Elders' legal bid to save homes, culture coming to end
Their Country on the outer islands of Zenadth Kes (Torres Strait), less than 10 kilometres off Papua New Guinea, is under siege from the impacts of climate change.
The two men fear the loss of their islands, their culture and their way of life, forcing their families and communities to become Australia's first climate refugees.
The Uncles have taken the federal government to court in the Australian Climate Case, seeking orders which would require the Commonwealth to undertake steps to prevent further harm to their communities.
This would include cutting greenhouse gas emissions in line with the best available science.
The Commonwealth has argued it is not legally required to consider the best available science or the impacts of climate change when setting emissions reduction targets.
On Tuesday, the Federal Court is due to make a decision in the case and the men hold hope that their fight might safeguard the future of their people.
Mr Pabai and Mr Kabai launched the action against the federal government in 2021.
They are arguing that the Commonwealth owes a duty of care to Torres Strait Islanders to take reasonable steps to protect them from harm.
During on-country hearings in 2023, witnesses described how devastating their loss of culture due to climate change had been.
"We don't want to be climate refugees," Pabai Pabai, who has spent his life on the low-lying island of Boigu, tells AAP.
Paul Kabai remembers a time when his family would hunt, fish and eat produce from gardens grown by the community.
But that has all changed, he says.
The beaches on his island - Saibai - have receded, turning to mud and mangroves.
Its river system is inundated with saltwater and, alarmingly, even the island's cemetery has been impacted by flooding.
"Even our cultural sites are being destroyed by rising seas," he laments.
"We're both very worried about what we are losing, our hunting grounds are being destroyed by strong currents.
"Where can we show our culture to the younger generation?" he asks.
"In this way we are losing our culture, everything that belongs to our ancestors."
Drawing closer to a decision in the case is a significant milestone for Mr Pabai and Mr Kabai.
It has been an emotional journey for them, their communities and supporters but as the Uncles approach the end of this battle, they hold close the reasons they began such a long fight.
Pointing to the example of fellow Torres Strait Islander Eddie Mabo whose lifetime of campaigning resulted in a landmark High Court ruling, recognising the rights of First Nations people to their lands, countering the idea of 'terra nullius' asserted by the British at colonisation, Mr Pabai says the battle has been waged for his ancestors.
"I'm standing firm on his shoulders," he says.
"If we come to winning this case, this is a victory for my family and communities on Boigu and all the community around the country and around the world."
As much as this is about the people who came before and protecting what they've left, Mr Pabai says his two-year-old son and the generations to come, in the Torres Strait and further afield, are front of mind.
"My main focus is on the new generation," he says.
"This is why I'm doing it - for the love of my son, for all the people in my community in the Torres Strait, for bushfire and flood survivors, for the farmers and the children and grandchildren."
No matter the legal outcome, Mr Kabai says he believes the action he and Mr Pabai have taken will make a difference.
"We will be very proud, even if we win or if we lose," he says.
"The government is listening now, they know what is happening and they must do something about climate change."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
2 hours ago
- The Age
Melbourne freight rail infrastructure: How Victoria's failed $6b pitch to Canberra put a new rail line in limbo
'When constructed, the OMR will act as the backbone to developing areas in the north and west, ensuring that freight movements around the area are accommodated on high-quality built-for-purpose roads,' the 2021 analysis found. That year, the Victorian government lodged a $123.4 million funding submission to Canberra to begin to develop the Outer Metropolitan Ring, beginning with a standard-gauge rail connection from Beveridge to Werribee, connecting to a giant new freight terminal in Truganina. The Victorian government argued that Canberra should bear the full cost of the project because the line would form part of the national rail network – traditionally a federal responsibility. It sought to tie the enormous project to Inland Rail, a $31 billion, federally funded freight link between Melbourne and Brisbane, which is under construction. Had the Commonwealth accepted Victoria's submission, the Inland Rail line would have been extended deep into Melbourne's industrial west, the correspondence reveals. A new orbital rail line could then have been under construction today, snaking through some of the city's fastest growing suburbs, including Mickleham, Diggers Rest, Aintree, Rockbank and Manor Lakes. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese views construction plans at the Beveridge intermodal precinct. Credit: AAP But the Albanese government ultimately baulked, anxious to rein in rising costs on Inland Rail. It chose in 2023 to build Melbourne's Inland Rail terminal in Beveridge, 44 kilometres north of central Melbourne. The decision forced the Allan government to put its preferred terminal location, in Truganina, on ice indefinitely earlier this year. Building the Truganina terminal would have cost up to $1.9 billion, but could have involved substantial private sector contributions, correspondence states. Australian Rail Freight Alliance chief executive Reid Mather said the outcome was disappointing. 'The cheapest time to build is today. It won't get any cheaper,' he said. Mather said the Truganina terminal was more expensive to build than the Beveridge terminal, but better located. The federal government would not get full value out of the enormous investment in Inland Rail until freight trains could reach Truganina, and that required building the Outer Metropolitan Ring, he said. The terminal in Beveridge was remote from most industrial precincts so would do little to reduce truck traffic on city freeways, he said. 'To be able to pack down a 1.8-kilometre train that would be double-stacked and get it back to do its 24-hour cycle to Brisbane, the most efficient way for that to occur is to unload it as close to the port as possible,' Mather said. 'If we're going to unload trains at Beveridge, the dilemma is … are you going to truck those containers in and cause more congestion? Rail Freight Alliance chief executive Reid Mather says Inland Rail needs a direct link to the Port of Melbourne via the western suburbs to fulfil its purpose. Credit: Alex Coppel 'None of these things are easy, but the only way you get double-stacked container trains in [to the Port of Melbourne] is to use the outer metro road corridor that has been gazetted for years.' Melbourne's west is the biggest freight and logistics precinct in Australia, moving about 12 per cent of the nation's total freight, and 37 per cent of Victoria's, according to Port of Melbourne figures. Confidential correspondence argued Beveridge was an inferior option to Truganina because it was remote from Melbourne's western suburban industrial heartland and its south-eastern population centres, it was a smaller site with less capacity to grow, and was more complex to build. Victoria's submission proved ill-timed, and too costly. Ballooning costs led the Albanese government to review Inland Rail the year after Victoria lobbied Canberra to inject billions more into the project. Loading The 2023 review acknowledged that the Port of Melbourne and the freight and logistics industry unanimously favoured Truganina over Beveridge, but concluded that building a rail line via the Outer Metropolitan Ring 'is likely to be cost prohibitive and not needed for Inland Rail in the near or medium term'. The Outer Metropolitan Ring is a planned 100-kilometre road and rail line running in an arc around Melbourne's northern and western periphery. The corridor was placed under a public acquisition overlay in 2010. The Victorian and Commonwealth governments jointly invested $20 million in a preliminary business case for the project in 2021-22. The business case is being kept secret. A freedom-of-information request was rejected due to cabinet confidentiality, but The Age understands the mega-project was costed at about $31 billion in 2021. A spokesperson for federal Infrastructure Minister Catherine King said the Albanese government remained supportive of building two terminals for Victoria, at Beveridge and Truganina. Loading 'Beveridge is being developed first because it can be delivered more quickly and is necessary in order to service Inland Rail's double-stacked freight trains by 2027, while [Truganina] is anticipated to become the larger intermodal terminal over time,' the spokesperson said. The Australian government has committed $1.72 billion towards the future development of the Outer Metropolitan Ring Rail and the Western Intermodal Freight Terminal in Truganina. Funding for the rail line is contingent on it being matched by Victoria. Asked on Monday about revelations in The Age that government planners predicted the first road component of the OMR was needed by 2031, acting Premier Jaclyn Symes said the road was 'not a proposal that we're actively considering'. 'But as is appropriate, preserving land for a future decision is an appropriate course of action,' she said. An Allan government spokesperson said the ring was a crucial future transport corridor, but did not answer questions on when it was scheduled to be built, given the state's failure to secure full federal funding for it. Start the day with a summary of the day's most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.
Sky News AU
4 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Federal court rules against Commonwealth duty of care claim over climate change impacts for Torres Strait Islanders
The Federal Court has issued a ruling against a landmark claim the Commonwealth has failed Torres Strait Islanders in its duty of care regarding 'human-induced climate change' affecting the islands. Justice Michael Wigney's decision on Tuesday found the applicants - Guda Maluyligal nation men Pabai Pabai and Guy Paul Kabai – had not been successful in producing a case of negligence against the Commonwealth. Mr Pabai and Mr Kabai asserted that the Commonwealth had responded inadequately and had fallen short in protecting Torres Strait Islanders from the impacts of climate change, claiming it had breached an owed duty of care. In the decision's summary, Judge Wigney said though he accepted many 'factual allegations' put forward by the men, current Australian law did not allow a 'real or effective avenue' for them to pursue their claims. His decision stated there is 'no doubt' the Torres Strait Islands have been and are being 'ravaged by the impacts of human-induced climate change'. 'The islands themselves have been, and continue to be, eroded and inundated by rising seas and increasingly severe extreme sea level and weather events,' the judgment said. Judge Wigney also found that previous governments' efforts to reduce climate change and its impacts had been lacking. 'When the Commonwealth identified and set Australia's greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets in 2015, 2020 and 2021, it failed to engage with or give any real or genuine consideration to what the best available science indicated was required for Australia to play its part in the global effort to moderate or reduce climate change and its impacts,' the decision said. Mr Pabai and Mr Kabai lack of success in their case was not due to their arguments having no merit, the judge added. 'Rather, it failed because the law in Australia as it currently stands provides no real or effective avenue through which the applicants were able to pursue their claims,' the decision said. 'In particular, the common law of negligence in Australia was an unsuitable legal vehicle through which the applicants could obtain relief in respect of the type of governmental action or inaction which was in issue in this case, or relief in respect of their loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom.' The judge ordered Mr Pabai and Mr Kabai and the Commonwealth provide the court with either an agreed draft orders or supply their own differing draft orders regarding the judgement to the court within the next six weeks.
Sydney Morning Herald
7 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Nation has what it takes to become a green superpower
How encouraging to read Peter Hartcher picking up on economist Ross Garnaut's theme of Australia as a future energy superpower and provider of green iron (' Australia's great leap forward', July 15). I especially rejoice as a retired engineer. This is more than just a technological fix, although I know from personal experience with hydrogen how challenging its use will be. However, I remain confident that our young scientists, engineers, economists and politicians have what it takes. Let's go for it, but let's also recognise the sobering challenge of too many egotistical politicians with their fingers close to nuclear buttons. John Court, Denistone Peter Hartcher should have read Nick O'Malley's article on the drawbacks of green steel before predicting it's the answer to the world's steel production problems (' The PM talked up green steel. But is it even a thing?' July 15). As O'Malley points out, the industrial supply chain to produce green steel is long, complicated and expensive. It's a great idea, but its time has not yet come. Ian Adair, Hunters Hill Full marks to Andrew 'Twiggy' Forrest for pledging to produce green iron in Australia (' Green metals, Australia's power play ', July 15). While his determination to produce commercially viable green hydrogen has stalled, the electric smelting furnace, which is preferably powered by renewables, has progressed to the pilot stage. The idea of value-adding to our vast iron ore resources is a welcome step away from the 'quarry Australia' mentality. Now the crucial challenges of location of smelters, provision of renewable electricity and infrastructure, disposal/utilisation of waste and access to a trained workforce remain. It is certainly encouraging to note that both the WA and federal governments are supporting the transition, presumably as their considerable income stream from mining royalties will remain intact. Roger Epps, Armidale Envoys for all Is it sensible to have 'envoys' representing some segments of the population while omitting others (' Burke spares Segal from criticism ', July 15)? During the referendum 'debate', the racism was extraordinary as an alarming number of No proponents appeared to enable people to express once taboo but increasingly common slurs and disinformation about Indigenous people. Yet not only did an official First Nations envoy not materialise, but 60 per cent of Australians thought it was fair to deny them a voice. If we are to have envoys, let's ensure they represent all minorities who are the butt of ignorance and discrimination. Alison Stewart, Riverview We certainly should oppose all forms of bigotry and so Minister Tony Burke's mention of misogyny, an evil as persistent as antisemitism, was welcome. Despite regrettable instances of antisemitism making Jews feel unsafe, it is women who are actually being killed in Australia at an average of one a week. Yet, there is no Special Envoy to Combat Misogyny, and if such an office were created, imagine the furious outcry about 'wokeness' and 'political correctness'. Caroline Graham, Cromer Councils run monopoly Cindy Yin's article highlights the cost-shifting by state and federal governments onto local councils, who are then forced to seek special rate variations to make up the lost revenues (' The $500 burden every Sydney ratepayer is carrying ', July 15). This issue has been ongoing for more than 30 years and is well known. The federal government has reduced overall funding to councils from 2 per cent of tax receipts to less than 0.5 per cent over the same period. This is largely why there is such a backlog of maintenance and repairs in (especially) regional councils. Still, no one questions the monopoly provider position for council services such as water, sewer and garbage. Ratepayers are forced to pay for services they either do not need or could perhaps get more cheaply from a different provider. As a single-person household, I am required to pay the same annual charge for garbage collection as much larger families, yet my bins only go out every other month. Effectively, I pay $503 for $70 worth of actual garbage collection. Hardly an equitable scenario. An actual usage cost model would definitely help with my cost of living, as it would for every other small household, as we effectively subsidise those who are filling the landfills. Mark Walker, Kempsey Bradfield folly So the judge will review cherry-picked votes that the AEC allegedly miscounted, until 26 + 1 are found to be invalid and the result reversed ('Liberals mount court challenge in last ditch bid to reclaim Bradfield', July 15). Do the Liberals really think this sort of dummy-spit will sway any of the highly reputable judges on the Court of Disputed Returns. Spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to try to reverse one seat makes no real difference to the overall election massacre of the Liberals. The 'better economic managers' surely realise that money would be better spent promoting the candidate for the next election in 2028 by door-knocking every one of the 120,000-plus voters. Gisele Kapterian agreeing to this appeal puts her judgment in doubt and suggest the 'born to rule' mindset that was just comprehensively rejected by Australian voters. Peter Kamenyitzky, Castle Hill I am disappointed but not surprised at Gisele Kapterian's court challenge after her narrow loss in Bradfield. Her opponent, Nicolette Boele, also lost on her first attempt but stayed active and engaged in Bradfield and stood at the next election; the sitting member Paul Fletcher chose to resign, perhaps not relishing another three years in opposition. Now taxpayers' money is to be squandered on lawyers in the Court of Disputed Returns because this late entrant feels she and her party have a right to rule. I trust Ms Boele is not distracted by this uncertainty and is able to continue to focus on the interests of the constituents she represents. Marjorie Sutcliffe, The Rocks Liberal diehards appealing against the Bradfield election result is like the dying days of the British Empire – 'we can't believe those peasants want us gone – it's our right to govern.' Well, a majority of progressive members of the electorate wanted the Liberal Party with its woeful (now non-existent) policies on climate and the environment out of the picture. The fact that Gisele Kapterian, the Liberal candidate, didn't even turn up for a 200-plus audience of electors representing socially progressive groups spoke volumes. A quiet rebellion has happened and the army of volunteers who supported and funded community independent Nicolette Boele will make sure the Liberals can't take them for granted ever again. Carolyn Pettigrew, Pymble Pay tax proudly I would suggest that rather than talking about tax cuts, Treasurer Jim Chalmers might want to start a campaign to change the electorate's mindset and educate people of the reasons we pay tax, the benefits everyone receives and to ultimately encourage people to feel pride in paying their share (' To cut taxes we need ways to raise revenue: Chalmers', July 15). Governments don't help themselves when they constantly try to seduce us with tax cuts, which, from the top down, instil the overall understanding that paying tax is bad, and any way to reduce tax payments is good. Of course, the other, possibly challenging, aspect is that politicians then have to convince us that the tax revenue collected has been spent wisely. I know, tell me I'm dreaming. Mark Tietjen, Redfern Puppet show I've been to an afternoon performance in the Paddington Reservoir Gardens, with William Barton on didgeridoo playing with a violinist. It was a wonderful performance and well suited to that venue. I think it's also a great site for a puppet show (' Other places would be delighted to host Paddington's puppet show ', July 15). However, the biggest drawback is getting there. It's either drive (and try to find an elusive parking spot), bus, or a fairly long walk from the light rail. For that reason alone, there may be better site options to draw a crowd from far and wide. Lisa Clarke, Watsons Bay How good that the City of Sydney's Art and About festival threatens 'art in any corner of our city, at any time'. But are the Paddington residents with reservations about the four-metre puppet called Fauna, exploring 'themes of climate change and deforestation', equally concerned about reality, which is far scarier? Fauna would be most welcome in Melbourne as a friend of Blinky, a four-metre koala who regularly accompanies climate and forest rallies. As Kermit the Frog said, 'Life's like a movie, write your own ending.' While our ending looks increasingly grim, we are at least still writing it. Fauna and Blinky are part of that story. They make us think. Ray Peck, Hawthorn (Vic) Fuel for thought No, David Sayers, it is not 'pure folly' to believe that EV trucks will be used in the remote places of Australia (Letters, July 15). It is actually pure progressive thinking. Remote trucking refuelling stations can be set up with solar arrays and batteries alongside other energy alternatives including hydrogen, diesel and petrol. The change away from fossil fuels has to happen because eventually, some time in the future, there will be no oil available for anyone to use. That future may arrive sooner than you think, not because it has all been drilled up, but because of conflict in the oil-rich centres of the world. Neil Quinn, Vincentia David Sayers claims EV trucks cannot be used in remote areas because there is no grid electricity. Putting aside for a moment the role of solar-generated electricity, the objections to green energy generally are getting to the point where they are jostling for curiosity value with the alleged phenomena of curtains that fade when daylight saving returns. Joe Weller, Mittagong David Sayers asserts that EV trucks will never be able to work for long hauls. I disagree. Road trains have large roofs that could carry multiple solar panels to charge the vehicle as it drives along. Tom Meakin, Port Macquarie AUKUS positives The AUKUS 'deal' has two pillars, the first being the nuclear submarines and the second being advanced capabilities (' PM tested on US alliance ', July 14). The second is the one correspondents and the media either gloss over or choose to forget. Pillar two is about collaboration and sharing advanced military technology (AI, computing, cyber technologies, undersea tech, hypersonics, electronic warfare and information sharing). It seems many commentators are too engrossed with the nuclear angle to see beyond the other possible benefits. Michael Cronk, Dubbo What intelligence? The implications of superintelligence seem too much for most of us simple humans to deal with (' Mark Zuckerberg's $150 million job offers are spreading fear', July 15). Look hard and it's scary indeed. 'The end of human history,' says historian Nassim Nicholas Taleb. Meanwhile, the rest of us concentrate on gossip, celebrities and the State of Origin while Donald Trump tries to recreate the 20th century and our churches expend their energy debating the place of women in worship. It looks like the horse has bolted. Game over. Brian Haisman, Winmalee Dodgy science Racism is also a failure to keep up with scientific research which has proven through the human genome project that race is a social construct not a biological phenomenon (Letters, July 15). Given that all living human beings belong to the subspecies homo sapiens, you really can't help but love your neighbour because any differences that exist are minor cosmetic ones. Sister Sledge didn't know it, but the group was spot-on with their big hit song We are Family. Genetic essentialism is old hat and dodgy science. Trevor Somerville, Illawong Lucky after all I see that the annual Global Liveability Index published by The Economist' s intelligence unit this year has three Australian cities in the world's top 10 most liveable cities: Melbourne (#4), Sydney (#6) and Adelaide (#9). This index uses an objective quantitative approach to assigning the rankings. No other country has more than one city in the top 10. No US city is in the top 10. For all of our whingeing, we must be doing something right in Australia to have such a result. Enjoy! Dale Bailey, St Leonards Natural air-con The solution to cold trains is from cold Europe and is very simple. Each door should have a button to be pressed only if passengers need to open it (Letters, July 15). It also helps in hot summers when the air-conditioning is running. On busy stations, there can be an override when all doors open automatically. Matt Mushalik, Epping Bespoke madness For cycle commuters, Sydney's cycle ways don't offer much help (' The cycleway from hell was paved with good intentions ', July 15). You have to ride on the road to get to them, often negating the most direct way to get to your destination, and they all make you join road traffic again. May as well just stay on the road and hope to God that motorists steer clear of you. Increasing the one-metre car distance rule to two metres could be helpful. Claudia Drevikovsky, Croydon Just stop already Recent moves to reduce urban speed limits to 40km/h do not go far enough. It is scientifically proven that to minimise road accidents, injuries and fatalities, the optimum speed limit is zero km/h. This should be applied universally to cars and trucks, bikes, skateboards, prams etc. Doubtless some people will carp about the impact on convenience, economic activity and so on, but human life is priceless. Josh Shrubb, Turramurra Whey to go There are much better ways to dispose of or, in my case, transform milk that is past its use-by date (' Is milk bad now? No, but it is contributing to a $12m plumbing problem ', July 15). All milk, old or fresh, when simmered on a stove makes delicious cottage or farm cheese. In fact, you get a tastier result when the milk has already begun to curdle. The old-fashioned 'curds and whey' of Miss Muffet fame is simply that – one litre of milk, a teaspoon of salt, in a saucepan and brought to just below boiling point. Turn off the heat, add the juice of half a lemon, wait until the mixture separates, then sieve through a cheese cloth. Hey presto, curds ie farm cheese and whey – the high-protein liquid for further use in cake or breadmaking. Mix the curds with a little cream for a delicious cottage cheese – and have no concerns about clogging up the plumbing. Eva Johnstone, Blackheath If your milk is going off, make a chocolate cake. The milk will act as a rising agent. Delicious. Irene Thom, Vaucluse
