Supreme Court rejects final attempt by Ryanair to halt €200m Dublin Airport cargo underpass
In February, Mr Justice Richard Humphreys dismissed the airline's challenge to An Bord Pleanála's decision to approve the Dublin Airport Authority's (DAA) planned 1.1km tunnel, which is to run beneath the 'crosswind' runway.
The judge subsequently refused Ryanair permission to appeal that ruling to the Court of Appeal.
The Supreme Court this week said it would not allow Ryanair to challenge Mr Justice Humphreys' judgment in a leapfrog appeal, after deciding its case did not meet the threshold required for the granting of permission to appeal.
READ MORE
The Supreme Court will only hear appeals involving matters it deems to be of general public importance, or if it deems the hearing of an appeal is in the interest of justice.
The court said the interests of justice weighed 'significantly against' granting permission to Ryanair to appeal, given the proposed underpass is safety-related.
Ryanair's leave for appeal application arose from what it said was An Bord Pleanála's erroneous interpretation of the Dublin Airport Local Area Plan (LAP) in considering DAA's planning application for the underpass.
Ryanair argued that determining whether material legal errors made by An Bord Pleanála in the interpretation or understanding of a relevant LAP in coming to a planning decision can be grounds to quash such a decision is an issue of general public importance.
'The panel is not satisfied that the issue identified by Ryanair as the issue of general public importance justifying the grant of leave ... properly arises on the facts here,' a three-judge Supreme Court panel wrote.
In the High Court proceedings, Ryanair argued An Bord Pleanála did not recognise that the proposed development is inconsistent with the Dublin Airport Local Area Plan, as it requires the loss of two aircraft stands.
While Mr Justice Humphreys said he tended to agree with parts of the Ryanair's argument on this point, he said the airline relied on Section 37(2) of the Planning and Development Act 2000 in making this argument, a subsection that he said does not apply to cases of material contravention of local area plans.
Mr Justice Humphreys had held that An Bord Pleanála had correctly interpreted the relevant Local Area Plan in granting permission to DAA.
The underpass is needed to improve access and safety on the airfield and to facilitate segregation of aircraft and ground vehicles, according to DAA.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Water bonuses are hard to swallow
Sir, – I noted three headlines in The Irish Times on July 2nd which surprised me. They are as follows:- (1) 500,000 people across State use 'at risk' drinking water, (2) Water system a major block on growth, Ifac says, (3) Total bonuses at Uisce Éireann top €13 million. READ MORE I'm mystified why employees at Uisce Éireann should receive bonuses for doing what they are employed to do. – Yours, etc, LESLEY KERRIGAN, Rathfarnham, Dublin 14.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on plans for the GPO: a terrible idea is born
The GPO occupies a space in Irish life that transcends bricks and mortar. More than a functioning post office or architectural anchor of O'Connell Street, it is the most resonant physical symbol of the struggle for Irish independence. It is no surprise, then, that the Government's vague and ill-defined outline for its redevelopment, framed in response to the Dublin City Taskforce report, has drawn such emotional and at times overheated criticism. Sinn Féin and Aontú have accused the Government of plotting to turn the GPO into 'a shopping centre'. While this charge is more rhetorical than realistic – the proposals include 're-imagined retail components' in the existing shops on Henry Street and the GPO Arcade – it reflects an understandable fear that the site's dignity might be compromised in the name of commercial convenience. The idea of a Starbucks beneath the watchful gaze of Cúchulainn rightly causes discomfort, however improbable it may be. Still, the reaction should not obscure the need for careful scrutiny of what is being proposed. Among the Government's stated intentions are to retain a post office function, enhance the public realm, integrate retail elements and introduce 'significant cultural uses'. Thus far, so good. But it also includes a plan to install a 'high-quality office element on the upper floors to meet ongoing and additional Government requirements'. This is where the proposal veers off course. READ MORE At a time when central Dublin is not short of modern office space – much of it lying vacant – it is difficult to comprehend why the State would invest in converting a historic and architecturally sensitive complex from the 1920s into more civil service workspace. Such a move appears not only unnecessary but tone-deaf to the symbolic role of the building and the opportunity it presents. The north inner city, and O'Connell Street in particular, have suffered decades of neglect and decline. The GPO, if imaginatively and respectfully revitalised, could be a cornerstone in the area's cultural and civic renewal. That opportunity must not be squandered. A successful redevelopment should put heritage and public engagement at its core. It must help residents and visitors alike understand the GPO's extraordinary role in Ireland's history, something the current museum on the premises only begins to do. It should also include new public cultural venues: not just one, but several, ensuring that this central, national site is animated with meaning and public value. As Labour's Marie Sherlock and An Post CEO David McRedmond (who chaired the original taskforce and knows the building as well as anyone) have rightly pointed out, there are better options for additional office space elsewhere. The GPO deserves more than functional repurposing. It deserves vision, respect and ambition.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
European shares dip ahead of US tariffs
European shares ended lower on Friday as losses in banks and mining-related stocks weighed, with focus now shifting to the July 9th deadline for trading partners to reach a deal with the United States. US President Donald Trump said Washington will start sending letters with tariff rates to countries on Friday, subduing markets globally. With Trump's 90-day pause on higher US tariffs ending next week, investors have taken a cautious stance as several large trading partners, including the European Union (EU), are yet to secure trade deals. Dublin The Irish index of shares closed the week marginally lower, falling 0.33 per cent to end the week at 11,320. READ MORE The main banking stocks edged lower, mirroring the decline in the wider market and trends elsewhere in Europe. AIB was just under half a per cent lower by the end of the day, clawing its way back to €6.82 after hitting a low of €6.82 early in the session. Bank of Ireland was down 0.37 per cent, after an early high of €12.22 dipped to a €12.04 low, settling down at €12.12. Permanent TSB ended the day up almost 1 per cent, but volumes were thin in comparison. Food groups Kerry and Glanbia were both off, with the latter down 0.39 per cent and the former shedding 0.16 per cent. Shares in insulation specialist Kingspan were marginally higher, gaining back some of the ground it lost on Thursday, ending the day at €70.90. Hotel group Dalata Hotel shed 0.15 per cent over the day, and airline Ryanair fell 0.55 per cent. The airline has been hampered by strike action among French air traffic controllers over the past two days, leading to the cancellation of more than 400 flights. London London's main stock indexes closed mixed on Friday, with investors assessing domestic fiscal worries and the rate cut path. The blue-chip FTSE 100 was unchanged on the day but notched up a second weekly gain, while the domestically-focused FTSE 250 lost 0.7 per cent on Friday and ended the week lower. Home builder stocks led sectoral losses on Friday, dropping 2.1 per cent after MJ Gleeson warned of profit being at the lower end of market expectations for fiscal 2026 due to subdued demand. The group slumped 6.7 per cent and was the top decliner on the smallcap index. Larger peers Vistry, Persimmon and Taylor Wimpey fell 2.8 per cent, 1.3 per cent and 1.6 per cent, respectively. Industrial metal stocks fell, tracking lower metal prices. Anglo American, Antofagasta and Glencore slipped more than 1 per cent each. Atalya lost 3 per cent. Among individual stocks, greeting card and gifting retailer Moonpig fell 8.7 per cent to the bottom of the midcap index after a rating downgrade by Deutsche Bank. Europe The pan-European STOXX 600 index closed 0.5 per cent lower, clocking a marginal weekly fall. Other regional indexes also declined, with Germany's DAX down 0.6 per cent and France's CAC 40 losing 0.8 per cent. Spain's benchmark lagged with a 1.5 per cent fall. Euro zone banks slid 1,3 per cent, with Spain's BBVA topping declines at a 2.6 per cent fall. Helping limit losses, healthcare advanced 1.1 per cent. Drugmakers Novartis, Roche and Novo Nordisk – some of the biggest weights on the STOXX 600 – all clocked gains. Shares of French spirits makers Pernod Ricard, Remy Cointreau and LVMH – the owner of Hennessy – all finished well off their session lows after China spared major cognac producers from new duties on EU brandy, provided they sell at a minimum price. Despite a roaring start to the year, European shares fell behind the US S&P 500 on year-to-date basis on Friday, driven dominantly by tech shares. The STOXX 600 was last up 6.6 per cent for 2025, compared with the 6.7 per cent advance for the S&P 500. Among individual stocks, Germany's Rheinmetall advanced 3.3 per cent after JP Morgan and Deutsche Bank raised their price targets on the defence contractor. New York The US markets were closed due to the July 4th holiday.
