Mia Hughes: Canadian Medical Association wants to force Alberta to ignore science on gender care
The entire field is built upon research out of the Netherlands that has been shown to be methodologically flawed, and the diagnosis of gender dysphoria is shaped by political lobbying intended to reduce stigma and distress.
Article content
What's more, the Canadian Pediatric Society bases its recommendations on the field's standards of care which are set by the discredited World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH). In a recently withdrawn legal challenge to Alabama's youth gender medicine ban, WPATH was forced to disclose over two million internal emails that revealed the organization blocked independent systematic reviews that showed low-quality evidence, consulted 'social justice lawyers' when drafting its medical guidelines, and, at the Biden administration's request, removed almost all lower age limits from its adolescent chapter to avoid undermining state-level legal battles.
Article content
Reimer also stated, without irony, that medical decisions should be based on 'the best science.' Yet the best science — specifically the systematic reviews from Sweden, Finland, England, and a team of researchers in Canada — has all concluded the evidence base for paediatric medical transition is of very low certainty. Alberta's Bill 26 reflects that consensus. The CMA's position contradicts it.
Article content
This isn't the first legal challenge to Alberta's legislation. Late last year, Egale Canada — originally a gay rights charity that expanded into trans advocacy in the early 2000s — teamed up with the Skipping Stone Foundation and five families to contest the law. That move is surprising given early research conducted by leading figures in gender medicine, Psychologist/Sexologist Kenneth Zucker and Psychiatrist Susan Bradley, found that most children with early-onset gender dysphoria would grow up to be gay or lesbian if left untreated, and same-sex attracted teens are overrepresented in the adolescent patients who began flooding gender clinics in the 2010s and among detransitioners. That a gay rights group would back medical interventions that have the potential to sterilize homosexual adolescents is a tragic reversal of purpose.
Article content
In an interview, Dr. Jake Donaldson, one of three Alberta doctors who filed the challenge alongside the CMA, inadvertently highlighted the questionable rationale for these extreme medical interventions. He believes that puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones help gender-distressed youth blend in better as members of the opposite sex, which makes them 'safer and happier.' But even if that were true — and there is no high-quality evidence to suggest that it is — this approach only offers a superficial, short-term fix that ignores the deeper psychological struggles of these youth. And it can come at such immense long-term cost in the form of sterility, sexual dysfunction, and lifelong medical dependence.
Article content
'Medicine is a calling,' explained the CMA president in her statement. 'Doctors pursue it because they are compelled to care for and promote the well-being of patients.'
Article content
Yet noble intentions are no safeguard against harm. History is littered with medical scandals. At the centre of each one, there were well-intentioned doctors who left a trail of devastation in their quest to help patients. The doctors who prescribed thalidomide didn't do so with the intention of causing major birth defects; the obstetricians who sent expectant mothers for prenatal X-rays didn't deliberately set out to cause childhood leukemia, and Walter Freeman famously believed his prefrontal lobotomies were a humane alternative to the deplorable conditions in insane asylums.
Article content
At this point, there is little doubt that paediatric gender medicine is destined to take its place in history alongside these medical catastrophes. Therefore, Alberta is not acting unreasonably; it is acting responsibly. By restricting unproven and irreversible treatments for minors, the province has commendably joined a global wave of governments re-asserting evidence and ethical principles in the face of medical groupthink. It is the CMA — not the Alberta government — that must reckon with its conscience.
Article content
Mia Hughes specializes in researching pediatric gender medicine, psychiatric epidemics, social contagion and the intersection of trans rights and women's rights. She is the author of ' The WPATH Files,' a senior fellow at the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, and director of Genspect Canada.
Article content
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
11 minutes ago
- CTV News
Wall Street dips in premarket but remains near record highs as another raft of earnings pours in
Traders Neil Catania, left, and Daniel Kryger work on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, Monday, July 21, 2025. (AP Photo/Richard Drew) Wall Street dipped in premarket trading Tuesday, but indexes remained near record highs on another big day for corporate earnings reports. Futures for the S&P 500 lost 0.1 per cent before the bell, while futures for the Dow Jones Industrial Average and Nasdaq were each off 0.2 per cent. Homebuilders were the early winners, with D.R. Horton climbing nearly seven per cent after easily surpassing Wall Street's third-quarter sales and profit expectations. PulteGroup also topped analysts' forecasts, rising 1.7 per cent, while Lennar rode the wave of optimism and was up 2.1 per cent. General Motors shed 3.6 per cent in the early going after the automaker reported that its profit and revenue declined from the previous quarter. GM maintained its full-year guidance from May, however that forecast was cut as the company braced for a potential impact from auto tariffs as high as US$5 billion in 2025. Shares of Coca-Cola Co. were largely unchanged after the soda giant beat Wall Street profit expectations but fell a tad short on revenue projections. Coke said that its pricing rose six per cent for the April-June period, making up for the one per cent decline in case volumes both globally and in North America. Elsewhere, in Europe at midday, Germany's DAX lost 1.1 per cent, the CAC 40 in Paris gave up 0.9 per cent and Britain's FTSE 100 was nearly unchanged. In Asian trading, Japan's benchmark surged and then fell back as it reopened from a holiday Monday following the ruling coalition's loss of its upper house majority in Sunday's election. The Nikkei 225 shed 0.1 per cent to 39,774.92. Analysts said the market initially climbed as investors were relieved that Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba vowed to stay in office despite the setback. But the election's outcome has added to political uncertainty and left his government without the heft needed to push through legislation. A breakthrough in trade talks with the U.S. might win Ishiba a reprieve, but so far there's been scant sign of progress in negotiating away the threat of higher tariffs on Japan's exports to the U.S. beginning Aug. 1. 'Relief may be fleeting. Ishiba's claim to leadership now rests on political duct tape, and history isn't on his side. The last three LDP leaders who lost the upper house didn't last two months,' Stephen Innes of SPI Asset Management said in a commentary. Elsewhere, Hong Kong's Hang Seng rose 0.5 per cent to 25,130.03, while the Shanghai Composite index advanced 0.6 per cent to 3,581.86. South Korea's Kospi sank 1.3 per cent to 3,169.94, with investors concerned over next week's deadline for making a deal with U.S. President Donald Trump or facing 25 per cent tariffs on all the country's exports to the U.S. Many of Trump's stiff proposed tariffs are paused after he extended the deadline to Aug. 1 to allow more time to reach potential trade deals that could lower those rates. Australia's S&P/ASX 200 added 0.1 per cent to 8,677.20. India's Sensex was flat. In Thailand, the SET sank 1.1 per cent after the government named Vitai Ratanakorn as the new future governor of the central bank. He is viewed as likely to be less independent than the current governor, raising concerns about the bank's independence, analysts said. In energy trading, U.S. benchmark crude oil lost 61 cents to $65.34 per barrel, while Brent crude, the international standard, gave up 65 cents to $68.56 per barrel. The U.S. dollar inched up to 147.40 Japanese yen from 147.38 yen. The euro gained to $1.1701 from $1.1696. By Elaine Kurtenbach and Matt Ott
CBC
34 minutes ago
- CBC
Hamilton dentist welcomes community's 'zero-tolerance' stance after racist graffiti sprayed on office
Social Sharing It seems hate has no fixed address in Hamilton — it recently surfaced on Main Street East, where Sagewood Dental Care, a family-focused practice led by Dr. Brian Yim, was defaced with white supremacist graffiti. "When we returned from the long weekend, the Canada Day long weekend, we saw the graffiti on the building, on the signage and on our glass railing," Yim recounted recently to CBC Hamilton. Initially, he and his team were unsure of its meaning, but that quickly changed. "A couple of our patients pointed it out, unfortunately, and then we realized the implications of the graffiti and what that could mean to us." As a "multinational office," Yim said, he immediately began to worry about the safety of his staff. "All of these things start kind of playing out in your mind of the implications on my responsibility to protect my staff and my team." The graffiti featured numerals that refer to a white nationalist slogan and code that glorifies late Nazi leader Adolf Hitler, the second instance reported to CBC News that occurred in Hamilton that weekend. It highlights a growing concern among community members, and has prompted an assistant professor in the department of religious studies at McMaster University to call for more education and support for organizations that work to eliminate racist ideology and hate. Jeremy Cohen told CBC Hamilton that he's been observing instances of people trying to propagate racist graffiti and white supremacist ideology, especially in Hamilton's Ward 3. "About a week and a half ago, I was going to a dentist appointment, and as I was coming up to the building I noticed the ... graffiti in black bold letters on their white sign," Cohen said. "It's been very upsetting. Ward 3 is a working-class community, but it is such a diverse community. There are people from all over the world here. "I think that it is trying to create a very unwelcoming message. It is trying to tell people that certain people do not belong in this city and that is really unfortunate," added Cohen. Hamilton, like many cities in Canada, clearly has a hate issue. - Jeremy Cohen, McMaster University department of religious studies "Hamilton, like many cities in Canada, clearly has a hate issue [and] a problem with these individuals and groups organizing in this city, and it is very upsetting to know that there are people in our city who feel this way." Ongoing investigation of 'hate-related graffiti' Earlier in July, CBC Hamilton reported about a caterer and community advocate — Reena Rampersad — who found a racial slur scribbled across the front door of her home. Her storefront window was also defaced with numerals that represent white supremacist sentiments sprayed over a poster for an upcoming Caribbean cultural event. Rampersad said the vandalism was a targeted act of hate meant to intimidate her. Last week, city police told CBC Hamilton they continue to investigate the "hate-related graffiti" incident at Rampersad's home and place of business. "Sagewood Dental was also a victim to this hate-motivated crime and is involved in an investigation," a police spokesperson, Trevor McKenna, said in an email. In a July 3 news release, the police service said it was working to identify those responsible, adding that a canvass for video surveillance in the area is ongoing. "We recognize that hate has no place in our city, and we are committed to ensuring all residents feel safe and respected in their homes and places of business," it said. While such hate is deeply concerning, Yim also emphasized the strong community response. "I really am impressed with just the community and how there's a zero tolerance for this kind of thing in our neighbourhood," he said, noting the immediate priority was the removal of the graffiti to avoid perpetuating any hate. "In the end, we haven't really had any altercations ... we've never been confronted by anybody, so we still feel quite safe." Cohen said the graffiti with the numerals is not the only white supremacist slogan or recruitment attempt he's noticed in the area. "For the past several years, posters have been showing up in Ward 3 on telephone poles. A lot of these have been very explicitly white supremacist and trying to recruit individuals. "The posters are often making references to conspiracy theories like the great replacement theory and talking a lot about white identity." Cohen said he's torn down as many of the posters as he could. Ward 3 Coun. Nrinder Nann said there's been "emboldened graffiti activity" in and across her ward, but also into the downtown core. "It's totally unacceptable and concerning to see the increase in activity. It's also my understanding that a lot of these tags showed up around Canada Day, if not on Canada Day, which is even more concerning that people are … connecting the dots between Canadian nationalism and white nationalism." Nann said Hamilton has had "an unfortunate reputation of being a hate incident capital of Canada" and local authorities have been "working aggressively" to speak out every time this kind of incident takes place. Tracking white nationalist 'active clubs' "We have a lot of work to do in terms of better respecting different cultures and backgrounds," Nadine Ubl, executive director of Barton Village BIA, said in an interview, calling the graffiti "concerning." "It's sad to think that this is something that we even have to be concerned about." Hamilton Mayor Andrea Horwath urges residents who discover hate in their neighbourhoods to report it. Her message came after the CBC visual investigation unit found members of white supremacist groups have been preparing for a "race war" in Hamilton-area gyms and parks. Police said they are aware of these groups and "continue to monitor their activities," but "there have been no criminal offences reported to Hamilton police related to these clubs." Anti-racism advocates and researchers said more needs to be done to combat hate. That may include the creation of a hate-crimes task force or a strategic program to address the underlying causes of hate groups.
National Post
41 minutes ago
- National Post
Real Chemistry Deepens Media and Technology Edge With Acquisition of Greater Than One
Article content Acquisition brings proprietary media planning and analytics tools into Real Chemistry's platform – enhancing strategy, performance and measurable impact for pharma and biotech clients. Article content NEW YORK — Real Chemistry, a leader in AI-driven insights and marketing communications for the healthcare sector, today announced it has acquired Greater Than One, an award-winning agency specializing in healthcare-first media, technology and omnichannel strategy. The acquisition brings expanded precision, stronger performance analytics and greater strategic clarity to Real Chemistry clients along every step of the commercialization journey. Article content 'Greater Than One brings deep media expertise, powerful proprietary tools and a culture that matches ours—focused, fast-moving and built to deliver results,' said Shankar Narayanan, CEO of Real Chemistry. 'Greater Than One brings deep media expertise, powerful proprietary tools and a culture that matches ours—focused, fast-moving and built to deliver results,' said Shankar Narayanan, CEO of Real Chemistry. 'Together, we'll help clients make smarter decisions and create more meaningful engagement with the audiences who matter most. We are rewriting the next chapter of what's possible for healthcare marketing and adding Greater Than One to our team gives us even more firepower to drive this revolution.' Article content Precision That Drives Performance Article content Founded nearly 25 years ago, Greater Than One has earned a reputation for helping healthcare brands get the most from their omnichannel and media investments through a combination of data, predictive modeling and proprietary planning tools. These include: Article content Greater Reach, a predictive media planning engine that helps brands model budget and channel mix based on audience and engagement goals. Greater Score, an advanced engagement scoring tool that empowers healthcare brand marketers and sales teams by providing a holistic view of healthcare professional interactions across all addressable media and CRM channels that helps marketers prioritize outreach and improve performance. Greater Omni, Greater Than One's centralized omnichannel platform strategy and implementation capability, gives teams real-time visibility across campaigns—so clients know what's working, where to spend, and how to pivot. Their Omnichannel Maturity Model breaks the process down into clear, actionable stages – no jargon, just a roadmap to smarter engagement, better measurement and stronger returns. Article content These capabilities will be integrated into Real Chemistry's platform – giving clients access to unified planning, measurement and activation strategies grounded in data-driven behavioral science. Article content At the same time, Greater Than One clients will benefit from Real Chemistry's offerings in AI-driven strategy, creative, influencer engagement, medical communications, integrated communications and market access – unlocking a more complete and connected experience for healthcare marketers. Article content 'This move multiplies our capability,' said Kevin Johnson, Group President and Managing Partner at Real Chemistry. 'In a healthcare environment that demands more agility and precision than ever, Greater Than One brings the technology, talent, and focus to help us deliver faster decisions, smarter planning, and measurable impact where it matters most.' Article content Aligned Cultures. Shared Ambition. Integrated Growth. Article content Greater Than One's employees will join Real Chemistry and continue operating under the brand Greater Than One, part of Real Chemistry. The agency will maintain its New York headquarters and remote-first structure. Article content 'Finding a match like Real Chemistry, where our employees and clients will benefit, is exactly what we wanted for Greater Than One,' said Elizabeth Izard Apelles, President and CEO, Greater Than One. 'Our shared belief that building innovative, client-first partnerships leads to impact and results is a powerful force behind this acquisition.' Article content Terms of the transaction are not disclosed. Article content The acquisition builds on a year of strong momentum for Real Chemistry, which was ranked the No. 2 Healthcare Network at Cannes Lions Health 2025, named PRWeek's no. 1 PR Agency, and placed no. 3 on MM+M's Agency 100. The firm was also honored as Outstanding Healthcare Agency of the Year at the 2025 PRWeek U.S. Awards – underscoring its consistent leadership in strategy, innovation and measurable client impact in healthcare. Article content About Greater Than One Article content Greater Than One, part of Real Chemistry, is an advanced media and technology agency serving the healthcare industry. The agency delivers precision media, proprietary technology solutions, and strategic expertise to help clients navigate complexity and drive measurable growth. Greater Than One's unique technology products empowers marketers to understand customer journeys, build evidence-based strategies, forecast marketing budgets, and take actionable steps to drive prescriptions. Article content About Real Chemistry Article content Article content Article content Article content Article content Article content
