UNESCO Backs Japan's Position on Hashima Coal Mine Dispute
Since their inscription on the UNESCO list in 2015, the South Korean government has argued that the Japanese side has not fully honored its commitments regarding the Hashima Island and its coal mine.
Seoul claims that Tokyo has failed to properly acknowledge what it calls the forced labor of Koreans at the mine during its colonial rule.
On Monday, the South Korean representative requested the committee to reexamine Japan's follow-up measures and suggested adding it to the formal agenda. Japanese representatives opposed, asserting that it had faithfully implemented earlier resolutions.
With no consensus reached, the committee chair called for a vote.
An anonymous ballot was conducted among the 21 member states, with Japan's revised proposal adopted by seven votes in favor, three against, and several abstentions. Aerial view of Hashima Island, also known as Gunkanjima. (© Sankei)
Instead of reopening the issue as South Korea requested, the committee endorsed the position that disputes over the Hashima Island and its coal mine should be resolved through bilateral dialogue rather than UNESCO procedures.
With this outcome, it is unlikely that the issue will be formally discussed again during the current session, which ends on July 16, or in future meetings.
Hashima Island, also known as Gunkanjima, is a former undersea coal mine located off the coast of Nagasaki. It was designated a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 2015 as one of the 23 Sites of Japan's Meiji Industrial Revolution.
At the time of registration, Tokyo pledged to explain the full history of the site, including the conscription of Koreans under wartime labor policies.
Seoul insists Japan has not fulfilled that promise, pointing in particular to the Industrial Heritage Information Center opened in 2020, which it says omits or downplays the history of what South Koreans allege was forced labor. Photos of former residents of Gunkanjima in Nagasaki at the Industrial Heritage Information Center in Shinjuku, Tokyo, March 30, 2020. (© Sankei)
Over the past decade, the UNESCO committee has revisited the subject, adopting resolutions in 2015, 2018, 2021, and 2023. The 2021 decision echoed South Korea's concerns, expressing "strong regret" over Japan's limited follow-through. In contrast, the 2023 resolution took a more conciliatory tone, acknowledging Japan's additional efforts and encouraging further dialogue.
The 2023 resolution also downgraded the reporting requirement from a "formal report," which requires committee review, to an "update report," which does not.
Despite the latest vote, Seoul is expected to continue raising the matter in other forums and on the international stage.
Meanwhile, Tokyo maintains that it has fulfilled its obligations, stating that conscription at the time applied to all nationals, including Koreans, and denies any discriminatory treatment.
At the latest meeting, Japanese delegates expressed concern that discussing issues unrelated to the cultural heritage value could lead to the "politicization" of the World Heritage Committee.
The recent UNESCO decision reflects the committee's tendency to steer politically sensitive historical disputes toward direct bilateral dialogue instead of prolonged arbitration.
Author: Kenji Yoshida
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Japan Forward
2 hours ago
- Japan Forward
East Asia Faces Uneasy Alignments Amid Trump's Pressure
Facing a deteriorating security environment in East Asia, Japan, the United States, and South Korea are working to strengthen trilateral cooperation. That commitment was on display at two high-level gatherings on July 11. One in Kuala Lumpur during the ASEAN Foreign Ministers' Meetings, and the other in Seoul among top military officials. At both venues, representatives from the three countries reaffirmed their resolve to confront shared regional threats. Yet even as they recommit to regional security, renewed US tariff threats and looming defense burden-sharing talks risk complicating those efforts and rekindling doubts over long-term alignment. In Kuala Lumpur, Japanese Foreign Minister Takeshi Iwaya met with US Secretary of State Marco Rubio and South Korean First Vice Foreign Minister Park Yoonjoo. The senior officials expressed concern about North Korea's advancing nuclear and missile capabilities and reiterated their commitment to Northeast Asia's stability. They also pledged closer coordination on a range of security challenges, including the deepening Russia–North Korea ties and Pyongyang's cyber activities, particularly cryptocurrency thefts that help fund its weapons programs. Japan's Chief of Staff Gen. Yoshihide Yoshida (right), South Korea's Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Gen. Kim Myung-soo (center), and US Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Daniel Caine pose for a photo during the trilateral defense chiefs' meeting at JCS headquarters in Seoul, on July 11. (©ROK JCS) That same day in Seoul, military chiefs gathered for the 22nd Trilateral Chiefs of Defense meeting. Chairman of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff Dan Caine commented that both North Korea and China were undergoing an "unprecedented military buildup" with "a clear and unambiguous intent to move forward with their own agendas." He stressed that wider integration was necessary to restore regional deterrence. "We need to be able to demonstrate resolve, to be entrepreneurial and proactive in our partnerships," General Caine said. In recent years, Washington has pushed to expand the US–Japan–South Korea security partnership beyond North Korea to address growing Indo-Pacific risks, especially from China. But this strategic vision is unfolding at an awkward moment. Four days before the public show of unity, President Donald Trump revealed plans to impose a 25% tariff on all imports from Japan and South Korea. This comes on top of a baseline 10% rate and sector-specific tariffs already imposed on two of Washington's closest allies. Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba meets with US President Donald Trump in Kananaskis, western Canada, on June 16. (©Cabinet Public Relations Office) The reaction in Tokyo was swift. Speaking during a campaign stop on Wednesday, Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba made a rare show of defiance. "Do not look down on us," he said. "We will protect what must be protected" in negotiations over the tariffs. It's uncommon for a Japanese leader to address frictions with Washington in such strong language, even ahead of a critical domestic election. South Korea's First Vice Foreign Minister Park Yoonjoo speaks with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi at the ASEAN+3 Summit in Malaysia on July 11. (©ROK MOFA) Meanwhile, in South Korea, there is growing speculation that officials may be considering their own leverage. While National Security Adviser Wi Sung-rak recently denied the reports, some believe Seoul's left-wing government is weighing the return of wartime operational control (OPCON) as a potential bargaining chip. The idea is to link an increased defense burden with greater military autonomy and, in turn, leverage that position in pursuit of tariff relief. Signs of divergence in strategic priorities are already beginning to show. The joint statement issued after the Seoul defense summit omitted any mention of China, despite early talks of identifying it as a rising security threat. According to diplomatic sources, the exclusion was likely made to reflect Seoul's desire to avoid antagonizing Beijing directly. That same hesitancy is also playing out in the domestic arena. On July 3, South Korea's National Assembly passed a resolution condemning China's installation of steel structures in the West Sea, within Korea's Exclusive Economic Zone. Though it passed 252 to 0, seven lawmakers, including three from Lee's ruling party, abstained. Japanese PM Ishiba meets President Xi of China on the sidelines of APEC in Peru. (©Cabinet Office of the Prime Minister) Japan, too, is moving cautiously. Though Ishiba has reiterated his support for the US alliance, his tone on China has been noticeably softer than his conservative predecessors. In June, when a China Coast Guard vessel and helicopter violated Japanese territorial waters and airspace near the disputed Senkaku Islands, Ishiba refrained from issuing a formal condemnation. A similar trend has been evident as Chinese aircraft have been maneuvering increasingly recklessly around Japanese planes. All of this comes as the US is pressing its two closest regional allies to expand their roles in collective security. Experts argue that as Trump's economic pressure and defense cost-sharing disputes reignite tensions, the window for stronger tripartite cooperation could narrow, potentially pushing Seoul and Tokyo closer to Beijing's orbit. With North Korea accelerating its weapons program, China's expanding maritime assertiveness, and Moscow's deepening ties with Pyongyang, the Indo-Pacific faces heightening volatility, exactly when harmony among US allies is most needed. Author: Kenji Yoshida
Canada Standard
2 days ago
- Canada Standard
Daily World Briefing, July 12
Chinese FM calls for joint efforts in finding right way for China, U.S. to get along China and the United States should work together to find the right way to get along with each other in the new era, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi said here on Friday. Wang, also a member of the Political Bureau of the Communist Party of China Central Committee, expressed his hope that the U.S. side would view China with an objective, rational and pragmatic attitude. Wang made the remarks during a meeting with U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio in the Malaysian capital on the sidelines of the ASEAN Foreign Ministers' Meeting and related meetings. China's Xixia Imperial Tombs inscribed as UNESCO World Heritage Site China's Xixia Imperial Tombs were inscribed on the World Heritage List on Friday during UNESCO's 47th session of the World Heritage Committee, held in Paris, France. With this addition, the total number of World Heritage sites in China has reached 60. Xixia Imperial Tombs is a group of imperial burial sites from the Xixia Dynasty (Western Xia, 1038-1227), founded by the Tangut people in northwestern China during the 11th to 13th centuries. Covering an area of nearly 40 square km, the site comprises four types of architectural remains: 9 imperial mausoleums, 271 subordinate tombs, a northern architectural complex covering 0.05 square km, and 32 flood control works. Trump says U.S. to impose 35 pct tariffs on Canada starting Aug. 1 U.S. President Donald Trump on Thursday announced a 35 percent tariff on imports from Canada starting Aug. 1. Trump posted a letter addressed to Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney on his social media platform Truth Social, criticizing Canada for retaliating against previous U.S. tariffs. He pointed out that the new tariff is in part caused by the flow of fentanyl from Canada, as well as allegedly unfair trade practices, and that he would "consider an adjustment" to the tariffs if Canada cooperated with the United States to stop the flow of fentanyl. Canada continues trade talks with U.S. towards revised deadline of Aug. 1 Canada will continue the trade talks with the United States towards the revised deadline of Aug. 1, Prime Minister Mark Carney said Thursday. Carney said on his social media that throughout the current trade negotiations with the United States, the Canadian government has steadfastly defended the workers and businesses. "We will continue to do so as we work towards the revised deadline of August 1," he said. Canada has made vital progress to stop the scourge of fentanyl in North America, he said, affirming Canada's commitment to continuing to work with the United States to save lives and protect communities in both countries. Lebanese president says normalization with Israel not on agenda Lebanese President Joseph Aoun affirmed on Friday that normalizing diplomatic relations with Israel is currently not under consideration, emphasizing that Lebanon's current focus is on maintaining peace, not entering formal ties. "Peace means a state of non-war, and that is what matters to Lebanon right now," he said, according to a statement released by Lebanon's presidency. Aoun's remarks came during a meeting with a delegation from the Arab and International Relations Council. During the meeting, Aoun stressed that the unity of the Lebanese people is crucial to overcoming the country's ongoing challenges. U.S. State Department starts laying off at least 1,300 staffers The U.S. Department of State has begun firing more than 1,300 people as part of a dramatic overhaul of the agency, U.S. media reported on Friday. "The firings will affect 1,107 civil service and 246 foreign service officers," reported CNN after reviewing an internal notice. "It comes as the State Department implements a drastic reorganization as part of the Trump administration's broader efforts to shrink the federal government." Hundreds of offices and bureaus are being eliminated or altered as a result of the changes being implemented on Friday, it added. Nearly 800 killed while trying to access aid in Gaza Nearly 800 people have been killed while trying to access humanitarian aid in the Gaza Strip, the UN human rights office (OHCHR) said on Friday. Speaking at a press briefing in Geneva, OHCHR spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani said that as of July 7, the OHCHR had documented 798 killings in aid distribution areas in Gaza. "Including 615 in the vicinity of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) sites and 183, presumably on the routes of aid convoys," she said. She also noted that most of the casualties resulted from gunshot injuries. Shamdasani said that such a situation is unacceptable, yet it continues.
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Cambodian sites of Khmer Rouge brutality added to UNESCO heritage list
PHNOM PENH, Cambodia (AP) — Three locations used by Cambodia's brutal Khmer Rouge regime as torture and execution sites 50 years ago have been added by UNESCO to its World Heritage List. The three locations were inscribed to the list by the United Nations cultural agency Friday during the 47th Session of the World Heritage Committee in Paris. The inscription coincided with the 50th anniversary of the rise to power by the communist Khmer Rouge government, which caused the deaths of an estimated 1.7 million Cambodians through starvation, torture and mass executions during a four-year reign from 1975 to 1979. UNESCO's World Heritage List lists sites considered important to humanity and includes the Great Wall of China, the Pyramids of Giza in Egypt, the Taj Mahal in India and Cambodia's Angkor archaeological complex. The three sites listed Friday include two notorious prisons and an execution site immortalized in a Hollywood film. Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum, located in the capital Phnom Penh, is the site of a former high school used by the Khmer Rouge as a notorious prison. Better known as S-21, about 15,000 people were imprisoned and tortured there. The M-13 prison, located in rural Kampong Chhnang province in central Cambodia, also was regarded as one of the main prisons of the early Khmer Rouge. Choeung Ek, located about 15 kilometers (10 miles) south of the capital, was used as an execution site and mass grave. The story of the atrocities committed there are the focus of the 1984 film 'The Killing Fields,' based on the experiences of New York Times photojournalist Dith Pran and correspondent Sydney Schanberg. The Khmer Rouge captured Phnom Penh on April 17, 1975, and immediately herded almost all the city's residents into the countryside, where they were forced to toil in harsh conditions until 1979, when the regime was driven from power by an invasion from neighboring Vietnam. In September 2022, the U.N.-backed Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia, better known as the Khmer Rouge tribunal, concluded its work compiling cases against Khmer Rouge leaders. The tribunal cost $337 million over 16 years but convicted just three men. Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Manet issued a message Friday directing people to beat drums simultaneously across the country Sunday morning to mark the UNESCO listing. 'May this inscription serve as a lasting reminder that peace must always be defended,' Hun Manet said in a video message posted online. 'From the darkest chapters of history, we can draw strength to build a better future for humanity.' Youk Chhang, executive director of the Documentation Center of Cambodia in Phnom Penh, said the country is 'still grappling with the painful legacies of genocide, torture, and mass atrocity.' But naming the three sites to the UNESCO list will play a role in educating younger generations of Cambodians and others worldwide. 'Though they were the landscape of violence, they too will and can contribute to heal the wounds inflicted during that era that have yet to heal,' he said. The UNESCO inscription was Cambodia's first nomination for a modern and non-classical archaeological site and is among the first in the world to be submitted as a site associated with recent conflict, Cambodia's Ministry of Culture and Fine Arts said in a statement Friday. Four Cambodian archaeological sites were previously inscribed as UNESCO World Heritage Sites including Angkor, Preah Vihear, Sambo Prei Kuk and Koh Ker, the ministry said.
