Fantasy baseball: Stashing prospects can be solid strategy — but don't bank on it
Prospect fever is real. Every season, fantasy baseball managers scour minor league boxscores and prospect rankings in hopes of discovering the next big breakout star before anyone else.
Though this strategy can pay off, stashing rookies on your fantasy roster is trickier than it seems — especially when roster spots are limited and immediate playing time isn't guaranteed. Talent alone isn't enough, opportunity is just as important.
Take, for instance, top prospect Matt Shaw.
He is loaded with upside, but what makes him an appealing stash is his clear path to at-bats.
An infielder in the Cubs organization, Shaw has surged through the system and is knocking on the door with little in his way at second base or third, depending on team needs.
Matt Shaw hits a single in the ninth inning of the Cubs' road loss to the Nationals on June 5, 2025.
AP
When a rookie's timeline aligns with organizational need, stashing makes sense — even if the player is not on the roster yet.
Nevertheless, many prospects, even those producing elite numbers in Triple-A, are stuck behind established big leaguers. Case in point: Jordan Lawlar.
Lawlar, one of the most talented young infielders in the game, is raking at Triple-A Reno. His numbers are fantasy gold — .339/.419/.583 with seven home runs, 37 RBIs and 13 stolen bases.
But there is one big problem: There is no room for him in Arizona's infield. Ketel Marte is an All-Star at second, Geraldo Perdomo is quietly excelling at shortstop, and Eugenio Suárez remains a productive veteran at third.
Lawlar's recent eight-game MLB call-up underscored the issue — he barely saw the field and was quickly sent back to the minors.
As long as the Diamondbacks remain healthy and competitive, Lawlar's fantasy impact will remain limited — regardless of how ready he looks in the minors.
Roman Anthony runs to first base during a Red Sox spring training game against Mexico's Sultanes on March 24, 2025.
AFP via Getty Images
Another prime example is Red Sox outfielder Roman Anthony. The 20-year-old is drawing attention with his high OBP and emerging power — .291/.422/.485 with nine homers and three steals at Triple-A Worcester.
From a raw talent perspective, Anthony looks like a future star. But Boston's outfield is crowded. Ceddanne Rafaela is a regular in center field, Wilyer Abreu is playing well in right, and Jarren Duran has secured left field.
Unless the Red Sox make a trade, shift Rafael Devers to first base (which opens up the DH spot or third), or move Rafaela to shortstop (pushing Trevor Story off the field), there is no room for Anthony to see regular big league at-bats.
In redraft leagues, wasting a roster spot on a stash with no clear timetable for promotion is dangerous. Roster flexibility is critical, especially during the long grind of the fantasy season, when injuries and slumps require constant adjustments.
Learn all you need to know about MLB Betting
The bottom line: Fantasy managers need to weigh not just talent but opportunity. Stashing a prospect like Matt Shaw? Go for it. But holding onto Jordan Lawlar or Roman Anthony in standard formats may do more harm than good — at least for now.
Howard Bender is the head of content at FantasyAlarm.com. Follow him on X @rotobuzzguy and catch him on the award-winning 'Fantasy Alarm Radio Show' on the SiriusXM fantasy sports channel weekdays from 6-8 p.m. Go to FantasyAlarm.com for all your fantasy baseball news and advice.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
2 hours ago
- Washington Post
Los Angeles Sparks riding hot start as 2nd half of season is underway
NEW YORK — No team has been playing better since the All-Star break than the Los Angeles Sparks and they've been doing it with a stellar offense. The Sparks won five straight games, including three on the road, before falling at home to Las Vegas on Tuesday night. It's only the third time in the past five years that Los Angeles has won five or more games in a row. The Sparks had a nine-game winning streak in 2020 and a six-game one in 2023.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Expert roots for Knicks to sign sharpshooting West forward
An insider is rooting for the New York Knicks to ink a still-unsigned free agent sharpshooting Western Conference forward to a new contract. The Knicks have been relatively steady during the offseason in terms of on-court changes. Instead, the big transition was ownership's decision to fire head coach Tom Thibodeau and install another former two-time Coach of the Year, ex-Sacramento Kings head coach Mike Brown. After a stint as an assistant coach on the Golden State Warriors, Brown has demonstrated far more offensive flexibility than Thibodeau generally did, and could help open up New York's offense a bit. Under Thibodeau, two-time All-NBA Second Team point guard Jalen Brunson has been leaned on heavily as the club's offensive fulcrum. With a possibly more egalitarian approach from Brown, five-time All-Star center Karl-Anthony Towns — and maybe even All-Defensive Team wing Mikal Bridges — could get far more touches. The Knicks did add two solid rotation pieces in free agency this summer, without losing anyone. New signings Guerschon Yabusele, a power forward, and combo guard Jordan Clarkson should be able to contribute right away. Michael Pina of The Ringer proposes that New York consider adding a little more shooting help on the perimeter. Pina advocates for several contenders — including the Knicks, the Golden State Warriors and the Miami Heat — to consider bringing aboard free agent L.A. Clippers forward Amir Coffey. "Coffey is 28 years old and 6-foot-7 and can't be left alone behind the arc," Pina writes. "He's consistent, understands his limitations, and was the longest-tenured Clipper other than Kawhi Leonard and Ivica Zubac before the club decided to go in a different direction." Pina notes that the Clippers do have an opening on their standard 15-man roster for Coffey, but bringing him in would move L.A. into the league's first luxury tax apron. "Bottom line: This is a dependable NBA rotation player. Why don't the Golden State Warriors sign him? Or the New York Knicks? Or the Miami Heat?" Pina wonders. "A good team should sign him." Across 72 contests for a pretty good 50-32 Clippers squad, Coffey averaged 9.7 points on .471/.409/.891 shooting splits, 2.2 rebounds and 1.1 assists a night. The fact that he's remained unsigned this long is a bit surprising. MORE NEWS:Knicks predicted to sign 6-foot-9 veteran big, former Karl-Anthony Towns teammate
New York Times
3 hours ago
- New York Times
Ask anyone what Ryne Sandberg meant to the Cubs and Chicago
CHICAGO — 'What did Ryno mean to you?' Late Tuesday afternoon, 670 The Score host Laurence Holmes began his show's interview of Cubs legend Andre Dawson with that simple question about the late, great Ryne Sandberg. Dawson went quiet. He said he needed a minute to collect himself, and his silence spoke volumes. It was raw, uncomfortable radio. Advertisement 'Ryno was everything to me,' Dawson said. 'You're talking about, right there at the top, one of my all-time favorite teammates. You know, he was like a brother.' 'What did Ryno mean to you?' It was the same question I asked a 66-year-old Cubs fan named Jim Rodgers, who was standing by Sandberg's statue outside of Wrigley Field earlier in the day. 'He meant everything,' said Rodgers, who drove down from suburban Round Lake because he hadn't seen the statue in person since it was unveiled last summer. 'MVP in '84, how many gold gloves he had, he was one of the best.' Dawson knew Sandberg intimately. Rodgers watched him on TV. Sandberg, who passed away from prostate cancer on Monday, was different things to different people. To Cubs fans, he was a legend. That's why they took pictures of the statue on Tuesday. That's why they dropped off flowers and hats and jerseys. That's why they've named their dogs and kids Ryne or Ryno over the last 40 years. To those who really knew Sandberg, he was a husband, a father, a teammate, a friend, a mentor, and yes, he was a hero to them too. But to those who knew him and to those who just worshipped him, it seems like Sandberg meant about the same. That is to say, everything. For Ned Colletti, who would go on to a storybook career in baseball, Sandberg was his first up-close look at a baseball legend. A few years after they both started working for the Cubs — Colletti in the media relations department and Sandberg in the middle infield — Colletti was sitting in the TV booth with NBC's Bob Costas and Tony Kubek. It was June 23, 1984, and you know what happened next. 'From that moment on, I mean, it was like an explosion of interest in him,' Colletti said in a phone conversation from London, where he's teaching a class for Pepperdine University. 'I'm working in PR, so you know, you've got a lot of things to figure out, and he was a reluctant hero. He did whatever we asked him to do, but it wasn't like he was seeking it out. 'Hit me a thousand ground balls, I'd rather do that and stand in front of a microphone.' But he made it to the All-Star Game. And from then on … he was terrific.' Advertisement To Colletti, a child of Chicago who grew up in the Wrigley Field bleachers, the impact Sandberg had on the team was immeasurable and he traces it all back to that moment in 1984 when Sandberg burst onto the national scene with two game-tying homers off Cardinals closer Bruce Sutter. 'I mean no exaggeration by this,' Colletti said. 'I don't know if one game has ever changed a career as much as that game did. But he just kept at it.' Colletti said he and Sandberg hit it off early and their friendship stayed strong even in the later years, when he changed jobs in the Cubs front office as he charted a path to being a general manager. In the spring of 1992, Sandberg and the Cubs were working on a contract extension and Colletti was in the middle of some complicated negotiations between Sandberg and the Tribune Company. They wound up getting a deal done that made Sandberg the highest-paid player in baseball. Colletti was fired by GM Larry Himes a few days after Christmas in 1993. The next year, Sandberg retired in mid-June. Colletti's career then took off in San Francisco, and he eventually became the GM of the Los Angeles Dodgers. Sandberg, of course, returned to play baseball for two years before retiring for good. The two remained friends. One night during the pandemic when everyone was home watching TV, Colletti flipped to MLB Network and found 'The Sandberg Game.' He called up Sandberg and told him to turn it on. 'So we watched the rest of the game, going pitch by pitch. I mean, it was so much fun,' Colletti said. 'He comes up against Sutter and I say, 'I think this guy's going to get him right here.' And he goes, 'I don't know. He's kind of a weak-hitting second baseman. What could he do against Bruce Sutter with that splitter?'' For Darwin Barney, Sandberg was the mentor he needed in the minor leagues. Sandberg was Barney's first manager in Class-A Peoria in 2007. Sandberg managed him again in Double-A Tennessee in 2009 and once more in Triple-A Iowa in 2010. (He also was a hitting coach for Barney in the Arizona Fall League.) Advertisement Sandberg was new to coaching, let alone managing in 2007. And Barney could see the seams a little bit with how the Hall of Famer was adjusting to the role. Communication didn't always come naturally, but passion did. 'As a manager, you could always see how baseball lit him up,' Barney said in a phone conversation Tuesday. And that's why Barney never got tired of moving up the ladder with Sandberg. 'I remember going into a season with him as my manager and I had weird feelings of wanting to go to battle for him,' Barney said. 'Like excitement for the season to get to play for him. I would say it's more of a college-type feeling of wanting to go to war with this guy. … So obviously, we had that relationship and I just always felt like he was in my corner.' Never more so than in 2010, when the Cubs called up Starlin Castro from Double A to play shortstop. Barney, who was putting together a sterling season in Iowa, was obviously disappointed. And that's when Sandberg took charge. 'Ryno came up to me and said we're going to work at second base every day,' Barney said. Barney still started at shortstop, but before every game, Sandberg drilled him at second until he got the hang of it. In mid-August, Barney made his big-league debut at second base. People wondered why Sandberg went into managing. Was he bored? Was it ego? Maybe, but Barney thinks Sandberg just wanted to give something back to the game. And so he did. In 2012, Barney won a Gold Glove at second base with the Cubs, just like Ryno. 'I felt like he was proud of what I accomplished, because he was a big part of that as well,' he said. 'It's hard to say I would have gotten where I got in my career without Ryne Sandberg.' For Shawon Dunston, Sandberg was his polar opposite, and that was just what he needed. 'If I had a second baseman that played like me, we wouldn't have gotten nothing done,' the former Cubs shortstop said in a phone conversation Tuesday. Dunston was a mile-a-minute talker and an electric, sometimes erratic shortstop. Meanwhile, Sandberg was Sandberg. Advertisement 'I had a Hall of Famer next to me and he didn't talk much,' Dunston said. 'He just told me certain things, what to do, what not to do. And he just delivered.' When Dunston got the majors in 1985, he was already well-versed in what kind of player Sandberg was. After all, he got WGN-TV in Midland, Texas, and Des Moines, Iowa, the year before. In person, he quickly realized Sandberg was the real deal. 'When you have a superstar in Ryno that's never bragging and acting like one of us, that's very nice,' Dunston said. 'It's very comfortable to be around a guy like that.' The two formed an exciting double-play combination and even made the All-Star Game together in 1990 at Wrigley Field. When Sandberg upstaged the big boppers in the Home Run Derby, it was Dunston who was doing the bragging because it was his teammate. (Sandberg hit a whopping three home runs in a wind-ruined contest to beat Jose Canseco.) They wound up hitting 57 homers that season, a record for a Cubs double-play combination. Sandberg hit 40 of them. 'They used to tease me, 'Shawon, come on now, you've got to swing it a little bit more,' Dunston said. 'I said, I'm trying, but you know what, man, it's OK, Ryne will take over.' Dawson got to the Cubs in 1987, and Dunston found himself in the locker between two of the quietest stars in the game. The three became close friends, the kind that transcends clubhouses. Mark Grace and Shawon Dunston surprise Ryno at spring training 💙 — Marquee Sports Network (@WatchMarquee) February 15, 2025 A little less than two weeks ago, they found themselves on a three-way phone call. Sandberg wanted to talk to them. They knew he was suffering from prostate cancer, but he didn't want to talk about it. He was asking them how they were doing. He wanted to know when the Cubs would induct Sammy Sosa and Derrek Lee into the team's Hall of Fame. Dunston told him it would probably be in September. Advertisement 'So he said, 'Let's get together then,' and we spoke and spoke,' Dunston said. 'And then he said, 'The Cubs are on right now, so I'm gonna go watch the Cub game. Before I go, you guys take care. I love you like my brothers and I really appreciate you.'' As they processed that, Sandberg's daughter got on the phone and informed the two that her dad wasn't going to make it to Wrigley again. He was going into hospice. This call was to say goodbye. They were devastated then. They are devastated still. Dunston said he talked more to Sandberg in the last three years than he did for the decade-plus they played together. Everyone noticed how Sandberg opened up as he got older and they all got a kick out of it. But when Sandberg told Dunston and Dawson how much he cared about them, it surprised them, even if shouldn't have. 'Most of us men don't know how to express ourselves to each other and say, 'I love you,'' Dunston said. 'It doesn't sound right. But, you know, as the years go on, it sounds really good. I really appreciate he told me he loved me. I think that was more important he told me that than he loved being my teammate or double-play partner. That meant a lot to me.' You could say it meant everything.
