Plea to reopen consultation into plans to close Auckland mental health facility
Photo:
Google Maps Street View
A union representing public service workers is urging health officials to reopen consultation into proposals to
close an Auckland mental health facility
, citing concerns about predetermination.
The PSA has sent a lawyer's letter to Health NZ Te Whatu Ora with the plea about Rauaroha Segar House, which offer a publicly funded intensive programme for people with long-standing or chronic mental health problems.
Health NZ says it is working through feedback on the proposed closure, after staff put forward a plan to keep a service they and many patients say is unique.
After the period seeking submissions closed, correspondence obtained by Labour spokesperson for mental health Ingrid Leary and reported by RNZ revealed officials had
intended to vacate
the Khyber Pass Road facility Segar House operates from in January, before a pre-Christmas move to extend the lease until June.
It has since been extended again until 30 September.
The correspondence makes no mention of possible alternative venues for the programme, but Health NZ said the building lease was not a factor in its decision making, and the proposal was about providing the best healthcare and value for money.
The PSA's letter, from its solicitor Caroline Mayston to Health NZ co-director of mental health and addiction services in Te Toka Tumai, Stacy Silva Garay, last Friday said after learning of the lease information in the media the union had serious concerns about "predetermination of the change process".
It said Health NZ breached its duty to provide all relevant information to employees and unions during the Segar House consultation process.
"We request that consultation be reopened to allow affected employees to consider and respond to this additional information, as is their right," Mayston wrote.
The union's concerns were not alleviated by Health NZ saying lease arrangements had nothing to do with the proposal to close Segar House.
"This [the correspondence obtained by Leary] indicates to us that Te Whatu Ora was planning for the disestablishment of Rauaroha Segar House well prior to opening consultation with affected employees and had no intention of maintaining the service elsewhere.
"We do not accept this information was not relevant to the change process."
Rauaroha Segar House has offered a publicly funded intensive programme for people with long-standing or chronic mental health problems.
Photo:
123RF
RNZ asked Health NZ if it would allow staff and other parties to have a say on the new information, what its response was regarding concerns about predetermination, and when a decision on Segar House's future would be made.
Health NZ northern regional acting deputy chief executive Mike Shepherd said officials were considering the information the PSA provided.
"We have received a large volume of feedback on the change process for the facility and we have been carefully reviewing this feedback.
"We will be in a position to make a decision shortly and this decision will be communicated to affected stakeholders as soon as possible."
Leary said allowing the PSA's suggestion of reopening consultation seemed fair and logical.
"Extending the time to ensure proper consultation is happening is the right thing to do. That's what I've said all along and that's what needs to happen."
It made sense to give the staff idea of loosening the criteria for people to use the service a go, to see if it worked, she said.
But, it looked like officials hadn't entered the process with an open mind as they scrambled to save money, Leary said.
Health NZ has cited low referral numbers in its proposal to axe Segar House, although entry requirements were tightened about six years ago.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
'Mark your own homework': Healthy Homes checks under fire for DIY loophole
Photo: 123rf Like drivers issuing their own warrants of fitness - that's how building experts and renter advocates describe the new Healthy Homes Standards. Since 1 July, all rental properties across the motu have been required to comply with the new standards, which set minimum requirements for heating, insulation, ventilation, moisture ingress and drainage. But who gets to say whether a property is up to scratch? Well, with no certification required in order to complete an assessment, the role could technically be filled by anyone. This has prompted calls for an independent certification system. Ideally, under the new standards, damp and draughty rentals should now be a thing of the past. But the New Zealand Institute of Building Inspectors isn't convinced. Chief executive Graeme Blissett, said the standards contain several loopholes. Not least, that anyone can label themselves a healthy homes assessor. "It's a huge problem, because there's no one looking at what they're actually inspecting and writing reports on is actually correct. "There are no guarantees because no one's double-checking what they're doing, and I believe that if you're charging $150, $200 to do a healthy homes inspection on a house, you're not doing it correctly." It doesn't take long to find companies offering Healthy Homes assessments - Checkpoint found a business online, offering to carry out a certification for around $200. But Blissett fears that without certification, many of these businesses will prioritise "quantity over quality". He said he's seen several certificates that ticked off each of the standards, despite the properties falling short. "The tenants [are] usually up to speed with these sorts of regulations and rules, so if the landlords do it on their own property and they get it incorrect, and the tenant finds out about it or talks to someone, and they've got a little bit of knowledge on it. There is a chance for them to be taken [to] the Tenancy Tribunal. "I believe there's fines of like $5000 or something like that for non-compliance." Renters United President, Zac Thomas, said the Healthy Homes Standards are a positive step towards a warmer and drier housing stock. But he's also concerned about the assessment process. "There is a mark your own homework situation where landlords don't even need to use an independent assessor in the first place. They can say that they are healthy homes compliant, that's the first thing. "But then the second thing is they can get this assessment from an agency that in many cases won't actually be complying or assessing to the standards as they should be." Thomas said that if the checks were completed by qualified assessors, it would give peace of mind to both landlords and tenants. "A renter might go, 'hey, please show me your healthy homes compliance.' They might be worried that the house is not compliant, and the landlord will probably show this, and then they might go, 'Oh well, I guess I have nothing to complain about'. "In reality, if there was a consistent standard, tenants would have the confidence to say, 'Okay, like this does meet standard, therefore I don't need to worry about going to the Tenancy Tribunal." University of Otago Professor, Lucy Telfer Barnard, said that as winter rolls around, if houses aren't up to standard, it's the tenants who face the consequences. "The tenants may not necessarily initially know that's why they're feeling unwell, but then if they do start to wonder, there's whole process that they can then have to go through to get those standards met. "To have that after the fact when they've moved in, in good faith, thinking that the property meets the standards, really isn't fair and puts a whole burden onto people." Landlords who fail to meet the Healthy Homes standards can face fines of up to $7200. Owners of six or more rentals that do not comply could be hit with $50,000 fines. A statement from the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development said they don't assess how landlords achieve compliance, and there is no licensing requirement to undertake Healthy Homes Standards assessments. Moving to this sort of "WOF" scheme would be a big undertaking with significant costs and impacts. It said landlords need to satisfy themselves that the person they hire is suitably experienced and can undertake the required inspection or work to an acceptable standard. If a tenant thinks the property they are renting is not up to standard, they can make a complaint on the Tenancy Services website or apply for a work order from the Tenancy Tribunal. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
A turn off or 'ofally' good? The forgotten food on the cusp of a comeback
While most of New Zealand's offal is exported, there's a growing number of people who advocate for greater use. (File photo) Photo: Pixabay It was revealed earlier this week that offal mince has been used for some of the meals in the government's revamped school lunch programme. The meat in the meal contained 50 percent beef trim and 50 percent beef heart. The food code specifies if a blend was being used it must be disclosed, either as offal or the specific names, like liver and kidney. While most of New Zealand's offal was exported, there was a growing number of people who advocate for greater use, including the organisers of the 'offaly good' festival coming up in Auckland. Hannah Miller, a chef turned butcher who runs 'A Lady Butcher', was also a huge fan of using a 'nose to tail' approach. She told Checkpoint offal came with huge benefits. "Some of the cool things about it... the sustainability from the standpoint of making sure that we're using everything and nothing is being wasted. But more than that really is offal actually has huge health benefits of nutrition around getting your iron, but also has lots of other vitamins as well." Miller called the addition of the food to school lunches "awesome". "I think it's a really smart approach. It's great nutrition for our kids, but also it's a really cost-effective option. So we're sort of delivering a little bit more bang for buck really... getting that higher nutrition content at a lower cost." When it comes to cutting costs, Miller said offal was worth trying. "If people are keen to give it a go, it is worth it because you can actually save quite a bit." She said chicken hearts were a good option for those trying offal for the first time. Hannah Miller is a chef turned butcher. Photo: A Lady Butcher "You can pick those up from your local butcher for you know $12 a kilo... I've seen them quite regularly at Pak n Save... a tray might be a couple bucks. "If you look at that from a protein or vitamin content you're really getting good bang for buck." However, she said actually getting used to the food was the main hurdle for most people. " would love to say, hey, get used to it, get over it. But really that's not that's not the way to do it." "[For] getting people on board finely chopping some heart and putting it into a mince is an easy way to do it." Currently retailers must disclose if meat includes offal. Miller said that when it came to cafes and restaurants, she had never encountered anyone trying to hide the blend. "Technically it is more of a retail requirement... anyone that is using it out in New Zealand, everyone I've found does disclose it." Offal included all the internal organs of an animal, and Miller said there's no part she wouldn't eat. "Pretty much everything can be used so from the bones becoming stocks and broths, to the intestines being cleaned and used to then be filled with meat to make sausages. "Slow cooked pigs head is amazing, tongue is fantastic to use instead of a sort of corned beef... everything really does have purpose." While it may not be for everyone, she maintained that it was worth a go. "By the time it's on your plate, it shouldn't look like what it is." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
A turn off or 'offally' good? The forgotten food on the cusp of a comeback
While most of New Zealand's offal is exported, there's a growing number of people who advocate for greater use. (File photo) Photo: Pixabay It was revealed earlier this week that offal mince has been used for some of the meals in the government's revamped school lunch programme. The meat in the meal contained 50 percent beef trim and 50 percent beef heart. The food code specifies if a blend was being used it must be disclosed, either as offal or the specific names, like liver and kidney. While most of New Zealand's offal was exported, there was a growing number of people who advocate for greater use, including the organisers of the 'offaly good' festival coming up in Auckland. Hannah Miller, a chef turned butcher who runs 'A Lady Butcher', was also a huge fan of using a 'nose to tail' approach. She told Checkpoint offal came with huge benefits. "Some of the cool things about it... the sustainability from the standpoint of making sure that we're using everything and nothing is being wasted. But more than that really is offal actually has huge health benefits of nutrition around getting your iron, but also has lots of other vitamins as well." Miller called the addition of the food to school lunches "awesome". "I think it's a really smart approach. It's great nutrition for our kids, but also it's a really cost-effective option. So we're sort of delivering a little bit more bang for buck really... getting that higher nutrition content at a lower cost." When it comes to cutting costs, Miller said offal was worth trying. "If people are keen to give it a go, it is worth it because you can actually save quite a bit." She said chicken hearts were a good option for those trying offal for the first time. Hannah Miller is a chef turned butcher. Photo: A Lady Butcher "You can pick those up from your local butcher for you know $12 a kilo... I've seen them quite regularly at Pak n Save... a tray might be a couple bucks. "If you look at that from a protein or vitamin content you're really getting good bang for buck." However, she said actually getting used to the food was the main hurdle for most people. " would love to say, hey, get used to it, get over it. But really that's not that's not the way to do it." "[For] getting people on board finely chopping some heart and putting it into a mince is an easy way to do it." Currently retailers must disclose if meat includes offal. Miller said that when it came to cafes and restaurants, she had never encountered anyone trying to hide the blend. "Technically it is more of a retail requirement... anyone that is using it out in New Zealand, everyone I've found does disclose it." Offal included all the internal organs of an animal, and Miller said there's no part she wouldn't eat. "Pretty much everything can be used so from the bones becoming stocks and broths, to the intestines being cleaned and used to then be filled with meat to make sausages. "Slow cooked pigs head is amazing, tongue is fantastic to use instead of a sort of corned beef... everything really does have purpose." While it may not be for everyone, she maintained that it was worth a go. "By the time it's on your plate, it shouldn't look like what it is." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
