Accidental email calling doctors in NSW ‘a workforce of clinical marshmellows' sparks furore
The email, seen by Guardian Australia, was sent by a medical administration manager at a hospital who appears to be complaining about a doctor's response to a rostering issue.
The misfired message starts: 'Seriously!
'I wonder if any of them realise that they are a doctor and that this is what happens. Oh that's right … I forgot. Life style [sic] before career,' the message continued.
'God help us in the future. We are going to have a workforce of clinical marshmellows!'
The union representing doctors, the Australian Salaried Medical Officers' Federation (Asmof), called the message 'tone-deaf' and 'unacceptable', particularly 'when NSW is facing a healthcare workforce crisis'.
A spokesperson for the relevant local health district said: 'Junior medical officers (JMOs) work hard and are a vital part of our health service, and we sincerely apologise for the hurt and frustration caused by a recent email that was circulated.
'We are committed to fostering a workplace where junior medical officers feel valued and respected. The email did not reflect this commitment or our values, and we have written to the relevant JMOs to apologise. The matter is being addressed appropriately,' they said.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
The email has sparked furore and memes on online doctor forums.
JMOs include interns who have just completed their university medical training and are in their first year of being practising doctors, and residents who have completed internships and hold a general registration.
On a Reddit forum for junior doctors, one commenter shared a joke job advertisement for the position of 'clinical marshmallow', drawing several comments that it was 'unfortunately a very common attitude amongst HR/admin towards JMOs'.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The Asmof executive director, Andrew Holland, said the email was 'not only offensive but reveals a deep disconnect between hospital administration and frontline staff who are working under immense pressure'.
'They deserve respect and support, not ridicule from those who should be advocating for them,' Holland said in a statement.
'At a time when NSW is facing a healthcare workforce crisis, these comments are not just tone-deaf – they are damaging, demoralising, and unacceptable.
'Junior doctors enter this profession to care for people, but they cannot do their jobs if they are belittled and dismissed by their own employers.'
In April, NSW Health settled a class action brought by junior doctors for almost $230m, claiming to have been underpaid in relation to issues such as overtime and meal breaks. Experts hoped the suit would change a culture where junior doctors do not complain and instead can protect time off for their personal lives.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
What is vitamin B6 toxicity and what are the symptoms of taking too much?
In January Guardian Australia told the story of Simon Bogemann who developed a nerve condition known as peripheral neuropathy after consuming excessive vitamin B6 from multivitamin and magnesium supplements. Since then, the potential of these over-the-counter supplements to cause harm has attracted increasing attention. An interim decision from the Therapeutic Goods Administration proposes changes that could see products containing more than 50mg of vitamin B6 become pharmacist-only medicines. A potential class action against Blackmores is also being considered for excessive B6 levels in the company's vitamin supplements. As the regulator considers further action, here's what you need to know about vitamin B6. Vitamin B6 toxicity occurs when people consume excessive amounts of B6-containing supplements and have levels in their blood higher than what the body needs. Dr Terri-Lynne South, a GP, dietician and spokesperson for the Royal College of General Practitioners, says: 'Back in the day, B6 was what we would call a water-soluble vitamin, and the wisdom was you can't overdose on water-soluble vitamins … But we found, certainly with B6, that's not the case, that it is stored in the body.' Higher than normal amounts of B6 stored in the blood can have damaging effects, South says, 'particularly to some of our peripheral nerves – nerves in the extremities'. It can cause dysfunction, including pain, pins and needles, loss of sensation and loss of motor function in extreme cases. Vitamin B6 is found naturally in many foods including fish, non-citrus fruits and starchy vegetables. High intake of B6 from natural sources have not been reported to cause adverse effects. Sign up: AU Breaking News email B6 is also found in many supplements, including magnesium, multivitamins, zinc, and B-complex formulas, as well as fortified foods, including energy drinks, breakfast cereals and weight loss shakes. B6 toxicity occurs when people consume excessive amounts of B6 from these non-natural sources. People only need about 1mg of B6, so it can be very easy to consume too much, South says. 'Part of the problem is that B6 is known by different names [including] pyridoxine, pyridoxal, and so it can be difficult for people to actually know how much B6 they're getting from all sources.' People should be mindful if they are taking vitamin or mineral supplements, or using products with B6 such as energy drinks. The symptoms of B6 toxicity which lead to peripheral neuropathy are not very specific, meaning they could have many causes, South says. If people have pins and needles in the hands and feet, or a burning sensation, numbness or difficulty with balance or walking, 'I wouldn't necessarily jump to say that it's B6 toxicity.' Be aware of the many sources B6 is found in, as well as its numerous names including pyridoxine, pyridoxal or pyridoxamine, South says. 'Work out how much you might be having a day,' South says. If it's greater than 50mg, South recommends talking to a GP or pharmacist about your consumption. Even if people don't have symptoms, they should not be taking more than 50mg a day, she says. There is still some conjecture about whether amounts even lower than 50mg can cause toxicity. 'It is very individual at what point in time someone who's having excessive sources of B6 may get symptoms of toxicity,' South says. If people do experience symptoms, a blood test could help work out whether it is B6 toxicity or something else, she says.
The Guardian
6 days ago
- The Guardian
Australian employers view their older workforce with contempt. They need to understand 70s are the new 50s
Hey recruiters, get with the program: 70s are the new 50s. Australians, just like in wealthy societies all around the world, are living and staying healthier for longer. You'd think this would be great news, but no. We are told that an ageing population is an albatross around the neck of our economy and a curse on our budget. It doesn't have to be this way but it will require smart policymaking to make the most of a willing and able older workforce. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email It will also require employers not to be such bloody dills. This week, a survey by the Australian HR Institute and the Australian Human Rights Commission found that nearly one-quarter of employers classify over-50s as 'old'. To see just how ridiculous this is, consider that somebody who works for 45 years and retires at age 67 will have been considered 'old' for 17 years. That's nearly 40% of their working lives! Like all opinions rooted in discrimination, all this defies reason. A new article from the International Monetary Fund shows just how out of date these views are. The IMF has looked at data across 41 countries and found that a person who was 70 years old in 2022 had the same cognitive health scores as a 53-year-old at the turn of the century. Unsurprisingly, this spectacular improvement in mental acuity went hand-in-hand with people staying in better physical shape into their 60s, 70s and beyond. 'Better health means better labour market outcomes,' the IMF economists Bertrand Gruss and Diaa Noureldin noted. Gruss and Noureldin show that enlightened policies – such as a focus on ongoing training and more incentives to keep people in the workforce longer – can offset three-quarters of the expected drag from ageing on the world economy over the coming decades. 'Over a decade, the cumulative improvement in cognitive capacities experienced by someone aged 50 or over is associated with an increase of about 20 percentage points in the likelihood of remaining in the labour force,' they write. 'It's also associated with an additional six hours worked per week and a 30% increase in earnings. All this could mitigate ageing's drag on growth.' Treasury's intergenerational reports have increasingly focused the minds of Australians on the budget implications of an ageing population. As useful as these reports have been to inform the current debate around taxation reform, they may also have fed a narrative of drooling oldies who need to be propped through their autumn years by vibrant and athletic under-50s. If the IMF is right, that trite adage that 'demography is destiny' is, to a large degree, wrong. As ever, our destiny is what we make of it.
Daily Mirror
19-07-2025
- Daily Mirror
Woman left in agony by rare condition that stops her being able to burp
Lucy Hodson a singer from Hertfordshire, says the rare condition left her with painful bloating and sounding like she had a "frog trapped in her throat" - but has hailed Botox for changing her life A woman says she's left in constant pain from a rare condition that prevents her being able to burp. Singer Lucy Hodson, 27, has hailed a £900 botox injection for changing her life after spending years suffering pain and humiliation from the ailment, which left her sounding life she had a "frog trapped in her throat". Lucy - who performs under the name Lumarie - says the condition would cause painful bloating, a sensation of bubbling in her chest, and leave her making " weird" noises. They were so embarassing she would avoid attending meditation classes. "It sounded like there was a little frog sitting in your throat trying to get out but it's trapped in there," Lucy, from Hertfordshire, said. The condition even stopped her from enjoying food and drink – and eventually began to impact her singing career, reports the Manchester Evening News. "I got a lot of bubbling sensations in my chest and throat that would make me feel sick and stop me from being able to sing properly," she added. "It was so bad that it was all I could focus on because it was just so intense." For years, Lucy said she had no idea what was wrong and believed it was simply a "quirk" that set her apart from school friends. However, she eventually began to experience difficulties with her voice that led her to see a doctor. After waiting more than a year for an NHS appointment with an Ears, Nose and Throat (ENT) specialist, she was "frustrated" to only be told she was suffering with acid reflux – but says that diagnosis "didn't make sense". Instead, she turned to the internet, where she finally discovered retrograde cricopharyngeal dysfunction (R-CPD), a condition only formally recognised in 2019. Known as "no burp syndrome", it occurs when the upper oesophageal sphincter fails to relax, stopping trapped air from escaping. Online support groups, including a 37,000-strong Reddit community within the r/noburp subreddit, helped Lucy realise she wasn't alone. "That Reddit page has been a real game changer because there's just loads of people with it," Lucy said. "Once I knew it had a name everything started making sense." That's when Lucy discovered there was a treatment – a high-dose Botox injection into the cricopharyngeal muscle that allows the muscle to relax and the burp reflex to return. She added: "It started to get to the point where I couldn't do a gig without an 'air vomit'. It was really horrible knowing that something you love is paired with something that feels really wrong. "The treatment was definitely a difficult decision because I was really worried about the effect on my voice and the impact on me financially and mentally from not being able to sing. "But I just thought even if the Botox does mess with my voice it's better than this, because this is just terrible." Lucy paid just under £900 for a same-day consultation and procedure at Shirley Oaks Hospital in London, where she says the Botox injection into her throat "didn't hurt that much". The results were instant. "I had my first burp the next morning which was pretty amazing," she said. "It just took me by surprise when I was yawning and it came out." Within days, she was enjoying fizzy drinks, burgers and nights out without pain or embarrassment. While Lucy is cautious about how long the effects will last, she says the transformation has been "life-changing". She said: "I just felt great. That was pretty life-changing and emotional in itself to enjoy life and indulge and not be in horrible pain all night and not be able to sleep." Since the procedure, Lucy says she has noticed some side effects, including a "slow swallow" sensation and an "awful" incident where she choked on water due to a laryngeal spasm, which she says her doctor had warned her about. Lucy says the treatment has slightly weakened her voice, which has so far led her to cancel one gig. However, she hopes that she will return to performing "better than ever" in a few weeks – free from pain and with a new-found ability to burp.
