Mum who fell down Tube platform 'contributed to her own injuries'
Sarah de Lagarde, 47, had her right arm and right leg partially removed after she was run over by two Northern Line trains at High Barnet in September 2022.
Ms de Lagarde, who is the global head of corporate affairs at City investment firm Janus Henderson, fell asleep while on the train home at around 10pm when she was woken up by a fellow passenger.
She got off the train and then slipped over, falling down the gap between the train and the platform.
She then called out for help but no one heard her, and she was struck by two different trains.
Ms de Lagarde is now suing London Underground Ltd (LUL), which is part of Transport for London (TfL).
In defence documents submitted to the Royal Courts of Justice and seen by the Evening Standard, TfL has denied liability and claimed she was 'negligent' in the way she exited the train and 'placed herself in a position of danger'.
The documents said: 'The claimant took a few steps forward on to the platform and then took a few steps backwards, before the rear of her body struck the rear side of the door of the train she had exited from.
'The claimant continued to move backwards and, approximately seven seconds after exiting the train, she fell into the gap between carriages five and six of the train.'
Lawyers for TfL said shortly afterwards, the driver walked through the train to start his return journey and saw her brown bag wedged between the carriage and platform.
He gave it to lost property but did not investigate it further as the driver 'did not see or hear the claimant at that point and did not look into the gap, having no reason to do so'.
The documents said the train set off at about 10pm, running over Ms de Lagarde's right arm.
About five minutes later, a second Northern line train arrived at platform three, crushing Ms de Lagarde's right leg under its wheels.
Speaking outside the Royal Courts of Justice previously, Ms de Lagarde said: 'I was commuting home from work. I fell through the gap. I was run over and crushed by not one, but two London underground trains on the Northern Line. More Trending
'Miraculously, I survived, but it cost me dearly – the first train took my arm, and the second train took my leg.
'That night I also lost my mobility, my independence, my dignity and, above all, my ability to hug my two young children with both arms.'
An eight-week trial has been set for 2027 and a further hearing is set to take place in September.
Got a story? Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk. Or you can submit your videos and pictures here.
For more stories like this, check our news page.
Follow Metro.co.uk on Twitter and Facebook for the latest news updates. You can now also get Metro.co.uk articles sent straight to your device. Sign up for our daily push alerts here.
MORE: Woman pulls out huge knife and lunges at young reveller in London park
MORE: Hottest tube line forecasted where passengers face 32°C carriage hell
MORE: First picture of teen shot dead after 'running for his life' in north London
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
2 days ago
- Glasgow Times
Wrongly jailed Malkinson hails benefits rule change, but will continue fighting
Andrew Malkinson, who was the victim of one of the worst miscarriages of justice in British legal history, will still have the right to apply for means-tested benefits despite receiving his first six-figure payout from the Government miscarriage of justice compensation scheme. A change laid in a statutory instrument in Parliament on July 1, and coming into force on July 22, means that those who receive such compensation payments can continue to claim benefits. Mr Malkinson outside the Royal Courts of Justice in 2023 after his conviction was quashed (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Mr Malkinson said: 'When I was stuck behind my cell door I would never have believed that my case would lead to so many reforms – but I am determined to tear down the system that failed me for so long and is failing so many others. 'I am intensely relieved that thanks to this change to the law, I will still have access to benefits even though the state is starting to compensate me for my wrongful conviction. 'My compensation fund is supposed to pay for the support I need to help me heal, not just day to day life, and that sort of support is expensive, especially as I will need it for so many years to come. 'And this reform will be in place for those who come after me as well.' Mr Malkinson was left living on benefits and using food banks after his release, having to wait two years to get his first interim compensation payment. The 59-year-old has already successfully campaigned to stop prison lodging costs being deducted from payouts, and has spoken out against a £1 million cap on the compensation payments, and rules under which payments are only awarded to people who can prove innocence beyond a reasonable doubt. Ministry of Justice data showed that 6.5% of people who had applied for compensation due to a miscarriage of justice between April 2016 and March 2024 were awarded payouts. Of 591 people who applied, 39 were granted compensation. Mr Malkinson said: 'I remain determined to challenge the completely unfair cap on compensation for the wrongfully convicted – and the ridiculous requirement that a person in my position be required to prove their innocence a second time to get compensated.' His solicitor Toby Wilton urged the government to lift the £1 million cap that was set in 2008. The issue again came to the fore in a separate case in May, that saw Peter Sullivan freed from jail after serving 38 years for a murder he did not commit. Mr Wilton said while the benefits change 'ends a stark injustice', further reforms are needed. 'Miscarriage of justice victims like Andy Malkinson will no longer lose their benefits or social housing on account of having received compensation under the statutory miscarriage of justice compensation scheme. 'They are free to use their compensation payments to try to rebuild their lives. 'But while Andy and other future applicants will no doubt breathe a sigh of relief, the truth is that this change tinkers around the edges of a miscarriage of justice compensation scheme which is not fit for purpose. 'Currently, compensation can only be paid to the very few applicants who can prove their innocence beyond a reasonable doubt – effectively forcing them to prove a negative. 'On top of this, the scheme arbitrarily disadvantages people like Andy who have suffered the most serious miscarriages of justice by capping compensation at £1 million. 'This cap was set in 2008 and would be worth nearly £2 million today, but while the Government has the power to change this cap or remove it, it has so far refused to do this. 'It must act now.'
Western Telegraph
3 days ago
- Western Telegraph
Wrongly jailed Malkinson hails benefits rule change, but will continue fighting
Andrew Malkinson, who was the victim of one of the worst miscarriages of justice in British legal history, will still have the right to apply for means-tested benefits despite receiving his first six-figure payout from the Government miscarriage of justice compensation scheme. A change laid in a statutory instrument in Parliament on July 1, and coming into force on July 22, means that those who receive such compensation payments can continue to claim benefits. Mr Malkinson outside the Royal Courts of Justice in 2023 after his conviction was quashed (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Mr Malkinson said: 'When I was stuck behind my cell door I would never have believed that my case would lead to so many reforms – but I am determined to tear down the system that failed me for so long and is failing so many others. 'I am intensely relieved that thanks to this change to the law, I will still have access to benefits even though the state is starting to compensate me for my wrongful conviction. 'My compensation fund is supposed to pay for the support I need to help me heal, not just day to day life, and that sort of support is expensive, especially as I will need it for so many years to come. 'And this reform will be in place for those who come after me as well.' Mr Malkinson was left living on benefits and using food banks after his release, having to wait two years to get his first interim compensation payment. The 59-year-old has already successfully campaigned to stop prison lodging costs being deducted from payouts, and has spoken out against a £1 million cap on the compensation payments, and rules under which payments are only awarded to people who can prove innocence beyond a reasonable doubt. Ministry of Justice data showed that 6.5% of people who had applied for compensation due to a miscarriage of justice between April 2016 and March 2024 were awarded payouts. Of 591 people who applied, 39 were granted compensation. Mr Malkinson said: 'I remain determined to challenge the completely unfair cap on compensation for the wrongfully convicted – and the ridiculous requirement that a person in my position be required to prove their innocence a second time to get compensated.' His solicitor Toby Wilton urged the government to lift the £1 million cap that was set in 2008. The issue again came to the fore in a separate case in May, that saw Peter Sullivan freed from jail after serving 38 years for a murder he did not commit. Mr Wilton said while the benefits change 'ends a stark injustice', further reforms are needed. 'Miscarriage of justice victims like Andy Malkinson will no longer lose their benefits or social housing on account of having received compensation under the statutory miscarriage of justice compensation scheme. 'They are free to use their compensation payments to try to rebuild their lives. 'But while Andy and other future applicants will no doubt breathe a sigh of relief, the truth is that this change tinkers around the edges of a miscarriage of justice compensation scheme which is not fit for purpose. 'Currently, compensation can only be paid to the very few applicants who can prove their innocence beyond a reasonable doubt – effectively forcing them to prove a negative. 'On top of this, the scheme arbitrarily disadvantages people like Andy who have suffered the most serious miscarriages of justice by capping compensation at £1 million. 'This cap was set in 2008 and would be worth nearly £2 million today, but while the Government has the power to change this cap or remove it, it has so far refused to do this. 'It must act now.'
Metro
6 days ago
- Metro
Mum hits back at TfL for 'blaming her' for losing arm and leg under Tube trains
A PR executive who was crushed by two Tube trains has accused TfL of blaming her for the accident that left her with life-changing injuries. Sarah de Lagarde, 47, had parts of her right arm and leg amputated after two Northern Line trains ran her over at High Barnet on September 30, 2022. She told MailOnline: 'TfL is blaming me for being run over and crushed by not one, but two London Underground trains. 'TfL's initial reaction was to label me as a drunk woman wearing high heels, both claims were baseless and have since been withdrawn. 'TfL has posters up across its network urging everyone to 'be kind', which couldn't be further from how they have treated me.' On the night in question, Ms de Lagarde lost her footing and fell down the gap between the train and platform edge. The mother-of-two called for help but nobody heard her, including the Tube driver who saw her handbag and took it to lost property before going on with his journey at 9.54pm, running over her arm. Five minutes later a second train pulled into the platform, crushing her right leg. Ms de Lagarde said: 'I knew in that moment, there was a high chance I was going to die on those Northern Line tracks. 'I started to think about my children, and I knew I owed it to them to come home. I thought to myself, there is no way I am dying here. I need to be with my daughters.' Ms de Lagarde, who is head of PR for the investment firm Janus Henderson, has taken the case to the High Court, and is suing TfL for £25 million. Defence documents seen by Metro show that TfL has denied liability, accusing her of being 'negligent' in the way she alighted the train and 'placed herself in a position of danger'. TfL says Ms de Lagarde did not maintain her balance, was not on a stable footing, had insufficient regard for her own safety, and was not listening to the 'mind the gap' announcements. Prashant Popat KC, for LUL, said: 'We recognise that this is a tragic case, and the claimant sustained some horrific injuries.' He added in written submissions: 'The defendant denies these allegations. 'It also pleads contributory negligence. 'The parties are agreed that the case should proceed first towards a preliminary issue trial on liability. This would encompass breach of duty, causation and the issue of contributory negligence.' She also said previously: 'Miraculously, I survived, but it cost me dearly – the first train took my arm, and the second train took my leg. 'That night I also lost my mobility, my independence, my dignity and, above all, my ability to hug my two young children with both arms.' She now uses two prosthetic limbs including a bionic arm, and is 'absolutely terrified' of using public transport. An eight-week trial has been set for 2027 and a further hearing is set to take place in September. Thomas Jervis, a partner at the law firm Leigh Day, which is representing Ms de Lagarde, said: 'Like millions of other Londoners, Sarah de Lagarde was just trying to get home from work when she was hit by two tube trains at High Barnet station. 'Transport for London is refusing to accept liability and positively blames Sarah for what happened. More Trending 'This case is incredibly important and may have a profound impact on how London's transport network is operated in the future.' A TfL spokesperson said: 'We are responding to a legal claim brought by Sarah de Lagarde. It is not appropriate to discuss details of our defence while this case is ongoing. 'Our thoughts continue to be with Sarah and her family following this terrible incident, and we will continue to make every possible effort to learn from any incident on the Tube network. 'Safety is our top priority and we will always place it at the forefront of our thinking.' Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Huge flames force Brixton Underground station to close while firefighters tackle blaze MORE: Pub staff tried to save man after he was stabbed to death outside Wetherspoons MORE: Erin Patterson found guilty of murdering her three in-laws with death cap mushrooms
