Salwa Judum case: Legislative workaround and limits of contempt power
The contempt plea claimed that the Chhattisgarh government failed to comply with the 2011 order to stop open backing of vigilante groups like the Salwa Judum, and instead went ahead and armed tribal youths in the fight against Maoists. It said there had been a clear contempt of the SC order when the state government passed the Chhattisgarh Auxiliary Armed Police Force Act, 2011, which legalised arming tribals in the form of Special Police Officers (SPOs) in the war against Maoists.
The petitioners further submitted that instead of disarming SPOs, which was a key constituent of the SC's 2011 order, the Chhattisgarh government legalised the practice of arming them. They also argued that the victims of the Salwa Judum movement had not been adequately compensated.
In the latest ruling of May 15, the Supreme Court said the Chhattisgarh Auxiliary Armed Police Force Act, 2011 does not constitute a contempt of court per se, and that the balance between sovereign functionaries must always be delicately maintained. 'Every State Legislature has plenary powers to pass an enactment and so long as the said enactment has not been declared to be ultra vires the Constitution or, in any way, null and void by a Constitutional Court, the said enactment would have the force of law," the bench said. If any party wants that the legislation be struck down for being unconstitutional, the legal remedies would have to be presented before an appropriate constitutional court, the bench noted.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
Tazias under 9 feet, no loudspeaker at night: Surat Police issues instructions for Muharram processions
The height of Tazias should not exceed 9 feet, Tazia makers should ensure that religious sentiments of other faiths are not harmed, and no loudspeaker should be used from 10 pm to 6am: These are some of the instructions that Surat Police has issued ahead of the upcoming Muharram processions. Tazia processions will be carried out on July 17 in Surat and are expected to see participation by hundreds of people. On Wednesday evening, Surat police commissioner Anupam Singh Gahlaut held a meeting with members of Surat city Tazia committee and Shanti Samiti (peace committee). Apart from top police officials, people from both Muslim and Hindu communities attended the meeting in which an appeal was issued to strictly follow the notification and ensure peaceful conduct of the procession. According to the notification issued by Gahlaut, Tazias should be kept at designated locations and should not be taken out on the roads, except on the day of the procession. The area where Tazias are made and kept should not create any road blockages or traffic issues, it added. Tazias should not be abandoned, it said. On the day of the procession, only those Tazias that have the permit will be allowed to pass through the allotted route, the notification said. A sound limiter should be installed in the sound system, it added. Due to the ongoing work of the Metro rail project on Raj Marg, the route of Tazia procession has been changed. The procession will start from Zampa Bazaar area, reach Lalgate on Raj Marg, take a turn and pass through Shahpore, Muglishara, and finally culminate at Hodi Bungalow. To ensure law and order, police officers will wear body-worn cameras, allowing for continuous monitoring of the procession and identification of those who could disrupt the atmosphere. Besides, the proceedings will be monitored through the CCTV network. Surat city Tazia committee president Arshad Kalyani said, 'This year, we have got requests from 330 Tazia makers. We have given them permit numbers and also prescribed them the routes they have to follow on the procession day. Our volunteers will stand on the roads to ensure the procession passes by peacefully.' Commissioner Gahlaut said, 'We held a meeting with the Tazia committee and Shanti committee leaders and asked them to ensure that the processions go by peacefully. We have acted on Supreme Court guidelines… The height of Tazia has been fixed at 9 feet.'
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Bring back snake worship for Nag Panchami: Forest minister
Mumbai: State forest minister Ganesh Naik said that he would urge the govt to convince the courts to allow the worship of real snakes for Nag Panchami . Naik mentioned that a meeting will be held on July 7-8 with Union minister of environment, forest and climate change, Bhupender Yadav , about this. BJP MLA Satyajit Deshmukh made the demand during a calling attention motion moved by him and raised the issue of serpent worship saying that Jallikattu, a traditional and ancient bull-taming sport practised in Tamil Nadu, was restarted by the Supreme Court. "The use of elephants for ceremonial and religious purposes has also been allowed. Nag Panchami festival in Battis Shirala is a religious tradition with historical significance. The festival has found a place in school textbooks as well," he said. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai Deshmukh demanded that the practice be restarted in the Battis Shirala town of Sangli district, which is part of his constituency. Several other MLAs also backed Naik's demand. The Bombay High Court in 2002 had banned the procession of cobras in the town and was stopped after wildlife conservationists moved the court, saying reptiles were captured and harmed in the process. "I will see how we can get permission to restart the practice as per the rules. The govt will find a way to ensure that the reptiles are not harmed and the religious tradition continues," Naik said. Deshmukh said on Nag Panchami, locals look out for live cobras, worship them, and release back into their natural environment without harming them. BJP MLA Gopichand Padalkar backed the demand and NCP (SP) MLA Jayant Patil said govt reports that record incidents of people dying while handling live snakes during the festival were not true. According to Naik, the festival holds religious meaning for locals.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Maharashtra Assembly members seek revival of live snake worship tradition in Battis Shirala
Members of the Maharashtra Legislative Assembly on Wednesday (July 2, 2025) urged the State government to explore ways to revive the traditional practice of worshipping live snakes during the Nag Panchami festival in Battis Shirala, Sangli district — a ritual halted following a court directive in 2002. Raising the issue through a Calling Attention Motion, BJP MLA Satyajit Deshmukh said that the religious and cultural tradition of serpent worship in Battis Shirala held deep significance for the local community and had even found mention in school textbooks. He drew parallels with the Supreme Court's decision to allow the resumption of Jallikattu — the traditional bull-taming sport in Tamil Nadu — and the continued ceremonial use of elephants in religious rituals. 'Just like those practices were allowed while ensuring the welfare of animals, this tradition too can be revived by adopting safeguards,' Mr. Deshmukh said, rejecting claims that snakes were harmed during the festival. Battis Shirala, located in western Maharashtra, was once renowned for its vibrant Nag Panchami celebrations, where local residents would capture live cobras, worship them, and then release them into their natural habitat. However, the Bombay High Court banned the parading of live snakes in 2002 following concerns raised by wildlife conservation groups. Responding to the motion, Forest Minister Ganesh Naik acknowledged the religious importance of the tradition for the people of Battis Shirala and said the matter would be discussed with Union Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav during meetings scheduled on July 7 and 8. 'We are committed to ensuring that such cultural traditions are preserved without compromising wildlife protection norms. The government will explore options for reviving the practice in a manner that safeguards both heritage and animal welfare,' Mr. Naik said. Supporting the demand, NCP (SP) leader Jayant Patil said that no injuries or fatalities had ever been reported from the handling of snakes during the festival. BJP MLA Gopichand Padalkar also endorsed the appeal, pointing out that the unique ritual attracted foreign tourists and contributed to cultural tourism in the region. Mr. Deshmukh reiterated that the locals have long treated the snakes with reverence, and the ritual involves returning the reptiles unharmed to the wild after worship. 'This is not about spectacle — it is about faith and continuity of tradition,' he said.
