
Mark Clattenburg interview: ‘Referees just live a normal life, we don't have the protection of football players'
But referees have one of the most thankless jobs in football and even officials as accomplished as Clattenburg were not immune to criticism and scrutiny.
Advertisement
On the latest episode of The Athletic FC Podcast, Ayo Akinwolere and Rory Smith spoke to Clattenburg about the growing blame culture surrounding referees and the role the VAR system has played in fuelling it.
A partial transcript has been edited for clarity and length. The full episode is available on YouTube below or in 'The Athletic FC Podcast' feed on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Rory: There is a tendency among fans, players, managers, and executives not to regard referees as human. This seems stupid and sounds like a massive exaggeration, but we like to ascribe all these motivations to what referees do.
I haven't got this right every time either but I've always made a point in coverage of trying to acknowledge when referees do well in an unspectacular fashion. But also not to buy into this easy out of, 'the defining thing here was the referee', because too often it's easy to look at referees and think they want to be the centre of attention.
Mark: That's the furthest thing from the truth, really…
Rory: It is, but then at the same time, if someone is standing with a whistle in the middle of 22 people, it's a bit like, 'Well, they're the one who's got the tool to get attention'. But mostly they are people trying to do their best in an incredibly difficult situation. A situation we are making more difficult by failing to understand that they are doing their best.
It's been tolerated for so long that the immediate thing everyone comes out with after a game is, 'Well, the referee did this wrong'. Mark says he went into a club and realised the impact refereeing decisions can have on a club. But on the other side, we as a football culture in general don't necessarily realise the impact our reactions have on the referees as people and that's important.
Mark: The problem also is that clubs don't understand. I've always said, for example, that Michael Oliver should go to Newcastle United to train and integrate with them and get a better understanding.
Advertisement
I remember my issue in 2012 with the Chelsea and Mikel John Obi situation. I remember Bruce Buck (former chairman of Chelsea) coming to St George's Park because the referees were going to go on strike and everybody was upset because the scrutiny I was put under wasn't fair. And his comment was, 'We were duty-bound to report the incident'. You're duty-bound, of course you are, but you should have done some investigation first because it wasn't John Obi who heard it, it was Ramires who didn't speak any English. It's very clever that a person who can't speak English can make up something I've said in my Geordie accent. But that's another point and another argument.
But Bruce Buck said, 'What your problem is', to us as referees, is that 'you live in a gated community and you've got security guards protecting your house'. That was the first time you realised they don't know what goes on in the real world.
We're just referees living a normal life in a normal housing estate and we don't have the protection like football players have. We're so far apart. That's when I understood that football clubs are in this glass house and they don't realise what is outside. Everybody is duty-bound to protect the image of the game and everybody gets frustrated with referees.
Being inside a club, and Rory hit a really important point, everything that filters down doesn't just affect the football players. Yes, they have a duty to try to play well. But for the kitchen staff, for example, if you get removed from the Premier League, the financial hit is so much that the kitchen staff know they could be made redundant. The morale and the mood across the whole of the club are always affected by the results.
There's an excuse culture brought in now where there wasn't years ago when I first got in the Premier League. There were much less excuses. But it's growing more and more now. I don't know if it's financial or if it's pressure. Working for a club, I could understand both sides. But ultimately, what's created a bigger problem is the VAR system.
Advertisement
Everybody accepted a referee making a wrong decision or analysing the decision from what they saw. But in the end, people accepted that. But what they can't accept is VARs still not getting decisions right. This is what has created an even worse feeling in football. They think they have a system in place that is foolproof and it's not. It's not even technology. I hate when people say it's technology because it's not. It's a human being. Yes, the offside has now changed because it's more technology-based, but it's still a human being who has to verify the decision. So it's a human error.
It's created a big problem now because when the VAR doesn't get decisions correct, it creates even bigger frustration.
You can listen to full episodes of The Athletic FC Podcast free on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, and watch on YouTube.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Match Tactical: Manchester United vs West Ham United
Manchester United are set to kick off their Premier League Summer Series tour to the US when they take on West Ham United. Coming off an understated goalless draw with Leeds United, Ruben Amorim's men will surely look to be more effective in front of goal as they look to bring cheer to their American fanbase. While Amorim will almost certainly look to rotate his squad with a flood of half-time substitutions, there are some common tactical decisions that the Man United manager should consider taking if he hopes to get the better of the Hammers in New Jersey. Learning from past mistakes During the Leeds game, we saw United take a barrage of shots, yet with little accuracy. Out of their 18 attempts on goal, only four reached their target, while two unluckily hit the woodwork. (Sky Sports) What's particularly alarming about this statistic is that the vast majority of United's chances came from the centre of the box, where players were facing the goal head-on, albeit at varying distances from the goal. A minority of chances, namely five, were taken from tight angles outside of the goalposts' jurisdiction. One could only hope that Amorim spotted this lack of shooting accuracy and has worked on it with his players during training. After all, it's incredibly wasteful for his players to complete all of the necessary work to create 19 chances, only to fall at the final hurdle each and every time. Although it may be important to reflect on the previous match, some bad habits from last season persist. Speed things up If one looks at the attacking momentum chart from the Leeds' draw, we see how United continued a long-standing frustrating habit from last season. With the exception of the final minutes of the second half, United's attacking intensity was underwhelming, with the team very seldom bursting forward at a quick pace to knock Leeds' defence off balance. By exhibiting a slow build-up, they gave the opposition sufficient time to drop back and defend in comfort, squandering their chance to secure what should have been a straightforward win. While Amorim's starting lineup remains to be seen, it would be good for him to leverage the pace of his quickest attackers. These could be long-standing players such as Amad Diallo or new talents such as Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo. Whoever ends up playing, Amorim should make the most of the fast legs at his disposal. For United, this pre-season marks a moment of rebuild, with fans hoping that their club can bounce back from what was a lacklustre debut campaign under Amorim, to say the least. In addition to being achievable, a victory over West Ham would go a long way to restoring the confidence of an anxious fanbase that certainly deserves more to cheer about than what they've been receiving in recent times. Featured image Linnea Rheborg via Getty Images Follow us on Bluesky: @
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Benjamin Lecomte joins Fulham from Montpellier
Fulham have confirmed the signing of Benjamin Lecomte (33) from Montpellier HSC in an official announcement made on Saturday, marking the Premier Leagueside's first addition of the summer transfer window. The French goalkeeper has penned a two-year deal with the Lilywhites. Despite several other clubs already being active on the market, Fulham have remained patient — Lecomte's arrival being their first senior reinforcement ahead of the 2025/26 season. 'I'm really, really happy and proud to join Fulham because it's a new step in my career, and I think it will be really nice to be part of the club,' Lecomte said to Fulham TV after signing for the West London club. 'He is a talented goalkeeper with valuable experience, including more than 300 appearances in Ligue 1, and his arrival will further strengthen the team and add depth to Marco [Silva]'s squad,' added Fulham Sporting director Tony Khan. | George Boxall


CNET
24 minutes ago
- CNET
Premier League Summer Series: Stream Everton vs. Bournemouth From Anywhere
The second edition of the Premier League Summer Series tournament kicks off in the US on Saturday as David Moyes' Everton take on Andoni Iraola's Bournemouth. Below, we'll outline the best live TV streaming services to use to watch the game as it happens, wherever you are in the world, and how to use a VPN if it's not available where you are. Taking place at three venues across the US, the six-match, round-robin style tournament also includes fellow EPL sides Manchester United and West Ham, and serves as a key warmup for the teams ahead of the start of the 2025-2026 Premier League season in three weeks time. Bournemouth finished in an impressive ninth position in the EPL last season but the Cherries face a major rebuild this summer, having sold key defenders Dean Huijsen and Milos Kerkez in big-money moves to Real Madrid and Liverpool, while Illia Zabaryni looks poised to follow them out the exit door to PSG. Everton are meanwhile looking forward to their first season in their new $500 million Bramley-Moore Dock and have made significant squad reinforcements in the form of Villarreal striker Thierno Barry and Bournemouth goalkeeper Mark Travers. Everton take on AFC Bournemouth on Saturday, July 26, at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey, with kickoff set for 4 p.m. ET local time, 1 p.m. PT in the US. That makes it a 9 p.m. BST start in the UK and a 6 a.m. AEST kickoff in Australia on Sunday morning. Senegalese midfielder Idrissa Gueye was named as Everton's Player of the Season for the 2024-2025 to watch Everton vs. Bournemouth in the US without cable Saturday's Everton vs. Bournemouth game will be broadcast on NBC and can also be streamed via Peacock. You'll need a Peacock Premium or Premium Plus account to catch the game live. How to watch the Premier League Summer Series 2025 from anywhere with a VPN If you're traveling abroad and want to keep up with all the Summer Series action while away from home, a VPN can help enhance your privacy and security when streaming. It encrypts your traffic and prevents your internet service provider from throttling your speeds, and can also be helpful when connecting to public Wi-Fi networks while traveling, adding an extra layer of protection for your devices and logins. VPNs are legal in many countries, including the US and Canada, and can be used for legitimate purposes such as improving online privacy and security. However, some streaming services may have policies restricting VPN use to access region-specific content. If you're considering a VPN for streaming, check the platform's terms of service to ensure compliance. If you choose to use a VPN, follow the provider's installation instructions, ensuring you're connected securely and in compliance with applicable laws and service agreements. Some streaming platforms may block access when a VPN is detected, so verifying if your streaming subscription allows VPN usage is crucial. James Martin/CNET ExpressVPN Best VPN for streaming Price $13 per month, $100 for the first 15 months (then $117 per year) or $140 for the first 28 months (then $150 per year) Latest Tests No DNS leaks detected, 18% speed loss in 2025 tests Network 3,000 plus servers in 105 countries Jurisdiction British Virgin Islands ExpressVPN is our current best VPN pick for people who want a reliable and safe VPN, and it works on a variety of devices. It's normally $13 a month but if you sign up for an annual subscription for $100 you'll get three months free and save 49%. That's the equivalent of $6.67 a month. Note that ExpressVPN offers a 30-day money-back guarantee. 61% off with 2yr plan (+4 free months) See at ExpressVPN Livestream Everton vs. Bournemouth in the UK Today's match at MetLife Stadium is exclusive to Sky Sports, showing on its Sky Sports Main Event, Premier League and UHD channels. If you already have Sky Sports as part of your TV package, you can stream the game via its Sky Go app but cord-cutters will want to get set up with a Now account and a Now Sports membership to stream the game. Livestream Everton vs. Bournemouth in Canada If you want to stream this EPL Summer Series game live in Canada, you'll need to subscribe to Fubo Canada. The service has exclusive rights to every match of the pre-season tournament once again this season. Livestream Everton vs. Bournemouth in Australia Football fans down under can watch Summer Series matches live on streaming service Stan Sport, which is showing every game of the tournament live in Australia. Stan Stan Sport Watch the Summer Series in Australia from AU$32 a month Stan Sport will set you back AU$20 a month (on top of a Stan subscription, which starts at AU$12). It's also worth noting that the streaming service is currently offering a seven-day free trial. A subscription will also give you access to Premier League, Champions League and Europa League action, as well as international rugby and Formula E. See at Stan Sport Quick tips for streaming the Summer Series using a VPN