Social media and U-16s
The Senate is considering a groundbreaking bill to ban social media access for children under 16, citing mental health risks, cyberbullying and predatory content. The bill would impose fines up to Rs5 million on non-compliant platforms and even jail time for adults aiding minors in setting up or using social media. But while safeguarding youth is a laudable goal, this proposal suffers from fatal flaws in enforcement and overreach, risking privacy and digital rights.
Proponents rightly argue that social media exposes children to several harms, including anxiety and depression, vulnerability to exploitation and distraction from studies. The bill also aligns with global steps such as Australia's recent under-16 ban and the EU's General Data Protection Regulation, which mandates parental consent for minors to use several types of online services and products, including social media.
The problem, however, is that the mechanics of age verification pose severe practical and ethical challenges. Requiring platforms like TikTok or Instagram to authenticate ages could force 16-year-olds to submit government IDs or biometric data. As seen in EU trials, such systems create honeypots for hackers and normalise surveillance. Meanwhile, Pakistan's own history of internet bans has made almost everyone familiar with VPNs.
Tech-savvy teens will almost certainly find ways to circumvent age gates whenever they want. At the same time, PTA would need to audit millions of accounts — a herculean task for an agency already struggling with enforcing politicised censorship under PECA and related laws. The bill also overlooks nuances such as parental autonomy. Many argue that monitoring children's online activity should rest with families, not the state.
Instead of unenforceable prohibitions, the government should invest in digital literacy programmes for schools and parents, including encouraging family rules for responsible social media use, and work with platforms and international partners to encourage platform accountability via transparent content moderation.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Oil prices edge lower with trade talks in focus
LONDON: Oil prices fell for the fourth consecutive session on Wednesday, as investors assessed trade developments including a U.S. tariff deal with Japan ahead of a U.S. stocks data announcement. Brent crude futures were down 50 cents, or 0.7%, at $68.09 a barrel as of 1119 GMT. U.S. West Texas Intermediate crude futures were down 47 cents, or 0.7%, at $64.84 per barrel. Both benchmarks lost about 1% in the previous session after the EU said it was considering countermeasures against U.S. tariffs. U.S. President Donald Trump said on Tuesday that the U.S. and Japan had struck a trade deal that included a 15% tariff on U.S. imports from Japan. 'The slide (in prices) of the past three sessions appears to have abated but I don't expect much of an upward impetus from news of the U.S.-Japan trade deal as the hurdles and delays being reported in talks with the EU and China will remain a drag on sentiment,' said Vandana Hari, founder of oil market analysis provider Vanda Insights. The European Commission plans to submit counter-tariffs on 93 billion euros ($109 billion) of U.S. goods for approval to EU members, while the Commission's primary focus is to achieve a negotiated outcome with the United States to avert 30% U.S. tariffs. Investors are awaiting U.S. oil inventory data from the Energy Information Administration later on Wednesday. In another bullish sign for the crude market, the U.S. energy secretary said on Tuesday that the U.S. would consider sanctioning Russian oil to end the war in Ukraine. The EU on Friday agreed its 18th sanctions package against Russia, lowering the price cap for Russian crude. On the physical supply side, Azeri BTC crude oil loadings from the Turkish port of Ceyhan resumed on Wednesday, after increased checks linked to a contamination issue delayed loadings in recent days, several industry sources told Reuters.
Business Recorder
7 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Finance minister lauds CCP's for ‘reducing pending court cases'
Federal Minister for Finance Muhammad Aurangzeb expressed satisfaction over the performance of the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP), saying the commission's had brought significant improvements, particularly in reducing the number of pending court cases. Addressing the Senate, the finance minister requested the chairman Senate Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue, to invite Dr Kabir Sidhu, Chairman CCP, for a detailed briefing to appreciate the true extant of reforms undertaken by the commission. He informed the house that over the past two years, the CCP's new management actively pursued litigation in various courts, which resulted in reducing the backlog of cases from 577 to approximately 300. Responding to a motion moved by Senator Mohsin Aziz, the minister emphasised that a transparent and robust regulatory framework is essential in a market-based economy to foster competition and ensure accountability. In this context, he highlighted CCP's recent performance as crucial and deserving of support. He shared that the CCP issued 11 major orders in the past year alone, imposing fines exceeding Rs1 billion. Of this amount, approximately Rs120 million has already been recovered. The inquiry process has been expedited, the issuance of show-cause notices has become more efficient, and the overall hearing mechanism has improved to ensure timely action against violators. The minister further stated that CCP's Cartels Department completed 20 inquiries during the current fiscal year, while the Office of Fair Trade finalised 13 investigations related to misleading advertisements and deceptive marketing. These investigations have led to the issuance of show-cause notices and the initiation of formal hearings, he said. He also informed the Senate about the establishment of a dedicated Market Intelligence Unit within the CCP, which proactively monitors market distortions, price manipulation, and other potential violations of competition law. The minister said that the unit has so far identified 170 potential violations across sectors such as banking, e-commerce, telecom, and real estate, with 28 inquiries already initiated. CCP tells Aurangzeb: 23 major actions taken against cartels and cos Highlighting the CCP's role in facilitating investment, he said that the commission Mergers Department approved 69 transactions during the current year, resulting completion of transactions worth $30 million in foreign direct investment (FDI). Moreover, the Exemptions Department granted 83 exemptions, helping to ease business operations. He added that a Centre of Excellence has also been established within the Commission to conduct research and data-driven analysis of various market sectors.
Business Recorder
12 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Oil rises on Japan trade deal and stronger demand indicated by US inventories
BEIJING: Oil prices steadied in early trading on Wednesday after falling for three consecutive sessions as a U.S. trade deal with Japan signaled progress on tariffs and a poll showed U.S. crude stockpiles fell last week, indicating stronger demand. Brent crude futures rose 33 cents, or 0.48%, to $68.92 a barrel by 0023 GMT. U.S. West Texas Intermediate crude futures rose 33 cents, or 0.51%, to $65.64 per barrel. President Donald Trump said on Tuesday that the U.S. and Japan had struck a trade deal that includes a 15% tariff on U.S. imports from Japan. He also said Japan had agreed on $550 billion in investments in the U.S. Oil had fallen in the previous session after the EU said it was considering countermeasures against U.S. tariffs, as hope faded for a deal ahead of the August 1 deadline. And U.S. crude oil stockpiles were expected to have fallen last week, along with distillate and gasoline inventories, an extended Reuters poll showed on Tuesday. Nine analysts polled by Reuters ahead of weekly inventory data estimated on average that crude inventories fell by about 1.6 million barrels in the week to July 18. U.S. crude and gasoline stocks fell last week while distillate inventories rose, market sources said, citing American Petroleum Institute figures on Tuesday. In another bullish sign for the market, the U.S. energy secretary said on Tuesday that the U.S. would consider sanctioning Russian oil to end the war in Ukraine. The EU on Friday agreed its 18th sanctions package against Russia, lowering the price cap for Russian crude. But analysts said a lack of U.S. participation would hinder the effectiveness of the package.
