logo
Iraq's Provincial Councils: Dysfunctional return deepens public disillusionment

Iraq's Provincial Councils: Dysfunctional return deepens public disillusionment

Shafaq News4 days ago
Shafaq News
Eighteen months after Iraq reinstated provincial councils through elections held in December 2023, what was intended as a milestone for local democratic renewal has instead descended into institutional paralysis. Across the country, these councils—originally designed to decentralize authority and improve service oversight—are now widely seen as symbols of political infighting, legal uncertainty, and eroded public trust.
The councils' revival followed a decade-long suspension, but their comeback has been marred by opaque power arrangements and factional dominance. The result: a system that privileges political quotas over citizen representation, and where council decisions often reflect elite rivalry rather than local needs.
From Oversight to Gridlock
In the immediate aftermath of the 2023 elections, nearly every provincial council struggled to form a working majority or elect key leadership. In many cases, the absence of binding performance standards allowed dominant blocs to assert control through informal negotiations. Rather than functioning as local watchdogs or policy facilitators, councils became arenas of partisan competition.
'Provincial councils have turned into an empty loop that feeds corruption,' said independent MP Hussein al-Saabri. 'There's little effective governance, and public services are stagnant.' His concern is echoed by Babylon council member Hussein al-Dahmooshi, who attributed the dysfunction to Iraq's entrenched quota system. 'Any decision not backed by powerful blocs simply fails,' he noted, adding that independents are often marginalized.
Former MP Mazen al-Faili warned that repeated institutional failures were accelerating the erosion of citizen trust: 'There's poor oversight from both the councils and Parliament. This has allowed corruption to take root.'
Baghdad: Legal Battles and Power Struggles
In Baghdad, months of internal discord have highlighted the legal ambiguity and partisan friction plaguing Iraq's largest provincial council. Early in 2025, the council voted to dismiss Governor Abdul-Muttalib al-Alawi on grounds of retirement eligibility—a justification the governor rejected. While the Administrative Court initially upheld his removal, the State of Law Coalition challenged the process, accusing the council chairman of overreach. Weeks later, the council moved to dismiss the chairman himself, Ammar al-Qaisi. That decision, too, was reversed by the court, deepening the governance stalemate.
In July 2025, the Ishraqat Kanoon bloc expelled its only council representative, Hussein al-Khuzai, over alleged violations of party discipline. Separately, the National Resolution Coalition withdrew from the Baghdad Bloc, citing political deviation.
Kirkuk: Fragile Balances Collapse
In Kirkuk, ethnic and political tensions have destabilized the post-election landscape. In August 2024, a controversial session held in Baghdad—boycotted by the Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) and several Arab lawmakers—resulted in the appointment of Ribwar Taha as governor and Mohammed Hafiz as council chairman. Though the Administrative Court upheld their appointments in early 2025, the session's legitimacy remained in dispute.
A power-sharing pact, intended to balance Kirkuk's Kurdish, Arab, and Turkmen constituencies, collapsed in May when two Arab council members withdrew from the ruling coalition, accusing partners of violating the agreement. Although they retained their seats, their withdrawal effectively ended any pretense of consensus governance.
Saladin and Diyala: Court Rulings Ignored
In Saladin, the appointment of former governor Ahmed Abdullah al-Jubouri (Abu Mazen) in February 2024 triggered a deadlock between provincial and federal authorities. Despite his amnesty, the Iraqi Presidency refused to issue a formal decree confirming his return due to prior convictions. Local tribal and political factions backed the council's decision, but the impasse remains unresolved.
Further tensions arose when the council voted to dismiss its chairman, Adel al-Sumaidaie, replacing him with Ali al- Kareem. The Administrative Judiciary Court later invalidated al-Kareem's appointment, reinstating al- Sumaidaie. However, the conflict revealed a deeper institutional weakness: political blocs often ignore or delay implementing court decisions, undermining judicial authority.
Diyala presents a similar picture. Repeated efforts to remove the council president have led to a cycle of court-mandated reinstatements, which the majority of council members have refused to honor. The result is near-total administrative paralysis and a growing perception that the rule of law is selectively applied.
Dhi Qar, Najaf, and Al-Diwaniyah: Corruption Allegations and Resignations
In Dhi Qar, the dismissal of Governor Murtadha al-Ibrahimi in early 2024 deepened long-standing internal divisions. Rival factions within the council have failed to agree on a successor, leaving key administrative and budgetary decisions in limbo.
In Najaf, a senior council member resigned in April 2025 amid accusations of misconduct in awarding public contracts. In Al-Diwaniyah, citizen protests erupted over claims that council members colluded with contractors to inflate project costs. The backlash prompted a judicial investigation and the temporary suspension of several officials.
Rooted in Quotas, Not Service
Political analyst Nawal al-Mousawi traced the dysfunction back to the quota-based system used to distribute council seats and executive roles. 'Since their inception, these councils have operated under a partisan logic that undermines transparency,' she told Shafaq News. 'The conflicts are more about political positioning ahead of national elections than about public service.'
Al-Mousawi also emphasized that the councils' return, after a ten-year suspension, has failed to bring lessons learned. 'Rather than reforming themselves, they've reverted to the same practices that led to their previous abolition. This illustrates how entrenched institutional stagnation has become.'
A Crisis of Democratic Legitimacy
At its core, the crisis in Iraq's provincial councils is not just administrative but democratic. Conceived as mechanisms for local oversight and citizen representation, the councils have instead become symbols of dysfunction. Voter turnout for the 2023 elections hovered around 41%, but more recent surveys indicate declining interest in the upcoming parliamentary elections—a reflection of deepening public disillusionment with both local and national governance.
Outlook: Reform or Repetition?
While some voices have called for a second suspension of the councils, others advocate sweeping reforms: revising electoral laws, imposing performance benchmarks, and limiting partisan appointments. Yet such reforms would require political will that has so far been lacking.
In the meantime, many political blocs continue to use provincial councils as platforms for influence ahead of federal elections. Without decisive legislative or judicial intervention, Iraq risks repeating the cycle of failed decentralization—a trajectory that threatens not just local governance but the broader credibility of the country's democratic institutions.
Comparatively, Iraq's experience mirrors failed decentralization efforts elsewhere in the region—such as Lebanon's paralyzed municipalities or Tunisia's reversed local empowerment experiment—underscoring that without safeguards, local governance can become a new arena for elite dysfunction rather than a remedy for centralization.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Risks of Transitioning to AI-Powered Digital Administration in Iraq
Risks of Transitioning to AI-Powered Digital Administration in Iraq

Iraq Business

time3 hours ago

  • Iraq Business

Risks of Transitioning to AI-Powered Digital Administration in Iraq

By Dr. Saad Mohsen Naji - Expert in Digital Economy | Vice President and Secretary General of Jordan's Iraqi Business Council . Any opinions expressed are those of the author(s), and do not necessarily reflect the views of Iraq Business News . The Risks of Transitioning to AI-Powered Digital Administration: Iraq Between Aspiration and Reality In the midst of an intense global race toward digitization, AI-driven digital administration has become a defining feature of institutional transformation. While such technologies promise unprecedented levels of efficiency, accuracy, and speed, they also carry inherent risks and challenges. If not managed wisely, these risks can undermine the sustainability of economic organizations-particularly in developing economies such as Iraq and several Arab countries. A critical review of e-government initiatives across the region reveals that their shortcomings often stem not from financial constraints, but from the failure to establish well-structured teams proficient in the latest technologies and capable of managing them effectively. This underscores the centrality of human capital and the need for continuous education. Technology, no matter how advanced, remains ineffective without qualified human resources to harness its potential. Digital transformation, when pursued through abrupt leaps rather than gradual integration, tends to disrupt traditional organizational structures. Field studies show that downsizing skilled personnel without offering reskilling opportunities creates dangerous execution gaps. A striking example is the collapse of Borders Books, which failed to adapt to digital publishing and exited the market in 2011. More recently, the streaming platform Quibi invested nearly $1.8 billion into short-form video content without adequately addressing user behavior, leading to its shutdown just six months after launch in December 2020. These cases highlight the non-negotiable need to align digital solutions with market behavior and user expectations. The integration of artificial intelligence also reveals a significant digital skills gap among public sector employees. The World Bank recommends a phased approach to digital transformation that incorporates sustainable reskilling of staff to ensure long-term success. Moreover, the lack of interoperability between legacy systems and new digital platforms leads to disjointed user experiences and market losses-as seen in the case of Sears , the retail giant whose failure to integrate physical stores with its digital platform led to its closure in 2018. The company's downfall was rooted in a disconnect between corporate culture and the digital capabilities of its workforce. Economically, digital platforms exert downward pressure on prices due to their inherent transparency. Without delivering clear added value, institutions risk losing their competitive edge rapidly. Additionally, building secure and highly available digital infrastructure is a costly endeavor-especially in countries lacking robust technological ecosystems. Cybersecurity threats are becoming more acute in tandem with the expansion of digital operations. Security reports from 2024 highlight a sharp increase in cyberattacks targeting government systems in countries where digitization has outpaced cybersecurity investments. The primary vulnerability, according to these reports, lies in the imbalance between spending on user interfaces or cloud infrastructure and underinvestment in cybersecurity. Digital inclusion remains a fundamental challenge. Digital services often benefit urban populations and younger generations, while the elderly and rural communities are left behind-widening the digital and social divide. Harvard Business Review stresses that institutional resistance to change-whether from employees fearing job loss or from senior leaders who fail to genuinely embrace transformation-is a key driver behind the failure of digital initiatives. In conclusion, AI-powered digital administration offers a powerful lever for enhancing performance and transparency in Iraq and across developing economies. However, it is not a silver bullet. Success requires a balanced approach that harmonizes technology with human capability, and ambition with realism. This involves adopting an integrated strategy based on sustained investment in human capital, the endorsement of transformative leadership, the implementation of secure and equitable digital governance, and the pursuit of inclusive digitization that reaches all segments of society. Through this holistic framework, developing countries can reap the benefits of digital transformation while avoiding its pitfalls.

SDF, Syrian government trike preliminary deal in Amman
SDF, Syrian government trike preliminary deal in Amman

Shafaq News

time4 hours ago

  • Shafaq News

SDF, Syrian government trike preliminary deal in Amman

Shafaq News – Damascus The Syrian government, Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), and US Special Envoy Thomas Barrack reached preliminary agreements during recent talks in Amman, Kurdish officials confirmed on Wednesday. Officials from the Autonomous Administration told the Saudi Al-Arabiya Al-Hadath tv channel that the agreements included joint control of border crossings and the Tishrin Dam. However, discussions on prison facilities and oil fields were postponed to a later stage. The SDF expressed readiness to integrate into the Syrian army as an independent corps, though no specific timeline was set for the process, the sources noted, adding that the SDF insisted on maintaining its presence in its current areas of control. A follow-up meeting is expected in Paris on July 25 and will include French, American, and British officials, Syrian Foreign Minister Asaad al-Shibani, and SDF Commander, Mazloum Abdi. Earlier, Abdi and Syria's Transitional President, Ahmad Al-Sharaa, reached an agreement to integrate the SDF into the country's official military structure, transferring all its territories, border crossings, and oil fields while rejecting any calls for division.

Existential threat: ICJ warns on climate change
Existential threat: ICJ warns on climate change

Shafaq News

time4 hours ago

  • Shafaq News

Existential threat: ICJ warns on climate change

Shafaq News – Amsterdam On Wednesday, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruled that countries affected by climate change are eligible for compensation, describing global warming as an "existential threat." The United Nations' highest judicial authority affirmed that access to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment is a human right. Japanese judge Yuji Iwasawa, President of the Court, said, 'it has concluded that the consequences of climate change are severe and profound. They cause harm to both natural ecosystems and populations,' confirming that the states have strict obligations to protect climate systems. Iwasawa warned that the effects of global warming will also impact human rights, stressing that it 'could severely undermine the enjoyment of certain human rights, including the right to life.' His remarks came during the reading of excerpts from an expert report consisting of several hundred pages, for what is considered the most significant case ever reviewed by the ICJ. The United Nations tasked the Court's fifteen judges with answering two questions, regarding the obligations of states to protect the Earth from gas emissions—primarily resulting from the consumption of oil, coal, and gas—and the legal consequences for states whose emissions have caused environmental harm. 'The failure to protect the planet from the effects of climate change may amount to a violation of international law,' the ICJ stated. Small nations are demanding compensation from historically high-polluting states, including the United States and India—an appeal that most wealthy countries reject. However, the advisory opinions issued by the ICJ are non-binding, and critics argue that major polluters will disregard them. Although the Court's opinion is advisory and not enforceable, it may still have influence and contribute to advancing climate justice by encouraging legislation and judicial action around the world.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store