'Unjust': push to jail cop for great-gran Taser death
The loss of confidence in police after a cop fatally tasered a 95-year-old aged care resident should have been taken into account when he was spared jail for killing, a court has been told.
Then-senior constable Kristian James Samuel White fired his Taser at Clare Nowland minutes after being called to the Yallambee Lodge nursing home at Cooma in southern NSW.
She died in hospital a week after the incident in the early hours of May 17, 2023.
The 35-year-old was handed a two-year good behaviour bond and ordered to complete community service in March after a jury found him guilty of manslaughter.
The Crown quickly lodged an appeal against the "manifestly inadequate" penalty, with the state's most senior prosecutor on Friday arguing the sentencing judge made a number of errors.
NSW Director of Public Prosecutions Sally Dowling argued Justice Ian Harrison should have taken into account victim impact statements from Mrs Nowland's family as evidence of the broader harm wreaked on the community.
Several relatives previously told the court they had lost trust in the ability of police officers to protect vulnerable people.
"It's shock, it's loss of confidence ... it's torn the fabric of society," Ms Dowling told three judges in the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal.
While Justice Harrison considered the statements when assessing the objective seriousness of the manslaughter, he didn't stress the harm done to the wider community.
It amounted to a mishandling of the evidence that fed into the delivery of an inadequate sentence, she argued.
During a two minute and 40 second interaction, White drew his weapon and pointed it at Mrs Nowland before saying "nah, bugger it" and discharging the Taser at her chest.
The elderly woman, who weighed less than 48kg, fell and suffered a fatal brain injury.
In his judgment, Justice Harrison said the need to deter other police officers from committing similar offences played "only a minor role" in his sentencing decision.
But Ms Dowling argued he made a mistake by not issuing a strong warning to other officers.
"(Police) occupy a trusted role in our community and they must take the utmost care to use those weapons carefully," she said.
"This case required a sentence that sends a clear message that an unjustified resort to force or violence when other options are available will result in serious criminal punishment."
Mrs Nowland was experiencing dementia symptoms, relied on her walking frame to move and was "extremely vulnerable" when she encountered White, the prosecutor said.
The great-grandmother was holding a knife but didn't advance towards White while brandishing it and had no discernible reaction to his requests to put the blade down.
"(White) did not give her any real chance to avoid being tasered," Ms Dowling said.
"There were many other options available to him".
Justice Harrison also made a mistake when he found the officer made a "terrible mistake" but his crime was less serious than other manslaughter offences, Ms Dowling argued.
As a result, she alleges the non-custodial sentence handed to White was "plainly unjust".
"The truly senseless, impatient, and violent conduct of the offender requires a sentence that gives weight to denunciation," she said.
White's lawyers are expected to address the court on Friday afternoon.
The loss of confidence in police after a cop fatally tasered a 95-year-old aged care resident should have been taken into account when he was spared jail for killing, a court has been told.
Then-senior constable Kristian James Samuel White fired his Taser at Clare Nowland minutes after being called to the Yallambee Lodge nursing home at Cooma in southern NSW.
She died in hospital a week after the incident in the early hours of May 17, 2023.
The 35-year-old was handed a two-year good behaviour bond and ordered to complete community service in March after a jury found him guilty of manslaughter.
The Crown quickly lodged an appeal against the "manifestly inadequate" penalty, with the state's most senior prosecutor on Friday arguing the sentencing judge made a number of errors.
NSW Director of Public Prosecutions Sally Dowling argued Justice Ian Harrison should have taken into account victim impact statements from Mrs Nowland's family as evidence of the broader harm wreaked on the community.
Several relatives previously told the court they had lost trust in the ability of police officers to protect vulnerable people.
"It's shock, it's loss of confidence ... it's torn the fabric of society," Ms Dowling told three judges in the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal.
While Justice Harrison considered the statements when assessing the objective seriousness of the manslaughter, he didn't stress the harm done to the wider community.
It amounted to a mishandling of the evidence that fed into the delivery of an inadequate sentence, she argued.
During a two minute and 40 second interaction, White drew his weapon and pointed it at Mrs Nowland before saying "nah, bugger it" and discharging the Taser at her chest.
The elderly woman, who weighed less than 48kg, fell and suffered a fatal brain injury.
In his judgment, Justice Harrison said the need to deter other police officers from committing similar offences played "only a minor role" in his sentencing decision.
But Ms Dowling argued he made a mistake by not issuing a strong warning to other officers.
"(Police) occupy a trusted role in our community and they must take the utmost care to use those weapons carefully," she said.
"This case required a sentence that sends a clear message that an unjustified resort to force or violence when other options are available will result in serious criminal punishment."
Mrs Nowland was experiencing dementia symptoms, relied on her walking frame to move and was "extremely vulnerable" when she encountered White, the prosecutor said.
The great-grandmother was holding a knife but didn't advance towards White while brandishing it and had no discernible reaction to his requests to put the blade down.
"(White) did not give her any real chance to avoid being tasered," Ms Dowling said.
"There were many other options available to him".
Justice Harrison also made a mistake when he found the officer made a "terrible mistake" but his crime was less serious than other manslaughter offences, Ms Dowling argued.
As a result, she alleges the non-custodial sentence handed to White was "plainly unjust".
"The truly senseless, impatient, and violent conduct of the offender requires a sentence that gives weight to denunciation," she said.
White's lawyers are expected to address the court on Friday afternoon.
The loss of confidence in police after a cop fatally tasered a 95-year-old aged care resident should have been taken into account when he was spared jail for killing, a court has been told.
Then-senior constable Kristian James Samuel White fired his Taser at Clare Nowland minutes after being called to the Yallambee Lodge nursing home at Cooma in southern NSW.
She died in hospital a week after the incident in the early hours of May 17, 2023.
The 35-year-old was handed a two-year good behaviour bond and ordered to complete community service in March after a jury found him guilty of manslaughter.
The Crown quickly lodged an appeal against the "manifestly inadequate" penalty, with the state's most senior prosecutor on Friday arguing the sentencing judge made a number of errors.
NSW Director of Public Prosecutions Sally Dowling argued Justice Ian Harrison should have taken into account victim impact statements from Mrs Nowland's family as evidence of the broader harm wreaked on the community.
Several relatives previously told the court they had lost trust in the ability of police officers to protect vulnerable people.
"It's shock, it's loss of confidence ... it's torn the fabric of society," Ms Dowling told three judges in the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal.
While Justice Harrison considered the statements when assessing the objective seriousness of the manslaughter, he didn't stress the harm done to the wider community.
It amounted to a mishandling of the evidence that fed into the delivery of an inadequate sentence, she argued.
During a two minute and 40 second interaction, White drew his weapon and pointed it at Mrs Nowland before saying "nah, bugger it" and discharging the Taser at her chest.
The elderly woman, who weighed less than 48kg, fell and suffered a fatal brain injury.
In his judgment, Justice Harrison said the need to deter other police officers from committing similar offences played "only a minor role" in his sentencing decision.
But Ms Dowling argued he made a mistake by not issuing a strong warning to other officers.
"(Police) occupy a trusted role in our community and they must take the utmost care to use those weapons carefully," she said.
"This case required a sentence that sends a clear message that an unjustified resort to force or violence when other options are available will result in serious criminal punishment."
Mrs Nowland was experiencing dementia symptoms, relied on her walking frame to move and was "extremely vulnerable" when she encountered White, the prosecutor said.
The great-grandmother was holding a knife but didn't advance towards White while brandishing it and had no discernible reaction to his requests to put the blade down.
"(White) did not give her any real chance to avoid being tasered," Ms Dowling said.
"There were many other options available to him".
Justice Harrison also made a mistake when he found the officer made a "terrible mistake" but his crime was less serious than other manslaughter offences, Ms Dowling argued.
As a result, she alleges the non-custodial sentence handed to White was "plainly unjust".
"The truly senseless, impatient, and violent conduct of the offender requires a sentence that gives weight to denunciation," she said.
White's lawyers are expected to address the court on Friday afternoon.
The loss of confidence in police after a cop fatally tasered a 95-year-old aged care resident should have been taken into account when he was spared jail for killing, a court has been told.
Then-senior constable Kristian James Samuel White fired his Taser at Clare Nowland minutes after being called to the Yallambee Lodge nursing home at Cooma in southern NSW.
She died in hospital a week after the incident in the early hours of May 17, 2023.
The 35-year-old was handed a two-year good behaviour bond and ordered to complete community service in March after a jury found him guilty of manslaughter.
The Crown quickly lodged an appeal against the "manifestly inadequate" penalty, with the state's most senior prosecutor on Friday arguing the sentencing judge made a number of errors.
NSW Director of Public Prosecutions Sally Dowling argued Justice Ian Harrison should have taken into account victim impact statements from Mrs Nowland's family as evidence of the broader harm wreaked on the community.
Several relatives previously told the court they had lost trust in the ability of police officers to protect vulnerable people.
"It's shock, it's loss of confidence ... it's torn the fabric of society," Ms Dowling told three judges in the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal.
While Justice Harrison considered the statements when assessing the objective seriousness of the manslaughter, he didn't stress the harm done to the wider community.
It amounted to a mishandling of the evidence that fed into the delivery of an inadequate sentence, she argued.
During a two minute and 40 second interaction, White drew his weapon and pointed it at Mrs Nowland before saying "nah, bugger it" and discharging the Taser at her chest.
The elderly woman, who weighed less than 48kg, fell and suffered a fatal brain injury.
In his judgment, Justice Harrison said the need to deter other police officers from committing similar offences played "only a minor role" in his sentencing decision.
But Ms Dowling argued he made a mistake by not issuing a strong warning to other officers.
"(Police) occupy a trusted role in our community and they must take the utmost care to use those weapons carefully," she said.
"This case required a sentence that sends a clear message that an unjustified resort to force or violence when other options are available will result in serious criminal punishment."
Mrs Nowland was experiencing dementia symptoms, relied on her walking frame to move and was "extremely vulnerable" when she encountered White, the prosecutor said.
The great-grandmother was holding a knife but didn't advance towards White while brandishing it and had no discernible reaction to his requests to put the blade down.
"(White) did not give her any real chance to avoid being tasered," Ms Dowling said.
"There were many other options available to him".
Justice Harrison also made a mistake when he found the officer made a "terrible mistake" but his crime was less serious than other manslaughter offences, Ms Dowling argued.
As a result, she alleges the non-custodial sentence handed to White was "plainly unjust".
"The truly senseless, impatient, and violent conduct of the offender requires a sentence that gives weight to denunciation," she said.
White's lawyers are expected to address the court on Friday afternoon.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
a day ago
- News.com.au
Aussie nan jailed over $400k ‘cancer' scam
A Sydney grandmother who faked a cancer diagnosis as part of an elaborate scheme to fleece almost $400,000 from her loved ones has been led away in handcuffs after a failed bid to appeal her one-year jail sentence. Viviana Varas had her appeal dismissed on Thursday in the NSW District Court after a series of lengthy delays to the case, as the 64-year-old continued to avoid custody. Varas was sentenced to one year in jail, with a non-parole period of five months in May 2024, however, was out on bail until the appeal decision was handed down. In a statement to the four victims of Varas said that the case had been a 'long and painful' chapter in their lives. 'What makes this case sad, is that even after being arrested, Viviana continued to lie and showed no remorse in court,' the statement said. 'While no sentence can undo the damage, [we] are grateful that today bring some measure of closure.' The court heard how Varas frauded the four victims, all of which considered her a friend, out of $382,000 between September 2016 and March 2021 after telling them she would 'invest' their money. Varas told her victims she had a great-great-grandfather who had set up a 'family trust' in the US before making up various excuses when they asked for the money back. One of the excuses was that she had cancer and was undergoing various treatments. Another was that her mother had died of COVID-19 and she needed the funds to organise a funeral. Both turned out to be a lie, the court heard. The full-time jail sentence came as a shock to both the victims and the police prosecutors last year, who had previously said a conviction to be served in the community would suffice. However, on Thursday Judge Paul Conlon confirmed the original sentence, with Varas appearing at the hearing unrepresented. She will first be eligible for parole on November 25. The best friend One of the four victims was the woman's best friend, who she met in 2016 while living in the same building as her in Pyrmont. She told she had even trusted Varas to help with her young family and knitted clothes for them. 'She befriended me and built up that trust,' she said. 'She just really integrated herself into my life and said you're just like a daughter to me. She just groomed me and at my most vulnerable time.' The court heard Varas first asked her for money in 2017 for storage costs. Over a two-year period, Varas managed to convince her to invest into her 'family US trust' with the victim sending her a total $145,000. When she asked for her money back, Varas gave the woman a cheque for $104,000 which bounced. She reported Varas to police in May 2018. Star casino Another victim met Varas at the Star Casino about 10 years ago. She said she sent her about $100,000 to invest across the last decade. She last heard from Varas after she deposited $30,000 into her account. 'She rang me up and said that ATO needed the tax,' she told 'It makes you feel really stupid. She makes it out that she's a multi-millionaire and then when I spoke to her best friend's family, she was just poor as anything. She's done this to a lot of people.' Another victim, a Sydney salesman, met Varas while playing poker at Star Casino. He said she was making thousand-dollar bets and asked where she got the money from. She said she was an investor, with the man sending her $32,000. He was able to get $5000 back from the bank, but is still $27,000 out of pocket. 'She's just like an immoral person. A psychopath scammer,' he said, comparing the case to that of Melissa Caddick. The court previously heard Varas told the victims she had previously 'worked on Wall Street' and that her daughter was a model, all of which turned out to be lie. The fourth victim moved to regional NSW since his run in with Varas. In his victim impact statement, he said his wife had 'suicidal thoughts' after the pair had their life savings of $105,000 taken by Varas. 'They are no longer the optimistic people they once were,' the statement said.
ABC News
2 days ago
- ABC News
Townsville remembers Jennifer Board, four years on from tragic death
When Jennifer Board was killed by a driver chasing a stolen car in Townsville in 2021, it sent shock waves through the community. What followed was an immediate and public outpouring of anger and grief. "I think the community could feel it," her sister, Siana Board, said. Jennifer was an innocent casualty of a car chase involving vigilante Christopher Hughes and car thief Gregory Clubb on February 5, 2021. Both vehicles hit 160kph on Ross River Road before Hughes lost control of his car, which struck Jennifer on her motorbike. Four years later, the two drivers involved in the crash have both been sentenced. Clubb was found guilty of manslaughter and sentenced to 13-and-a-half years' jail in the Supreme Court this month. Justice David North told the Townsville courtroom that Clubb's offending had tragic consequences. "[The conviction] condemns you as the unlawful killer of a young woman," Justice North said. "[She] was innocent, had a bright future and played no role in the circumstances that led to her death." Justice North said Clubb "baited" Christopher Hughes into the chase by seeking him out and throwing items at his car. Hughes pleaded guilty to manslaughter and was sentenced to 12 years' jail in 2023. While legal arguments dragged on, Jennifer's loved ones created events to keep her memory alive. Jennifer's love of football, animals and the colour orange is celebrated each year at a football carnival in her honour. Next weekend will be the fourth Jennifer Board Memorial Football Carnival, arranged by close friend and police officer Luke Southgate. He never expected the event to become as popular as it has, with thousands of attendees and dozens of sponsors. "I don't think that has anything to do with the organisers," he said. This year, the event will be on July 5 rather than the February anniversary of Jennifer's death. "We can solely focus on who she was as a person," Sergeant Southgate said. "We try to spread that vibe and that passion and that joy that she had, to everyone." Jennifer was a gym trainer with a bubbly personality who found friends easily. She was embarking on a new phase of her life, sitting an entry exam to join the Queensland Police Service three days before she died. In her final months, Jennifer splurged for the first time in her adult life on her dream motorbike. Members of Townsville's motorcycling community were the first to attend a rally the day after the fatal collision. They've since raised more than $10,000 in an annual charity ride for children at Townsville University Hospital. Hospital foundation CEO Stephanie Naunton said she was touched by the community's generosity in Jennifer's name. "That's an amazing contribution of the community, coming together to turn pain into purpose," Ms Naunton said. "It makes a huge difference to a lot of the children." The annual carnival, charity ride, and a soon-to-be unveiled memorial bench in Jennifer's name keeps her alive, Siana Board said. "When you lose somebody, it can feel like they cease to exist," she said. "Just to talk about her is one of the best gifts that you can give.
SBS Australia
2 days ago
- SBS Australia
Morning News Bulletin 28 June 2025
Listen to Australian and world news, and follow trending topics with SBS News Podcasts . TRANSCRIPT Two men who murdered Indigenous teenager Cassius Turvey receive a life sentence The US brokers a peace deal between Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo Australian teenager Rocco Zikarsky one of four Australians selected in the NBA draft — Two men have been sentenced to life in prison over the killing of Aboriginal schoolboy Cassius Turvey in Western Australia's Supreme Court. The judge said the 15-year-old boy was robbed of his life in a brutal act which can never be made right. Jack Brearley and Brodie Palmer will need to serve at least 22 and 18 years respectively before they're eligible for parole. Cassius' mother Michelle spoke outside court after the sentencing. "The first thing that came to mind when Jack Brearley was sentenced to life was how he said my son had learnt his lesson after he had bashed him in the bush ... Well, he learnt a life lesson now." --- The US Supreme Court has issued a ruling that curbs the ability of lone judges to block the powers of President Donald Trump nationwide. In a 6-3 ruling stemming from the bid to end birthright citizenship in the US, the court says nationwide injunctions by individual district court judges likely exceed their authority. Critics say the decision will embolden Mr Trump's aggressive use of executive orders to further his agenda. Donald Trump, however rejects concerns about the concentration of power in the White House. He says the ruling is a giant win. "So thanks to this decision, we can now promptly file to proceed with these numerous policies, those that have been wrongly enjoined in a nationwide basis, including birthright citizenship, ending sanctuary city funding, suspending refugee resettlement, freezing unnecessary funding, stopping federal taxpayers from paying for transgender surgeries and numerous other priorities of the American people." The Democratic Republic of Congo and Rwanda have signed a peace deal facilitated by the US to help end decades of deadly fighting in the region. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio took part in the signing ceremony in Washington, along with the foreign ministers of the two African nations. The conflict has been described by the UN as "one of the most protracted, complex and serious humanitarian crises on Earth". With roots in the 1994 Rwandan genocide, it has displaced seven million people in the Congo, and escalated earlier this year with M23 rebels seizing major cities in the eastern part of the DRC. DRC Foreign Minister Thérèse Kayikwamba Wagner says the deal offers a rare chance to turn things around with real change on the ground. "With this peace agreement, we open a new chapter, one that calls not only for commitment, but for the courage to see it through. By signing this agreement, we reaffirm a simple truth. Peace is a choice, but also responsibility. To respect international law. To uphold human rights and to protect the sovereignty of states." A senior New South Wales Labor staffer has told an that inquiry Premier Chris Minns characterised the Dural Caravan plot as terrorism during a press conference because of a briefing provided by police. The Premier's Chief of Staff James Cullen is among five government political advisers appearing before the inquiry that is examining what the state government staffers knew about an apparent terrorist plot, which investigators later revealed to be a hoax. The inquiry is examining what the government knew about the caravan plot and when, amid concerns parliament may have been misled before passing controversial hate speech laws. Mr Cullen told the hearing the premier described the event as a terrorist attack because it was the language used by police in a briefing, despite police also alerting the public there were 'alternative lines' of inquiry. "Potential mass casualty event was not a term thrown around lightly at all. That was a very serious thing that was introduced by police in those briefings. I think that there has been a bit of a squashing here after the fact. The potential for that caravan with that explosives and so ignited could have been devastating and that had to be treated seriously." Australian teenager Rocco Zikarsky will start his NBA career at Minnesota, after being recruited with pick No.45 in the draft. Rising talent Zikarsky, who is 2.2 metres tall, was one of four players from the NBL's Next Star program to declare for the draft. The 18-year-old from the Sunshine Coast was overlooked on the first night of the event at Barclays Center in Brooklyn. But Zikarsky was snapped up with the 15th pick of the second round.
