Veteran broadcaster Michael Buerk slams 'white saviour' criticism of Live Aid: 'If you're dying of starvation, you're not really that concerned about the colour of the person saving you'
The veteran broadcaster – whose heart-rending reports on the Ethiopian famine in 1984 led to musicians Bob Geldof and Midge Ure organising the event – rejected accusations that the West was being 'paternalistic'.
It came as the global charity fundraiser marked its 40th anniversary yesterday.
The BBC presenter told Radio 4's Broadcasting House current affairs programme: 'If you were one of the women picking through donkey dung trying to find undigested seeds or one of the children whose eyes were rotting through vitamin deficiency, if you were a guy... have you seen somebody dying from starvation? The body eats itself from inside.
'If you're one of those people... you're not really that concerned about whether your saviour is white or black and I think The Guardian thinks we're being paternalistic.
'It's rather obscene that people should go around talking about white saviours. Any saviour in that context is very welcome indeed.'
The veteran broadcaster – whose heart-rending reports on the Ethiopian famine in 1984 led to musicians Bob Geldof and Midge Ure organising the event – rejected accusations that the West was being 'paternalistic'
The 79-year-old, who now presents Radio 4's Moral Maze, added he thought the wave of compassion generated by his reports, on the then BBC Ten O'Clock News, was no longer possible to achieve today.
'There were ten million audiences for the main evening news and fewer distractions. People weren't on their phones all the time.
'I think we live in a more selfish, more cynical and more stupid world.'
Buerk admitted he had misgivings when he 'first heard what Geldof was up to'.
'I thought what are these prancing stars, for goodness' sake? But now I take the opposite view about Geldof and what happened then.'
Live Aid, which was seen by about 1.5billion people in more than 150 countries, helped in raising around £150 million for famine relief.
But since then some have questioned the symbolism of white people in the West coming to the rescue of a helpless and impoverished Africa.
Mail photographer Murray Sanders' incredible unseen photographs of Live Aid are featured in a new book, Live Aid Relived. Order a copy at music2you.co.uk/liveaid
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Human review – history at its most irresistibly infectious
'I can't help it,' says Ella Al-Shamahi. 'It reminds me of The Lord of the Rings!' It's not easy to make prehistory accessible, but a Tolkien comparison works for the time before Homo sapiens ruled the world. Al-Shamahi's five-part documentary traces the rise of humanity, beginning with the era when Homo neanderthalensis, Homo floresiensis and Homo erectus each staked a claim in their own ragged domain. Before written history, when our story was 'written in our bones and DNA', some early humans were in Europe and Asia and had adapted to the cold. Some were learning to harness the power of fire. Some were only about 3ft 6in (1 metre) tall. Others wore hard hats and polo shirts – wait, no, that is one of the archaeologists on a dig in Morocco, where a skull named Jebel Irhoud 1 holds many secrets about our early ancestors. It's the start of a journey that will, in an illuminating first episode, take Al-Shamahi to spectacular locations across Africa and the Middle East. At the risk of repeating what some critics said seven years ago when Al-Shamahi fronted Neanderthals – Meet Your Ancestors on BBC Two (she has popped up in the odd thing since then), it feels as if a presenting star is being born here. An explorer, paleoanthropologist and standup comedian, she passes all the tests that the job of helming a major science or history series throws up. Her bits to camera borrow the old Kevin McCloud trick of pretending to come up with big thoughts on the fly and being delighted by them: she will break eye contact, look away to gather something fascinating, then meet our gaze again to emphasise the key point. It's theatre, but it helps to achieve her main goal, which is to transmit the wonder she experiences as a learned expert to us, the keen but ignorant at home. The urgent whisper she employs in her voiceover – where a less adept presenter would reveal any weaknesses in their intonation – has the same effect. So we are in the company of the best teacher most of us never had, one who joyfully shares knowledge that is too interesting to be intimidating and who trusts us to keep up. Al-Shamahi is unafraid to toss in arcane paleoanthropological terms if the viewer can draw meaning from context – 'gracile' and 'prognathic' are about to slide into your vocabulary – or to converse with Moroccan scientists in Arabic. Her best work here has her cradling the Jebel Irhoud skull and using her own head to illustrate how this ancient creature is different from us, yet almost the same. Someone like Homo sapiens, the upright, tool-and-weapon-using primate that became us, existed as far back as 350,000 years ago, much earlier than was once thought. From there we trace the little breakthroughs that, put together across many millennia, constitute our evolution. Al-Shamahi visits the Great Rift valley in eastern Africa to explain how, 200,000 years ago, climate crises (it was humid in the east and arid in the west, then vice versa) forced communities to move around and mingle, sharing fresh discoveries and their best genes. In Israel, however, we find evidence of one of countless false starts, when Homo sapiens tried to live in the cave next door to neanderthals – a nightmare-neighbour scenario so bad that this branch of Homo sapiens didn't survive it. But we persevered. Al-Shamahi highlights the surprising details of how we gained hegemony. In the Tsodilo Hills of Botswana, there are stone tools that, 100,000 years ago, their owners broke. Why? Because they were offerings to a god, made by primates who were starting to 'see beyond the tangible' and were developing ceremonies and rituals nourished by abstract thought. In the words of Al-Shamahi, who can turn a lyrical phrase when it's warranted, we were 'venturing into the unknown and into the unseen'. This expansion of the brain delivered practical benefits when, only 30 or so millennia later, curiosity about 'the power held in wood and string' saw us move on from axes and spears to the bow and arrow. The programme's landscape shots are frequently stunning. On a perfectly unspoiled, dune-flanked African beach, even the tiniest seashells hold a narrative: about 70,000 years ago we started turning them into necklaces decorated with red ochre, a sign that cultural exchanges were under way. Al-Shamahi's delight in this revelation is irresistibly infectious. In Human, the leap of imagination necessary to understand our very distant past is no distance at all. Human airs on BBC Two and is available on BBC iPlayer
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Lydia Bright breaks down in tears as she meets Ugandan family her daughter Loretta, five, sponsored after donating her birthday money
TOWIE star Lydia Bright has shared video of the emotional moment she met a Ugandan family she has been sponsoring. The star has travelled to Uganda to see where Joy For Humanity charity donatations have been utilised on the ground. Lydia shared a video of herself meeting up with a little girl named Rahufa and her family as she explained how her daughter Loretta, five, had chosen to forgo birthday gifts from her friends in favour of donations for the charity. Loretta subsequently became the charity's youngest sponsor for a child - her 'sister' Rahufa. Lydia couldn't contatin her emotions as she finally met the little girl, her three siblings and her mother at their home this week, sharing video and photos of little Rahufa in her school uniform. 'Like so many children in the UK, Loretta has too much. Too many toys, too many clothes, too many books.' 'After planning a birthday party for her school friends back in February, I found myself dreading the 40+ presents she'd receive (a very privileged problem to have, I know.)' Lydia explained to her followers. 'A few years ago through my mums fostering connection she began supporting children in Uganda through uniform donations.' 'That's when I learnt more about Uganda, how it still remains one of the poorest countries in the world and the heartbreaking fact that 1 in 8 children in the the Lwengo District won't live to celebrate their 5th birthday. It felt like the perfect time for a change.' 'This year, my Loretta became the youngest sponsor. Instead of gifts, we asked her friends to donate to sponsor a child's education.' 'Loretta will eventually outgrow or misplace toys, but through her annual birthday sponsorship she'll be putting a child, her sister in Uganda, Rahufah through school and I dream of the day they'll one day meet in person.' I know as she grows this will teach Loretta the importance of giving back and I know how impactful this will be on her throughout her years. Her birthday raised over £500, enough to fully sponsor a child (it costs just £300 a year to send a child to Kyazanga Modern Primary School) and provide much needed school supplies and resources for many others.' Lydia's posts were met with an outpouring of love and support from her family and friends, including her mum Debbie and TOWIE pal Chloe Lewis. Some followers criticised the post though, with one commenting of Loretta: 'Im sure she is just thrilled to be the only kid in class that noone gives any presents to foe her birthday. Won't make her grow up to be even more [sic]' But a defiant Lydia pointed out: 'She received presents from her family and I don't believe any child needs over 40 gifts. My child, my parenting choice.'
The Independent
7 hours ago
- The Independent
Adorable moment baby Zebra plays with older brother at zoo
Watch the heart-warming moment that a pair of Zebra brothers play with each other at Whipsnade Zoo. Footage shared by the zoo on Monday (14 July) shows the unnamed two-month-year-old calf chasing his older brother Zinabi around a tree at the zoo near Dunstable. The baby, who was born in May, can also be seen feeding on the grass and lying out in the sun. The pair of zebras are part of the zoo's Grevy's zebra herd, which hail from grassland and shrubland of Ethiopia and Kenya. They are well adapted to the heat, so have had no problem coping with the UK 's recent stream of heatwaves.
