A Trump bid for a third term could set off legal battles in states nationwide
It was just one of several instances in which Trump mused over the prospects of an extra-constitutional reign in the White House.
'He's talked about it for a really long time,' said John Bolton, Trump's national security advisor from 2018 to 2019, recalling the meeting. 'It's on his mind, and he'd like to do it.'
The possibility of Trump running for a third term gained fresh attention this weekend after the president told NBC that he was 'not joking' about pursuing one.
'There are methods,' Trump said. 'But I'm not — it is far too early to think about it.'
Attorneys, scholars and state officials disagree. The knowledge that Trump may bid to stay in power, in a direct challenge to the 22nd Amendment, already has election officials in secretaries of state offices throughout the country bracing for legal battles that could begin as soon as next year.
The plain language of the amendment, which states that 'no person shall be elected to the office of the President more than twice,' will also factor into local races starting next year for secretaries of state across the nation — key offices that will determine ballot qualification and interpret, or ignore, inevitable rulings on Trump's eligibility from the courts.
'Individual states and federal courts would almost certainly move to keep him off ballots,' said Alex Conant, former communications director for Marco Rubio's 2016 presidential campaign and a founding partner of Firehouse Strategies. 'It could,' he added, 'get messy.'
Some of Trump's most prominent current and former attorneys doubt that the president has a path to a third term, absent a laborious, politically challenging and time-consuming constitutional amendment. An amendment must be approved by three-fourths of the states (38 out of 50).
Pam Bondi, the president's attorney general, told senators in her confirmation hearing that Trump could not serve a third term 'unless they change the Constitution.'
'It could not happen absent a constitutional amendment, which could not possibly be enacted in time,' said Alan Dershowitz, a longtime constitutional professor at Harvard and a lawyer to Trump during his Senate impeachment trial. 'It will not happen.'
And yet in Arizona, where Trump and his allies tried to overturn the election results in 2020 to remain in power, discussions are already underway over the logistical pathways Trump might take to secure ballot access there. As in many other states, Arizona's process for accepting candidates onto primary ballots relies heavily on the internal decisions of political parties.
How could Republicans, who are so reluctant to defy Trump, oppose such an effort?
'The first line of defense would be the Republican Party standing up for the Constitution and saying, 'No, you're constitutionally ineligible, so we're not going to put you forward as a candidate,'' said a former Arizona election official, granted anonymity to speak candidly.
'But assuming that that fails, and the Republican Party nominates Trump for a third term, then they would try to submit his name and his vice presidential nominee, and their presidential electors in Arizona, to the secretary of state's office for ballot qualification. That would be the office to assess legal grounds for refusing to put them on the ballot.'
The term for Arizona's secretary of state, currently a Democrat, ends in 2027.
Given the opportunity, five senior administration officials within Trump's inner circle contacted by The Times refused to rule out an effort by Trump to remain in office. The White House referred to a statement by the president's press secretary, Karoline Leavitt, to reporters on Monday in which she said, 'It's not really something we're thinking about.'
Bolton, who went from Trump loyalist to fierce Trump critic, says otherwise.
'People need to think about it,' Bolton added. 'Trump's thinking about it, you can guarantee that.'
Trump launched his prior reelection bids historically early, announcing his first on Jan. 20, 2017 — the day of his first inauguration — and his second in November 2022, just a week after the midterm elections that year. This time, Trump's supporters began calling for another run within weeks of him taking office.
Trump was excluded from a straw poll of 2028 candidates at this year's Conservative Political Action Conference. But 'Trump 2028' material still circulated the event, drawing vocal support from prominent figures in the party, including Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina.
Stephen K. Bannon, a former White House strategist to Trump during his first term, said last month that he, conservative attorney Mike Davis and others are devising strategies for Trump to stay in office, warning that Democrats will try to imprison the president if he relinquishes power.
'We're working on it — I think we'll have a couple of alternatives,' Bannon told NewsNation. 'We'll see what the definition of term limit is.'
Legal challenges could come swift and early, experts said.
'Could he solicit money legally for something which you're ineligible to run for? That might be the first place where somebody would have standing to sue,' said Andrew Rudalevige, a professor of government at Bowdoin College.
The 'methods' and 'alternatives' referenced by Trump and Bannon are not clear. But Trump acknowledged one idea circulating among his supporters: Running for the vice presidency, and then either having the elected president resign or allowing Trump to effectively run the government.
That plan would face multiple hurdles, requiring Trump to trust someone enough to win the presidency and relinquish power to him.
It would also raise questions over the 12th Amendment, which states that 'no person constitutionally ineligible to the office of President shall be eligible to that of Vice-President.'
'It's just cut and dry — he's ineligible,' said Richard Painter, former chief White House ethics lawyer during the George W. Bush administration, 'and to put an ineligible candidate on a state ballot for a primary, you're denying everyone in that political party the right to vote for president, because someone ineligible is on the ballot.
'I think you could go to federal court for an injunction, and I think the Supreme Court might just have a nationwide injunction against it,' Painter added.
Only one former president, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, ran for and won more than two terms in office, breaking with a tradition that started at the advent of the nation.
'The norm created by George Washington was that the president would serve only two terms, and then Roosevelt decided not to,' said Peter Kastor, chair of the History Department at Washington University in St. Louis. 'After FDR died, before the conclusion of his fourth term, a variety of people came together and concluded they needed to codify the notion of a two-term presidency.'
Now, with the 22nd Amendment in place, the question legal scholars and election officials are asking isn't whether the law is clear, but whether Trump will follow it.
'I don't think I've really heard serious discussion among serious people — there are certainly musings about it among conservatives, but not necessarily conservative lawyers,' said Curt Levey, president of the conservative Committee for Justice.
'There's no doubt that the administration is being assertive and it means to test the boundaries of executive authority,' Levey added. 'But I think it's extremely unlikely that he would order Republican officials, in many states, to defy court orders — and even if he ordered them, doesn't mean they would comply.'
Trump will be 82 at the end of his current term, older than President Biden was when he ran for reelection against Trump last year.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
3 minutes ago
- CNN
Trump to sign legislation cracking down on illicit fentanyl
President Donald Trump will host congressional leaders and families affected by the fentanyl epidemic on Wednesday for a signing ceremony on bipartisan legislation that would strengthen prison sentences for fentanyl traffickers, White House officials tell CNN. The Halt All Lethal Trafficking of Fentanyl Act, which recently passed both the Senate and the House with bipartisan support, represents a key priority for the president who has claimed the illicit flow of fentanyl is one of the underlying reasons for his tariff threats against Canada, Mexico and China. The bill will place all fentanyl-related substances, specifically, copycat versions of the drug, on the US Drug Enforcement Administration's list of most dangerous drugs, classifying them as Schedule I under the Controlled Substances Act. The Trump administration argues the move will limit the incentive for cartels to create new synthetic, fentanyl-like drugs to evade the reach of the Controlled Substances Act. 'Under the HALT Fentanyl Act, anyone who possesses, imports, distributes, or manufactures any illicit FRS (fentanyl-related substances) will be subject to criminal prosecution in the same manner as any other Schedule I controlled substance,' a White House document on the legislation obtained by CNN reads. 'First, we close the loopholes criminals use to skirt around the law. Second, we make it easier for law enforcement to prosecute those criminals,' the document says. While the legislation has received strong bipartisan support, some critics argue the bill could lead to harsh penalties for millions of people struggling with drug addiction, especially Black Americans. The White House event, scheduled for 3 p.m. on Wednesday, will prominently feature families who have lost loved ones due to fentanyl use, including activist Anne Funder, who lost her eldest son — 15-year-old Weston — to fentanyl poisoning. Funder was also a speaker at the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee last year, where she called on the government to do more to deal with the fentanyl crisis in the US. Gregory Swan, whose son Drew died of fentanyl poisoning, will also speak. In the years following his son's death, Swan started a group known as Fentanyl Fathers, in which parents tell their story to high schools across America. Jacqueline Siegel, the founder of Victoria's Voice, an organization born from the loss of her 18-year-old daughter Victoria to a drug overdose in 2015, is also expected to speak. House Speaker Mike Johnson and Senate Majority Leader John Thune will attend the ceremony, the officials said. GOP Sens. Chuck Grassley, chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, and Bill Cassidy — who introduced the legislation with Democratic Sen. Martin Heinrich — will also be in attendance. Several organizations that have backed the legislation will also join the president for the ceremony, the officials said, including the Fraternal Order of Police and anti-immigration groups the Center for Immigration Studies and Federation for American Immigration Reform, among other drug, immigration and law enforcement groups.
The Hill
4 minutes ago
- The Hill
Trump planning 10 percent tariffs on smaller countries
President Trump said there will be a roughly 10 percent tariff set across the board for smaller countries, including those in Africa and the Caribbean. 'We'll probably set one tariff for all of them,' Trump told reporters on Tuesday evening. When asked for the amount, the president said 'a little over 10 percent.' Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick added during the gaggle with reporters that they were referring to African and Caribbean countries, among others. The president has sent two dozen letters to countries setting tariff rates to be imposed Aug. 1, but he has also left the door open to negotiations to lower those rates with trading partners. He said this week that Europe may come to the table to try to lower the 30 percent that it's been hit with. Earlier on Tuesday, Trump lowered the tariff rate on Indonesia to 19 percent after he had imposed a 32 percent tariff on the country on July 7. His other latest letters to trading partners imposed tariffs of 20 percent on the Philippines, 25 percent on Japan and Malaysia, 40 percent on Myanmar, 35 percent on Bangladesh and 36 percent on Thailand and Cambodia, among others.
The Hill
4 minutes ago
- The Hill
Bondi suggests she has no plans to step down, dodges Epstein questions
Attorney General Pam Bondi sidestepped questions and calls for her to resign over the Justice Department's (DOJ) handling of disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein's files on Tuesday, instead focusing on the Trump administration's goals to fight the fentanyl drug crisis. 'I'm going to be here for as long as the president wants me here,' Bondi told reporters during an event Tuesday evening. 'And I believe he's made that crystal clear.' One reporter asked the attorney general to explain discrepancies between the joint DOJ-FBI memo issued last week — which concluded that Epstein died by suicide and that a 'client list' did not exist — and comments she made in February suggesting such a list was on her desk waiting for review. Bondi brushed off the question, seeking to turn the conversation back to the war on drugs. 'This today is about fentanyl overdoses throughout our country and people who have lost loved ones to fentanyl,' she said. 'That's the message that we're here to send today. I'm not going to talk about Epstein.' In recent days some Republicans and Democrats alike have pressured the Trump administration to release the Epstein files in full or offer more of an explanation. Some conservative commentators have gone as far as to ask Bondi to resign over the controversy. The White House and Trump have stuck behind Bondi amid the turmoil, seeking to clarify her previous comments. 'She was saying the entirety of all of the paperwork, all of the paper in relation to Jeffrey Epstein's crimes,' White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said earlier this week. 'That's what the attorney general was referring to, and I'll let her speak for that.' Amid pushback over word choice, Trump too has vehemently defended his attorney general's work ethic — especially as fissures emerge among his ' Make America Great Again ' base over the controversy. 'They're all going after Attorney General Pam Bondi, who is doing a FANTASTIC JOB!' Trump wrote over the weekend. 'We're on one Team, MAGA, and I don't like what's happening.' On Tuesday, the president said Bondi should release 'whatever she thinks is credible.' He also pressed his supporters to move on, calling the Epstein drama 'boring.' 'I don't understand why the Jeffrey Epstein case would be of interest to anybody. It's pretty boring stuff. It's sordid, but it's boring,' Trump told reporters. 'And I don't understand why it keeps going. I think really only pretty bad people, including fake news, want to keep something like that going.' Bondi lauded the president for his support throughout public criticism and reaffirmed her commitment to the administration. 'We're going to fight to keep America safe again and we're fighting together as a team,' she said Tuesday.
