Letters to the Editor: water, Israel and lefties
The CDC Southern Water Done Well Decision Meeting today will be a well-attended meeting by the public, I suspect.
Hilary Calvert's opinion piece ( ODT 19.6.25) is a good assessment of the critical issue of water.
The Clutha Council's preferred Jointly Council Controlled Organisation led by Mayor Bryan Cadogan is opposed by the majority of submitters supported by a couple of public groups who have had several meetings and expressed considered opinions through social media.
I along with 24 others gave oral submissions to support our written ones, as requested by our council. The CDC oral submissions delivered the council a strong opposition to CCOs. The mayor's reaction to submitter, Phil Barrett, accusing him of manipulating the process by organising public meetings and helping others with their submissions was astounding ( ODT 26.6.25).
Is the Clutha District under mayor Cadogan a separatist enclave of New Zealand where free speech and freedom of association is not allowed? If the mayor thinks he can operate under authoritarian rules, I suggest he consider an early and immediate retirement. None of their business
Dunedin City Council has no business writing letters to support a party in government backing sanctions against Israel. ( ODT 3.7.25).
They have no business even discussing wars in other countries in council time. This is a personal conscience issue and councillors represent a wide constituency with many personal views on issues of wars across the world.
They are not representing the views of all their constituents, only their own beliefs on the issue. They are also inadvertently forcing members of council to reveal their own beliefs or perhaps vote against their own beliefs if worried this may affect them in the next elections or peer pressure.
Councillors are free to form action groups for world issues they feel strongly about in their own time, not the ratepayers' time. It is their business
Like many, I too shared the anger and utter disappointment reading the letter the mayor sent to the PM and Minister of Foreign Affairs. It was a disgraceful letter.
But I'm writing to let you know that regardless of how many sand bags the Zionists and their accomplices try to stack in an attempt to mend the wall, the massive tides of change are already in motion. No-one can unsee what they witness unfolding in Gaza.
Thankfully the majority of the world's population have a heart and a conscience. Have you seen the millions of people marching around the world? What was once only known to few who dared to look into the occupation is now common knowledge.
Even in Israel/Palestine there are more and more voices refusing to be silenced and bullied any longer.
Manipulate words all you want, it won't change a thing. The seismic shifts are here. You were backing on the wrong horse. Experience matters
I can think of no more compelling argument for at least one term of "councillor" experience, than our present dithering, dismissive, evasive prime minister, completely out of his depth. Of course, at least one term of council experience should be a pre-requisite required of any mayoral candidate, especially given the degree of dysfunctionality and entrenched opposition he, (or she), is likely to encounter. Freedom, fairness and those old-time lefties
Gerrard Eckhoff was correct when he crowed ( ODT 3.6.25) "Whoever said life was meant to be fair other than the good ole boys of the Left."
He will be pleased to see the old lefties have long gone as a political force. Sadly, cheap government housing loans for families on modest incomes went with them. In their place we have a Labour Party leader who asserted proudly that he would ensure food banks remained as part of the infrastructure by funding them.
He still doesn't get it what a massive betrayal of the Left that was. He and the new so-called Left also appear to see nothing wrong in significant numbers of the working poor lining up at food banks, and nothing callous about low-paid workers living in cars and tents in winter because they cannot afford rents. This gross insensitivity appears to be the way the good ole boys on the Right and the phony new boys on the Left want it. Someone said the defining difference between two countries was that America valued freedom where New Zealand valued fairness. But that was a long time ago. Opening fire
How can Future Dunedin fire Rob Hamlin for complaining about karakia and then its leader Andrew Simms comes out against Māori wards and mana whenua on committees.
This is the problem with teams. Members could now be tainted by their leaders' actions whether they agree with it or not. I would not be surprised if this causes division in the ranks given Bex Twemlow came out so strongly against Rob's comments.
Bring back Rob I say, he's been treated unfairly. One rule for the leader, another for Rob. Mayoral candidate — Dunedin
[Andrew Simms and Rebecca (Bex) Twemlow reply: "As a sitting councillor Cr Houlahan should consider applying her efforts to address the problems in front of Dunedin city rather than concerning herself with the machinations of Future Dunedin.
At a recent South Dunedin hui, Cr Houlahan approached me aggressively while I was speaking with residents proclaiming that I was 'wasting my time' advocating for action to deal with flooding in South Dunedin 'because councillors had no power'. .
I fully accept that I do not understand mana whenua's position on representation at the council table, particularly their resistance to a Māori ward for Dunedin and the preference for unelected committee positions instead. My mistake was opening my mouth without a full understanding of Te ao Māori, something I am very keen to understand and learn about. I remain very uneasy about unelected council positions, not just those set aside for mana whenua.
I am committed to Te Tiriti and to improving representation for tangata whenua on council. This includes our promotion of Bruce Ranga, an outstanding representative who should gain a council seat on his own merit.
Andrew Simms, mayoral candidate — Dunedin
Carmen is reaching a new level of ridiculous here. Two facts: Dr Rob Hamlin was removed because his comments were racist and harmful; Andrew Simms isn't against mana whenua or Te Tiriti, his comments were about the structure of representation, not the principles behind it. I stand alongside Andrew 100% and I stand by our decision.
Rebecca (Bex) Twemlow, council candidate — Dunedin.]
Address Letters to the Editor to: Otago Daily Times, PO Box 517, 52-56 Lower Stuart St, Dunedin. Email: editor@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Green shoots ahead for party: Swarbrick
After a turbulent beginning to this Parliament, Greens co-leader Chloe Swarbrick tells ODT political editor Mike Houlahan it is only up from here. "Forged in fire, mate," a chipper Chloe Swarbrick says as she summarises the first half of the parliamentary term from a Green Party perspective. And then some. For a start, she is sitting in the ODT offices speaking as her party's co-leader — a role she did not have at the start of the current Parliament, although many expected she would eventually rise to it. However, Ms Swarbrick replacing the now retired James Shaw was the least troublesome of the many travails which have beset the Greens. The sudden death of Fa'anānā Efeso Collins last February was followed soon after by the prolonged and messy expulsion of former MP Darleen Tana. Then her replacement, Benjamin Doyle, was placed under the blowtorch by New Zealand First leader Winston Peters. And last but not least, for much of this Ms Swarbrick was the solo leader of her party; Marama Davidson requiring time off for breast cancer treatment. "That, unfortunately, is part of being in such a snow globe of public pressure, with the spotlights on. It's not unusual to have circumstances in workplaces where things go awry, but you add to that the level of public scrutiny, which is absolutely due," Ms Swarbrick said. "I knew that, sitting around the caucus table, we had a group of people who were dedicated to a cause that was bigger than something that any one of us could create by ourselves, so I always felt like the team was working together and prioritising that bigger picture. "But in terms of the personal reflections on it all, I mean, like, I didn't really intend to be a politician, I protested so hard, I raged against the machine so hard, but I got inside the machine somehow, right? "What I take from that is, yeah, the way that we tend to conceptualise of leadership is, you know, putting somebody at the top of the pecking order and going, 'That person's going to make all the decisions and have all the glory and all the other things', and the responsibility, obviously, is on the flip side of that coin. "But I've always felt really grounded in a team that I know has my back." It is not unusual for the Green Party to feel out of step with its parliamentary colleagues — an accusation the governing parties are happy to widen out to include the entire country. It has felt more stark than usual this term though, as its MPs have been assailed as being luddite opponents of progress for questioning the need for economic growth and the requirement for natural resources to be dug up to fuel it. While many of those attacks have come from National, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon's gentle urging that the Greens back the fast-track legislation are nowhere near as stinging as Mr Peters adorning the Greens' recently released alternative budget with a Soviet-era hammer and sickle or his NZ First colleague Shane Jones' exhortations to the Greens to not worry about moths or Freddy the Frog and push ahead with mining. If there is such a thing as a philosophic debate in the New Zealand Parliament, these two parties are having it. It can even be intellectual listening once the sloganeering is stripped away from it. "What they are saying is pretty boring, and it misses the mark in terms of the real debate that New Zealanders expect of the people who occupy positions of power to be having," Ms Swarbrick said. "That's part of the reason that we are currently all across the country touring the Green budget and talking to people directly about the things that matter to them, as opposed to waiting for it to be mediated, whether that be through the headlines that we manage to grab or otherwise. "Honestly, the experience of sitting in our chamber of Parliament, particularly under the tenor of toxicity that this government is ushered in, is so far removed from the reality that you experience and you talk to with New Zealanders up and down this country when you're actually on the ground and outside of those walls." The building blocks at the foundation of what will be the Green policy platform for the 2026 election are contained within that alternative budget. It is a beguiling document, opening with pledges of free community healthcare and dental treatment, full funding a new Dunedin hospital, publicly funded early childhood education, free school lunches, a guaranteed income for all, climate action, healthy oceans, a resurgent Jobs for Nature scheme, and a green jobs industrial strategy. But then comes the method of paying for it all — essentially making corporations, and those individuals at the apex of the existing progressive tax system, pay more through introducing a wealth tax (a long-standing Greens policy), an extra tax band at the top end, and hiking business tax. Despite Ms Swarbrick's immediate assertion that 91% of New Zealanders would pay less income tax under her party's plan, it is these revenue-gathering methods that stand her party accused of promoting communism. "Yes, the top 3%, the wealthiest 3% in this country, will pay the wealth tax," she said. "But in doing so, that unlocks the resources which are currently being bound up in unproductive uses, i.e., the likes of property speculation. It also addresses some of the unfairness in our tax system, which the 2023 IRD High Wealth Individuals Report showcased, where the wealthiest 311 households pay an effective tax rate less than half of the average New Zealander. "We currently have a situation where half a million New Zealanders are using food banks every single month; 191 New Zealanders, the majority of them of working age, are leaving the country every single day. "We do not arrest that issue with half measures." The next election is about a year away and, unlike some previous electoral cycles, the Greens have cause to be optimistic. The Greens' polling has held relatively steady — from a record election result high of 11.6%, its current average rating across all public polls is 10.4% — and its caucus now has a more settled look about it. Its southern rookie MPs, Scott Willis and Francisco Hernandez, have performed well and are helping to give the Greens a wider geographic representation than in recent years. It is also doing well in the House, thanks in no small part to the work of the impressively forensic Lawrence Xu-Nan. With three electorate seats and 15 MPs, Ms Swarbrick is adamant the Greens have great potential to grow that vote still further. "I think you're seeing the rise of meaningful progressive platforms like, for example, Zohran Mamdani in New York, who has unified people on the basis of material needs being met," she said. "That stuff is winning. That is a winning formula. And that is the formula that we are going to consistently keep rolling out. "We are talking to people about what really matters, not just poking holes and critiquing, but putting forward those productive solutions, but also mobilising people. "We do things a little bit differently and we are a little bit different, and we try and reflect what modern Aotearoa New Zealand looks like. "Hopefully that means that more people can see themselves in that so-called House of Representatives by virtue of us being there."
Otago Daily Times
4 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
‘Enduring' solutions important, councillors say
The Otago Regional Council building on the corner of Broadway and MacLaggan st. PHOTO: ODT FILES Resource management reform should produce "enduring, consistent and stable" solutions, Otago regional councillors say. The Otago Regional Council this week approved wide-ranging submissions on infrastructure and development, the primary sector, and freshwater management ahead of government reforms of the Resource Management Act and the national policy statements and standards that sit under it. Cr Tim Mepham said he was hopeful the council submissions would help to shape the new national directions. "But I definitely have concerns for our environmental management and the future of our freshwater quality. "I'm pretty happy with the comments that have been made in the submission in regards to the need for cross-party agreement because with the political cycles, to-ing and fro-ing, it doesn't create a lot of certainty." Cr Alan Somerville agreed. "Finding some enduring, consistent and stable solution to all this, so there aren't always changes, is very, very important," he said. The submissions demonstrated the value of local government and bringing together a diverse set of views around the council table, chairwoman Cr Gretchen Robertson said. "We listen to each other, just as we have again today and generally, we do come up with solutions that we all agree with — sometimes we don't, though, and that's fine as well." As well as the direct points the submissions made, the submissions made a "broader point" about the value the regional council provided "in partnership with central government and with mana whenua and with our communities", she said. The council submission on infrastructure and development national directions said infrastructure "in particular" needed a stable regulatory environment to drive investment. However, the submission on the primary sector also addressed the "need for enduring solutions". "Without broad political support for the proposals, there is a risk that future governments will reverse this reform, undermining the commitment of communities, industries, agencies and local authorities to plan their future and buy into actions that achieve the desired outcomes." The council supported moves "to better enable quarrying and mining". Its submission on commercial forestry had been drawn up with community concerns in mind, it said. "ORC is aware of the concerns that exist within Otago's communities about the conversion of large tracts of pastoral farmland into commercial forestry and how this may affect Otago's rural communities." The council submission on freshwater management said "three large overhauls" of freshwater policy — in 2014, 2017 and 2020 — "put considerable financial strain on councils and ratepayers and have disrupted planned or ongoing initiatives". The council also said it did not have a consensus view on whether the controversial concept of Te Mana o te Wai should be retained as the fundamental concept underpinning the national direction for freshwater. The council decided to finalise its submission on "going for housing growth" — a reform package designed to free up land for development and remove planning barriers — after staff had spoken to Otago's district and city councils.
Otago Daily Times
6 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Alley, Quinn to contest mayoralty
Central Otago Mayor Tamah Alley. PHOTO: ODT FILES The race is on with two candidates putting up their hand for the mayoral chains in Central Otago. It will the first election either contestant has faced because sitting mayor Tamah Alley was appointed by her fellow councillors following the resignation of her mentor Tim Cadogan. Mr Cadogan left office at Labour Weekend last year, timing his resignation to avoid a by-election as it was within a year of the next round of local body elections. Mrs Alley, a former police officer and two-term councillor, was appointed by the district councillors at a meeting on October 30. Before being appointed as interim mayor, Mrs Alley was the only Local Government New Zealand zone chair who was not a mayor or deputy mayor. Challenging Mrs Alley is Roxburgh resident Mark Quinn. He is the founder of Challenging Councils — a movement set up to reclaim control over local government decisions and ensure councils are operating in a fair and transparent manner. He could not be contacted yesterday. Mr Quinn's LinkedIn profile says he worked as a self-employed troubleshooting business consultant, as a quotes administrator for Mitre 10 in Rangiora, and as a shellfish manager for Talleys in Motueka before being self-employed for the past 10 years. Currently, Mr Quinn has an almond orchard in Roxburgh. He has been travelling the country holding meetings for Challenging Councils. Challenging Councils' website says it is time for action and to hold councils to account for rising rates and council debt. It says Challenging Councils is not political, incorporated, funded or conspiracy theorists.
