US judge sides with Meta in AI training copyright case
District Court Judge Vince Chhabria in San Francisco ruled that Meta's use of the works to train its AI model was "transformative" enough to constitute "fair use" under copyright law, in the second such courtroom triumph for AI firms this week.
However, it came with a caveat that the authors could have pitched a winning argument that by training powerful generative AI with copyrighted works, tech firms are creating a tool that could let a sea of users compete with them in the literary marketplace.
"No matter how transformative (generative AI) training may be, it's hard to imagine that it can be fair use to use copyrighted books to develop a tool to make billions or trillions of dollars while enabling the creation of a potentially endless stream of competing works that could significantly harm the market for those books," Chhabria said in his ruling.
Tremendous amounts of data are needed to train large language models powering generative AI.
Musicians, book authors, visual artists and news publications have sued various AI companies that used their data without permission or payment.
AI companies generally defend their practices by claiming fair use, arguing that training AI on large datasets fundamentally transforms the original content and is necessary for innovation.
"We appreciate today's decision from the court," a Meta spokesperson said in response to an AFP inquiry.
"Open-source AI models are powering transformative innovations, productivity and creativity for individuals and companies, and fair use of copyright material is a vital legal framework for building this transformative technology."
In the case before Chhabria, a group of authors sued Meta for downloading pirated copies of their works and using them to train the open-source Llama generative AI, according to court documents.
Books involved in the suit include Sarah Silverman's comic memoir "The Bedwetter" and Junot Diaz's Pulitzer Prize–winning novel "The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao," the documents showed.
"This ruling does not stand for the proposition that Meta's use of copyrighted materials to train its language models is lawful," the judge stated.
"It stands only for the proposition that these plaintiffs made the wrong arguments and failed to develop a record in support of the right one."
© 2025 AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AFP
2 hours ago
- AFP
Posts target former South Korean first lady with misleadingly blurred image
The altered image was featured as the thumbnail of a shared on June 23, 2025. The clip shows Kim holding a blurred object to her mouth, with superimposed text that reads: "Kim Keon Hee chain-smoking in a hospital room" and "[She] continues to chain-smoke." The 25-second video does not contain any footage of Kim smoking. Instead, it features individuals repeating unverified claims that a hospital employee saw Kim smoking after she was admitted to the Asan Medical Center in Seoul on June 16 for what local media described as "severe depression" (archived here and here). Kim is currently under investigation for multiple alleged crimes, including a suspected stock-rigging scheme tied to Deutsch Motors, the receipt of a luxury Dior handbag, interference in candidate nominations ahead of the 2022 parliamentary by-elections, and influence-peddling in a major highway rerouting project (archived here and here). Image Screenshot of the misleading video thumbnail shared on YouTube, with an orange X added by AFP The same video was widely shared by multiple Facebook users critical of Kim. Comments left in the misleading posts indicated several users believed the image genuinely showed Kim lighting a cigarette. "Wonder who captured this video, they must have risked their life," one user wrote. Another said: "Caught red-handed, the hospital should kick her out." The image, however, is not from a hospital room -- nor does it show Kim smoking. A reverse image search on Google found the photo is a manipulated still from news footage published on YouTube on January 11, 2023 by the South Korean broadcaster YTN. In the original footage — timestamped at 1:10:57 — Kim is seen using chopsticks to eat "tteok", Korean rice cake, during a visit to a traditional market in Daegu (archived link). In the doctored version, the rice cake and chopsticks have been obscured and blurred to create the appearance of Kim holding a cigarette. Image Screenshot comparison between the doctored image shared on YouTube with an orange X added by AFP (left) and a corresponding still from the original YTN news footage of Kim's visit to a market in 2023 Kim's visit to the market in Daegu at the time was widely reported by local news outlets, many of which carried similar footage of her eating rice cakes (archived here and here). Newsis, a Korean news agency, also captured a photo of Kim eating a rice cake from a similar angle as the YTN footage (archived link). AFP was unable to independently verify the claim that Kim was seen smoking inside the hospital. No images or video footage have emerged to support the allegation. Kim has frequently been the subject of misinformation online, which AFP has previously debunked. Reality TV show Days after an altered image of Kim Keon Hee circulated, supporters of the rival camp shared a doctored image of First Lady Kim Hea-kyung, falsely claiming it also showed her smoking (archived link). But a reverse image search on Google led to a YouTube video posted by South Korean broadcaster SBS on July 18, 2017 (archived link). The clip is from a 2017 reality TV show that featured the first couple when President Lee Jae-myung was still mayor of the northwestern city of Seongnam. Image Screenshot comparison of misleading post (left) with orange X added by AFP and YouTube video from SBS In the original video, Kim Hea-kyung is holding chopsticks, with the tips lightly touching her mouth. But in the doctored image, her hand and the chopsticks were blurred. Her husband has been a frequent target of misinformation, which AFP has previously debunked here.
France 24
5 hours ago
- France 24
Kenyan women jockey for place at DJ turntables
Kimtai gushed over the skills she learnt on the intensive four-week course at the Santuri Electronic Music Academy (SEMA), which she hopes will help her thrive in a world historically dominated by men. "I can do everything. I can mix, I can beat-match. I can assess the energy level of music," said the 32-year-old aspiring DJ. Established in 2021 and named after the Swahili word for vinyl, the academy sees itself as a hub for musical innovation and inclusion. "Prior to this I was just a lover of music," said Kimtai, whose stage name is "But I wanted to be able to fuse different genres -- travel across different worlds." Carving out a place in the electronic scene remains a challenge for Kenyan women. The organisation that runs the academy interviewed dozens of artists in 2020 for a study and found women were gaining visibility as DJs in east Africa. Yet they remained marginalised and paid significantly less than men, while music production was also male-dominated and training costs too high for many. SEMA has since trained hundreds of people in production, mixing, DJing and other elements of the business. Besides encouraging women and minorities to take part, the academy also raises sponsorship funding for those who need it. "When I started DJing, I would have really liked to have had something like this because the teachers I had were all men," said DJ Shock, who was leading a class on the commercial side of the business during a visit by AFP. She only knew two other female DJs when she started out 20 years ago, and said the men would "gatekeep" the art. "It was a bit of a struggle to get them to share information equally," she said. 'Equal dopeness' At the back of the classroom, speakers were stacked behind a turntable, while trainees tapped away on mixing software in preparation for an imminent final presentation. "We're the people who are going to make spaces get safer for everyone," said Daisy Nduta, 28, a recent sound engineering graduate. She was excited to be DJing live soon under her stage name Naniwho. Santuri organises frequent events for the students to test their skills. "We welcome everybody the same... We put anybody prime time who we feel can do the spot well," said DJ Shock, denouncing the way clubs often relegate women to play the opening slots when audiences are sparse. Things are rapidly improving for women who DJ in Nairobi, however. Women are earning headline slots at major clubs while collectives like "Sirens" organise women-centric events. That success is part of a global pattern. Industry network "female:pressure" says the number of women performing at electronic music festivals rose from just over nine percent in 2012 to 30 percent in 2023. In Kenya, "there are more and more female DJs coming up... They're getting more confident, which I love," said Tina Ardor, who regularly performs at Muze, a Nairobi electro mecca. She said there was still a widespread, often unconscious, favouritism toward men. But the SEMA course, which she did two years ago, is helping to change attitudes. "I'm not a fan of pulling the gender card," said Ardor, hoping the scene soon gets to a point where there is "equal opportunity and equal dopeness" for everyone. © 2025 AFP
France 24
6 hours ago
- France 24
India-Pakistan conflict hits shared love of film, music
The deadly fighting in early May -- the worst in decades -- affected artists previously untouched by animosity between their leaders. Ali Gul Pir, a Pakistani rapper and comedian with a huge Indian following, released a song years ago mocking Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. While he was spared consequences then, in May his YouTube channel and Instagram profile were blocked in India. "Indians now recognise that the digital space serves as a bridge between Pakistanis and Indians, and they seem intent on severing that connection," Pir told AFP. The collapse in bilateral relations was caused by a deadly April attack on tourists in India-administered Kashmir, which New Delhi blamed on Islamabad. Pakistan denied the allegation and, after tit-for-tat diplomatic retaliation, their militaries fought for four days before a ceasefire was reached. The conflict hit the music industry for the first time, with Pakistani singer Annural Khalid also remembering how her Indian following dropped off. "Delhi was my top listening city before the ban," said Khalid, who has 3.1 million monthly listeners on Spotify. "I suffered a great loss in the audience" from India, she told AFP. "Listeners were deprived of content because music was turned into something it is not," Khalid added. The conflict also scrubbed out some prior exchanges, such as the soundtrack of the 2017 film "Raees" on Spotify in India. It now shows only Indian actor Shah Rukh Khan, without his Pakistani co-star Mahira Khan. 'The same traumas' With Pakistan producing just a handful of movies each year under strict censorship rules, Bollywood has always proven popular among viewers. "I grew up watching Bollywood. We have the same traumas, we have the same history, we have the same stories," said Pakistani film critic Sajeer Shaikh. Pakistani actors and directors have for decades seen making it to Bollywood as the ultimate recognition. But this month, Indian star Diljit Dosanjh announced his latest movie, "Sardaar Ji 3", which features four Pakistani actors, would be released "overseas only", after New Delhi banned Pakistani content and artists from productions. "Abir Gulaal", a love story starring Pakistan's Fawad Khan and Indian actor Vaani Kapoor, was scheduled to hit Indian cinemas on May 9 but the release was postponed. Even some in the industry who had previously backed the cross-border artistic trade changed their tune last month. "Everything should be banned... cricket, films, everything," said Indian actor Suniel Shetty, who has a big fan following in Pakistan. He starred in the 2004 movie "Main Hoon Na", which subtly promotes peace between India and Pakistan. "It's something really unfortunate about politics, creating that rift and putting boundaries around art," said Dua Zahra, assistant manager at Warner Bros South Asia's music label in Pakistan. 'Let's just make art' As part of its measures in the wake of the Kashmir attack, New Delhi's ban on some Pakistani YouTube channels included private broadcaster HUM TV. The channel, which says around 40 percent of its viewers are from India, simply told its fans to use a VPN to continue watching. Since Modi took office more than a decade ago, many Indian critics and filmmakers have warned that Bollywood is now increasingly promoting his government's Hindu nationalist ideology. While the conflict has created divisions on the cultural scene, there are signs that the trade will endure. Over a month after the ceasefire, three Indian films were in the top 10 on Netflix Pakistan, while the top 20 trending songs in India included two Pakistani tracks. Pir, the rapper and comedian, vowed to "bridge gaps". "Let's not make war, let's just make art," he said. "Let's just not bomb each other." © 2025 AFP
