logo
China's rare earth export controls are good for Beijing, bad for business

China's rare earth export controls are good for Beijing, bad for business

Time of India3 hours ago
China's export restrictions on rare earths brought parts of the global auto supply chain to a halt and U.S. President Donald Trump to the negotiating table. But at home, they're a big headache for companies already struggling with a slow economy.
Beijing curbed rare earth and magnet exports in April in retaliation against U.S. tariffs, driving down magnet makers' offshore sales at the same time as they face pressure from a weak economy and tough times in one of their key markets - EVs.
The pain for magnet makers is unlikely to ease soon, even after the U.S. announced a deal with China on June 27 to get rare earths flowing again.
Any agreement would take time to implement, said Baotou Rare Earth Products Exchange, a state-backed trading platform, noting that inventory was piling up in warehouses, in a post on WeChat 12 hours after the deal was announced.
The export curbs led to a 75% drop in magnet exports in the two months after the restrictions were imposed and forced several global auto makers to pause some production.
Live Events
The restrictions caused a "crisis" for some local magnet makers, the Baotou exchange, based in Inner Mongolia, one of China's rare earths hubs, said in May.
While China produces 90% of the
rare earth magnets
used worldwide and consumes most of them, exports ranged from 18% to 50% of total revenue in 2024 among the 11 largest publicly listed magnet producers by capacity, public filings show.
"Their sales are now being squeezed from both ends - disrupted exports and flagging domestic demand," said Ellie Saklatvala, head of metal pricing at commodities information provider Argus.
"They have temporarily lost an important part of their customer base, with no certainty about when they will regain it."
Rare earths are politically sensitive in China and few major listed rare earth companies have commented directly about how the controls will affect their business.
However, two rare earth magnet producers told Reuters revenue is expected to fall this year, speaking on condition of anonymity given the issue's sensitivity.
"It will have a huge impact on the export business, although it's hard to tell exactly how much of a loss we will suffer for now," said one of the rare earth magnet producers, requesting anonymity due to the sensitivity of the matter.
Small- and medium-sized producers cut production by around 15% in April and May, according to another source with knowledge of the matter, who also declined to be named.
EXPORT CURBS' IMPACT UNDERESTIMATED
Much like U.S. chipmaker Nvidia, China's rare earth magnet makers are victims of their own importance.
Caught in the geopolitical crossfire of Washington's tariffs and China's retaliation, share prices of the listed magnet makers slumped in April after the export curbs were announced. However, they have climbed off their lows over the past three months.
The rebound does not appear to be based on any reasonable forecast of the industry's future, said Cory Combs, head of critical mineral research at consultancy Trivium China.
"I can see various market outlooks, more or less negative depending on the assumptions, but none of them yield a sustainable rise in share price like we're seeing," he said.
Many magnet makers are also private, so share prices only tell a limited story, he said.
Many producers already faced weaker conditions at home, including a price war among electric vehicle makers, a key customer segment, that has seen manufacturers demand discounts from suppliers.
In addition, the highly customised nature of many magnet products makes it hard to resell cargoes domestically, forcing magnet makers to store them during the wait for licenses, four sources said, also speaking anonymously.
CHALLENGES MAY SPUR CONSOLIDATION
Listed magnet maker Baotou Tianhe Magnetics Technology Co noted the export curbs in its annual report released in late April, and said its export revenue could decline if the international situation deteriorated.
Yantai Zhenghai Magnetics said last week it had received export licenses and production was normal. It referred investors to its upcoming financial filings for specific operating results.
However, a quick return to the previous status quo is unlikely if the rare earth controls are implemented in a manner similar to those on other critical minerals including germanium and antimony, according to Argus' Saklatvala.
China imposed export controls on germanium and antimony over the course of 2023 and 2024. Despite being used mostly by civilian industries, which in theory should face few issues getting licenses, exports have still not recovered fully, customs data shows.
Europe is receiving only a tiny fraction of the antimony it imported from China before export controls were imposed last September. The shortages are already causing major problems for lead-acid battery makers, commonly found in gasoline engines.
"Looking at China's recent export controls on other critical minerals - such as antimony - it is clear that it can sometimes take longer than expected for exports to resume and normalise," Saklatvala added.
The large amounts of information required by export license authorities are a permanent change for the industry that will add delays and costs for producers, said David Abraham, affiliate professor at Boise State University, in Idaho.
"In some sense, there's no going back," he said.
In an industry that has hundreds of manufacturers, the pressures could lead to consolidation, he said.
"I do not know if Beijing sees that as a bad thing, because further consolidation is helpful for controlling and understanding where materials go."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

90-day pause on Trump tariffs set to expire soon. Can renewed trade barriers complicate US Fed's rate cut path?
90-day pause on Trump tariffs set to expire soon. Can renewed trade barriers complicate US Fed's rate cut path?

Mint

time19 minutes ago

  • Mint

90-day pause on Trump tariffs set to expire soon. Can renewed trade barriers complicate US Fed's rate cut path?

US Fed Rate Cut: US President Donald Trump's tariff policies have added a layer of complexity to the Federal Reserve's rate-cut deliberations, as the US central bank remains concerned about potential inflationary fallout from higher tariffs. Now, ahead of the expiry of the 90-day pause on tariffs this week on July 9, Trump said on Sunday that the US is close to finalising several trade agreements in the coming days and will notify other countries of higher tariff rates by July 9. Trump in April announced a 10% base tariff on most countries and higher "reciprocal" rates of up to 50%. Trump also threatened an extra 10% tariff on countries aligning themselves with what he called the anti-American policies of the BRICS group of developing nations. While no substantial trade deals are in place yet, the concerns for the economy continue to linger, further impacting the US Fed's rate cut decision. The US Fed Chief Jerome Powell has already communicated that the central bank will 'wait and learn more' about how these tariffs are filtering into higher inflation before they start to focus on interest rates. Other Fed officials also say that the unclear trade policy and the chance that adding or bringing back higher fees could push prices up again means they will be careful and rely on data before cutting rates. Pranay Aggarwal, Director and CEO of Stoxkart said the approaching expiry of the 90-day pause on Trump-era tariffs could reignite trade tensions, especially between major economies like the US and China. "If renewed trade barriers are introduced, we may see a ripple effect on global inflation, supply chains, and investor sentiment. For the US Federal Reserve, this adds another layer of complexity; rising trade-related inflationary pressures could delay or limit the scope of planned rate cuts, as the Fed continues to balance between cooling inflation and supporting growth," Aggarwal added. Palka Arora Chopra, Director, Master Capital Services believes the reimposition of trade barriers by the US, and may further postpone any rate cuts. Delayed rate cuts also don't bode well for emerging markets (EMs) like India, as higher US interest rates curb FII inflows into EMs. In the last policy meeting, the US Fed along expected lines kept the rates unchanged at 4.25-4.5%, while the Fed's dot plot continued to signal two rate cuts for 2025. The dot plot is a chart published by the US Fed that shows the FOMC's future path on interest rates. Last week, data showed US job growth was unexpectedly solid in June, further easing pressure for the Fed to cut rates. Minutes from the US Fed's last meeting due later this week could shed more light on the US central bank's rate cut path. Indian stock market has traded on a backfoot ahead of the tariff pause deadline. On Monday, July 4, both BSE Sensex and NSE Nifty ended with small cuts as investors continued to stay on the sidelines. Analysts believe From an Indian market perspective, such developments often translate into increased volatility. "Additionally, any global uncertainty tends to impact foreign institutional investor (FII) flows, which are a key driver of Indian equity markets. While India remains structurally strong, short-term knee-jerk reactions cannot be ruled out if global trade disruptions escalate," Aggarwal said. Meanwhile, commenting on the impact of a possible US-India trade deal, Chopra said that the larger impact on Indian stock markets hinges upon the outcome of the trade negotiations: a deal would sell well, while failure would certainly have a spillover effect on exporters and general market sentiment. Disclaimer: This story is for educational purposes only. The views and recommendations made above are those of individual analysts or broking companies, and not of Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.

Foxconn second quarter revenue rises 15.82% on year
Foxconn second quarter revenue rises 15.82% on year

Time of India

time23 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Foxconn second quarter revenue rises 15.82% on year

Taiwan's Foxconn , the world's largest contract electronics maker, reported record second-quarter revenue on strong demand for artificial intelligence products but cautioned about geopolitical and exchange rate headwinds. Revenue for Apple 's biggest iPhone assembler jumped 15.82% year-on-year to T$1.797 trillion, Foxconn said in a statement on Saturday, beating the T$1.7896 trillion LSEG SmartEstimate, which gives greater weight to forecasts from analysts who are more consistently accurate. Robust AI demand led to strong revenue growth for its cloud and networking products division, said Foxconn, whose customers include AI chip firm Nvidia. Smart consumer electronics, which includes iPhones, posted 'flattish' year-on-year revenue growth affected by exchange rates, it said. June revenue roses 10.09% on year to T$540.237 billion, a record high for that month. Foxconn said it anticipates growth in this quarter from the previous three months and from the same period last year but cautioned about potential risks to growth. "The impact of evolving global political and economic conditions and exchange rate changes will need continued close monitoring," it said without elaborating. U.S. President Donald Trump said he had signed letters to 12 countries outlining the various tariff levels they would face on goods they export to the United States, with the "take it or leave it" offers to be sent out on Monday. The Chinese city of Zhengzhou is home to the world's largest iPhone manufacturing facility, operated by Foxconn. The company, formally called Hon Hai Precision Industry, does not provide numerical forecasts. It will report full second quarter earnings on August 14. Foxconn's shares jumped 76% last year, far outperforming the 28.5% rise for the Taiwan market, but are down 12.5% so far this year, reflecting broader pressure on tech stocks rattled by Trump's tumultuous trade policy. The stock closed down 1.83% on Friday ahead of the revenue data release, compared with a 0.73% drop for the benchmark index.

Samsung Electronics Q2 profit likely to drop 39% on weak AI chip sales
Samsung Electronics Q2 profit likely to drop 39% on weak AI chip sales

Time of India

time23 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Samsung Electronics Q2 profit likely to drop 39% on weak AI chip sales

Samsung Electronics is expected to forecast a 39% plunge in second-quarter operating profit on Tuesday, weighed down by delays in supplying advanced memory chips to artificial intelligence chip leader Nvidia . The world's biggest maker of memory chips is projected to report an April-June operating profit of 6.3 trillion won ($4.62 billion), its lowest income in six quarters, according to LSEG SmartEStimate. The prolonged weakness in its financial performance has deepened investor concerns over the South Korean tech giant's ability to catch up with smaller rivals in developing high-bandwidth memory (HBM) chips used in artificial intelligence data centres. Its key rivals, SK Hynix and Micron , have benefited from robust demand for memory chips needed for AI, but Samsung's gains have been subdued as it relies on the China market, where sales of advanced chips have been restricted by the U.S. Its efforts to get the latest version of its HBM chips to Nvidia certified by Nvidia are also moving slowly, analysts said. "HBM revenue likely remained flat in the second quarter, as China sales restrictions persist and Samsung has yet to begin supplying its HBM3E 12-high chips to Nvidia," said Ryu Young-ho, a senior analyst at NH Investment & Securities. He said Samsung's shipments of the new chip to Nvidia are unlikely to be significant this year. Samsung, which expected in March that meaningful progress over its HBM chip could come as early as June, declined to comment on whether its HBM 3E 12-layer chips had passed Nvidia's qualification process. The company, however, has started supplying the chip to AMD , the U.S. firm said in June. Samsung's smartphone sales are likely to remain solid, helped by demand for stock ahead of potential U.S. tariffs on imported smartphones, analysts said. Many of its key businesses including chips, smartphones and home appliances continue to face business uncertainty from various U.S. trade policies including President Donald Trump's proposal for a 25% tariff on non-US-made-smartphones and the July 9 deadline for "reciprocal" tariffs against many of its trading partners. The U.S. is also considering revoking authorisations granted to global chipmakers including Samsung, making it more difficult for them to receive U.S. technology at their plants in China. Shares in Samsung, the worst performing stock among major memory chipmakers this year, have climbed about 19% this year, underperforming a 27.3% rise in the benchmark KOSPI.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store