Return of corporal punishment? Minister of Education responds
The Minister of Correctional Services made the controversial claim whilst discussing how to curb overcrowding in prisons.
In 1996, corporal punishment was officially abolished in South African schools.
Delivering his budget vote at the National Assembly on Tuesday, 1 July, Minister of Correctional Services Pieter Groenewald discussed several challenges within his department.
They included overcrowding, particularly of offenders who could not afford to pay their bail for petty offences. Some of them included minors, as young as 10 years old, who were jailed for stealing loaves of bread.
Groenewald then suggested a debate on reintroducing corporal punishment, which was abolished in South African schools in 1996 under the Corporal Punishment Act, and later the South African Schools Act, specifically Section 10.
In his speech, he said, 'If you look at our criminal justice system, we must start a debate about whether we should bring back corporal punishment.'
'A young person who steals 10 loaves of bread sits in prison and waits about three years for sentencing. Think about whether we should bring back corporal punishment.'
Groenewald added: 'We must consider the costs. Keeping each of these individuals in custody costs the taxpayer R463 per person each day'.
Although Pieter Groenewald's suggestion was met with strong opposition, ACDP leader, Dr Kenneth Meshoe, agreed with the minister's stance, claiming that the 1996 corporal punishment ban had 'fuelled lawlessness in schools'
He said: 'We have seen a number of children acting foolishly. Bullying has increased in schools, rape is taking place in schools much more than before the banning of corporal punishment.
'Many teachers need protection from their own students. Students have learned to attack teachers, some even attack their parents at home. Now these children end up in prisons because there are parents who are brave enough to lay charges against their own children.'
Meshoe added to the National Assembly: 'There's a difference between abuse and correctional discipline. I know that there are some parents out of frustration, who have gone to extremes and used corporal punishment where they shouldn't have used it.'
Although Pieter Groenwald did not specifically indicate that corporal punishment should be reintegrated into schools, Minister of Education Siviwe Gwarube has already firmly rejected the idea.
She simply posted 'No', responding to the fellow minister's suggestion.
Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 .
Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp , Facebook , X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
27 minutes ago
- TimesLIVE
Trump wants ANC to denounce 'Kill the Boer' song: FF Plus after US visit
Freedom Front Plus leader Corné Mulder has revealed the outcome of the recent visit to the US, in which the party engaged with White House officials under the theme of 'an Afrikaner perspective on US/SA relations'. Mulder said there were four specific non-negotiable conditions US President Donald Trump's administration set out to mend ties between the countries. Among the conditions were for the ANC to denounce the 'Kill the Boer' song and prioritise the fight against farm murders. Problems with the Expropriation Act were also raised. 'I specifically asked, are you talking about the government of national unity? What are you talking about? And the response was we want the ANC as a political party to do that in public,' Mulder said. He said they had meetings with different segments, including people responsible for South African issues. He emphasised that the visit was not to complain to the US government but to help restore diplomatic and trade relations. 'We had a successful visit and we were very well received. It was a comprehensive visit. 'We did not go to the US to complain. We were clear from the beginning that we would like to see our country prosper and be successful. We are of the view that there are certain challenges that are making that very difficult. If we want to succeed, we needed to discuss these things in a frank manner, and we did.' South Africa and the US have had strained relations over misinformation about South Africa's land policies. In May, a group of South African Afrikaners arrived in the US as 'refugees' under an executive order signed by Trump in February. The controversy surrounding the 'Kill the Boer' song resurfaced at the White House in May during President Cyril Ramaphosa's visit at which Trump called for EFF leader Julius Malema's arrest for chanting the song. Ramaphosa dismissed Trump's call, citing the equality court's ruling that the song did not constitute hate speech. 'The slogan, 'kill the Boer, kill the farmer,' is a liberation chant and slogan,' Ramaphosa said. 'That's not meant to be a message that elicits or calls upon anyone to go and be killed. And that is what our court decided. 'We follow the dictates of our constitution because we are a constitutional state, and we are a country where freedom of expression is the bedrock of our constitutional arrangement,' Ramaphosa told Trump.
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
How mathematics education deficiencies threaten South Africa's economic future
Basic Education Minister Siviwe Gwarube. Image: File At least 50% of South Africa's matric pupils need to pass Grade 12 with pure mathematics to provide relevant skills to boost the economy, according to experts. This is largely because economic growth is now happening in the tertiary sector, which requires specialised skills, especially mathematics. However, the Department of Basic Education recently revealed that 464 schools do not offer mathematics as a subject in the country, due to resource constraints and teacher shortages. The most affected province is KwaZulu-Natal with 135 schools. The Eastern Cape has 84 schools, Limpopo has 78 schools, the Western Cape has 61 schools, the North West has 31 schools, Gauteng has 31 schools, the Northern Cape has 19 schools, the Free State has 14 schools, and Mpumalanga has 11 schools. Over the years, the department has experienced budget cuts. Experts argue that South Africa needs to improve its Basic Education if it wants to grow skills that will enable the country to compete globally. Dawie Roodt, chief economist at Efficient Group, said current economic activities are based in the service industry, which is driven by skills and new technology that require mathematics. 'Big companies such as Meta, Google, Tesla, and Microsoft are based on new technology. And they are currently employing mostly programmers and experts in artificial intelligence (AI). If you want to be a programmer or an expert in artificial intelligence, there is one requirement: you must be good at mathematics,' Roodt stated. He added that in the South African economy as well, growth happens in the tertiary sector. However, in primary industries such as agriculture, it happens to a much lesser extent. Agriculture is now also becoming a service industry. Highlighting how sectors were switching to new technology, he said cars now are fixed by guys who plug in a computer to analyse the problem, and that is based on mathematics. Even a language model on ChatGPT is based on an algorithm, which uses mathematics, he said. 'You need a heavy dose of mathematics in all economic activities in order to grow the economy in a way that modern economies are supposed to. If you don't have good mathematics experts in your economy, it is just not going to perform well,' Roodt said. What are the prospects for pupils who are not learning mathematics as a subject? Roodt said not all is lost for these pupils. All they have to do is learn to be good at using technology (AI tools) in whatever field they are in, because this, while effective, does not require one to be good at mathematics. 'But you must have somebody else who knows mathematics to write the application for you to use the technology,' he added. Everyone, including those who excel in mathematics, has to stay on top of whatever the newest, most recent developments are, he said. 'You have to keep on sharpening up your skills. So, don't think for one single moment that you are going to learn something, get a qualification, and then stop learning. You have to learn for the rest of your life. And it doesn't end in all careers,' Rood said. He clarified that this does not mean that everybody must be a mathematician. 'If I had the power, as a minister of Basic Education, I would put all sorts of incentives in place to encourage teachers to improve their skills development. And then start paying those with better skills and better outcomes more than those without the necessary skills and the necessary outcomes. Then, I would start working out those teachers who are not doing their jobs. 'Teaching is a calling and is crucial for any economy. Many good teachers in South Africa are doing an excellent job. Unfortunately, that is not most of them,' Roodt said. He added that there are two things that one needs to teach a child. One is mathematics, and the other is a love for reading. And when a child loves reading and does read, they will be able to learn all other things on their own. Professor William Gumede from the Wits School of Governance said the government must improve the basic education system to avoid setting up learners for failure. 'All countries whose economies are performing well in the tertiary sector have more than 50% of their matriculants passing with mathematics,' he said. Elijah Mhlanga, spokesperson for the Department of Basic Education, stated that to support early mathematics development, the department is reviewing the Post Provisioning Norms to ensure smaller Foundation Phase class sizes and prioritisation of teaching posts that enhance numeracy development, addressing inefficiencies in current post distribution. 'The DBE has advised that learners, in consultation with their parents and schools, are required to select subject streams in Grade 10 that align with their interests and prospective career paths. While Mathematics remains a high-priority subject, schools, particularly smaller ones, may not have sufficient resources or demand to offer both mathematics and mathematical literacy. 'Additionally, some schools face challenges such as limited enrolment in the mathematics stream, making it unviable to run a full class; a shortage of qualified mathematics teachers; and budgetary or timetabling constraints that limit subject offerings,' Mhlanga said.
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
BRICS+ Series: Reforming South Africa's Education System
Mbuyisa Makhubu Primary School in the are of Orlando West, in the South African township of Soweto. For many South Africans, education is a privilege and praised once completed. However, for many other South Africans, quality education is a far distant dream for a multitude of reasons. To begin with, South Africa is severely unequal and really, that can be considered the root or foundation for all the other reasons behind the inaccessibility of quality education. By virtue of quality education being distributed disproportionately and the vast majority of South Africans falling under the bracket of 'low quality schooling', a similar majority of students will be disadvantaged when trying to enter the workforce; because if former students are not well educated, how will they fulfil complex or meet the entry expectations and requirements of their future jobs? The education system for any country is massively critical for the development of the country and the continuity of the country's skills and knowledge. It has been said that the South African education system is characterised by 'crumbling infrastructure, overcrowded classrooms and poor educational outcomes'. Infrastructure Failures That Persist Poor education, poverty, and societal problems are a recurring cycle. Public schools suffer from horrific infrastructure, leading to tragic incidents like children dying in pit latrines. This reflects apartheid's legacy of under-maintained infrastructure, hindering conducive learning environments. Apartheid's racial segregation dictated school access and quality. Wealthier students have an advantage with tutors and adapted better to online learning during COVID-19 lockdowns. As of 31 March 2025, 93% of pit latrines have been eradicated under the SAFE initiative. However, 141 schools, especially in Limpopo and the Eastern Cape, still use these dangerous facilities. A 2 June 2025 report attributes delays to funding and logistical shortfalls, urging stronger corporate-sector involvement and deployment of the Khusela sanitation unit in public–private partnership schools. Physical accessibility to schools remains an issue, despite a collaboration between the Departments of Transport and Education to provide transport for students living over 3km away. This initiative faces challenges like funding, insufficient, and unsafe transport options, disproportionately affecting low-income households. Students arriving fatigued or with safety concerns impact their performance. When educators lack resources and support, and students arrive already disadvantaged, a prosperous outcome is unlikely. The Workforce Equation: Skills, Unemployment and the Future South Africa faces a challenge: preparing its workforce for a rapidly changing, tech-driven labor market. The education system is outdated, ill-equipped to train students for the future, especially with the global rise of AI. This is reflected in the country's high unemployment rates in Q1 2025: 32.9% nationally, 43.1% expanded, and 46.1% for youth (15-34), leaving over 4.8 million young people jobless. However, progress is being made. Microsoft's R5.4 billion initiative aims to train 1 million South Africans in AI and cybersecurity by 2026, funding 50,000 certification exams to boost digital skills and tech employment. Youth programs like the Wind Industry Internship (June 2025) are also providing green energy sector training. A BRICS+ Opportunity for Shared Development The current education system and skills development pipeline is not good enough. But this is not just a domestic crisis. As a founding member of BRICS, and now within the expanded BRICS+ framework, South Africa's educational challenges reflect shared realities across much of the Global South. Issues like under-resourced schools, youth unemployment, and digital skills gaps are familiar not only to South Africa, but also to countries like Ethiopia, Iran, Egypt, and even large emerging economies like India and Indonesia. This shared experience also opens space for shared solutions. South Africa has much to gain from deeper cooperation with BRICS+ peers. Countries like China and India have pioneered low-cost, large-scale digital education programmes that bring coding and AI training to rural youth. Brazil and Cuba have longstanding public–private vocational training models that balance academic learning with real-world skills. Russia and Kazakhstan have developed university–industry partnerships that could inspire more hands-on, work-integrated learning. From Malaysia to Uzbekistan, governments are experimenting with green-skills development and dual education systems that better prepare youth for fast-changing labour markets. At the same time, South Africa brings its own strengths to the bloc, a young population, world-class universities, and a regional position that makes it a key gateway to the rest of Africa. Through coordinated investment, cross-border edtech initiatives, collaborative teacher training, and multilateral funding for infrastructure (including sanitation and connectivity), BRICS+ can play a transformative role in reshaping South Africa's education landscape. This isn't about charity, it's about strategic partnership, where improved education outcomes in South Africa uplift the entire BRICS+ bloc. A more literate, skilled, and confident South African workforce is an asset to shared development, sustainable industrialisation, and South–South solidarity. Shared Accountability, Shared Potential The onus does not only fall on the government or individuals, South African society at large, including corporates, investors, unions, civil society, and international partners, must take part in building the education system the country deserves. With dedicated effort, adequate funding, and the adoption of modern technology, South Africans can become more literate, more skilled, and better positioned to boost employment, drive innovation, and contribute meaningfully to both national and BRICS+ development. The question isn't only whether South Africa is ready for the future, it's whether BRICS+ is ready to help shape it, together. *Dr Iqbal Survé Past chairman of the BRICS Business Council and co-chairman of the BRICS Media Forum and the BRNN *Banthati Sekwala Associate at BRICS+ Consulting Group Egyptian & South African Specialist **The Views expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of Independent Media or IOL. ** MORE ARTICLES ON OUR WEBSITE ** Follow @brics_daily on X/Twitter & @brics_daily on Instagram for daily BRICS+ updates
