive upturn' in China-Australia relations under the Albanese government as 'desirable' to restart negotiations on a free-trade agreement. Mr Morrison responded to the comments in a statement made to The Australian. 'Having a character reference from the China Daily was never one of my foreign policy aspirations,' he said. The China Daily editorial highlighted 'difference in terms of geopolitics' between the two nations but welcomed Mr Albanese's trip. 'Albanese's visit, his second since becoming prime minister, is intended as a 'friendly gesture' to ensure the positive development of bilateral relations on a stable track, according to his office,' it said. 'China, on its part, stands ready to work with Australia to take this visit as an opportunity to strengthen communication, enhance mutual trust, expand practical co-operation and push forward the two countries' comprehensive strategic partnership, as the Chinese Foreign Ministry indicated.'
