Colaba residents move HC against controversial jetty and terminal project
The residents have objected to the scale of the proposed project, calling it excessive, and have specifically contested the MCZMA's approval of March 2, 2023, which treated the project as a 'standalone jetty'. The petition states that the Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) notification permits only consideration of 'standalone jetties'—a category that this large multi-functional structure does not fall under.
The petition also contests the heritage NOC of February 7, 2025, granted by the municipal architect despite the fact that the project site lies within the buffer/vista zone of the Gateway of India, a Grade I listed heritage monument, and the Fort precinct. It also submits that access to the terminal reportedly involves the removal of a section of the Gateway promenade/sea wall, an area where even minor facade changes to private buildings are currently restricted. It states that the MHCC has nonetheless approved the project, which threatens to dwarf and visually disrupt the iconic Gateway structure.
CHRCA has thus sought a review of the decision to build the jetty and terminal from the P J Ramchandani Marg footpath area into the sea, and urged the court to restrain MMB from demolishing the promenade wall, and proceeding with construction. It argues that the project threatens the character of the Gateway precinct and will obstruct pedestrian access along the popular seafront promenade.
The citizens' group has also contested the traffic NOC issued by the Mumbai police on February 28, 2025. Its contention is that despite ongoing and severe congestion in the area, the Mumbai traffic police granted an NOC, considering only the construction phase and not the operational impact of the terminal and jetty. It also states in the petition that there was no public notice, hearing, or opportunity for objections afforded to the local residents at any stage of the approval process.
Following the bhoomi poojan in March 2025, the state's minister for ports development publicly stated that the jetty would be used exclusively for VIPs, celebrities and cricketers' yachts, further reinforcing the project's exclusionary and non-public nature, says the petition. It submits that the proposed passenger jetty and terminal facilities, covering nearly 15 acres of sea area, with a jetty extending over half a kilometre into the sea and directly abutting a protected heritage site, is illegal, arbitrary, irrational, and destructive to the character and heritage of the Gateway of India precinct.
CHCRA's advocate Prerak Choudhary told HT, 'We tried our best to have a dialogue with them but despite giving us assurances, they proceeded with the project and left us with no option but to move court.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Coastal villages of Vasai fear sea-water flooding; anti-erosion embankments stuck in red-tape
VASAI: Coastal villages like Bhuigaon, Arnala, Navapur, Rangaon and others are running from pillar to post just to make sure that the approved anti-erosion embankments are built up at the earliest. The coastline has suffered extensive damage , intensity of which increases during the monsoon as the water currents are more stronger. This has threatened the existence of citizens' homes, suru (Casuarina) plantations, resources of potable water and farmlands. As per the GR Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation MSRDC is supposed to construct the anti-erosion embankments but they say that they are yet to receive approvals from various government agencies. Work on a proposed coastal anti-erosion embankment at BhuiGaon Seashore, Vasai (West) is planned to be undertaken. However, the necessary CRZ (Coastal Regulation Zone) clearance for this project is yet to be obtained, said Joy Joseph Fargose, Secretary, Aam Aadmi Party, Vasai. This project is critically important for ensuring the safety of residents in the Vasai Taluka region, as the coastline and nearby villages suffer significant damage due to recurring sea surges. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Invertir en Cervecería Nacional CFD podría proporcionarte un ingreso adicional Empieza a invertir hoy Registro Undo Therefore, it is essential that the construction of the anti-erosion embankment is initiated without delay, he added. He is of the opinion that all the concerned departments should come together to solve this grave issue. Letter sent to Joy by the MSRDC on July 1 states that the CRZ permission was pending and hence the contractor wasn't given any go-ahead for the construction work. The Suruchi Baug, suru (Casuarina) plantations, has suffered major blow as several trees could be seen uprooted since they form the first line of defence. These uprooted trees either rot on the beach, or are seen as harming the tourists or are washed away in the ocean with the reverse water flow of the waves and end up harming the ocean ecology.
New Indian Express
3 days ago
- New Indian Express
Iconic swimming camels face extinction threat as illegal salt pans ravage mangrove forests in Gujarat's Kutch
AHMEDABAD: The Kharai camel—a rare, sea-swimming marvel of Gujarat's Kutch's coast is fighting for survival as rampant deforestation of mangrove forests for illegal salt production continues unabated despite court orders and environmental laws. In the shimmering salt-swept coastlines of Kachchh in Gujarat, the Kharai camel has long been a symbol of harmony between ecology and culture. Known for its rare ability to swim through the sea to graze on mangroves, this nationally recognized breed is now facing extinction, caught in a deadly struggle between profit and preservation. At the heart of this crisis is the systematic destruction of Cheriya (mangrove) forests—vital feeding grounds for Kharai camels cleared illegally to make way for expanding salt pans. From Bhachau to Vondh, the mangroves have been vanishing at an alarming pace, threatening not just the camels but entire ecosystems. 'Our camels are dying. The Kharai camels that graze on the mangrove trees have been wiped out. The government talks about protection, but we are still waiting,' said Bhikhabhai Rabari, former president of the Kutch Camel Breeders' Association. 'This is not just about camels or trees—it's about survival. We've demanded cancellation of salt leases, a plan to revive the mangrove forests, and a joint monitoring committee.' Despite two clear orders from the National Green Tribunal (NGT) in 2019 and 2020—mandating restoration and a complete halt to salt works in CRZ-I protected areas, violations not only continue, they have intensified. Bulldozers, fire, and illegal embankments have wiped out vast stretches of mangroves, disrupting tidal flow and killing marine life. The numbers tell a chilling story. Between 2018 and 2023, mangrove cover shrank from 4,084 hectares to just 1,312 hectares. In the same period, salt production zones ballooned from 13,681 to 17,918 hectares—many encroaching deep into CRZ-I areas, where activity is strictly prohibited under the Coastal Regulation Zone Notification, 2011. 'Heavy machinery has been used to uproot mangrove trees and destroy marine habitats. Crabs, eelgrass, and other underwater species have vanished. In total, 14 salt factories have been found operating illegally in clear violation of the NGT, Environment Protection Act, and CRZ laws,' said Dr. Yashesh Shah, Marine researcher.
Time of India
5 days ago
- Time of India
Fishermen protest real estate project near Chirala beach
1 2 3 Vijayawada: Plans to develop a private real estate venture along the coast near Chirala have sparked a major controversy, with local fishermen strongly opposing the closure of the sea mouth. The agitated fishing community has threatened large-scale protests if the developers do not withdraw. The fishermen allege that the real estate firm pressurised officials to obtain land documents in violation of Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) norms. The Lok Ayukta has also directed the district collector and the chairman of district-level CRZ committee to investigate the allegations and safeguard the coastline. Fishermen from Vijayalakshmipuram, Adavipallepalem, Danavayipeta, Kripanagaram, Tsunami colony, Ramapuram, Vadarevu, Chinna Barapa, Pedda Barapa, and Ramachandrapuram depend entirely on fishing for their livelihoods. Around 12,000 people from these 10 villages rely on the sea mouth (or C-mouth) for decades, operating approximately 1,500 boats from the natural jetty formed near the Eepurupalem straight cut. During heavy rains, agricultural run-off from upstream flows through the Eepurupalem straight cut, passing through Adavi Pallepalem and curving at the coast before merging into the sea. This naturally formed sea mouth spans over a kilometre. Last week, fishermen were shocked to find the sea mouth and adjacent sand dunes destroyed. They have accused a Guntur-based real estate firm of causing the damage in blatant violation of CRZ rules. The firm allegedly started construction of a resort by laying roads and obstructing the natural water flow with boulders, narrowing the sea mouth. "They have obstructed natural flow of water with large boulders, reducing the nearly a kilometre-wide sea mouth to just four metres by filling up the area. The district level committee under the Andhra Pradesh Coastal Zone Management Authority (APCZMA) has remained silent," alleged social activist Nagarjuna Reddy. In a petition, he alleged that the developers used heavy machinery and hundreds of tractors to flatten sand dunes over a kilometre, fill aqua ponds on patta land to encroach upon the coastline. District collector JV Murali said the administration would verify the records and act based on facts.
