
‘A moral crisis': how the Sydney writers' festival grappled with the Israel-Gaza war
In February, the chair of the festival board, Kathy Shand, resigned over her concerns about some of the programming related to Gaza and Israel.
Robert Watkins, who replaced Shand as chair, promised the festival would present 'a plurality of voices [and] a diversity of thought' including 'both Jewish and Palestinian writers and thought leaders'.
Guardian Australia attended a number of events related to the conflict to see how the writers' festival covered the ongoing death and destruction, antisemitism, Islamophobia and the feelings of different communities being rejected and sidelined.
Raja Shehadeh – described by the Guardian as Palestine's greatest prose writer – was one of a few writers joining the festival by video link from the region, Zooming in from his home in Ramallah, in the West Bank.
Shehadeh, a human rights lawyer turned writer, has written a number of acclaimed books, including the Orwell prize-winning Palestinian Walks. He was at the festival speaking about his book What Does Israel Fear from Palestine? – a question he answers succinctly in his panel. 'The very existence of Palestine is what Israel fears.'
Describing his daily life, Shehadeh told the audience how Israeli settlers had attacked a nearby Palestinian village, firebombing houses and cars 'with the help of the Israeli army'.
IDF checkpoints made the hill walking he loves difficult but, he said, 'this is nothing compared to what's happening in Gaza'.
'We hear the planes, the jet fighters … they streak through the sky on the way to Gaza to kill more people,' he told Australian writer Abbas El-Zein, who moderated the session. 'And so we cannot complain.'
Ittay Flescher, an Australian Jewish writer, joined the festival via video link from Jerusalem, where he moved with his family from Melbourne in 2018. The audience was warned before the session began that earlier in the evening Flescher had had to evacuate his home because of incoming rockets from Yemen.
Flescher, who is the education director at Kids4Peace Jerusalem, an interfaith movement for Israelis and Palestinians, said a key element in working towards peace was combating the dehumanisation of the other side that has occurred in the region.
'I don't think Hamas could have carried out October 7 without extensive dehumanisation of Jews and Israelis … And what Israel has done in Gaza, not just killing Hamas, but killing so so many innocent men, women and children that were not connected to Hamas … and now the limiting of food into Gaza and the starvation, that can't happen without extensive dehumanisation.'
Peter Beinart, an Jewish-American political commentator, echoed the need for humanisation of the other, and listening to voices across the divides of the conflict in his sold-out event on Sunday.
'Palestinians lack permission to narrate,' he said, echoing the literary great Edward Said.
'There is this process in which, as a Jew, from the moment you can remember you've been talking about Palestinians, but you're never listening to Palestinians or actually meeting with Palestinians. And I think this is a recipe for both ignorance and dehumanisation,' Beinart told Debbie Whitmont.
Beinart said he wrote his recent book, Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza, to try to offer 'a voice that my mind comes from … from love and from Jewish solidarity, to say to the people in my life that I love that I think something has gone horribly, horribly wrong'.
'When I look at what's happening in Gaza, a place where most of the buildings and the schools and the universities and the mosques and the churches and the bakeries and the agriculture have been destroyed, and people have been displaced from their homes … every person I know from Gaza has lost count of the number of people who've been killed,' he said.
'It seems to me this is the most profound chillul hashem, desecration of God's name, that I have witnessed in my entire life, and it will constitute not just a moral crisis for the Jewish people but for those of us who take Judaism seriously.'
At a packed – and occasionally tense – session on Friday morning, the British Jewish barrister and author Philippe Sands and Michael Gawenda, the former editor of the Age, spoke about antisemitism and xenophobia.
Gawenda argued that many Jewish Australians working in the arts had been refused work because of their political stance on Israel.
'They feel like they are being rejected on the basis that they are Jews, Jews of a particular kind. And I think that there's evidence that this is widespread in Australia ... It's widespread in the arts, I'm absolutely convinced of that.'
Gawenda's comments prompted a heated question from an audience member about the experience of Arab-Australians who had missed out on opportunities due to their pro-Palestinian stance, naming Khaled Sabsabi and Antoinette Lattouf as examples.
Sabsabi had been selected as Australia's representative at the 2026 Venice Biennale but was dumped by Creative Australia over past works that involved imagery of Hassan Nasrallah, the now-dead Hezbollah leader, and the 9/11 terrorist attacks.
Of Sabsabi, Gawenda said: 'With his cancellation, there was a huge uproar ... Letters were signed, petitions were signed calling it out, including by Jews who would have been opposed to his views. There were no letters or petitions supporting these young Jewish artists, none. They got no support at all. Lattouf got heaps of support, as she should have. I think it was a mistake what the ABC did.'
Sands, who is a king's counsel, spoke about the risks of a sense of competition between marginalised groups, and of antisemitism being weaponised by politicians for their own political ends.
'The concern about creating the league tables of horror is that it leads to an instrumentalisation of what's going on. And what I really worry about right now is that what's going on is instrumentalising antisemitism for other purposes,' he said.
Tension among the audience was heightened when the first question from the crowd came from a woman asking about the 'Zionist lobby', which she said had put 'its tentacles into everything' – an antisemitic trope that attracted gasps and furious comments from other members of the audience. The question was shut down by the moderator.
For many in Australia with family and cultural ties to the region, art has become a place to express their rage and grief.
The Lebanese Australian writer Sara Haddad, the Lebanese Palestinian poet Hasib Hourani and the Palestinian Australian playwright Samah Sabawi discussed with moderator Micaela Sahhar their texts of home and identity against the backdrop of the Israeli bombardment and blockade of Gaza. All three works were published after 7 October 2023.
Sabawi started writing Cactus Pear for My Beloved, which tells the story of her family's expulsion from Gaza and settling in Queensland over 100 years, in 2016. It was intended as a celebration of her father and her home. By the time she got to writing the author's note, in December 2023, 'a lot of Gaza was fast turning into rubble'.
'My family was on the run, my grandfather's home destroyed. Much of our neighbourhood was gone. And then my father, watching the news, fell and broke his ribs,' Sabawi said. After her father died in 2024, the book 'became an obituary for both'.
Haddad began writing The Sunbird, a novel following a Palestinian woman's memory as a child in the Nakba and then adulthood in Australia, in response to Israel's bombardment of Gaza.
She started her novel in December 2023, after seeing the words written by Dr Mahmoud Abu Nujaila on a whiteboard in his hospital in Gaza: 'Whoever stays until the end will tell the story. We did what we could. Remember us.' Haddad finished the book in January and self-published.
'Watching this for many years … I knew that Israel had what it wanted and what it needed, and it wasn't going to stop. They were not going to stop. And so I knew that I had to do everything I possibly could to speak as loudly as I could.
'I wrote the book very quickly. I had a deadline. I knew it was urgent.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
8 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Ed Sheeran is coming to Australia! Global megastar reveals when his Loop Tour will arrive Down Under
Ed Sheeran is coming to Down Under. The global superstar, who was last here at the beginning of 2023 for his Mathematics Tour, announced on Tuesday via Frontier Touring and MG Live that he would be playing a slew of shows across the country as part of his Loop Tour. The A Team hitmaker is set to tick off New Zealand first, performing at stadiums across Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch, before making his way over the Tasman. Ed will kick of the Australian leg of his tour in Perth at Optus Stadium on January 31, before heading to Sydney 's Accor Stadium for two shows on February 13 and Valentine's Day. Then, the 34-year-old will be heading to Brisbane 's Suncorp Stadium for two shows on February 20th and 21st, followed by two shows at Melbourne 's Marvel Stadium on February 26 and 27. From A-list scandals and red carpet mishaps to exclusive pictures and viral moments, subscribe to the DailyMail's new showbiz newsletter to stay in the loop. Ed will then finish up his tour in Adelaide at the Adelaide Oval on March 5, marking over a month of touring across the country. The tour is set to bring a brand-new live show to Aussie fans, bragging music from his much-anticipated album Play. The album coming out on Friday September 12 this year. The Thinking Out Loud hitmaker let slip in June that he'd be returning to Australia in early 2026 - three years after his record breaking tour Down Under. The British star recently made the casual revelation in a TikTok comment, setting off a frenzy among fans already preparing for the next stadium spectacular. The tour bombshell was picked up by Nova 96.9 radio host Smallzy, who shared the exchange to his Instagram Story with the hilarious caption: 'BRB selling organs to buy concert tickets'. In the now-viral TikTok, a fan asked the singer: 'How does coming back to Australia soon sound to you?' Ed, without skipping a beat, replied: 'Start of 2026'. The tour is set to bring a new live show to Aussie fans, bragging music from his much-anticipated album Play, which is coming out on Friday September 12 this year Telstra Plus Members can access presale tickets from Friday July 25 here, while Frontier Members can access presale tickets from Monday July 28. Tickets go on sale to the general public on Tuesday July 29 here. With smash hits like Shape of You, Perfect and Photograph each pulling in more than two billion Spotify streams, Sheeran remains one of the most successful artists of his generation. He currently boasts 100 million monthly listeners on the platform, making him the third-most followed artist globally. Over the years, the former busker-turned-global superstar has collaborated with music royalty including Adele, Taylor Swift, Justin Bieber and Beyoncé - cementing his place in pop history.


Daily Mail
8 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
IDF launches huge new Gaza air raids and ground operation - as UK joins dozens of other nations demanding Israel end war and condemning 'inhumane killing'
Israel has launched a massive new air and ground operation against the Gaza Strip, targeting the enclave's main hub for humanitarian efforts as the UK joined 28 other nations in demanding the end of the war in the Middle East. As Foreign Secretary David Lammy, along with the foreign ministers of dozens of other western nations, described the suffering of civilians in Gaza as having 'reached new depths', witnesses in Deir al-Balah last night said they saw massive airstrikes. Local medics reported that three people were killed and dozens more were injured as Israeli tanks shelled homes and mosques in the area, in what appeared to be the latest effort to carve up the Palestinian territory with military corridors. The World Heath Organisation, meanwhile, accused the IDF of attacking its staff residence and main warehouse. It is the first time the IDF has pushed into Deir al-Balah, the only Gaza city that has not seen major ground operations or suffered widespread devastation in 21 months of war, leading to speculation that the Hamas militant group holds large numbers of hostages there. The main group representing hostages' families said it was 'shocked and alarmed' by the incursion and demanded answers from Israeli leaders. Israel says the seizure of territory in Gaza is aimed at pressuring Hamas to release hostages, but it is a major point of contention in ongoing ceasefire talks. The UN food agency, meanwhile, accused Israeli forces of firing on a crowd of Palestinians seeking humanitarian aid over the weekend. The Gaza Health Ministry called it one of the deadliest attacks on aid-seekers in the war that has driven the territory to the brink of famine. In the latest sign of international frustration, the United Kingdom, France and 23 other Western-aligned countries issued a statement saying 'the war in Gaza must end now.' They harshly criticized Israel's restrictions on humanitarian aid and called for the release of the 50 hostages remaining in Gaza. The countries in a joint statement condemned what they called the 'drip feeding of aid' to Palestinians in Gaza and said it was 'horrifying' that had been killed while seeking aid. The majority of those killed were in the vicinity of Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) sites, which the United States and Israel backed to take over aid distribution in Gaza from a network led by the United Nations. 'The Israeli government's aid delivery model is dangerous, fuels instability and deprives Gazans of human dignity,' the countries' foreign ministers said in a joint statement. 'The suffering of civilians in Gaza has reached new depths.' The call by about 20 European countries, as well as Canada, Australia and New Zealand, for an end to the war in Gaza and the delivery of aid comes from many countries which are allied with Israel and its most important backer, the United States. Among those calling for an end to the war are four out of five countries in the so-called Five Eyes intelligence-sharing alliance, which includes the U.S. Israel's foreign ministry said the statement was 'disconnected from reality' and it would send the wrong message to Hamas. 'The statement fails to focus the pressure on Hamas and fails to recognise Hamas's role and responsibility for the situation,' the Israeli statement said. Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar later said he spoke with his British counterpart David Lammy on Monday on regional issues, including Gaza. He blamed Hamas 'for the suffering of the population and the continuation of the war'. The U.S. ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee, called the statement 'disgusting' and said blaming Israel was 'irrational' because Hamas rejects every proposal to end the war. Israel's campaign in Gaza has killed more than 59,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza health authorities, with the latest deaths reported on Monday as Israel in central Gaza.


The Sun
8 minutes ago
- The Sun
Horrified MAFS star hits back after cruel troll branded two year old son ‘overweight'
MARRIED At First Sight star Michael Brunelli has hit back at cruel trolls called their two-year-old son "overweight". The fitness trainer, 33, and wife Martha Kalifatidis, 37, found love on season six of the Australian show and welcomed their first child Lucius in February 2023. 4 Michael shared a recent sweet photo of him cuddling their little boy, but one follower posted a comment questioning the toddlers health. They wrote: "You might want to watch his weight. Looks overweight to me." Michael screenshot the shock message and shared it with her fans. He hit back at the person, writing: "Imagine looking at a photo of a toddler and thinking the best course of action is to comment "better watch his weight. "That's not concern,' the father-of-one wrote. 'That's real-life brain rot.' "If you're wired to see a happy, healthy two-year-old and think 'fat', you shouldn't be around children. "Get help. Touch grass. Drink some water. "And keep your projections the f**k away from mine." Michaels fans were quick to write supportive messages to the dad-of-one, while slamming the follower for being inappropriate. One wrote: "Imagine body shaming a literal f**king two-year-old. What's wrong with the world? Bubba is happy and healthy and absolutely f**king gorgeous!" A second posted: "Some people are disgusting. My daughter and I are obsessed with how gorgeous your son is! Well replied." While another follower shared a touching message, writing: "I see love. I see joy. I see beauty." In January, Martha addressed speculation that she was expecting their second child. Taking to Instagram from the family's Thailand getaway - following a two-week-long social media absence - Martha clarified that she and Michael are not expecting another child at the moment. Despite the buzz, the couple are focused on their little one Lucius and enjoying their time as new parents. Alongside some sun-soaked snaps from the trip, Martha wrote: "Hi everyone. Im not pregnant (thanks for asking tho) I was just having some time off in Thailand. It was swell, missed you all." Martha had a tough pregnancy after being diagnosed with Hyperemesis Gravidarum at five weeks. It's a severe morning sickness condition, which was also suffered by Kate Middleton. Martha said at the time: "It hasn't been this exciting, wonderful time for us. I don't want to sound like I'm complaining. "We are so excited, we are so happy, it was a complete surprise. But at five weeks I was diagnosed with Hyperemesis Gravidarum. "Which is severe chronic nausea and vomiting with no relief. It is 24-7. I literally didn't get out of bed for two months." Martha revealed that the horrifying sickness meant she lost ten kilograms in weight in just a matter of weeks. "We have been in and out of the emergency room and hospital," she said, before revealing she was being treated with "life-changing" medication to tackle the nausea. Martha and Michael got together on the 2019 series of MAFS Australia and are one of the few couple that are still together. They join a small number of MAFS stars who have had children with someone they were matched with on the show. Zoe and Alex from series one had a daughter called Harper, before they split up. Jules and Cam from series six had a son called Oliver, and series eight stars Bryce Ruthven and Melissa Rawson have twins, Levi and Tate. 4