logo
Column: In a world of easily manipulated images, can movies retain their magic?

Column: In a world of easily manipulated images, can movies retain their magic?

Chicago Tribune05-06-2025
I love getting faked out by the movies.
I love believing the impossible, if only for a moment. Moviewise, I live for a lot of things; one of them, by which I was floored at the age 5, was Buster Keaton's 'Cops' (1922) and his startling genius as a physical and comic presence. Half the time, at that age, I wasn't sure if what I was watching was actually happening. That's how it is with beautiful illusions, created from real risks that become the audience's reward.
When the right people collaborate on the right movie, it sometimes happens: a fresh combination of legitimately dangerous stunt work and crafty but not frantic editing, along with the inevitable layer of digital effects elements. What do you get? Honest fakery. The best kind. The kind that elicits a single, astonished, delighted response in the mind of the beholder:
Can I believe what I just saw?
Across eight 'Mission: Impossible' movies, including the one now in theaters, Tom Cruise has been doing the damnedest stunts for nearly 30 years to provoke that response. Action movies can make anybody do anything on screen. Cruise doesn't do it alone; the digital effects teams stay pretty busy on the 'M:I' franchise. Cruise is now 62, and denying it with every maniacal sprint down some faraway city's waterfront boulevard. He knows that dangling, at high speed and altitude, from various parts of an antagonist's biplane in 'Mission: Impossible — The Final Reckoning' is a good, old-fashioned selling point, in an era crowded with deceptions.
In 'Final Reckoning' we don't see the harnesses and cables ensuring that stunt's relative safety. Those implements have been digitally erased, a visual filmmaking practice now as common as the common cold. But there he is, the secret agent ascending and descending, with someone trying to kill him. Tom Cruise, doing something most of us wouldn't.
Lately, though, the movie industry's most sought-after audience response — can you believe what we just saw? — lands differently than it did a few years ago. We mutter that question more darkly now, with troubling regularity. And it's not when we're at the movies.
The real world lies to us visually all the time. An onslaught of photographs and videos are presented as verified visual evidence without the verification part. It happens everywhere around the world, every day. And I wonder if it's altering, and corroding, the bargain we make with the movies we see.
Can honest fakery in the name of film escapism compete with the other kinds of fakery permeating our visual lives?
'It's an interesting question,' says University of California-Berkeley computer science professor Hany Farid, a specialist in digital forensics and manipulated media detection. 'It was easier to separate the movies from real life in the analog days, before digital. Now we live in a world where everything we see and hear can be manipulated.'
The real-world stakes are high, Farid warns, because so much evidence in courts of law rests on the truthfulness of visual evidence presented. He says he's been asked to verify a dizzying number of photos for a variety of purposes. The questions never end: 'Is this image really from Gaza? Is this footage from Ukraine real? Is the image Donald Trump holds up on TV real, or manipulated for political purposes?'
Farid's referring there to the alleged and quickly debunked veracity of the photo the president held up on camera during his March 2025 ABC News interview with Terry Moran. In the photo, Maryland resident Kilmar Abrego Garcia, deported to an El Salvadoran prison, is shown as having 'MS-13' gang-signifying tattoos on his hand. The image, widely cited as having been altered, doesn't qualify as a deepfake, Farid says. 'It's not even a shallow-fake.'
Manipulated images and audio have been with us as long as technology has made those images and sounds possible. Not long ago, manipulated falsehood and verifiable visual truth were a little easier to parse.
'When we went to the movies,' Farid says, 'we knew it wasn't real. The world was bifurcated: There were movies, which were entertainment, and there was reality, and they were different. What's happened is that they've started to bleed into each other. Our ground, our sense of reality, is not stable anymore.'
Part of that is artificial intelligence, 'no question,' says Farid. 'Generative AI is not just people creating images that didn't exist or aren't what they're pretending to be. They accumulate to the point where we're living in a world in which everything is suspect. Trust is shaken, if not gone.'
And here's the blurred line concerning the movies and real life, Farid says. Earlier, 'when we viewed images and video, or listened to audio, we thought they were real and generally we were right. And when we went to the movies, we knew the opposite: that they weren't real. Reality and entertainment — two different worlds. Now, though, they're bleeding into each other. The ground is not stable anymore.'
That, in Farid's view, has a lot to do with contemporary American politics and a climate of strategic mistrust created by those in power. 'The outright lying,' he says, is 'dangerous for democracy and for society. And it makes the idea of believing in movies sort of weird.'
Our entertainment can't get enough of AI as a villain right now. On HBO, we have 'Mountainhead' with its Muskian creator of next-generation deepfake software too good to pass up, or slow down. Meantime, the plot of the new 'Mission: Impossible' hinges on AI so fearsome and ambitious, the fate of the world hangs in the balance. Though, for some of us, seeing Ethan Hunt dangle from a biplane, however rickety the narrative excuses for that to happen, is more fun.
So we turn, still, to the movies for honest fakery we can trust. But these are strange days. As Farid puts it: 'You sit in the theater, you immerse yourself in the fantasy. But so much of our real world feels like that now — a fantasy.'
Maybe it's time to retire the phrase 'seeing is believing.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Brad Pitt Will Team with Tom Cruise If They Stay Grounded: ‘I'm Not Gonna Hang My Ass Off Airplane S***'
Brad Pitt Will Team with Tom Cruise If They Stay Grounded: ‘I'm Not Gonna Hang My Ass Off Airplane S***'

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Brad Pitt Will Team with Tom Cruise If They Stay Grounded: ‘I'm Not Gonna Hang My Ass Off Airplane S***'

At the June 9 'F1' premiere in Mexico City, star Brad Pitt spoke with E! News about potentially making a film with fellow box office champ Tom Cruise, an old buddy of Pitt. 'He's sweet,' the 'Ocean's 11' actor said. 'Yeah, we did have our go-cart days back in the '90s,' admitting that Cruise was the superior racer then. Pitt does have stipulations on what would be expected to him if he was ever to appear alongside the ambitious 'Mission: Impossible' stunt performer. More from IndieWire Learn the Lingo: Postproduction Terms Every Aspiring Filmmaker Should Know IFC Center's General Manager Picks Favorite Moments from 20 Years in New York City 'Well, I'm not gonna hang my ass off airplane shit like that,' he said. 'When he does something again that's on the ground.' No matter his stuntman bonafides, 'F1' director Joseph Kosinski, who also directed Cruise in 'Top Gun Maverick,' said that Cruise was not considered to play Pitt's role in the Formula One racing drama.'Tom always pushes it to the limit, but at the same time is super capable and very skilled. They both have the natural talent for driving. But, yeah, I could see Tom maybe scaring us a little bit more,' Kosinski told GQ. Pitt's new movie was first screened for an audience of real Formula One drivers in May ahead of the Monaco Gand Prix. Racer Lando Norris — who also appears in the movie — praised the 'inspirational story,' adding that 'it had a lot of different meanings behind it all. But a cool storyline and a lot of inspiration for young people coming into it.' 'It's going to make people want to watch F1, which is really the goal of it,' driver Oliver Bearman said. 'The onboard shots and the work that they did was actually quite incredible — it was impressive to see the technology that they can use.' Pitt said that, like his 'F1' character, he had precise rituals when preparing for each day of shooting. 'My OCD… before getting in the car, I always have to get in on the left side. I have to put my left shoe on first. I have to put my left glove on first. My belt — the guys knew we had to do left first [before] right. If they didn't we'd have to start over,' he explained. 'F1' hits IMAX theaters on June 25, with its wide release following two days later on June 27. Watch the trailer below: Best of IndieWire Guillermo del Toro's Favorite Movies: 56 Films the Director Wants You to See 'Song of the South': 14 Things to Know About Disney's Most Controversial Movie Nicolas Winding Refn's Favorite Films: 37 Movies the Director Wants You to See

Tom Cruise Celebrates ‘Days of Thunder' as ‘F1' Director Teases Possible Crossover Sequel
Tom Cruise Celebrates ‘Days of Thunder' as ‘F1' Director Teases Possible Crossover Sequel

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Tom Cruise Celebrates ‘Days of Thunder' as ‘F1' Director Teases Possible Crossover Sequel

Tom Cruise is embracing the need for speed… but not of the 'Top Gun' variety. On X June 27, Cruise wrote a congratulatory message to producer Jerry Bruckheimer, who not only is the man behind this weekend's box office hit 'F1,' but also the Cruise-starring NASCAR film 'Days of Thunder' — released in theaters 35 years to the day of the new Brad Pitt-led Formula One action drama. 'I always love the fun and adrenaline of a racing film,' Cruise wrote. 'Today marks two racing milestones for my friend Jerry Bruckheimer, the release of 'F1' and the 35 year anniversary to the day of our collaboration with the great Tony Scott on 'Days of Thunder.'' More from IndieWire Ari Aster Says 'We Have No Say' in How AI Will Impact the World: It's 'Already Too Late' How Victoria Mahoney's Groundbreaking 'Star Wars' Directing Gig Guided Her Work on 'The Old Guard 2' Cruise posted a series of photos from the production of 'Days of Thunder,' all on the race track. 'Incredible to look back on this film today, and congratulations to Jerry, Brad, Joe and the whole F1 team on their release,' Cruise added. The comparisons between Cruise and Pitt's action prowess was also made earlier this month at the 'F1' premiere, when Pitt responded to the suggestion that he star alongside his fellow box office champ in a 'Mission: Impossible'-style thriller. 'Well, I'm not gonna hang my ass off airplane shit like that,' he said in an interview with E! News. 'When he does something again that's on the ground.' The pair have known one another for decades, and racing has helped define their friendship since the beginning — albeit in not quite as high stakes a venue. 'He's sweet,' Pitt said of Cruise. 'Yeah, we did have our go-cart days back in the '90s,' though he said that Cruise usually beat him on the go-cart track. 'F1' director Joseph Kosinski, who also led 'Top Gun: Maverick' in 2022, said there is a possibility 'Days of Thunder' could be woven into a future 'F1' sequel. 'Well, right now, [the sequel would] be Cole Trickle, who was [Cruise's] 'Days of Thunder' character,' Kosinski told GQ (via Movieweb). 'We find out that he and [Brad Pitt's] Sonny Hayes have a past. They were rivals at some point, maybe crossed paths… I heard about this epic go-kart battle on 'Interview With the Vampire' that Brad and Tom had, and who wouldn't pay to see those two go head-to-head on the track?' Pitt and Cruise almost paired together in a racing drama based on the book 'Go Like Hell' by A.J. Baime. In 2013, THR reported that Pitt and Cruise were in talks to star in that movie, which would take six more years to actually make it to the screen. Even before that, the project had been through several potential incarnations, with Pitt rumored to be on the casting list as early as 2009. In the end, neither would end up starring in the movie, and 'Go Like Hell' was a title that eventually was scrapped, too. It instead became 'Ford v. Ferrari,' starred Christian Bale and Matt Damon, netted four Oscar nominations (including Best Picture), and raked in over $225 million at the box office. Best of IndieWire Guillermo del Toro's Favorite Movies: 56 Films the Director Wants You to See 'Song of the South': 14 Things to Know About Disney's Most Controversial Movie Nicolas Winding Refn's Favorite Films: 37 Movies the Director Wants You to See

Brad Pitt Says Tom Cruise Dropped Out of ‘Ford v. Ferrari' When He Realized He ‘Would Not Be Driving That Much'
Brad Pitt Says Tom Cruise Dropped Out of ‘Ford v. Ferrari' When He Realized He ‘Would Not Be Driving That Much'

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Brad Pitt Says Tom Cruise Dropped Out of ‘Ford v. Ferrari' When He Realized He ‘Would Not Be Driving That Much'

With an 'F1' sequel inevitable after its blockbuster opening for Apple, rumors are swirling that the film may race into theaters with not just one but two of Hollywood's biggest stars. Brad Pitt and Tom Cruise have been frequently mentioned in the same sentence over the last month — and it has been over 30 years since the pair appeared onscreen together in 'Interview with a Vampire.' Pitt and Cruise almost starred in 'Ford v. Ferrari,' actually — but Cruise dropped out when, according to Pitt, he found out he would not be spending very much time behind the wheel. 'Tom and I, for a while there, were on 'Ford v Ferrari' with Joe [to direct]. This was about 10 years before the guys who actually made it – and made it a great movie,' Pitt told The National. 'What it came down to is that we both wanted to drive, and [Tom] wanted to play Shelby, and I wanted to play Ken Miles. And when Tom realized that Carroll Shelby would not be driving much in the movie, it didn't come through. So I'm not sure how that's going to work [in a potential 'F1' sequel], but we'll give it a go. I'd love to.' More from IndieWire Searching for the Ideal 4th of July Movie? Look No Further Than 'Drop Zone' NYC Audiences Will Finally See 'Twin Peaks' Season 3 the Way David Lynch Intended Now, there's a shot that Cruise's 'Days of Thunder' character may end up in an 'F1' follow-up, as director Joseph Kosinski said in an interview with GQ Magazine UK. 'Well, right now, it'd be Cole Trickle, who was [Cruise's] 'Days of Thunder' character, we find out that he and [Brad Pitt's] Sonny Hayes have a past. They were rivals at some point, maybe crossed paths,' Kosinski said, adding, 'Who wouldn't pay to see those two go head-to-head on the track?' In discussing what would need to be included in the sequel, Pitt's demands were clear. 'I would want to drive again, selfishly speaking… F1 is still the focus. It needs to be on Joshua Pierce — Damson Idris's character – and the rest of the team fighting for a championship. Where does Sonny fit in? I'm not sure. Sonny's probably out on the Bonneville Salt Flats, setting speed records or something like that. So I'm not sure beyond that, just yet,' Pitt said. 'F1' has become an unqualified box office hit, grossing $161 million in just its first week of release. With the film likely to add much more to its total over the long Independence Day weekend, it has already become the first major theatrical success for Apple's fledgling film studio. Pitt made it clear that he's not taking the movie's unique appeal for granted. 'The greatest pleasure – the thing that puts a smile on my face — is seeing families, from kids to grandparents, big groups of friends all going together and taking photos in front of the poster or the car. It's a rarity for film to reach that level of reaction, especially in this day and time. I think the value of entertainment can sometimes be greater than the piece itself. And I think that's happening here,' Pitt said. Best of IndieWire Guillermo del Toro's Favorite Movies: 56 Films the Director Wants You to See 'Song of the South': 14 Things to Know About Disney's Most Controversial Movie Nicolas Winding Refn's Favorite Films: 37 Movies the Director Wants You to See

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store