Tory councillor suspended over 'inappropriate' Travellers comment
Her comments were made during discussions around plans to change the use of the Findon Park football pitch near Portlethen into a camp.
The issue flared up due to the retrospective nature of the application being voted on.
Mrs Agnew suggested this showed a willingness to ignore rules on behalf of the applicants.
READ MORE: Former SNP chief executive Peter Murrell granted legal aid in embezzlement case
She said: 'If they're ignoring this, they may ignore other things. That's my problem.'
When pressed by colleagues to retract her remarks, she added: 'I don't want to refute it. Anything could happen there. That's all. It's slightly worrying to me.
'And I'm not saying it's just because they're Gypsies. It would be the same if they were British people. I'd be worried about this massive site. That's all.'
The incident sparked some controversy and resulted in Mrs Agnew stepping down as committee chairwoman in the aftermath.
By standing down she lost out on an extra £10,000 each year.
Now more than 18 months later, she has faced standard watchdogs.
An investigation has now been carried out by the ethical standards commissioner.
The Stonehaven member faced the Standards Commission today.
Ethical standards commissioner Ian Bruce said: 'The respondent made inappropriate comments about Gypsy Travellers and the appropriateness of granting a retrospective planning application for a site, including insinuating that they are not British.
'This was deemed a failure to treat everyone with courtesy or respect, and also a failure to advance equality of opportunity.'
At the meeting, Mrs Agnew stressed she didn't 'feel hatred' towards gypsy travellers and blamed her comments on 'clumsy language'.
The councillor also argued she had 'no intent to be disrespectful'.
Before the recording of the fateful 2023 meeting was shared on YouTube, it had been edited to remove Mrs Agnew's comments.
READ MORE: Ryanair cancels more than 800 flights due to conflict in the Middle East
The council's head of legal and people, Karen Wiles, admitted this had been done to prevent the local authority from facing any potential legal challenges.
She said: 'It was apparent to me that people of a Gypsy Traveller community may have seen themselves as being differentiated from British people.
'That could be offensive since the two terms are not mutually exclusive.'
Standards Commission member and chairwoman of the hearing panel, Helen Donaldson, said members found Mrs Agnew had treated the applicant 'less favourably' because she was a Gypsy Traveller.
They based this on Mrs Agnew's suggested knowledge of unauthorised use of a different site and an assumption that Travellers were 'more likely to breach planning conditions'.
Ms Donaldson added: 'The provisions that state councillors … must avoid any perception that they are not acting fairly and without bias when making decisions on quasi-judicial matters.
READ MORE: LIVE: Latest updates as MPs vote on proscribing Palestine Action
'The panel noted that a failure to comply with the code's provisions in this regard can have a detrimental impact on the right of an applicant to be treated fairly, and can erode public confidence in the role of a councillor.
'Such a failure also had the potential to bring the committee, the council and its decisions into disrepute and open it up to the risk of a successful legal challenge.'
Members then decided to hand the Stonehaven councillor a two month suspension.
This means she will not be allowed to attend any meetings or represent Aberdeenshire Council during this time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Leader Live
2 hours ago
- Leader Live
Hundreds of town centres to see more police patrols in crime ‘blitz'
More than 500 towns across England and Wales have signed up to the Home Office's safer streets summer initiative, which will run to September 30, with more visible policing and stronger enforcement to 'restore confidence in policing'. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said residents and businesses have a 'right to feel safe in their towns' but the last government left a 'surge' in crime. In a statement, she said: 'It's time to turn this round, that's why I have called on police forces and councils alike to work together to deliver a summer blitz on town centre crime to send a clear message to those people who bring misery to our towns that their crimes will no longer go unpunished.' She said part of the neighbourhood policing guarantee includes investment of £200 million this year to begin the recruitment of thousands of new neighbourhood policing officers. Speaking to members of policing and business sectors at Derby County Football Club's Pride Park Stadium on Thursday, Ms Cooper said every area will have 'named contactable officers for residents and businesses to be able to turn to'. Ms Cooper said: 'It's one of the most important things to restore confidence in policing is to have those neighbourhood police back on the beat dealing with those very crimes that cause so much problem. 'And if we don't see the police on the streets, then confidence is lost. And I think that is what's happened for far too long. 'If shoppers don't feel safe, they will stay home. People will just stay out of our town centres, and that heart of community will be lost. 'I think these kinds of crimes have been dismissed for too long because crime erodes the social fabric that binds us together and keeps communities strong. 'We've made town centres the very heart of the safer streets mission for this summer, taking back town centres from thugs and thieves – at the heart of that is rebuilding neighbourhood policing.' Half a million shoplifting offences in England and Wales were recorded by police last year, up 20% from 2023. In a statement, Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds said: 'We are on the side of local businesses, and our plan for change is helping create the right conditions for our great British high streets to thrive. 'The safer streets summer initiative will play a vital role in achieving this by keeping footfall high, communities and those that work in them safe, and the economy growing.' Anthony Hemmerdinger, managing director of Boots, said: 'Retail theft alongside intimidation and abuse of our team members is unacceptable, so we welcome this additional support from Government and the police to strengthen shop worker protection.' Police and crime commissioners across England and Wales have developed local action plans with police, including in Nottinghamshire, Derbyshire, Humberside, Devon and Cornwall.
The National
2 hours ago
- The National
BBC 'out of step with reality' with Gaza coverage, journalists say
Joined by 306 prominent media figures, 112 journalists at the BBC have written to general director Tim Davie and the Board of Governors to voice concerns of censorship, bias, and undermining journalistic integrity by refusing to air the documentary Gaza: Medics Under Fire. The signatories have accused top bosses of being 'crippled by the fear of being perceived as critical of the Israeli government'. READ MORE: Senior BBC staff told to 'step back' from duties following Bob Vylan Glastonbury set The letter reads: 'We believe the refusal to broadcast the documentary 'Gaza: Medics Under Fire' is just one in a long line of agenda driven decisions. 'It demonstrates, once again, that the BBC is not reporting 'without fear or favour' when it comes to Israel. 'We understand that a decision not to broadcast the investigation has been taken by senior BBC management despite the film's content being signed off in accordance with BBC guidelines and editorial policy. 'This appears to be a political decision and is not reflective of the journalism in the film. A recent statement from the BBC said broadcasting the film 'risked creating the perception of partiality'. 'This illustrates precisely what many of us have experienced first hand: an organisation that is crippled by the fear of being perceived as critical of the Israeli government.' The letter continues on, accusing the BBC's coverage of being fuelled by anti-Palestinian racism and being 'increasingly out of step with reality'. READ MORE: SNP MPs should not have sat on their hands during vote on proscription Journalists at the corporation have also called the future of Robbie Gibb into question and noted concerns that an 'individual with close ties to the Jewish Chronicle' has had a say in the decision to pull the Gaza documentary from the service. Prominent media figures who have co-signed the letter include Owen Jones, Miriam Margoyles, Zawe Ashton and Catherine Happer of the Glasgow University Media Group. You can read the full letter here.
STV News
2 hours ago
- STV News
SNP attacks ‘disastrous' year of Starmer ‘U-turns, scandals and failure'
Sir Keir Starmer has been accused of presiding over a 'litany of broken promises, U-turns, scandals, and failures' since becoming Prime Minister. Marking the first anniversary of Labour's landslide general election victory, the SNP said the UK Government's record has been 'disastrous'. SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn pointed to Labour U-turns on the winter fuel payment and welfare cuts while criticising the Prime Minister's record on the economy. Labour won an overwhelming majority on July 4, 2024 but polling shows Starmer's ratings have since fallen dramatically, while a number of surveys now put Reform UK ahead of the party in Scotland. PA Media SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn attacked Labour's record on its first anniversary in Government (James Manning/PA). Flynn said: 'Keir Starmer's first year in office speaks for itself – a litany of broken promises, U-turns, scandals, and failures on the economy that have removed optimism from a public who were so desperate for change. 'Voters were promised a new direction but instead they got more of the same Westminster cuts and failure. 'Families and small businesses hammered by tax hikes, and soaring bills – with millions of people feeling worse off whilst being lectured that things are getting better. 'The UK economy has been downgraded, public finances have deteriorated, unemployment is up, poverty is at record levels and the cost of food, energy and household bills have risen by hundreds of pounds on Keir Starmer's watch. 'When people look back on the Labour Party's year in office they will remember the cuts to disabled people and pensioners' winter fuel payments, the betrayal of Waspi women and children in poverty, rising energy bills and food prices, and a Prime Minister who took thousands of pounds of designer clothes and freebies while imposing austerity cuts on the rest of us.' PA Media Tory MSP Rachael Hamilton said Keir Starmer is 'hopelessly out of his depth' (Andrew Milligan/PA). The Scottish Conservatives said the Prime Minister's first year has been 'catastrophic' as the party accused the Labour leader of 'betraying' its voters. Deputy leader Rachael Hamilton said Scotland 'can't afford another four years of a Prime Minister who is hopelessly out of his depth'. She said: 'Keir Starmer's first year in office has been a catastrophic series of broken promises and U-turns that people up and down the country are paying for. 'Labour's jobs tax and family farm tax have been utterly devastating for the careers, pay packets and bills of ordinary people. 'Their hostility to North Sea oil and gas is not just crushing livelihoods and communities across the North East, it's leading to higher fuel bills for everyone by making us more reliant on foreign imports. 'Ending universal winter fuel payments for pensioners was another broken election pledge and a betrayal of some of our most vulnerable people, one which the SNP shamefully copied in Scotland. 'Starmer has betrayed all those who voted for him by breaking his vow not to raise taxes – and he'll have to hike them again in the autumn after his humiliating surrender to Labour MPs on welfare reform.' PA Media Secretary of State for Scotland Ian Murray said Labour has already made life better for millions of Scots (Andrew Milligan/PA). But Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said millions of Scots are now better of since Labour came to power. He pointed to rises to the minimum wage worth up to £1,400 a year to low-paid Scots, the introduction of the right to sick and parental leave from day one of a job, and the extension of fuel duty cuts for drivers. Murray said the UK Government had given Holyrood a record settlement of £50bn, with at least £14bn in extra funding by 2029 when compared to Tory spending plans. He said: 'This time last year the Scottish people decided to stop sending a message to Westminster and sent a government instead – and every day since then Scottish Labour MPs have been at the heart of a Labour Government delivering a better deal for Scotland. 'After the Tories crashed the economy Labour got the public finances back on a secure footing and the result of that stability was four interest rate cuts in a row meaning cheaper mortgages for many Scots. 'The minimum wage got a record boost and stronger rights means Scots have more security at work. 'The UK Labour Government comprehensively ended austerity with billions of pounds more for public services in Scotland. 'But as waiting lists fall in England where Labour have taken control of the health service, the NHS in Scotland remains under SNP mismanagement, with one in six Scots on an NHS waiting list, people paying to go private because they can't wait anymore and cancer waiting times at their worst ever level. 'Scots can't risk a third decade of SNP mismanagement of our public services. That's why next May Scots should boot John Swinney out of office and chart a new direction, with Anas Sarwar as First Minister and a Scottish Labour government.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
