'SC must overturn unconstitutional order'
Justice Khan made this remark on Thursday while leading a 11-member constitutional bench (CB) of the Supreme Court that is hearing review petitions filed against the SC's July, 2024 verdict in the reserved seats case.
On July 12, 2024, a full bench of the apex court through a majority of 8 to 5 resurrected the PTI as a parliamentary party, noting that 39 of the lawmakers who had submitted certificates of their affiliation with the PTI along with their nomination papers were already PTI lawmakers.
The SC ruled that the remaining 41 lawmakers who had not submitted the affiliation certificates at the time of nomination papers' submission could do that now within a period of 15 days. The government had later filed review petitions against the verdict.
During the hearing on Thursday, Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar questioned whether the Constitution mandated that reserved seats must not remain vacant. The counsel for a petitioner Salman Akram Raja responded that the court had already declared that these seats cannot be left unfilled.
Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail asked which fundamental rights had been violated by not allocating reserved seats to the PTI, while Justice Naeem Akhtar Afghan queried whether the court could fill a political vacuum on its own initiative. The court will resume hearing of the case today.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PML-N emerges biggest beneficiary of CB ruling
Listen to article The National Assembly regained its full strength on Wednesday as the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) distributed reserved seats among the parliamentary parties in the house, in line with the decision of the Constitutional Bench (CB) of the Supreme Court last week. In a 7-3 majority ruling in the reserved seats review case, the CB on Friday overturned the Supreme Court's July 12, 2024 judgment, effectively taking away the reserved seats from the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) and handing them to their rival parties in the national and provincial legislatures. The CB restored the March 25, 2024, order of the Peshawar High Court (PHC), which had deprived the Sunni Ittehad Council – the party joined by PTI-backed independents after the Feb 8, 2024 elections – of reserved seats. The decision effectively meant that the PTI was no longer a parliamentary party. Therefore, the 77 reserved seats of the national and provincial assemblies were allocated among the parliamentary parties present in the respective assemblies, since they could not be kept vacant. As expected the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PKL-N) was the major beneficiary. In the light of the CB decision, the ECP distributed 19 reserved seats in the National Assembly, out of which, according to an ECP statement, 13 went to the PML-N, four for the Pakistan Peoples Party Parliamentarians (PPPP) and two to the Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (JUI). After the allocation of the reserved seats, the ruling coalition, comprising PML-N, PPPP, the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) and other parties, surged above the two-thirds majority of 224 in the 336-strong house. Acting on the court's verdict, the ECP issued an order on Wednesday, withdrawing its notifications of July 24 and 29, 2024 that had declared some independent candidates, winning on the general seats of the national and provincial assemblies as PTI lawmakers. In another order, the ECP notified the names of the returned candidates under various categories of the reserved seats with immediate effect. The National Assembly Secretariat later detailed the house composition, reflecting the actual party position after the court verdict and ECP's distribution. The data released by the Secretariat's Legislation Branch showed that the strength of the treasury benches swelled to 235 seats, with 98 of the opposition, in the house currently comprised 333 lawmakerswith one member being suspended and two reserved seats remaining vacant. The ECP also distributed the reserved seats in the provincial assemblies. In the K-P Assembly, 10 seats were given to the JUI-F, seven to the PML-N, six to the PPPP and one each to the PTI-Parliamentarians and Awami National Party (ANP). The PML-N was given 23 seats in the Punjab Assembly – two to the PPPP and one each to the Pakistan Muslim League-Quaid (PML-Q) and the Istehkam-e-Pakistan Party (IPP). In the Sindh Assembly, two seats were given to the PPPP and one to the MQM-P.
Express Tribune
7 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Sindh lifts ban on fishing before time
The Sindh government has prematurely lifted its annual fishing ban at coastal and freshwater bodies, which was originally set to end on August 1. The ban has been lifted from July 1 without any official explanation from the Department of Livestock and Fisheries, which issued the notification. Under the Sindh Fisheries Ordinance 1980, a two-month ban is imposed every year during June and July to allow for the natural breeding cycle of shrimp and fish. The ban plays a vital role in protecting marine life and future fishery stocks. The wildlife and marine experts have expressed serious concerns about the environmental and economic consequences of ending the ban prematurely. According to WWF-Pakistan's Technical Advisor, Muhammad Moazzam Khan, Pakistan's shrimp production has already seen a steep decline from 27,000 tons in 2020 to just 17,400 tons in 2024. He noted that, by international standards, a minimum three-month ban (from May to July) is recommended to ensure full breeding. "Sadly, in Sindh, even the two-month ban was not allowed to mature," he said. Khan warned that while the decision may be justified in the name of supporting fishermen's livelihood, the long-term result will be depletion of marine resources, ultimately harming the same communities. Fisherfolk representative Abdul Majeed Motani also opposed the early lifting of the ban, stating that it was influenced by a powerful political figure in the Sindh government, not by genuine concern for the fishing community. He added that fishing in this season is dangerous due to rough sea conditions, and claimed to have formally raised the issue with the Joint Maritime Information and Coordination Centre, warning them of the risks to both marine life and fishermen. Meanwhile, the Federal Marine Fisheries Department has also expressed alarm over the decision of prematurely ending the ban. Department's Director General, Dr. Mansoor Wassan, stated that lifting the ban early will accelerate the decline of fish and shrimp stocks, adversely affecting the Pakistan's seafood exports. Efforts by The Express Tribune to contact Sindh's Secretary of Livestock and Fisheries, Kazim Jatoi, for an explanation went unanswered. Calls and WhatsApp messages sent to his official number also received no response.
Business Recorder
7 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Rights' violations: PTI finalises post-Ashura protest plan
LAHORE: The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) Punjab has begun finalising its protest strategy in the light of directives issued by PTI's Patron-in-Chief Imran Khan, which is expected to be launched after Ashura 'to resist the ongoing human rights violations in the country and to restore constitutional and legal order'. According to the PTI Punjab, meetings are underway across different regions of the party under the supervision of Chief Organiser Punjab Aliya Hamza. Regional leadership is being consulted, and practical, on-the-ground strategies are being devised. To mobilise party workers, organisational office-bearers at the district, tehsil, and regional levels have been assigned responsibilities. 'In the face of this oppression and injustice, protest is now our only remaining option. The inhumane treatment and cruelty being inflicted upon PTI founder Imran Khan is condemnable and intolerable; detaining a political leader under such severe restrictions and in clear violation of human rights is the worst form of state oppression and political revenge,' it added. According to the party, Khan is kept confined for 22 hours a day in a small, dark cell with no sunlight or fresh air. This is not merely imprisonment, but it is systematic mental and physical torture. As a result of this inhumane treatment, he is rapidly losing weight, and his health is deteriorating. Yet the extent of state oppression is such that he is not even allowed to meet his physician. To make matters worse, Khan has been completely isolated from his family, legal team, and party leadership. This represents a grim image of authoritarianism in Pakistan. 'This treatment of Pakistan's greatest national hero is not only a clear violation of the Constitution of Pakistan and the Pakistan Prison Rules 1978 but also of the United Nations' Nelson Mandela Rules. According to these regulations, every prisoner has an inalienable right to natural light and air, a balanced diet, daily exercise and walking, regular medical checkups, and meetings with family, lawyers, and associates. If a globally renowned leader, a former Prime Minister, and a national hero can be deprived of these basic rights, it raises a painful question for the entire world: is Pakistan truly a democracy or has it become a political torture chamber,' it said. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
