Cogta minister Velenkosini Hlabisa leads review of the White Paper on local government
Co-operative governance and traditional affairs minister Velenkosini Hlabisa will on Monday lead deliberations with political parties on the review of the White Paper on local government in Midrand, Johannesburg.
The meeting will also look at local government restructuring before the 2026 local government elections.
TimesLIVE
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
2 days ago
- The Herald
'Time to fire Nkabane': DA MP Khakhau writes to Ramaphosa amid Seta board woes
'Once exposed, and once public pressure mounted, Nkabane made an effective admission of her infringements by withdrawing the appointments. Her ANC cadre deployment had been exposed, roundly criticised and she had to admit defeat.' In the list of the panel members, Nkabane falsely claimed legal expert advocate Terry Motau was part of the it. She later apologised, saying it was a misunderstanding. Khakhau said other members on the list were not independent. 'Some are on the payroll of her department and two are political appointments, including a chief of staff, in the office of the ANC minister.' Presidency spokesperson Vincent Magwenya said Ramaphosa has not yet received the letter from Khakhau. He added MPs do not have the power to demand that Ramaphosa fire Nkabane. 'MPs do not get to direct the president on how to manage and lead the executive,' Magwenya told TimesLIVE. 'The principle of separation of powers of the three independent arms of the state must be respected. 'The president has asked for a report from Nkabane, the matter is being attended to. Therefore there's no need for letters urging the president to act on a matter he is attending to.' TimesLIVE
Mail & Guardian
3 days ago
- Mail & Guardian
Why a review of the White Paper on Local Government matters
Local government are elected to provide services, but many struggle to do this. Photo: Delwyn Verasamy In April 2025, the department of cooperative governance and traditional affairs released a discussion document on the review of the 1998 White Paper on Local Government. The latter was a bold and necessary step in South Africa's democratic journey. Its main aim was to redefine and establish municipalities as development engines capable of delivering basic services and driving social and economic development. Yet, as the past 27 years have shown, its assumptions and prescriptions have not fully aligned with the complex realities facing municipalities and their residents. The persistent failures of local government are not merely technical glitches; they reflect deeper structural, financial and governance challenges. Therefore, a critical review of the White Paper is not just a bureaucratic exercise but a matter of urgent national importance. For millions of people, municipalities determine whether they have water, electricity, decent roads and a healthy and dignified life. They are the foundation upon which inclusive development, social justice and democratic legitimacy rest. A central problem facing local government is the widespread failure to deliver basic services consistently. Many are financially distressed and some argue this distress is rooted in the very assumptions and structural arrangements articulated in the Revenue One key assumption was that municipalities would be able to raise enough revenue to fund the bulk of their operational expenditures. It was anticipated that municipalities would finance 90% of their recurrent costs, including salaries, repairs, maintenance and other daily operating expenses, using their own revenue streams, such as property rates and service charges. In other words, the remaining 10% would be funded by national transfers. This assumption underpinned the funding model for local government. It implied a local government model that is financially self-sufficient and capable of meeting its constitutional developmental mandates. But years of evidence have shown that this model was overly optimistic — if not fundamentally flawed. Municipalities in rural or economically marginalised areas struggle with their revenue collection because ratepayers can't or won't pay. The former is linked to high unemployment and poverty levels, while the latter could be attributed to administrative weaknesses. Apart from the metros, debt collection rate ranges from an average of between Many rely heavily on intergovernmental transfers that are insufficient to cover operational and capital needs. The over-reliance on property rates and service charges has also exposed deep inequalities, with wealthier urban municipalities faring better than rural municipalities that remain trapped in a cycle of underfunding and As such, the anticipated 90% self-funding benchmark is a structural revenue shortfall that remains elusive in many municipalities with cascading effects on service delivery, infrastructure maintenance, and overall governance. The inability to generate adequate revenue has direct consequences for service delivery. Countrywide, people face persistent water shortages, unreliable electricity supply, deteriorating roads, and poor waste management. Problems with governance It is no secret that many municipalities suffer from chronic governance problems, such as the lack of accountability, political instability and infighting, cadre deployment, poor consequence management, and skills shortages. Back in 1998, the White Paper envisaged professional, accountable local administrations; instead, many councils today are beset by instability, political interference and a lack of technical expertise. This undermines both strategic planning and day-to-day operations. The funding model has inadvertently entrenched spatial and economic inequalities. Affluent municipalities with a stronger revenue base can deliver better services and maintain their infrastructure, while poorer municipalities continue to lag further behind. This perpetuates the legacy of apartheid-era spatial planning and undermines the goals of equitable development and developmental local government. For the average person, the failures of local government are not abstract policy issues; they are realities that shape daily lives. In short, the effectiveness of local government is a 'litmus test' for the health of the country's democracy. When municipalities fail, people pay the price, and the consequences are immediate and profound: Dysfunctional municipalities deter investment, hinder local businesses and restrict job creation, thereby exacerbating poverty and inequality. Without reliable municipal services, people are forced to use unsafe water sources and makeshift sanitation, with dire health implications. Power outages, potholes and crumbling infrastructure disrupt livelihoods, hinder economic activity and erode public trust. Poor waste management and inadequate environmental health services expose people to disease and environmental hazards. When local government is seen as corrupt or incompetent, it undermines legitimacy and trust, social cohesion and fuels disillusionment with democracy itself. Differentiated approach It is clear that the White Paper must be comprehensively reviewed and reformed. This moment also creates an opportunity to rethink the local government funding model critically. A re-imagined national policy on developmental local government must take seriously the funding model that is supposed to bring it to life. A differentiated approach is needed, one that recognises the local government history, the diverse capacities and contexts of municipalities. This may require increased and better-targeted national transfers, especially for poorer municipalities, alongside innovative approaches to local revenue generation. Such approaches may typically include a review of the Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations Framework to pursue a truly equitable sharing and allocation of revenue raised nationally. Reforming local government through a revised White Paper must also be part of a broader strategy to address spatial and economic structural inequalities. This must include targeted investment in infrastructure, support for local economic development and measures to expand the municipal rate base over time. But improving municipal governance will require both political will and systemic reforms that seek to professionalise local government and strengthen oversight mechanisms to root out corruption. Appointing skilled, qualified officials — rather than prioritising comradeship or political loyalty — must become the norm. This will go a long way toward strengthening local governance and accountability. As we look to the future, we must learn from the past, confront uncomfortable truths, and forge a new consensus on municipalities' role, funding, and functioning. This will go a long way in ensuring that all municipalities are 'fit for purpose' and capable of addressing the ever-evolving needs for all effectively. Dr Lungelwa Kaywood is a local government specialist and postdoctoral fellow in the Chair in Urban Law and Sustainability Governance at the Faculty of Law at Stellenbosch University.
IOL News
5 days ago
- IOL News
Exploring the call for better salaries for municipal councillors in South Africa
Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta) Minister Velenkosini Hlabisa says the remuneration of councillors was an issue that needed to be looked at in terms of the review of the White paper on local government. Image: Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs / Facebook Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta) Minister Velenkosini Hlabisa has suggested better pay for municipal councillors so they can focus on the jobs they were elected to do and not seek other income sources. He made the comment during a high-level dialogue held yesterday in Midrand, Johannesburg, with political parties as part of the ongoing review of the 1998 White Paper on Local Government. Hlabisa stated that the review aims to revive municipalities and ensure they are run like businesses. He said there is a need to consider better pay for councillors, senior managers, and municipal managers, especially to attract them to work in rural areas as part of the review. Hlabisa noted that many municipalities are in a dire state.'Local government is where policies become services and promises because infrastructure and governance become tangible. Local government must be capacitated and financially resourced. 'The state of our municipalities leaves much to be desired, and we know that the majority of our public holds the opinion that municipalities are not doing well. Year after year, the audit outcomes show that few municipalities receive a clean bill.' He explained that many municipalities face challenges, and the geographical locations and funding models of the municipalities are at the heart of these issues. 'We need to adopt a style where our municipalities are run like businesses. But to do so, we need to make a bold and new approach to structuring, funding, and remuneration of councillors.'If our councillors are paid peanuts, they will spend most of their time on other jobs and only pay lip service to service delivery. The issue of the remuneration of councillors should be a matter that must be engaged.' Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ 'The issue of the municipal manager and section 56 employees is critical. If you want to attract competent engineers, accountants, and municipal managers to deep rural municipalities, the remuneration must compensate those people so they will be eager to go and serve our rural municipalities.'When we review the white paper, these are the issues that we must engage with honestly and come up with recommendations,' the minister said. He also mentioned the importance of engaging traditional leaders to ensure their maximum participation in municipalities to advance democracy in the country. Hlabisa further warned that building local government is now a make-or-break moment. The call for better pay for councillors was met with mixed reviews, with a ratepayers group describing such a move as unwarranted. A councillor in a metro, such as the mayor or chairperson of the committee, could earn close to a million rand a year, while ordinary councillors in smaller municipalities could earn around R200 000 a year. Anthony Waldhausen of the Msunduzi Association of Residents, Ratepayers, and Civics in Pietermaritzburg stated that such a proposal would be unjust. 'We disagree completely, as they are being paid well and with other perks currently.'There should be a review of what councillors are being paid; for example, why ward councillors and PR councillors are paid the same. We don't know what roles and responsibilities the PR councillors have, and they should be paid less than the ward councillors.' A councillor in the Impendle Local Municipality in the KZN Midlands stated, 'Our municipality is very small; it does not have many of the things that generate money for municipalities, like water. So a councillor earns about R23 000 per month, and after deductions that include pension, tax, car allowance, and cell allowance, the councillor is left with about R14 000.' The Democratic Liberal Congress (DLC) leader Patrick Pillay in eThekwini Municipality said salaries were adequate.'Councillors are sufficiently remunerated and take our ratepayers for granted. They cannot be contacted nor are they available to attend to critical issues of the communities they represent.' Councillor Abbas Warasally in the Alfred Duma Local Municipality, however, said better pay could minimise corruption.'I personally believe that by doing so, it will cut down on corruption, and councillors will focus on service delivery as well as the needs of their communities. Presently, some councillors take on a second job to make ends meet, thus leaving communities unassisted. The only full-time councillors are those who are office bearers, whereas the rest are part-time contract workers.' Professor Pundy Pillay from the Wits School of Governance said while better pay for councillors may be a positive move, he questioned where the budget for this would come from. 'It might change the behaviour of councillors. The minister might have a point about the increase, but he should clarify where the money is going to come from.' He added that with the current funding model, money is predominantly spent on the national and provincial governments, leaving very little for local governments. Furthermore, he said while in theory municipalities can generate revenue, this was largely true for metros and not for the smaller, poorer municipalities.
