logo
Doctor who failed to spot girl, 13, was suffering from sepsis and died days later will face no disciplinary sanction

Doctor who failed to spot girl, 13, was suffering from sepsis and died days later will face no disciplinary sanction

Daily Mail​11-06-2025
A senior doctor who failed to spot that a 13-year-old girl was suffering from sepsis before she died will face no disciplinary sanctions for failings in his care.
Professor Richard Thompson did not refer Martha Mills to intensive care at King's College Hospital in London despite her displaying several high-risk indicators of the life-threatening condition.
The on-call consultant also chose not to return to the hospital to assess her in person as her condition deteriorated.
A Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS) panel sitting in Manchester had ruled those omissions were misconduct, which they described as 'particularly grave', and found his fitness to practise was impaired.
But today the tribunal decided there were 'exceptional circumstances' which justified taking no further action against the world-renowned paediatric liver specialist.
Martha had been an inpatient on the hospital's Rays of Sunshine Ward after she suffered a serious injury to her pancreas when she slipped while riding a bike on a family holiday in Wales in July 2021.
Weeks later she experienced a fever and increased heart rate, followed by more spikes in her temperature before the consultant hepatologist saw Martha on his morning ward round on Sunday August 29.
Prof Thompson left the hospital at 3pm, but was phoned at home two hours later by a trainee doctor, who gave an update on Martha's condition.
Medical records showed she had deteriorated over the course of the afternoon, and into the early evening, with a drop in her blood pressure, the appearance of a new rash and increases in heart rate, respiratory rate and body temperature.
Tribunal chairman Robin Ince noted that by 5pm there were 'several high-risk indicators' as set out in the Nice guidelines relating to sepsis.
The duty registrar called Prof Thompson again at 8.30pm because of ongoing concerns over Martha's fever, but she was kept on the ward despite the continued presence of moderate to high-risk indicators and the absence of meaningful clinical improvement.
Martha collapsed on August 30 and was moved to intensive care before she was transferred to London's Great Ormond Street Hospital, where she died in the early hours of August 31.
Announcing its conclusions on Wednesday, Mr Ince said: 'Professor Thompson has done everything possible to address his failings.
'The tribunal considered that the best way to repair any harm caused by his failings would be for him to continue to provide his specialist expertise at home and abroad.
'To now - some four years after the index event - remove Professor Thompson from practice, even for a short period of time, for one single lapse of judgment in an otherwise exemplary career would, in the tribunal's view, be akin to punishment which is not the role of the MPTS.'
Among the 'exceptional circumstances' cited were that there was no allegation or evidence that Prof Thompson either caused or contributed to Martha's death.
There were also systemic failings regarding how the ward functioned at the time with regard to referrals to the paediatric intensive care unit, said the tribunal.
Mr Ince said: 'A sufficiently clear message has already been sent to the profession and to the public - that even such an experienced doctor as Professor Thompson could still make serious errors of clinical judgment for which he will be called to account.
'The public would be aware that this finding would remain a stain on Professor Thompson's reputation for the rest of his life.'
At a 2022 inquest into her death, a coroner ruled that Martha would most likely have survived if doctors had identified the warning signs and transferred her to intensive care earlier.
Martha's mother, Merope Mills, said she and her husband, Paul Laity, raised concerns about Martha's deteriorating health a number of times but these were not acted on.
The couple later successfully campaigned for Martha's Rule to give patients, families and carers the chance to easily request a second opinion from a senior doctor in the same hospital in the event of a suspected deterioration or serious concern.
Giving evidence, Prof Thompson told the MPTS hearing that he no longer provided in-patient care because he began to 'doubt my own judgment' after the tragic events.
He said he felt 'deep remorse' for Martha's death but did not believe he made any errors in her case, as he denied all the allegations brought by the General Medical Council (GMC).
The tribunal heard he had since completed a training course relating to the management of sepsis and a deteriorating child in paediatric care.
His barrister, Ben Rich, said Prof Thompson has been a dedicated doctor and specialist for nearly 40 years and had never previously been investigated by a regulator.
He said he had a reputation as a 'hard-working and outstanding clinician and researcher, who has an international reputation as one of the leading paediatric liver specialists in the world'.
Mr Rich urged the tribunal members to impose an order of conditions involving supervision on Prof Thompson's registration, but the panel disagreed and said such a measure would be 'unnecessary and artificial', as they opted to take no further action.
Christopher Rose, for the GMC, said that Prof Thompson should be suspended to send a message to the wider public and the wider profession, given the seriousness of the failings found.
The tribunal had cleared Prof Thompson of the GMC's claims that he gave 'outdated, misleading' information on Martha's condition to a consultant colleague in the intensive care unit, and that he failed to mention her rash.
In ruling his fitness to practise was impaired, Mr Ince said: 'There had been a significant potential risk of harm to Martha and it was appropriate to send a message to the profession as to the importance of following the basic and fundamental principles as set out in good medical practice so as to ensure that the potential risks of an adverse outcome are always taken into account.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Experts reveal how dehumidifiers work in your home
Experts reveal how dehumidifiers work in your home

The Independent

time20 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Experts reveal how dehumidifiers work in your home

The best dehumidifiers not only defend against damp and mould in your home, but can help dry laundry loads and improve your abode's air quality – tick, tick, tick. They work by drawing excess moisture from the surroundings, which can speed up clothes drying times, oust odors and reduce dust and allergens in the air. A must-have during cold weather when dampness rears its ugly head, dehumidifiers are equally useful during the warmer months, as they help to reduce humidity levels in your home. Along with the best air fryers, dehumidifiers have become a buzzword when it comes to energy efficiency, too. Their cost-buzzing credentials reportedly save you on your household bills. But are they worth the initial investment? If you've been considering taking the plunge, I spoke to a range of experts about everything you need to know when it comes to dehumidifiers, from their health benefits to how they actually work. How do dehumidifiers work 'A compressor dehumidifier is the most common type of dehumidifier used in the UK and uses similar technology to a refrigerator,' explains Chris Michaels, chair and founder of leading company Meaco. 'The dehumidifier draws in air from the room using a fan and this air passes over a cold coil inside the unit, which cools it down and causes the moisture in the air to condense into water droplets.' He adds: 'This water is collected in the dehumidifier's tank, and the drier air is gently reheated and released back into the room.' Dr Rebecca Drummond, associate professor in the Institute of Immunology & Immunotherapy at the University of Birmingham, elaborates, saying: 'Dehumidifiers help remove moisture in the air, which can help your home feel less humid. Lots of moisture in the air can feel uncomfortable, but it also helps fungal spores from mould settle and grow. Dehumidifiers can therefore reduce the risk of mould growing in your home' Katie Lilywhite, air quality expert at AO, adds: 'High humidity levels can make a room feel uncomfortable and sticky. A dehumidifier works by pulling in humid air and extracting moisture from it through a refrigeration process.' The reduced humidity in your home can make the air feel cooler and more comfortable, even if the temperature remains the same. What are their benefits? Above all, Michaels says that dehumidifiers 'help prevent damp, mould and condensation, while improving indoor air quality'. But, according to Lilywhite, one of their most underrated uses is speeding up the drying time of your laundry. 'In colder months, when pegging your washing outside isn't an option, this can be a lifesaver,' she continues. 'Simply put your dehumidifier in the same room where your laundry is drying, near the drying rack or clothesline.' As dehumidifiers work by extracting moisture from the air in your room, they work to significantly reduce drying times. Michaels agrees, adding that they 'offer a low-cost alternative to dry wet washing indoors instead of electricity-guzzling tumble driers'. Dehumidifiers are also ideal for allergy sufferers. 'Many modern dehumidifiers also come with built-in air purifiers, improving indoor air quality by filtering out allergens like dust and pollen,' Lilywhite says. What are the dangers of mould? 'We breathe in mould spores all the time, but our immune system is very effective at destroying them,' Dr Drummond explains. 'In some people with compromised immune systems, mould can grow in the lung and cause a pneumonia-like infection. If not treated properly, mould infections can spread to other parts of the body and become life threatening.' But even people with healthy immune systems can suffer from excessive mould exposure (such as living in a damp home). 'Breathing in too many spores can overwhelm the immune system, and the fungus may produce toxins or other molecules that damage our lungs,' Dr Drummond says. 'Mould should therefore never be ignored, as it could cause a wide range of health issues.' our tried and tested review of dehumidifiers inform you on what model to buy. Duux's bora smart 30l gadget came out on top in our round-up of the best dehumidifiers for 2025. 'It's a high-performance model that's as stylish as it is functional. It might be large, but it features a premium, minimalist design, which is ideal if you're after a dehumidifier that won't ruin your home aesthetic,' our tester said. With a 30l per day extraction rate and a generous 4l water tank, it's perfect for larger rooms or open-plan homes. 'What really sets it apart is its smart functionality. The Duux app is intuitive, responsive, and packed with helpful features,' they added. 'It provides real-time air quality readings and enables you to control everything from fan speed to humidity settings, whether you're on the sofa or away from home.'

The signs of postnatal depression to look out for
The signs of postnatal depression to look out for

The Independent

time20 minutes ago

  • The Independent

The signs of postnatal depression to look out for

Up to 85,000 new mothers in England may have been impacted by postnatal depression last year, according to new analysis by the Royal College of Psychiatrists (RCPsych). The RCPsych warns that untreated postnatal depression, which affected almost 15 per cent of new mothers, can be 'truly devastating' and lead to the 'unnecessary' deaths of women and sometimes their babies. Maternal suicide is highlighted as the leading cause of death in women from six weeks to a year after birth. Symptoms can include persistent feelings of sadness, low mood, a lack of interest, trouble sleeping, and potentially thoughts of harming the baby. The RCPsych urges women and their partners to seek support for these treatable conditions, which can be managed with talking therapies or antidepressants, with medics assuring medication safety during pregnancy or breastfeeding.

NHS Sussex and Surrey Heartlands ICBs to merge in reforms
NHS Sussex and Surrey Heartlands ICBs to merge in reforms

BBC News

time20 minutes ago

  • BBC News

NHS Sussex and Surrey Heartlands ICBs to merge in reforms

Two NHS boards in Sussex and Surrey are preparing to merge as part of a government savings drive, putting hundreds of jobs at risk, a meeting Sussex and NHS Surrey Heartlands – two integrated care boards (ICBs) – are expected to have merged by next April, losing many of the 1,350 staff who currently work at the two changes are part of the latest round of NHS reforms which include the abolition of NHS England and the scrapping of independent watchdog a Brighton and Hove City Council meeting on Tuesday, Stephen Lightfoot, chairman of NHS Sussex, said a "significant number" of the boards' staff will not have a job in the coming year. Mr Lightfoot added: "Over the next three years, when our demand continues to increase, we're going to have to reduce our expenditure."We're going to have to work very hard to make better use of the money that we have."Mr Lightfoot said combining Sussex and Surrey would not affect the overall budget for the two ICBs but was the only safe and reliable way to deliver sustainable said the ICBs had both been told to halve their running costs by bring together NHS organisations, councils and others to plan and commission health services in their area, with the aim of improving health and reducing Minister Keir Starmer announced in March that NHS England will be abolished to "cut bureaucracy" and reform how the NHS is 9,000 administrative roles are being cut at NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care as part of the changes - amounting to roughly half of all roles at the two organisations.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store