
Doubt cast over suggestions incestuous ‘god-kings' ruled Newgrange during Neolithic Ireland
Such claims followed a study in 2020 that suggested evidence of incestuous unions at the site.
A study of the DNA of an adult male buried there revealed he had been born of an incestuous union. His parents were either siblings or parent and child.
The finding led the research team at the time, headed by Trinity College Dublin, to speculate that the elite associated with the monument practised incest as a way of maintaining a dynastic bloodline.
This implied he was among a ruling social elite akin to the similarly inbred Inca god-kings and Egyptian pharaohs.
But now, in findings published in the journal Antiquity, researchers say that the ancient genome of the adult male revealed a 'rare case of incest, which led to claims in 2020 that the individual was a high-status ruler, with press coverage dubbing them a 'god-king''.
Associate professors Jessica Smyth and Neil Carlin at UCD School of Archaeology point out that no other incestuous unions have been identified in Neolithic Ireland and Britain, and say there is a lack of evidence for inbreeding across prehistoric Europe.
They also say the evidence found at the site does not support the existence of a 'king' of Newgrange or any hereditary power or dynasty with a shared ancestry.
'People were definitely being selected for burial in passage tombs – the whole community does not end up in these monuments. However, we don't know the reasons behind this selection,' Professor Smyth said.
'Unlike today, bodies don't tend to be buried 'whole' or 'intact' in this time period. Before they end up in megalithic monuments, bodies are broken down, sometimes cremated and even circulated around their communities
ADVERTISEMENT
Learn more
.'
Professors Smyth and Carlin argue that these conclusions relied heavily on unsuitable comparisons with hierarchical societies where incest was limited to ruling families, such as in ancient Egypt, while ignoring examples of incest in non-elite or egalitarian communities.
'A one-off example of incest is a shaky foundation on which to reconstruct an elite, let alone a specific social [hierarchy],' the authors said.
Newgrange is believed to have been built by a farming community that prospered in the Boyne Valley, Co Meath, about 5,000 years ago.
It is far more likely, they argue, that rather than being reserved for elite rulers or a ruling dynasty, the tombs at Newgrange were places where people made their kin through a range of practices, including living, working and burying their dead together.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Irish Sun
6 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Incredible ancient lost city from 3,500-years-ago home to the Americas' oldest civilization uncovered in Peru
AN ANCIENT city that is over 3,500 years old has been unearthed in Peru. The ancient city of Peñico is thought to have been a vital link between early Pacific coast settlements and remote communities deep in the Advertisement 4 Aerial view of the archaeological zone in the northern Barranca province as archaeologists on Thursday unveiled a 3,500-year-old city in Peru Credit: Reuters 4 It is believed to date back to between 1,800 and 1,500 BC Credit: Reuters 4 Archaeologists say the discovery sheds light on what became of the Americas' oldest civilisation Credit: Reuters Located in the northern Barranca province - around 120 miles north of It is believed to date back to between 1,800 and 1,500 BC - around the period that early civilisations were flourishing in the Incredible Advertisement After eight years of research 18 structures were found including ceremonial temples and residential complexes. Objects were also discovered in buildings at the site including ceremonial objects, clay sculptures of human and animal figures and necklaces made from beads and seashells. Peñico is located close to where Caral was established 5,000 years ago in the Supe valley of Recognised as the oldest known civilisation in the Americas, Caral features 32 monuments. Advertisement Most read in The US Sun This includes large pyramid structures, sophisticated irrigation agriculture and urban settlements. It is believed to have developed in isolation to other comparative early civilisations in Ancient Pompeii home unseen for 2,000 YEARS finally unearthed Dr Ruth Shady, the She told the Reuters news agency that the Peñico community was "situated in a strategic location for trade, for exchange with societies from the coast, the highlands and the jungle." Advertisement Archaeologist Marco Machacuay, a researcher with the Ministry of Culture, unveiled the findings at news conference on Thursday. He said that Peñico's importance lies in it being a continuation of the Caral society. Many of the Americas' most significant archaeological discoveries have been found in Peru. This includes the Inca citadel of Machu Picchu in the Andes and the mysterious Nazca lines etched into the desert in southern Peru. Advertisement 4 Peñico is believed to have developed in isolation to other comparative early civilisations Credit: Reuters


Extra.ie
19 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Trinity and UCD students 'shocked' to learn their degrees aren't accredited
Students at two of the country's most prestigious universities were 'shocked' to learn their high-points degree courses are not accredited by the national regulatory body. It has also emerged that Trinity College Dublin and UCD have not even applied to get their Biomedical Science Degree accredited by CORU, the State regulator for health and social care professionals. The university courses lack accreditation because they do not provide the practical, hands-on training required for medical science professions. University College Dublin. Pic: File This means Trinity and UCD biomedical science degrees are not considered fully qualified by the industry regulator. A CORU spokesperson told 'It is the responsibility of individual education providers to apply for programme approval, and CORU has not received an application for approval for these programmes.' Jagoda Ennis, who is heading into her fourth year of Biological, Biomedical and Biomolecular Science at UCD – a course that required 566 CAO points when she sat her Leaving Cert in 2022 – said she was never informed about the lack of accreditation. Jagoda Ennis. Pic: Michael Chester She told 'It's nonsense. I'm going into my final year, and I have heard nothing about CORU or that my course isn't registered with it.' Trinity College Dublin offers three biomedical-related undergraduate degrees across different disciplines. These are Human Health and Disease, Biological and Biomedical Sciences and Biomedical Engineering, none of which are CORU accredited. UCD offers two relevant degrees that are not accredited: Biomedical Health and Life Sciences and Biological, Biomedical and Biomolecular Science, both of which have entry requirements of between 555 and 600 Leaving Cert points. University College Dublin. Pic: File UCD and TCD also offer master's courses in Biomedical Science, which are also not accredited. Ms Ennis, 21, said the other pathways to becoming an accredited biomedical scientist in Ireland are 'difficult'. The Tallaght student said: 'I'd have to do a masters in TUD or Limerick to even get CORU recognised. Otherwise, it costs €410, and they might reject me because I don't meet their requirements. And I'd have to find an internship. There are barely any in Ireland for my course. It makes no sense.' Jennifer Cummins. Pic: Stephen Collins/Collins Photos Social Democrats education spokeswoman Jen Cummins said she was 'flabbergasted' to learn the courses are not accredited. She told 'If they're offering courses and there is no career progression, that needs to be clarified. If people are paying fees and then they're not able to do what they're supposed to be doing, they need to know that.' Other medical students have chosen to study abroad because of issues in the third-level sector. Dubliner Udaiveer Parihar said he opted to study medicine at University College London (UCL) because of a 'lack of opportunities' and the Health Professions Admissions Test (HPAT), an admissions test all medicine students are required to take in Irish universities. Mr Parihar told 'The HPAT is a really outdated measure of gauging a person's ability or affinity for medicine and London has a greater and wider scope of opportunities than can be found back at home.' The 19-year-old student said it was 'deeply concerning' to learn that Trinity and UCD biomedical degrees are not accredited. 'It seems almost implied that these institutions would, given their reputation, provide degrees that are aligned with these professional requirements of their field. 'It's a serious oversight that not only misleads students but also contributes to lowered graduate employability.' Mr Parihar also called for greater transparency from Irish universities. He told 'The provision of non-accredited training at a time of healthcare shortages creates a workforce of capable yet unqualified graduates and represents a serious policy failure. There should be more light shed on uncovering the issues present with the academic framework governing these degrees and bringing these programmes into line with guidelines.' In response to queries, Trinity College Dublin said: '[We] are under no obligation to advertise what our course is not. Our students receive a large amount of information on careers in relevant research and other related fields of application and study.' Asked why the university did not apply for accreditation, a spokesperson said the biomedical degree course is 'not a professional course' it is a broader academic course which includes biological sciences'. UCD did not respond to requests for comment. The Department of Further and Higher Education was also contacted for comment.


Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Jaws at 50: the most significant piece of negative publicity sharks have ever received
The theme music alone of the classic film Jaws is scary but the dramatic footage of the giant fish itself, albeit a mechanical model, would be enough to give anyone nightmares. It is hard to believe that this iconic movie is half a century old this year but it is probably the most significant piece of negative publicity that sharks have ever received. Ask anyone you know what they think about sharks and the reply is rarely positive. The movie was based loosely on Peter Benchley's novel Jaws which describes a renegade great white shark on the east coast of the United States. Previously unknown in Irish waters, there are now confirmed records of this species as far north as the Bay of Biscay but reports around Ireland and the UK are confined to anecdotal sightings. Ireland is a globally recognised hotspot for other shark species, such as the basking shark, porbeagle and tope shark, but great whites have yet to be formally recorded here. Found throughout the world's oceans, great white sharks were historically common throughout the Mediterranean before overfishing caused major declines. In 2024, a team of scientists embarked on a major survey with the goal of documenting the presence of the great white shark in Irish waters. Dr Nick Payne of Trinity College Dublin, who led the expedition, said he was optimistic about the team's chances of confirming its presence off the Irish coast. I have never seen a great white shark but I have had an encounter with the largest fish in the Atlantic Ocean. I was sailing off the coast of Mayo when a pair of fins appeared in the water beside the boat, moving slowly on the surface. As the fins came closer, I realised that they were both part of the same animal, a basking shark. It moved sinuously across the sea with a large open mouth capturing the rich harvest of plankton. Basking sharks were once plentiful around the Irish coastline, migrating into our waters in summer and disappearing in the winter. The location of my sighting was not far from Keem Bay at the very western tip of Achill Island. This is a cliff-bound cove with a beautiful sandy beach at its head. Throughout the early 20th century this was the location for the capture and killing of basking sharks and large quantities of the valuable shark oil were exported to England. [ Eye on Nature: If bees can't see red, why is one drawn to this red poppy? Opens in new window ] A shortage of fuel after second World War led to an increasing market for shark oil for use in certain industrial products. The slow-moving basking sharks swam into the bay to feed on dense swarms of plankton near the sea surface. Here they became entangled in nets set by the islanders who then launched their lightweight curraghs and killed the struggling fish, stabbing them with scythe blades attached to long poles. Over a 30-year period up to the 1970s more than 12,000 basking sharks were landed on Achill – an average of at least 400 fish per year. Not surprisingly, catches declined markedly towards the end of this period and, with the availability of alternative mineral oils, the market for shark oil disappeared, allowing the few remaining animals to survive. Today, basking sharks are back, their population slowly recovering from this classic example of overfishing. READ MORE Other shark species are not immune from the pressures of overfishing either. These species fill ecological niches that are important in maintaining a balance within the ecosystem. Their removal can result in cascading effects that have a negative effect on marine biodiversity right down through the food chain. Irish waters are known to contain 71 cartilaginous fish species (sharks and rays), over half of the European list. Of these, 58 were assessed using the latest international categories in the Irish Red List. Six species were considered to be critically endangered – Portuguese dogfish, common (blue) skate, flapper skate, porbeagle shark, white skate and angel shark. For example, numbers of angel sharks recorded in tagging programmes show a decline of over 90 per cent since the 1980s. A further five species were assessed as endangered while six more species were rated as vulnerable. Sharks tend to grow slowly and produce small numbers of young each year, which can make them particularly vulnerable. [ How plans for new Guggenheim museum have triggered major biodiversity row in Spain Opens in new window ] While there are no longer any vessels fishing commercially for threatened cartilaginous fish in Irish waters, some are taken as by-catch in other fisheries, involving both Irish and non-Irish boats. Ireland is not unique in this as, since 1970, the global abundance of sharks and rays has declined by 71 per cent owing to an 18-fold increase in relative fishing pressure. Sharks could use some good PR to encourage better protection and recovery of the threatened species. Richard Nairn is an ecologist and writer. His latest book is Future Wild: Nature Restoration in Ireland .