Google moves SC against NCLAT order on Play Store billing practices
Empower your mind, elevate your skills
Google and its related companies have moved the Supreme Court against the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal's March order that partly upheld some of the Competition Commission of India 's (CCI) findings of unfair practices and abuse of dominant position by them in their Play Store billing policy.Google and its related companies – Alphabet Inc, Google Ireland, Google India, Google India Digital Services - have challenged the March 28 judgment by the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal ( NCLAT ) which largely affirmed the CCI's core findings that Google abused its dominant position in multiple markets in the Android mobile device ecosystem through its Play Store policies and engaged in unfair promotion of Google Pay, thereby violating Section 4(2)(e) of the Competition Act.The tech companies have also challenged the NCLAT's May 1 order that corrected its "inadvertent error" in its original judgment, reinstating CCI's two key data-related directives, which require tech gaint to disclose its data policies and refrain from leveraging billing data for competitive advantage.The appeal that was filed on Monday is expected to be listed soon for hearing.Google spokesperson confirmed that 'we have filed an appeal against the NCLAT's recent decision regarding the CCI's order. We remain committed to supporting the growth of the Indian app ecosystem for both developers and users.'CCI's October 20 order had penalised Google for allegedly exploiting its dominant position in markets such as online search and the Android app store. The competition watchdog had imposed a penalty of Rs 936 crore against the tech giant and its companies for engaging in anti-competitive behaviour by mandating the use of its Google Play Billing System for app purchases, while exempting its own applications like YouTube from similar commission structures. The antitrust body had also directed Google to cease these practices, including allowing third-party billing and ensuring data transparency.While the appellate tribunal affirmed the CCI's s order that Google imposed unfair and discriminatory conditions on app developers through mandatory use of Google Play billing system for paid apps and in-app purchases, it set aside the competition watchdog's findings regarding denial of market access and restriction of innovation on the grounds that Google's billing services constituted less than 1% of total UPI transactions and that there was insufficient evidence of market foreclosure or hindrance to technical development.The original penalty of Rs 936.44 crore was also reduced by the NCLAT to Rs 216.69 crore by limiting it to Play Store-specific revenues rather than the Google's global turnover.Indian startups including People Interactive India (operator of Shaadi.com), Mebigo Labs (owner of Kuku FM), the Indian Broadcasting and Digital Foundation and the Indian Digital Media Industry Foundation had moved the CCI seeking probe into the Google's functioning.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
19 minutes ago
- Time of India
Lured in earning high returns in stock market, 4 lose 1.25cr
Pune: Cybercrooks cheated four people in city out of Rs 1.24 crore in separate online share trading frauds between Oct last year and June. Separate cases have been registered with the Bavdhan, Koregaon Park, and Kondhwa police on Thursday. Inspector Bhaksar Kadam of the Bavdhan police said a woman (35) from Bhugaon, an employee of a prominent software company in Yerawada, lost Rs 52.4 lakh to cybercrooks in Oct last year. She filed an online complaint. After preliminary investigations, a case was registered on Thursday. "The complainant told us that a woman contacted her and claimed that she was from a prominent brokerage firm. She assured the victim of good profit on her investments in the stock market through their firm," Kadam said. You Can Also Check: Pune AQI | Weather in Pune | Bank Holidays in Pune | Public Holidays in Pune The officer said the victim downloaded the firm's app and started investing money. She transferred amounts and could see in the app that she was earning a good profit. After transferring Rs 47.38 lakh to different bank accounts, the complainant tried to withdraw her money. She was then told to pay Rs 5 lakh in tax. The victim transferred that amount as well. "The victim became suspicious when the brokerage firm stopped responding to her calls. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Many Are Watching Tariffs - Few Are Watching What Nvidia Just Launched Seeking Alpha Read More Undo She realised she was duped and approached the police," Kadam said. Similarly, a medical practitioner (28) from Koregaon Park lost Rs 28.2 lakh between May and June this year. She stated in her complaint that she came into contact with the cybercrooks through her father, who was already in a group of investors on his mobile messenger app. She was added to another group of investors, where she was given information about the stock market. She was then told to download an app to make investments. "Initially, the complainant transferred Rs 50,000 and earned a profit of Rs 4,500 on her investment. Between May and June, she transferred Rs 28.20 lakh to different bank account numbers," an officer from the Koregaon Park police said. The officer said when the woman tried to withdraw her money, she was told to pay Rs 12 lakh, claiming that she had been given additional IPOs of that amount. When the woman refused to pay the money, the crooks stopped responding to her calls and duped her, the officer said. Using same modus operandi, cybercrooks duped a private company official (46) from Katraj and a pharmaceutical firm manager (33) of Rs36 lakh and Rs7.76 lakh, respectively, between March and June. Two separate cases were registered with the Kondhwa police on Thursday. The 46-year-old victim was promised a 10% profit on his investments in the stock market and crooks took money from him to different bank accounts under the pretext of purchasing IPOs and payment of tax, an officer from the Kondhwa police said.
Time of India
20 minutes ago
- Time of India
IIM-Lucknow hosts investors meet highlighting startup growth in UP
Lucknow: The IIM-Lucknow Enterprise Incubation Centre hosted a dynamic Investors Meet on its Noida campus on Friday. Additional CEO Invest UP, Shashank Choudhary, said Uttar Pradesh was an emerging hotspot for innovation-driven startups, backed by progressive policy reforms and a robust funding ecosystem. He outlined how the UP Startup Policy 2020, supported by a Rs 1,000 crore corpus, laid a strong foundation for long-term startup growth. "Today's investors are not just financiers but strategic growth partners—providing capital, mentorship, market access, and governance support," he said. TNN
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
UK FTA: Textile sector needs to localise, scale up to win big
Chennai: The new trade deal with the UK has opened a significant opportunity for the $1.45 billion Indian readymade garment (RMG) industry to capture a larger share in the lucrative market but the success hinges on developing local value chain, especially of man-made fiber (MMF) and capacity for mass production. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Industry experts believe this is crucial for them to be globally competitive and realise the full potential of the deal. Indian apparel exports are expected to have 9% cost advantage, with the tariff cut making it competitive with Bangladesh, Vietnam and China. Indian RMG export is expected to double to $3.5 billion in the near future, according to Dr A Sakthivel, vice chairman of apparel export promotion council (AEPC), a trade body. "Out of this, Knitwear exports alone are expected to increase from $ 0.8 billion to nearly $ 2 billion, accounting for around 70% of total RMG exports to the UK," he said. The UK dept of business and trade, in its sectoral impact assessment report, estimated Indian textile, apparel and leather imports to increase 85%. Indian companies have been losing market share to Bangladesh due to tariff differential. Despite fluctuations, India ranks fourth among largest garment import sources in the UK Sakthivel said the deal offers an opportunity to gain market share from competing nations and to diversify its product portfolio. The Indian garment exports predominantly being cotton products like T-shirts, summer wear and baby garments. Exporters TOI spoke to stressed the need to expand into the fast-growing athleisure and winter garment categories. They called for increasing capacity in MMF supply chain from yarn and dyeing units to processing units which requires increased mechanisation. "In addition to the PLI for MMF and technical textiles, which caters to larger manufacturers, the union govt needs to incentivise small and medium scale manufacturers to invest in capital equipment (with the ticket size of Rs 10 crore to Rs 30 crore) and help them building larger facilities to achieve economies of scale," says Alexander Neroth, director of NC John Garments, an exporter from Tiruppur. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now These are crucial for competing with Asian majors in quality and price, he adds. Deloitte in a report said it would be important to evaluate strategic shifts in the supply chain to reap the full benefits of the CETA and mitigate risks. Currently India relies on imports from Taiwan and China for MMF. Indian footwear market to get more competitive, say makers Leather products and synthetic footwear makers say the deal will make Indian exports competitive. J Rafiq Ahmed, chairman of Kothari Industrial Corporation, who is working with global footwear brands said the deal will pave the way for increased sourcing of synthetic footwear for the UK market, as part of global shifts. He added that Indian makers need to focus on sustainability and aligning with global norms. GLC Vijayan, managing director of Good Leather, exporter of formal and children's leather shoes said the products imposed 16% duty are now duty free and expect a boost in the order this season.
