Star Bomber badly injured in Richmond's upset win
In arguably the lowest-quality match of the season on Saturday, the Tigers failed to score a goal in the second and third quarters, but still managed to secure their fourth win of the season.
A clutch goal from Jacob Hopper put Richmond in front midway through the final term, setting up the 6.10 (46) to 4.13 (37) victory.
It was the rebuilding Tigers' first win since beating lowly West Coast on May 11.
After each team kicked three goals in the opening quarter, the standard of the match collapsed dramatically.
Essendon kicked the only goal across the second and third quarters as both teams repeatedly butchered the ball.
No team scored a goal from Richmond ace Jayden Short's major late in the first quarter until midway through the third term, when Essendon young gun Archer May converted a free kick.
"It wasn't the prettiest game, but when we're sitting where we are are and what we're going through on our build, we'll take these wins and celebrate them, because they're really important for our group," Richmond coach Adem Yze said.
Leading by seven points at the final change, Essendon will be ruing a missed opportunity, but also devastated for Martin who has "almost certainly" ruptured his ACL.
The 24-year-old was shoved over the boundary line by Richmond forward Rhyan Mansell, before landing awkwardly.
He was subbed off after hurting his right knee midway through the first quarter
Martin, who was best on ground when Essendon defeated the Tigers in their Dreamtime clash two months ago, looked shattered as he was assessed by medical staff in the rooms.
He sat on the bench for the rest of the match, making his way out to the three-quarter time huddle on crutches.
Essendon coach Brad Scott is fearing the worst for Martin, continuing a miserable run with injury as they are already missing eight of their best team.
Six Bombers, including playmakers Sam Draper, Jye Caldwell and Zach Reid, have already been ruled out for the season.
The Bombers have started investigating why so many players are breaking down, many of them due to repeated soft-tissue injuries.
If scans confirm Essendon's fears, Martin will become the fourth Bombers player to injure his ACL this season, joining Nick Bryan, Lewis Hayes and Tom Edwards.
Tigers star Tim Taranto stood out in a scrappy contest with 34 touches and a goal, while Essendon captain Zach Merrett battled valiantly with 31 possessions.
"It was clearly a terrible game," Scott said.
"The second quarter probably summed it up a little bit.
"It doesn't mean terrible effort, it just means a comedy of errors."
It was Essendon's sixth straight loss, ahead of a Marvel Stadium date with surging GWS on Thursday night.
Richmond have snapped a seven-game losing streak, stunning Essendon by nine points in an MCG scrap where the Bombers lost star ball-winner Nic Martin to a season-ending knee injury.
In arguably the lowest-quality match of the season on Saturday, the Tigers failed to score a goal in the second and third quarters, but still managed to secure their fourth win of the season.
A clutch goal from Jacob Hopper put Richmond in front midway through the final term, setting up the 6.10 (46) to 4.13 (37) victory.
It was the rebuilding Tigers' first win since beating lowly West Coast on May 11.
After each team kicked three goals in the opening quarter, the standard of the match collapsed dramatically.
Essendon kicked the only goal across the second and third quarters as both teams repeatedly butchered the ball.
No team scored a goal from Richmond ace Jayden Short's major late in the first quarter until midway through the third term, when Essendon young gun Archer May converted a free kick.
"It wasn't the prettiest game, but when we're sitting where we are are and what we're going through on our build, we'll take these wins and celebrate them, because they're really important for our group," Richmond coach Adem Yze said.
Leading by seven points at the final change, Essendon will be ruing a missed opportunity, but also devastated for Martin who has "almost certainly" ruptured his ACL.
The 24-year-old was shoved over the boundary line by Richmond forward Rhyan Mansell, before landing awkwardly.
He was subbed off after hurting his right knee midway through the first quarter
Martin, who was best on ground when Essendon defeated the Tigers in their Dreamtime clash two months ago, looked shattered as he was assessed by medical staff in the rooms.
He sat on the bench for the rest of the match, making his way out to the three-quarter time huddle on crutches.
Essendon coach Brad Scott is fearing the worst for Martin, continuing a miserable run with injury as they are already missing eight of their best team.
Six Bombers, including playmakers Sam Draper, Jye Caldwell and Zach Reid, have already been ruled out for the season.
The Bombers have started investigating why so many players are breaking down, many of them due to repeated soft-tissue injuries.
If scans confirm Essendon's fears, Martin will become the fourth Bombers player to injure his ACL this season, joining Nick Bryan, Lewis Hayes and Tom Edwards.
Tigers star Tim Taranto stood out in a scrappy contest with 34 touches and a goal, while Essendon captain Zach Merrett battled valiantly with 31 possessions.
"It was clearly a terrible game," Scott said.
"The second quarter probably summed it up a little bit.
"It doesn't mean terrible effort, it just means a comedy of errors."
It was Essendon's sixth straight loss, ahead of a Marvel Stadium date with surging GWS on Thursday night.
Richmond have snapped a seven-game losing streak, stunning Essendon by nine points in an MCG scrap where the Bombers lost star ball-winner Nic Martin to a season-ending knee injury.
In arguably the lowest-quality match of the season on Saturday, the Tigers failed to score a goal in the second and third quarters, but still managed to secure their fourth win of the season.
A clutch goal from Jacob Hopper put Richmond in front midway through the final term, setting up the 6.10 (46) to 4.13 (37) victory.
It was the rebuilding Tigers' first win since beating lowly West Coast on May 11.
After each team kicked three goals in the opening quarter, the standard of the match collapsed dramatically.
Essendon kicked the only goal across the second and third quarters as both teams repeatedly butchered the ball.
No team scored a goal from Richmond ace Jayden Short's major late in the first quarter until midway through the third term, when Essendon young gun Archer May converted a free kick.
"It wasn't the prettiest game, but when we're sitting where we are are and what we're going through on our build, we'll take these wins and celebrate them, because they're really important for our group," Richmond coach Adem Yze said.
Leading by seven points at the final change, Essendon will be ruing a missed opportunity, but also devastated for Martin who has "almost certainly" ruptured his ACL.
The 24-year-old was shoved over the boundary line by Richmond forward Rhyan Mansell, before landing awkwardly.
He was subbed off after hurting his right knee midway through the first quarter
Martin, who was best on ground when Essendon defeated the Tigers in their Dreamtime clash two months ago, looked shattered as he was assessed by medical staff in the rooms.
He sat on the bench for the rest of the match, making his way out to the three-quarter time huddle on crutches.
Essendon coach Brad Scott is fearing the worst for Martin, continuing a miserable run with injury as they are already missing eight of their best team.
Six Bombers, including playmakers Sam Draper, Jye Caldwell and Zach Reid, have already been ruled out for the season.
The Bombers have started investigating why so many players are breaking down, many of them due to repeated soft-tissue injuries.
If scans confirm Essendon's fears, Martin will become the fourth Bombers player to injure his ACL this season, joining Nick Bryan, Lewis Hayes and Tom Edwards.
Tigers star Tim Taranto stood out in a scrappy contest with 34 touches and a goal, while Essendon captain Zach Merrett battled valiantly with 31 possessions.
"It was clearly a terrible game," Scott said.
"The second quarter probably summed it up a little bit.
"It doesn't mean terrible effort, it just means a comedy of errors."
It was Essendon's sixth straight loss, ahead of a Marvel Stadium date with surging GWS on Thursday night.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
8 hours ago
- West Australian
West Coast chief executive Don Pyke says the Eagles will use every avenue available to improve one-win list
West Coast chief executive Don Pyke has pledged the club will use every lever available to them to improve their list at the end of the season. It comes as the dual premiership Eagle conceded they had 'not won often enough' as they stare down a dire one-victory season for the first time in club history. Pyke addressed the members and fans in an open letter on Wednesday, where he thanked them for their support in another difficult year. The Eagles have won only 11 of their past 86 games since the start of 2022 in the darkest on-field period in the proud club's history. And there doesn't seem to be a return to September action in sight any time soon as they prepare to claim the third wooden spoon. Last year the Eagles traded in Liam Baker (Richmond) and Matt Owies (Carlton), while they also signed Jack Graham (Richmond) as a free agent to bolster their list. They also brought in five players through the national draft — Bo Allan, Jobe Shanahan, Tom Gross, Lucca Grego and Hamish Davis — as well as Malakai Champion as a next generation academy as a category-B rookie and former Gold Coast-listed backman Sandy Brock through the pre-season supplement selection period as part of a massive list overhaul. In his second season as CEO, Pyke said they would once again look to use every avenue at their disposal to improve their list. 'The club will again use every available lever of draft, trade and free agency at the end of the season to strengthen our playing list,' he wrote. 'Pleasingly, our next generation of players are maturing and developing, with Brady Hough, Reuben Ginbey, Elijah Hewett, Harry Edwards and Harley Reid consistently impressing. 'There is plenty to be excited about from recent draftees Jobe Shanahan, Tyrell Dewar, Bo Allan, Tom Gross, Clay Hall, Malakai Champion, Archer Reid and Tom McCarthy who have shown enough in their early opportunities to indicate plenty of good AFL football lies ahead.' Pyke said they backed the path they were on despite the lack of on-field results so far in 2025. 'While we have not won often enough, we have seen encouraging performances, particularly against top four contenders Brisbane, Geelong and Collingwood, and there has been progress,' he said. 'We know we have a lot of work to do to lift ourselves back up the ladder, but we believe in the path we are on and appreciate your support. 'Our new senior coach Andrew McQualter has led the team with commitment and energy, built a strong connection with our players and is establishing a clear style of play. 'While we have not won often enough, we have seen encouraging performances, particularly against top four contenders Brisbane, Geelong and Collingwood, and there has been progress. 'Every game between now and the end of the season is an opportunity to take steps forward and everyone in our football department are determined to get better quickly.'
7NEWS
9 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Adam Simpson ‘was in tears' after infamous 2022 nightclub incident involving Patrick Naish and six others
Former West Coast coach Adam Simpson was brought to tears in the aftermath of the club's infamous COVID nightclub incident in 2022. Seven Eagles players were fined $5000 after being spotted at a Perth nightclub during the late stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, at which point AFL players were living under strict parameters to ensure the competition could run with limited disruption during what was an unprecedented time. WATCH THE VIDEO ABOVE: Pat Naish explains story behind infamous nightclub incident. Pat Naish, Hugh Dixon, Jackson Nelson, Josh Rotham, Jake Waterman, Rhett Bazzo and Campbell Chesser were all sanctioned by the club. At the time, Simpson called it an 'error in judgement'. 'Decisions have been made, sanctions have been laid and now we need to get on with it,' Simpson told 7NEWS Perth after it happened. 'They're very remorseful, obviously it's an error in judgement and we'll move on. 'With the current environment and where we're at, it's just really poor judgement from those boys. 'They've got a bit of trust to earn back from the playing group and the club.' Speaking to new podcast What Could've Been about the incident for the first time, Naish — who moved to West Coast after being delisted by Richmond in 2021 — says he had even let then-Eagles captain Luke Shuey know about the night out in advance. 'It was (Richmond defender) Nathan Broad's engagement party, because he's from WA and so is his partner,' Naish said. 'I got invited to that, and we played Richmond that Friday night, and I reckon it was on a Saturday (the engagement). 'What I thought is that I was just catching up with a couple of Richmond mates for dinner and a couple of beers, and I ended up leaving there at like 10.30pm. It was a harmless night. 'But yeah, got out, left there early, went home, and thought nothing of it. 'And I ran it by 'Boots' (Shuey) before. I was like, 'Mate, don't know if this is all good but I've got a couple of the Richmond boys over, they're over for Broady's, and I've been invited to his engagement party'.' Simpson — who incidentally contracted COVID days later, along with several others at the club — was distraught when he spoke to Naish the next Monday. 'The photo that got leaked was a photo that Hip-E Club actually posted on their Instagram, and it was Jackson Nelson with Liam Baker, Josh Rotham and a couple other boys, and that's how the club found out,' Naish said. 'From there, in WA, it was literally like the biggest news ever. 'I remember we played Brisbane the next week and I was good mates with Cam Rayner, and Cam goes, 'Why are you blokes in trouble?' and I was like, 'Mate, I actually have no idea'. 'I remember we had to go in on the Monday and I walked into Simmo's office, and Simmo was in tears — in tears. 'Because he goes, 'Mate, we found you, we gave you a second life and you've repaid us like this'. 'I reckon I had four beers, like I wasn't even (doing anything bad).' A club statement at the time said the players had disobeyed 'guidelines', but didn't specify that any rules were broken. Naish, who had been given a lifeline by the Eagles earlier that year as a pre-season supplemental selection period (SSP) addition to the list, was delisted at season's end. 'Did it ruin my career? I don't know,' the 26-year-old said. 'I don't think about it much, to be completely honest. 'I enjoyed the first half of the year (in the AFL side) and then enjoyed playing WAFL. 'I went out of my comfort zone moving to WA for a year and lived in Wembley which is a good part of the world. 'But I wouldn't change it to be honest; it was unreal, I met some lifelong friends there, and had some fun along the way.' Naish, the son of former Tigers great Chris Naish was originally drafted as a father-son selection to the Tigers in 2017. He played nine games at Tigerland before being delisted at the end of 2021. He played another 11 games at West Coast in 2022.
News.com.au
a day ago
- News.com.au
AFL 2025: Essendon coach Brad Scott fears the future of big men due to a pair of rule changes
The AFL is at risk of 'breeding out' leaping ruckmen and Essendon coach Brad Scott says scrapping the substitute rule looms as a potential solution. Scott joined the chorus of senior coaches wanting to abort the limited minutes player and move to five players on the interchange. He said ruck rule changes and the need to select a more versatile player as the substitute is minimising the chances of a 'Nic Naitanui type ruckman'. 'We by definition are invested in our clubs and want what's best for our own club (but) I like to think we've all got a broader lens on the good of the game overall,' Scott said. 'What I would like to see is a really strong for and against having a sub, the argument around fairness, I don't see that argument – I didn't see it when I was at the AFL. 'My greatest concern around the sub is it creates all sorts of problem for player load, all sorts of problems for structure and balance of teams. 'I think ruck rule changes, we're very quickly breeding the Nic Naitanui type ruckman out of our game because you can't jump at centre bounces anymore. 'I genuinely can't remember the last time you saw two ruckman jump at each other for the course of a game. 'By having a sub it makes it very hard to have two ruckman, by having five on the bench I think more teams would at least look at it.' Incoming football boss Greg Swann plans to meet with officials about shortening the amount of elapsed time the game is now running for. He believes an immediate ball up instead of waiting for ruckmen to arrive could shorten the game by up to seven minutes. While Scott favours with the craft of ruckmen, he is in favour of an immediate ball up and feels it may also contribute to playing a second tall. 'I think we should just do that instantly, I don't know why we wait, if the ruckman can't get there that's their issue,' he said. 'The reason you can play one ruck is because the umpires wait for the ruck; if he's not there, throw it up. 'There's nowhere in the rules does that says we have to wait for the ruckman to get there, if the ball was thrown up quicker and the ruckman couldn't get there, maybe clubs would think, 'gee maybe we might need two'.
