Australian car dealers lose again as court rules in favour of Mercedes-Benz
The Federal Court has dismissed an appeal, filed in 2024, against a judgement it handed down in 2023.
In that ruling, where it found in favour of Mercedes-Benz Australia Pacific over a majority (38 of 50) of its franchised dealers, the Court found dealers hadn't been misled about the agency move and that Mercedes-Benz hadn't engaged in unconscionable conduct.
The Australian Automotive Dealer Association (AADA) said it's 'bitterly disappointed' by today's decision, particularly as it follows the Supreme Court of Victoria's ruling earlier this year which found General Motors didn't breach its agreement with Australian dealers when it axed the Holden brand in 2020.
Hundreds of new car deals are available through CarExpert right now. Get the experts on your side and score a great deal. Browse now.
It's pushing for the Federal Government to introduce additional protections for automotive franchisees 'so that the blueprint created by this court decision is not used by others'.
'We welcome the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court in this matter. Our focus continues to be on delivering luxury products and services for our valued customers around Australia,' said a spokesperson for Mercedes-Benz.
At the heart of the original case, which commenced in October 2021, was the compensation Mercedes-Benz offered to dealers, although Justice Beach indicated Australian franchise law may once again need to be revisited and potentially modified.
'Australian dealers have been fighting to stop Mercedes-Benz using their power over franchised dealers to force them into one-sided business relationships. Today's decision is a significant blow to that fight which will have detrimental effects on Australia's franchising sector,' said AADA CEO James Voortman.
'In handing down today's decision, there is now a clear need to protect Australian franchisees against unfair treatment from franchisors to arbitrarily change business models with no compensation.
'The presiding Judge in the original court decision clearly articulated the need for further amendments to the Franchising Code to protect the investments dealers make in their businesses.
'Today's decision confirms that current laws in Australia do not adequately protect new car dealers against unfair conduct and particularly are not being supported against unfair decisions being made in head office overseas.
'It is imperative that the Federal Government moves at speed to implement the commitments it made in the election to protect franchisees against unfair contract terms and unfair trading practices.'
The move to an agency retail model resulted in Mercedes-Benz taking ownership of dealership stock, and removing the ability for customers and dealership staff to negotiate on prices – a change which dealers claimed would drive up prices of new models.
At the time of the initial court action, the 38 dealers were pursuing approximately $650 million in compensation.
Mercedes-Benz isn't the only auto brand to switch to an agency model in Australia, with Honda also doing the same – also resulting in legal action from some of its dealers.
Like Honda, Mercedes-Benz experienced a sales downturn after the switch in January 2022.
Deliveries of vehicles from its Cars division fell from 28,348 in 2021 to 26,801 in 2022, before dropping again in 2023 to 24,315 and then 19,989 in 2024.
But there's light at the end of the tunnel, it would appear, with deliveries in the first half of 2025 up 15.9 per cent on the same period last year to 11,146 in total – its best first-half of a year since 2023.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
2 hours ago
- West Australian
Workplaces urged to back equality and diversity efforts
Australian workplaces have made considerable progress on gender equality and job quality but experts say some sectors are falling short on senior representation of women and gendered segregation. As humanitarian crises and foreign aid cuts threaten women's organisations amid a global backlash against gender equality, UN Women Australia is calling on leaders to foster inclusive and resilient workplaces. "Global instability is leading to the de-prioritisation of humanitarian causes, including gender equality and diversity, equity and inclusion, as governments and organisations redirect resources to immediate crises," chief executive Simone Clarke told AAP. "Economic pressures are causing cuts to equity-focused roles and programs, while rising job insecurity and political polarisation are undermining inclusive workplace cultures." While there has been progress and efforts to close the gender pay gap and better value work in highly feminised essential sectors, there is room to do more. The gender pay gap sits at 21.8 per cent for total remuneration, but this does not make sense given the high levels of education of women, Australian Centre for Gender Equality and Inclusion at Work director Rae Cooper said. "We have significant care gaps where women do the great majority of unpaid care - we need to focus on ways to boost men's contribution here," she said. "Affordable, accessible and high-quality care is a must if we want to get to a gender equal economy and society, so moving to a model of universal early childhood education is critical." Professor Cooper will speak at a UN Women Australia panel event on leading with resilience. She said Australia was at the top of international league tables, with a highly qualified and educated female workforce, but there was more to do. "To build resilient, inclusive and productive workplaces, Australia must continue its trajectory to foreground gender equality and job quality across the economy," she said. "We are still not there on strong representation of women in senior and strategic roles and gendered segregation, where jobs and whole sectors are dominated by one gender, is still a problem, so careful attention to these matters is critical."
Sky News AU
2 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Anthony Albanese to face mounting pressure from Coalition on when he'll meet Donald Trump in person as federal parliament resumes
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is set to face heavy questioning over his China trip and why he is yet to secure a face-to-face meeting with President Donald Trump. The Labor leader is yet to speak in person with the US commander-in-chief - who was sworn in more than six months ago - amid looming reciprocal tariffs. The Australian's Foreign Editor Greg Sheridan told Sky News a meeting between the two leaders has 'got to occur' and 'the sooner the better'. 'The United States has something like a trillion dollars of cumulative investment in Australia that totally dwarfs anything from China. An investment, in the end, is much more important than trade,' he said to host James Macpherson on Monday night. 'It is up to Albanese in the national interest to manage his relationship with Trump. He's been ill-advised and made bad decisions all the way through.' Mr Albanese on Monday insisted he is available for a meeting and pointed to the range of international forums coming up this year where he could meet President Trump.
Perth Now
2 hours ago
- Perth Now
Workplaces urged to back equality and diversity efforts
Australian workplaces have made considerable progress on gender equality and job quality but experts say some sectors are falling short on senior representation of women and gendered segregation. As humanitarian crises and foreign aid cuts threaten women's organisations amid a global backlash against gender equality, UN Women Australia is calling on leaders to foster inclusive and resilient workplaces. "Global instability is leading to the de-prioritisation of humanitarian causes, including gender equality and diversity, equity and inclusion, as governments and organisations redirect resources to immediate crises," chief executive Simone Clarke told AAP. "Economic pressures are causing cuts to equity-focused roles and programs, while rising job insecurity and political polarisation are undermining inclusive workplace cultures." While there has been progress and efforts to close the gender pay gap and better value work in highly feminised essential sectors, there is room to do more. The gender pay gap sits at 21.8 per cent for total remuneration, but this does not make sense given the high levels of education of women, Australian Centre for Gender Equality and Inclusion at Work director Rae Cooper said. "We have significant care gaps where women do the great majority of unpaid care - we need to focus on ways to boost men's contribution here," she said. "Affordable, accessible and high-quality care is a must if we want to get to a gender equal economy and society, so moving to a model of universal early childhood education is critical." Professor Cooper will speak at a UN Women Australia panel event on leading with resilience. She said Australia was at the top of international league tables, with a highly qualified and educated female workforce, but there was more to do. "To build resilient, inclusive and productive workplaces, Australia must continue its trajectory to foreground gender equality and job quality across the economy," she said. "We are still not there on strong representation of women in senior and strategic roles and gendered segregation, where jobs and whole sectors are dominated by one gender, is still a problem, so careful attention to these matters is critical."
