logo
BBC accused of violating own child protection guidelines in Gaza documentary

BBC accused of violating own child protection guidelines in Gaza documentary

Middle East Eye06-03-2025
The BBC is facing mounting criticism for "failing in its duty of care" to the 13-year-old Palestinian narrator of the documentary Gaza: How to Survive a War Zone, who said he has experienced intense online harassment and abuse amid the British broadcaster's withdrawal of the film.
The documentary, which sheds light on the experiences of children in Gaza amid Israel's assault through the eyes of narrator Abdullah al-Yazuri, was abruptly removed from the BBC iPlayer, after a campaign centred on al-Yazuri's relationship to a minister in the enclave's Hamas-run government.
Abdullah's father Ayman al-Yazuri, who is a deputy minister of agriculture in Gaza, has been labelled by media and pundits as a "Hamas chief" while he is in fact a technocrat with a scientific rather than political background, who has previously worked for the UAE's education ministry and studied at British universities.
Speaking exclusively to Middle East Eye this week, Abdullah explained that he and his family have been the targets of online abuse, adding that the affair has caused him serious 'mental pressure' and made him fear for his safety.
'I did not agree to the risk of me being targeted in any way before the documentary was broadcast on the BBC. So [if] anything happens to me, the BBC is responsible for it," he said.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
The boy also said the BBC had not reached out to him to apologise.
His interview with MEE about his experiences has sparked a debate on media ethics and the broadcaster's responsibility to protect children it works with.
"I posted about this concern shortly after BBC pulled this documentary," said Chris Doyle, chair of the Council for Arab-British Understanding, responding to Abdullah's video.
"BBC has a duty of care. The BBC used these children, aired their stories, but then ditched and dumped on them. Not one of the anti-Palestinian mob have expressed one iota of concern that I have seen."
I worked on a doc for @BBC and we went to GREAT lengths to protect the children we worked with per their policy below. Abdullah, the child in the Gaza doc, says he is facing online threats after the film was dropped — the BBC is responsible for his safety. They must rectify this. https://t.co/jHQm8BMQx3 pic.twitter.com/tb0XuNzmeY — Ahmed Eldin | احمد الدين (@ASE) March 6, 2025
"[The BBC] has completely failed in its duty of care," Artists for Palestine UK said. "It is playing politics with the lives of children traumatised by 17 months of genocidal violence."
Several journalists and social media users have highlighted Section 9 of the BBC's editorial guidelines concerning children and young people as contributors, which states that the BBC "must take due care over the physical and emotional welfare and the dignity of under-18s who take part or are otherwise involved in our editorial content, irrespective of any consent given by them or by a parent, guardian or other person acting in loco parentis. Their welfare must take priority over any editorial requirement".
The guidelines also emphasise that "protecting children and young people online is a shared responsibility for the BBC, parents/guardians, and the under-18 concerned".
This is what the BBC Editorial guidelines say about protecting children that it works with. Abdullah, the child in the Gaza doco, says that after the film was dropped he and his family received online threats. He says, the BBC is responsible for his welfare. He's right: https://t.co/t946KSKwv5 pic.twitter.com/PaEozxyW9u — Sangita Myska (@SangitaMyska) March 6, 2025
MEE reached out to the BBC to ask whether it had taken the steps outlined in the section, including guidelines that dictate that if a person under 18 is suspected to be at risk in the course of their work, 'the situation must be referred promptly to the divisional Working with Children Adviser or, for independent production companies, to the commissioning editor'.
Section 9 further states that "procedures, risk assessments and contingencies for the impact of participating on an individual's emotional and mental well-being and welfare may be appropriate in some circumstances".
A spokesperson said: "The BBC takes its duty of care responsibilities very seriously, particularly when working with children, and has frameworks in place to support these obligations" and directed MEE to its public statement on the documentary.
'Put a target on a 13-year-old'
Social media users accuse the BBC of exposing Abdullah to danger, and say the broadcaster has a responsibilty to ensure his safety.
"Abdullah says he's been targeted & the BBC hasn't reached out. As a former @BBCNews journalist I can tell you that child safeguarding is a key part of our training. To see none of it applied here is shocking & speaks to the dehumanisation of Palestinian children over months," a user wrote on X.
.@DanFriedman81 immediately deleted his post calling to bomb a Palestinian child and his family, then blocked me. What a coward. https://t.co/9P1MmuemPa pic.twitter.com/N9uXBQqwFR — Dan Cohen (@dancohen3000) March 5, 2025
Prominent British journalist Owen Jones described the BBC as having put "a target on the back of a 13 year old boy".
Others underlined the larger media context in which the film was removed, arguing that it appeared to be another example of media bias against Palestinians.
"Had the situation been reversed and an Israeli boy revealed to be the child of a junior minister in Netanyahu's government the BBC might have felt obliged to issue one of its 'corrections and clarifications' but it's highly unlikely the film would have been withdrawn and the - extremely vulnerable - production team humiliated in such a public manner," said journalist and film-maker Richard Sanders.
Former BBC journalist Sangita Myska said the makers of the documentary "did not meet editorial standards of transparency" but this was unlikely to have made "a material difference to the overall accuracy of the film".
"The BBC has apologised for the mistake, which was the right thing to do. Yet, the BBC's inconsistent application of editorial standards across its coverage (eg, over-scrutiny of some Palestinan sources vs under-scrutiny of some Israeli ones) means 'public trust' was dropping well before this controversy," she continued.
British-Israeli historian Avi Shlaim, an emeritus professor of international relations at Oxford, told MEE that the pulling of the film was 'only the latest example of the public broadcaster's regular capitulation to pressure from the pro-Israel lobby'.https://t.co/FTq3kLPiOR — Just Jews (@JustJewsUK) March 5, 2025
Tayab Ali, the director of the International Centre of Justice for Palestinians, wrote: "It terrifies those complicit in war crimes and genocide to see Palestinian children as not only human but eloquent. They would rather erase him, label him, dismiss him, silence him - than let the world hear his voice."
"Censorship won't hide the truth. Abdullah's story, and the suffering of Gaza's children, must be heard," he added.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Dropping aid into Gaza and the fate of a ceasefire
Dropping aid into Gaza and the fate of a ceasefire

The National

timean hour ago

  • The National

Dropping aid into Gaza and the fate of a ceasefire

Israel has begun allowing aid to be dropped into Gaza by parachute. In Israel, far-right figures are objecting to permitting aid into Gaza. Syria, France and the US have agreed to meet on Kurdish integration. On today's episode of Trending Middle East: UAE and Jordan planes drop food and humanitarian aid into Gaza Israel claims aid trickling in after widespread condemnation of blockade Paris to host Syria talks on integrating Kurds This episode features Hamza Hendawi, Cairo correspondent, and Thomas Helm, Jerusalem correspondent. Editor's note: We want to hear from you! Help us improve our podcasts by taking our 2-minute listener survey. Click here.

UN conference will test global resolve for Palestinian statehood
UN conference will test global resolve for Palestinian statehood

The National

timean hour ago

  • The National

UN conference will test global resolve for Palestinian statehood

Saudi Arabia and France are set to spearhead a high-stakes conference at the UN this week, launching a bold push to forge a path towards an independent Palestinian state − a move that has already ignited a fierce backlash from Israel and the Trump administration. This ambitious initiative aims to resurrect long-stalled peace efforts, setting the stage for a diplomatic showdown over the region's future. The two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is both more threatened and more necessary than at any time since the Oslo Accords, a French diplomatic source said ahead of the conference. The October 7, 2023 Hamas attack on Israel deepened Israeli scepticism towards Palestinian statehood, while the subsequent war in Gaza has devastated the enclave and weakened prospects for stability, the source told reporters in New York. Despite these challenges, the French official argued that the two-state solution remains the only viable path forward. It is 'even more necessary because there is no alternative', the source said. 'We cannot just discuss the situation in Gaza and the day after … we need to see beyond.' French President Emmanuel Macron last week announced that France would recognise Palestine as a state. 'The urgent thing today is that the war in Gaza stops, and the civilian population is saved,' he said. France's Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot told CBS News on Sunday that Paris's diplomatic efforts are 'very complementary' to Washington's. 'In fact, we will welcome any further efforts led by the US to implement the Abraham Accord logics. And what we're doing now with this very significant conference that will take place in New York will pave the way for such accords,' he said. 'But in the meantime, until the US administration provides, through the Abraham Accord logics, a political horizon for this crisis, we need to act in order to facilitate the or create an off ramp for the catastrophe ongoing in Gaza' The French diplomatic source indicated that no new normalisation agreements are expected to be announced during the meeting. This week's ministerial-level conference, which was postponed in June amid the 12-day air war between Israel and Iran, will focus on Gaza's reconstruction, its governance and security, disarmament of the Palestinian militant group Hamas and normalising relations between Israel and Arab states that have not yet done so. Volker Türk, the United Nations high commissioner for human rights, said the international community "will judge this conference on what it delivers." "We stand ready to support the Palestinians in state-building, with human rights and rule of law at its centre. When that time comes, programmes to support victims and survivors will be an important avenue for opening a pathway to accountability and redress," he said. China expressed its support for the UN conference on Friday, with Foreign Ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun saying 'the two-state solution remains the only viable path to resolve the Palestinian issue'. Max Rodenbeck, Israel-Palestine project director at the International Crisis Group think tank, said that while reviving international focus on the two-state solution is 'laudable', practical steps are needed. 'Rhetorical support needs to be matched by practical steps, as the practical possibility for creating a Palestinian state on the ground has been ebbing for years, and under the current Israeli government faces stubborn hostility,' Mr Rodenbeck said. France in September will become the third permanent member of the UN Security Council to recognise Palestine, along with Russia and China. Currently, 147 out of 193 UN member states officially recognise the state of Palestine. Mr Rodenbeck noted that Mr Macron's pledge to recognise a Palestinian state, even if symbolic for now, offers Palestinians 'a horizon for hope'. Pressure is intensifying on Israel to end its war in Gaza. Israel's strikes and ground offensive have killed nearly 60,000 Palestinians, displaced most of the population and laid waste to most of the enclave. This followed the Hamas-led attacks on Israeli communities on October 7, 2023, killing about 1,200 people and abducting 240. The conference takes place as ceasefire talks between Israel and Hamas appear to have collapsed, and as more than 100 aid agencies warned of mass starvation in Gaza. US President Donald Trump suggested on Friday that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu should intensify military action against Hamas to eliminate the group. 'Hamas didn't really want to make a deal, I think they want to die,' Mr Trump told journalists at the White House before a trip to Scotland, adding that it's time to 'finish the job' and 'get rid' of Hamas. Mr Rodenbeck said: 'It is tragic that ceasefire talks have broken down, but the more immediate tragedy – and a more solvable one – is the looming famine about to engulf Gaza.' 'Israel's use of food as a weapon is not only disgraceful, it has clearly proved ineffective as a negotiating tactic,' he said. The event will test international resolve to push for Palestinian statehood despite Israeli and US resistance, with Riyadh and Paris framing it as a critical step towards long-term stability.

Israel must let more food in to Gaza and end the starvation
Israel must let more food in to Gaza and end the starvation

The National

timean hour ago

  • The National

Israel must let more food in to Gaza and end the starvation

Since the Gaza ceasefire talks collapsed four months ago, Israel has had a total blockade in place that has prevented food and aid supplies from entering the Palestinian enclave. As a result, the 2.2 million Palestinians confined there have had inflicted on them constant hunger, malnutrition and, as the situation has worsened, a mounting death toll from an entirely avoidable, man-made famine. This is quite apart from the Palestinians still dying and being injured by Israeli aerial attacks and gunfire – Palestinian authorities say more than 59,821 people have been killed since the Gaza war began – and several dozen lives routinely being taken at aid distribution sites, where the clamouring and desperation for food is tragically clear. In response to the crisis and after several countries appear to have convinced Israel to allow alternative methods of aid distribution, the UAE on Saturday said it is resuming aid air drops to Gaza. Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs noted: "We will ensure essential aid reaches those most in need, whether through land, air or sea. Air drops are resuming once more, immediately. Our commitment to alleviating suffering and providing support is resolute and unwavering." Up until last year, the UAE dropped thousands of tonnes of humanitarian aid, food and relief supplies into Gaza. Its other relief operations have also continued. Just last month, the UAE sent a ship with 2100 tonnes of aid to Gaza. Given the context of starvation and the urgent need for food in Gaza, aid air drops at this time are necessary For the first time since the war began, Israel has also air dropped packages of supplies for Palestinians. And it has permitted Jordan (along with the UAE) to do so as well. Countries such as the UK are also in the process of facilitating the parachuting of aid. Given the context of starvation and the urgent need for food in Gaza, aid air drops at this time are necessary. But they are also inadequate and cannot be viewed as a long-term solution. The much more effective way to deliver aid, much of which is lying in warehouses ready to be delivered, is by road, access to which has been systematically denied by the Israeli government. The images of emaciated babies and skeletal helpless frames of their guardians speak for themselves. The death toll so far from malnutrition and starvation in Gaza over the past 20 months of war has risen to 133, including the deaths of 87 children. An Israeli concern frequently repeated is that the aid, were it to be allowed thorough the road checkpoints – as aid trucks from Egypt were let in from Rafah on Sunday –would likely be intercepted by Hamas, and looted. However, no proof has been presented of this. Some gangs have reportedly attacked convoys and without the UN, aid distribution is greatly disrupted. But even with these challenges, the logic doesn't stand up to scrutiny when on the other hand is the strategic starvation of Palestinians. UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres last week said: 'The last lifelines keeping people alive are collapsing." Teams of the UN's World Food Program delivered 350 truckloads of food aid into Gaza last week. The millions of impoverished people in the enclave need much more than what they are set to receive in the coming days. WFP says more than 62,000 tons of food assistance is needed monthly to cover the entire Palestinian population. And they need a constant supply through aid corridors that are allowed to stay open and not just when international stakeholders decide to turn up the heat on Israel. The Gaza ceasefire appears to have stalled. But just because the killings continue doesn't mean that the starvation campaign cannot be brought to an immediate and permanent end.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store