logo
BBC chief left IDF death chants on livestream

BBC chief left IDF death chants on livestream

Spectator14 hours ago
Well, well, well. The chants of Bob Vylan frontman at Glastonbury – 'death, death to the IDF' – sparked outrage at the weekend and it wasn't long before questions were asked of the BBC, which streamed the performance to viewers at home. Now it transpires that the Beeb's director general Tim Davie was made aware of the controversial chants after the public service broadcaster had shown them live on Saturday – and while Davie ordered the performance to be made unavailable to viewers on demand, the original livestream remained on iPlayer for five hours.
A BBC spokesperson has now lamented the decision not to pull the livestream, noting that:
Tim was there for a few hours to see the team. He was made aware during the time he was there of what had been said on stage. He intervened to make sure the performance was not made available on demand and he was very clear about that.
Pulling the livestream brings certain technological challenges. With hindsight, we would have taken it down.
How interesting. The statement comes as police commenced a criminal probe into the Glastonbury performances of both Bob Vylan and Irish rap trio Kneecap, both of whom delivered a pro-Palestine message to fans during their performances. The remarks made by the Bob Vylan frontman have had more immediate consequences for the punk group too. Its members have had their US visas revoked before a huge tour that was due to take place later this year and the group has been dropped by its agency. Oo er.
Meanwhile the republican rap group Kneecap saw Naoise Ó Cairealláin issue a hasty clarification during the performance, when he referenced the trial of his bandmate Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh – who has been charged with a terrorism offence for allegedly displaying a flag in support of Hezbollah at a gig in London in 2024. Initially Ó Cairealláin had urged supporters 'start a riot' outside Westminster magistrates court in August when the singer – who also goes by Mo Chara – appears for the next part of his trial. A few minutes later, after running back from the side of the stage, Ó Cairealláin told the crowd: 'I have to make a disclaimer: when we go to support at the court case, I don't want anybody to start a riot.' Mr S wonders just how many lawyers the band had hiding in the wings…
For their part, the Irish hip-hop group have said they have never supported Hamas or Hezbollah. The musicians also claimed clips of the events had been taken out of context and were being 'exploited and weaponised'. All the extra attention has certainly done their profile no harm, with Glastonbury's West Holts area closed 40 minutes before their set when it became completely packed out. Will much come of these new police probes? Stay tuned…
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

How David Attenborough inspired the 'awe and wonder' in Jurassic World Rebirth
How David Attenborough inspired the 'awe and wonder' in Jurassic World Rebirth

Metro

timean hour ago

  • Metro

How David Attenborough inspired the 'awe and wonder' in Jurassic World Rebirth

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Filmmaker Gareth Edwards is back at the helm once more of a major franchise (although he hates that word, he tells me) sequel with Jurassic World Rebirth, following his foray into Star Wars with 2016's Rogue One. This time he's fulfilling a childhood dream by working on one of the most influential 'creature feature' series of all time, working with Steven Spielberg – 'I call him Steve,' he grins, acknowledging the surrealism of that scenario. Coming onboard to direct the next instalment in such a popular run of films Edwards, 50, did have lots of little ways he wanted to put his stamp on it – but also one clear desire to ground the movie in reality, despite the fact it's set 'on an island in the middle of nowhere with dinosaurs on it'. 'One of the great things about Jurassic was that it wasn't that we'd gone back in time to see dinosaurs, it was that they'd come to our time, and so I wanted some iconography of some location that was now,' he explains. 'I wanted, at one point in the movie, there to be dinosaurs in something that was very familiar to us, like the kitchen scene in the original Jurassic Park. So I needed to somehow crowbar into this scenario some imagery that you would watch it and go, 'I know that, that's where I live' – even though it's not.' Without giving too much away before people have seen the movie, Edwards plays clear homage to that terrifying scene from the 1993 film with the hunting Velociraptors as well as plenty of fun Easter eggs from that era. 'I think that's important for people to relate to and feel like these things have come to us,' he adds. Edwards also reveals the way he was inspired by legendary broadcaster and biologist David Attenborough, 99, and wanted to bring his influence in Jurassic World Rebirth to another pivotal scene. He admits 'the way it was written probably wasn't aspiring to this' – but for the filmmaker it was clear. 'Being from the UK, I grew up with David Attenborough documentaries, and on a Sunday night on the BBC or wherever, one of the great things is sitting and watching a natural history show, [where] there's beautiful majesty and awe-inspiring nature,' he recalls. 'And I was like, to get through a Jurassic and not have this awe and wonder moment somewhere…' That was obviously not an option for Edwards, and the result is glimpsed in the movie's trailer when Scarlett Johansson's mission specialist Zora Bennett and Jonathan Bailey's palaeontologist Dr Henry Loomis are seen glimpsing the 50-foot Titanosauruses for the first time. It nicely acts as a throwback to the original film too, when Sam Neill and Laura Dern's expert characters are thrilled to see their first live dinosaur (coincidentally accompanied by Sir David's late actor brother Sir Richard Attenborough as Dr John Hammond, the owner of the park and the company that cloned the dinosaurs). 'That's what you're trying to do, is just navigate it so that you feel like it's that journey that you would want as an audience member.'. Alongside his previous Star Wars responsibility, Edwards is known for original projects as screenwriter and director like Monsters and 2023's The Creator. He appears comfortable switching between studio-led franchise blockbusters and more indie fare, ceding complete creative control for the prior. 'There are certain franchises where I feel like I don't know what I'd do with that, and also I think we'd all disagree about what that is. And there are other ones where you go, the best version of that, I think, is exactly what the studio would want as well.' Jurassic World Rebirth fortunately fell in this latter category and Edwards was delighted to be surrounded by a team who 'challenged' him. 'You want people who go, really? And double check what you're saying and go, how about this? Or throw in new ideas. But you also want to agree on what's a good film. And if they list ones that are your favourites, then you're probably in a good place.' That is something he fortunately found with screenwriter David Koepp too, who was returning to pen a Jurassic film for the first time since 1997's The Lost World, after it was suggested that meeting with producer Frank Marshall and Spielberg wasn't the conversation he should be most nervous about. 'They said, 'Oh, if you think this was tricky, wait 'til you meet David Koepp – if you can get your ideas past him'.' But it ended up a 'blissful' partnership Edwards says, from 'the second we started talking' on Zoom and found that they loved 'exactly the same movies'. Edwards also admits he was expecting the screenplay to be locked, with no way for him to suggest any of his own ideas and tweaks. 'That's what I thought was going to happen. And instead, it was like, 'Okay, you know this scene where this happens – what if we did it in this location instead? And what if this happened during it?'' he shared of his discussions with Koepp. 'And he was like, 'Great!', and would write it and give it his own flourishes, and you'd go, 'Oh, that's better than what I would have written!'' But there were also sections where Edwards felt Koepp had things 'dead right' and he didn't want to touch it. 'We were really on the same page.' This was also of great benefit considering the condensed timeline of making the movie, with Edwards only announced as director in February 2024, before any casting was done, and filming beginning that June. Star and producer Johansson even revealed to me that sound mixing conversations were still happening just days before the London premiere. Even with such a tight turnaround though, they managed to assemble a cast including Johansson, Bailey, two-time Oscar-winner Mahershala Ali and Rupert Friend, as well as Netflix's The Lincoln Lawyer star, Manuel Garcia-Rulfo. 'You worry when you've got not much time that you're going to get the bottom of the barrel, a lot of people that didn't get a job!' laughs Edwards of the situation. Luckily, the films are so definitive – and come with Spielberg attached ('I think when he calls, people pick up the phone') – that it wasn't an issue. 'I think if it had been another project, we might have been a bit stuck.' Hilariously though, Edwards was not aware of Jurassic super-nerd Johansson and how she had already pitched herself to Spielberg. 'I remember being in one of those early conversations at Universal, and there's Steven Spielberg and Donna Langley and everybody, and all these actors [on pieces of paper] and all these names being said. And then Steven goes, 'Well, if I don't give it to Scarlett, she's going to kill me.' And I'm just like, 'What do you mean?' And he goes, 'Scarlett's a massive Jurassic fan and I went for a meal with her,' and he started saying how much she loved it and wanted to be in one. And I was like, 'Hang on, why are we doing this meeting? Scarlett Johansson wants to do this film? Like, what are we talking about? Can you call her?!'' More Trending With Bailey, too, Edwards recalls an enjoyably unsuccessful first meeting when he had been prepped with questions from the producers for the actor but instead spent the entire three-hour chat over a meal in LA just 'joking around' and talking about 'random stuff' before the Wicked star realised he had to go. 'And so he left, and I hadn't said a word to him about Jurassic. And then the producers were like, 'Did he like the screenplay?' And I'm like, 'Yeah, no, it's all good, we're all good, no he didn't have any notes, he loves the character…' the director laughs of his bluffing. 'But it's the kind of movie. There's only a couple of things like this where you just get everyone's full attention. And it was a new chapter in it as well, so everyone felt they could come and put their stamp on it.' Jurassic World Rebirth is in cinemas from July 2. Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: Jurassic World Rebirth leaves critics crying 'let the franchise go extinct' with rotten debut MORE: Tom Cruise's 'breathtaking' 90s sci-fi hit quietly arrives on Netflix MORE: 'Underrated' horror movie hailed by fans finally arrives on Amazon Prime

Louis Theroux 'turned down by iconic girl band' for new BBC documentary
Louis Theroux 'turned down by iconic girl band' for new BBC documentary

Daily Mirror

timean hour ago

  • Daily Mirror

Louis Theroux 'turned down by iconic girl band' for new BBC documentary

Following the success of Louis Theroux's series called Boybands Forever, the journalist is planning a girl group version, but one iconic group has reportedly shunned his approach Louis Theroux is used to interviewing the best in the business. However, one band has reportedly shunned his advances to tell their story. The popular journalist is creating a new bombshell BBC documentary on girlbands following on from last year's successful production of Boybands Forever. It's thought Louis had seen the iconic band as being instrumental in any production. ‌ However, a TV insider has claimed that the quintet - made up of Victoria Beckham, Emma Bunton, Melanie C, Melanie Brown MBE and Geri Horner - aren't prepared to bare all just yet. ‌ While last year's boyband version saw Robbie Williams open up on his turbulent time in Take That, the source says the Girl Power group aren't looking to follow suit. Talking to the Sun, a source said: "The difference is that the Spice Girls are fast approaching 30 years since the release of their debut single Wannabe and have a string of projects in the pipeline. "Many of the issues that Robbie brought up on Boybands Forever were wholly justifiable, and most viewers sympathised with his situation when he was in Take That. 'But none of the Spice Girls want to do the same, and they feel it wouldn't be fair on their loyal fans to spoil the magic of Girl Power so close to their anniversary year. They want 2026 to be a moment when they celebrate the group's achievements.' ‌ While the Spice Girls are reportedly steering clear of the offering, other groups from the era are expected to feature. With it thought chats will be conducted face to face, members of groups such as Eternal, Atomic Kitten, Girls Aloud, Sugababes and All Saints are rumoured to be taking part. Boybands Forever, which was released at the back end of last year, was a series that focused on boybands of the 90s and early 2000s. Among those who featured, as well as Robbie Williams, was Simon Cowell. Prior to its release, Louis said of the series: "It involves some of the icons of modern British pop - and we see them through their highs and lows." He added: "It's how they came together, the experience of sudden fame, the opportunity and temptations that came their way, conflicts within the groups, between the groups, and between the boys and their managers. "It's a gripping fable about getting everything you dreamed of, and it not being what you imagined, centred on a generation of young men, and their managers, who were wildly successful and also immensely vulnerable, having the times of their lives and also in some cases cracking up."

Committee asks BBC boss for view on ‘what went wrong' with Glastonbury coverage
Committee asks BBC boss for view on ‘what went wrong' with Glastonbury coverage

The Independent

time2 hours ago

  • The Independent

Committee asks BBC boss for view on ‘what went wrong' with Glastonbury coverage

A Government committee has written to BBC director-general Tim Davie asking him for a 'personal assessment of what went wrong' with the broadcaster's Glastonbury coverage. The BBC has faced strong criticism for continuing to livestream the performance of punk rap duo Bob Vylan, which is now the subject of a criminal police investigation, at the festival on iPlayer. They led chants of 'Death, death to the IDF (Israel Defence Forces)' during their set on the West Holts Stage on Saturday, with the broadcaster providing on-screen warnings about discriminatory language on its platform. It later apologised on Monday and said the chants held 'antisemitic sentiments' that were 'unacceptable'. Irish rap trio Kneecap, who are also facing an Avon and Somerset Police investigation, appeared on the same stage directly after Bob Vylan and led the Glastonbury audience in 'Free Palestine' chants. It has since been revealed that Tim Davie was at Glastonbury when the pro-Palestine chants were broadcast. In a letter sent to Mr Davie by the Culture, Media and Sport Committee on Tuesday, chairwoman Dame Caroline Dinenage asked the BBC boss 12 questions after saying its coverage had caused 'widespread concern'. Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy previously said that 'several' editorial failures 'becomes a problem of leadership' during a statement on the BBC's coverage to the Commons. Among the questions, Dame Caroline said: 'Before the festival started, did the BBC consider streaming all or part of its Glastonbury coverage with a short time delay, to allow room to respond to events if necessary?' The Conservative MP went on to ask how many BBC staff and contractors were working at Glastonbury or on its coverage, if staff with the authority to cut Bob Vylan's live stream were present during their performance and whether ending the live stream was discussed mid-performance. Dame Caroline then asked: 'At what level were the decisions made to not stream Kneecap live and to stream Bob Vylan live, but with a warning on screen?' The letter asked if the BBC had a contingency plan for the event and who was responsible for forming and actioning the plan, before asking if the broadcaster would review its Editorial Guidelines and guidance for live output 'to ensure they are fit for live streaming'. The Tory MP added: 'In summary, what is your personal assessment of what went wrong and what (are the) key lessons that the BBC will take away from the experience of live streaming Glastonbury 2025?' Dame Caroline said she hoped for Mr Davie's response to the questions within two weeks. Avon and Somerset Police said it had launched a probe into both the Bob Vylan and Kneecap performances after reviewing video footage and audio recordings, with a senior detective appointed to lead the investigation. A force spokesman said: 'This has been recorded as a public order incident at this time while our inquiries are at an early stage. 'The investigation will be evidence-led and will closely consider all appropriate legislation, including relating to hate crimes.' In response to criticism of their performance on Tuesday, Bob Vylan said in a statement posted on Instagram that they were being 'targeted for speaking up' and that 'a good many people would have you believe a punk band is the number one threat to world peace.' The statement said: 'We are not for the death of Jews, Arabs or any other race or group of people. 'We are for the dismantling of a violent military machine. A machine whose own soldiers were told to use 'unnecessary lethal force' against innocent civilians waiting for aid. 'A machine that has destroyed much of Gaza.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store