Man who claimed his shoulder was broken when beaten by gardaí settles High Court action
A case taken by a man who claimed he was beaten by gardaí in riot gear on Halloween night while he was cycling to investigate a fire near his partner's home has been settled at the High Court.
This week, a jury was sworn in for the case of plaintiff Gerard McCarthy, who alleged that gardaí broke his shoulder on Halloween night almost 17 years ago.
Advertisement
Mr McCarthy (55) from Abbotstown Avenue in Finglas, Dublin 11, sued the commissioner of An Garda Síochána, the Minister for Justice, Ireland and the Attorney General, claiming that he was falsely imprisoned and assaulted by gardaí on Halloween, October 31st and November 1st 2008.
Mr Justice Alexander Owens was told on Thursday by James McGowan SC, for Mr McCarthy, that the case had been settled, which was confirmed by Richard Lyons SC, for the defendants.
Mr McCarthy was 38 at the time of the alleged assault and submitted to the court he was with his partner in her home on Findlater Street, near O'Devaney Gardens, in north inner city Dublin, on the night.
Findlater Street backs on to what used to be the O'Devaney Gardens flat complex.
Advertisement
Mr McCarthy submitted that on October 31st 2008, two separate fires broke out on the other side of his partner's back wall at the apartment complex.
He claimed that the first fire happened at around midday while the second fire began after dark in a large steel container close to the back of the Findlater premises.
He submitted to the court that he became concerned after smoke had billowed into the apartment through a rear extension.
Mr McCarthy claimed he cycled out to investigate and noticed gardaí in plain clothes nearby before he separately encountered gardaí in riot gear at the edge of O'Devaney Gardens. He said they charged him as he tried to turn his bicycle away.
Advertisement
The plaintiff claimed he heard the words "charge" from the riot gardaí, who numbered between 10 and 12. He said he was struck on both shoulders, his back and then legs while still on his bike in an attack that took between five and ten seconds.
After the alleged assault, Mr McCarthy attended the Mater Hospital that night but was anxious and dizzy and returned in the morning to have an X-Ray.
Mr McCarthy claimed that his X-Ray revealed a broken shoulder close to the collar bone. He said he was numb "all over" with the pain and still in "shock".
Mr Justice Owens struck out the case, which was expected to last up to four days, with no trial costs awarded and no costs to be imposed on the plaintiff.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
5 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Motorcyclist (20s) and driver (70s) hospitalised after Cork collision
Two men, aged in their 20s and 70s, were hospitalised following a collision between a car and a motorcycle near Clonakilty, Co Cork, on Sunday. The collision occurred on the N71 at Grillagh, north of Clonakilty, shortly after 4.30pm on Sunday. Advertisement The motorcyclist, a man in his 20s, was treated at the scene and taken by ambulance to Cork University Hospital. The driver of the car, a man in his 70s, was also transported to hospital for assessment. The road remains closed to traffic to allow for a technical examination by Garda forensic collision investigators, with local diversions currently in place. Gardaí are appealing to anyone who may have witnessed the incident to come forward. Road users who were travelling on this stretch of the N71 around the time of the collision and who may have camera footage (including dash-cam) are asked to make it available to investigating gardaí. Anyone with information is asked to contact Clonakilty Garda Station on 023 882 1570, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111, or any Garda station.
BBC News
7 hours ago
- BBC News
Police hunt teen after girl, 15, raped near Chertsey library
Police are searching for a teenage boy after a 15-year-old girl reported she had been raped close to a library in attack happened at about 19:00 BST on Friday, in the area around Chertsey library, Surrey Police girl was with a friend when they were approached by two males, one of whom allegedly assaulted suspect has been described as in his teens, with blonde slicked back hair, wearing a light coloured jumper, blue jeans and white trainers. Det Sgt Mihai Kerekes said: "Incidents of this nature are extremely concerning."We want to reassure the public that a full investigation is underway to identify the person involved."Anyone with information is urged to contact the force.
The Sun
8 hours ago
- The Sun
Rogue builder who charged £100k for kitchen refurbs and ripped out homes before fleeing to go on hols is jailed
A ROGUE builder who charged £100,000 for refurbishments and ripped out homes before fleeing on holiday has been locked up. Jamie Brown ripped off 19 families and fled with their money after wrecking their houses in the spring and summer of 2023. 4 The 56-year-old even ripped out the kitchen of a couple who were weeks away from having a baby and ran away without refitting it. Brown, who lived in Bristol, boasted about having over 25 years of experience carrying out "quality, fully guaranteed kitchen installations in and around the South West and Wales". The dad went on holidays and his wife posted glam pics of their adventures after he left the lives of other families in tatters. Brown was sentenced at Bristol Crown Court for 19 counts of theft. Charges were also brought against his wife Nina, who was listed as a company director at the time, but the case against her was formally discontinued in court last week. Brown was sentenced to 18 months in prison, BristolLive reported. The court heard he "lied and lied consistently" in his schemes. The cowboy builder would warn prospective customers that they needed to agree to the job and pay upfront swiftly, or prices would go up. Once they paid him and he ripped out their kitchen, he would disappear and provide a myriad of excuses. He later claimed he had a "mental breakdown" and his company had gone into liquidation, telling the distraught families they would not be receiving any money back or any new kitchens. The court heard that many had "wiped out" their savings and taken out massive loans to pay the dodgy builder - but were left with their kitchens in ruins. One victim told the court how they discovered Brown was splashing out on holidays while their lives were in tatters. They said: "What made it worse was that he continued to go on all these lovely holidays. "His wife would post pictures of them going on holidays, one after another, all the time. I stopped looking because she blocked me on Facebook, but friends would send me screenshots. "I was left thinking 'these are holidays we should be going on, not him'." The court heard that victims were left without running water and without anyway of cooking. "We didn't have running water, no way of cooking, no washing machine. We rigged up a temporary thing in the garage, but he left it and that went on for ten weeks, with different excuses. "In the end I rang Howdens and they said they could deliver the kitchen, but it would have to be paid for. That's when I realised for sure what was going on, it was devastating." There was some dispute in court about the total amount of money that he had stolen. The prosecution opened their case and put the amount at £101,602.91, but Brown's defence counsel David Sapiecha said the true figure was £84,817. The court was told that the couple are in the process of selling their home and the proceeds would be used to pay back every penny to people who had lost money. 4 4
