logo
Sanjaya Baru writes: After Op Sindoor, lessons from Manmohan and Vajpayee governments on communication

Sanjaya Baru writes: After Op Sindoor, lessons from Manmohan and Vajpayee governments on communication

Several experts and analysts have commented on poor, even faulty, messaging in the conduct of Operation Sindoor — before, during and after the operation. What were the faults? Before the operation began, it was not made clear that India would only target terrorist camps across the border and the Line of Control (LoC). While this was the stated objective of the government, there was no such clarity in the media on the nature of the Indian response to the Pahalgam attack. This raised expectations within India on what the Indian Armed Forces would do and subsequently contributed to disappointment at home. Bombastic claims by senior ruling party leaders about occupying Pakistan-occupied Kashmir did not help.
Second, during the conflict, there was no communication within India and to the international community as to what was actually happening and what India's objectives were. Third, after the conflict ended, there was confusion on (a) the reasons for the ceasefire; (b) terms of the ceasefire and; (c) the nature of future red lines. Prime Minister Narendra Modi's statement that Operation Sindoor has not ended and is merely on hold has raised more questions than provide answers.
Statements made overseas by the Chief of Defence Staff and by an Indian defence attache on the political guidelines within which the armed forces operated have added to this problem of mixed messaging. All this gives the impression that the military and civil leadership are not on the same page in their messaging on Operation Sindoor. Against this background, several analysts have drawn attention to the need for better 'strategic communication'.
The funny thing is that the subject of 'strategic communication' has been discussed time and again within and outside the government and certainly within the national security establishment. Yet, it seems few lessons have been learnt from past experience. I have myself lectured on this subject, based on the experience during the Kargil War, more than once at the National Defence College. It is instructive to recall what had happened at that time.
After hostilities began in the Kargil region, an army spokesperson was providing regular briefings to the media. The Kargil War was the first conflict in South Asia during which private Indian television wished to travel to the battle zones and cover events live. They were inspired by the example set by CNN during the first Gulf War in 1990. The then convenor of the National Security Advisory Board (NSAB), the late K Subrahmanyam, felt that better and more professional media management was needed. It may be recalled that Subrahmanyam, the guru of strategic policy analysts, had spent the 1990s in newspaper offices, first at the Business and Political Observer and later at The Times of India, and had a good grasp of how the media thinks and acts.
At his instance, the NSAB constituted a media advisory sub-committee chaired by Subrahmanyam and including N N Vohra (a former defence secretary), J N Dixit (a former foreign secretary and later the National Security Advisor), Major General Afsar Karim and myself (I was then Editor, The Financial Express). Our first recommendation to the then National Security Advisor Brajesh Mishra was that rather than an army officer, a diplomat adept at such communication should do media briefings on a daily basis. The then joint secretary in the Ministry of External Affairs in-charge of external publicity, the late Raminder Singh Jassal, was tasked to conduct the daily briefings.
Raminder was a talented and skilled diplomat, with good media handling skills and a sound understanding of India's strategic aims and objectives.
The NSAB media sub-committee would meet every day at 11 am in the room of the then-deputy NSA Satish Chandra. The minutes of our meeting would be communicated to the NSA who would then brief Jassal. The daily media briefings played an important role in shaping both domestic understanding and expectations from the conflict and global appreciation of India's strategy and tactics. Global opinion turned decisively in India's favour with the United States supporting the Indian view on Kashmir for the very first time. President Bill Clinton endorsed the idea implicit to the Simla Agreement that the LoC would be the de facto boundary between India and Pakistan.
It was on the basis of the conduct and outcome of the Kargil War that its main architect, General Pervez Musharraf, began to engage India. Regrettably, though, the Musharraf visit to India and his meeting with Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee at Agra in July 2001 proved a failure and the progress expected did not materialise. It was then left to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to take the baton forward.
In September 2004, when Prime Minister Singh decided to engage President Musharraf, he was advised by most of his senior officials not to undertake such a risky exercise so early in his term in office. He not only began a conversation but invited President Musharraf to Delhi in April 2005. Once again, the national security and diplomatic establishment was concerned about the political fallout of the meeting. In Agra, the Indian media was seen as being better briefed by the Pakistan delegation than by the Indian side. It was felt Musharraf had been let off too easily with senior editors being charmed by the general.
Prime Minister Singh tasked me to develop a media strategy for the Musharraf visit. With the support of senior officials in the Prime Minister's Office, I conducted several closed-door media briefings to different groups of journalists and analysts. This helped shape expectations of the visit and the visit went off without any embarrassment for the country or the PM.
There would be other such past episodes that others involved in media management would know. There are some very competent officers in the Indian Information Service as well as in the defence establishment. If media messaging is handled professionally, the country would be better served. It is the over-the-top, highly dramatised, purely ideological and sensational reporting by several media establishments during Operation Sindoor that has damaged Indian reputation and credibility.
As many around the world have commented, pro-Modi media outfits have done more harm than good for India's image and case vis-a-vis Operation Sindoor. Responsible and professional coverage, including putting out authentic information in time would have served the national interest better. What has further weakened the Indian case is the fact that the media that did the greatest damage to the country's reputation is viewed as being pro-government. Credible strategic communication requires a credible medium.
The writer was member, National Security Advisory Board of India, 1999-2001 and media advisor to the Prime Minister of India, 2004-08
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

India targets $300 bn bioeconomy by 2030
India targets $300 bn bioeconomy by 2030

Hans India

time8 minutes ago

  • Hans India

India targets $300 bn bioeconomy by 2030

New Delhi: The government is committed to realising a $300 billion bioeconomy by 2030, reiterated Union Minister of Science and Technology, Dr. Jitendra Singh on World Bioproduct Day on Monday. Calling for a wider public understanding and inclusive participation in India's biotechnology mission, Singh stated that every Indian was a stakeholder in the country's bioeconomy. The biotechnology ecosystem in the country 'has grown from just around 50 startups a decade ago to nearly 11,000 today -- a leap made possible by policy backing and institutional partnerships,' said Singh, while speaking at an event, organised by the Department of Biotechnology (DBT) and its agencies BIRAC and iBRIC+. Referring to the recently launched BioE3 Policy, Singh noted that it laid the groundwork for India to lead in sustainable biomanufacturing by aligning bioeconomy goals with environmental sustainability, economic growth, and equity. The BioE3 (Biotechnology for Economy, Environment and Employment) Policy aims to position India as a global leader in bio-based innovations. 'Bioproducts aren't limited to laboratories anymore. They're about livelihoods -- from biodegradable packaging to eco-friendly personal care, from rural employment to green jobs,' he said. He emphasised that the future industrial revolution will be driven by bioeconomy, and India, he believes, has taken the lead. Further, acknowledging the challenges faced by young scholars in biotech, the Minister pointed out the mismatch between parental expectations and individual aptitude in career choices. He termed the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 a 'game-changer' that would allow students to pursue disciplines of interest with flexibility. 'We are seeing a new generation with real aptitude and capacity to learn,' he said. Singh also urged for stronger social media outreach, using success stories, local languages, and relatable formats to communicate biotech's relevance to common citizens. 'If we want to attract young talent, we must link biotechnology to profitability and livelihood, not just academics,' he said. Meanwhile, Secretary, DBT and Chairman of BIRAC, Dr. Rajesh S. Gokhale outlined steps being taken to operationalise the BioE3 Policy in the country. These include 'support for pilot manufacturing, region-specific innovation missions, and strengthening the pipeline from research to market,' Gokhale said.

Delhi BJP to stage play on life of Syama Prasad Mookerjee today
Delhi BJP to stage play on life of Syama Prasad Mookerjee today

Hans India

time8 minutes ago

  • Hans India

Delhi BJP to stage play on life of Syama Prasad Mookerjee today

New Delhi: Bharatiya Janata Party Delhi unit President Virendra Sachdeva announced his party's plans to spread the ideals of Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee, the founder of Bharatiya Jana Sangh -- a forerunner of the BJP -- through a theatrical performance on Tuesday. Sachdeva told media persons that the play based on the life of Dr Mookerjee will be performed at Kamani Auditorium, as part of the continuing celebrations of Mookerjee's birth anniversary. He said the play will be performed in the presence of the BJP National president JP Nadda. Sachdeva said that the performance, to be held at 4 p.m. on Tuesday, will showcase various aspects of Dr Mookerjee's life — his nature in childhood, his journey from college days to becoming a young Vice-Chancellor, his entry into politics, his resignation from Nehru's cabinet for the sake of national unity, and his journey to Jammu and Kashmir and meeting with Sheikh Abdullah. 'All these themes have been depicted in the play. The performers are from the National School of Drama,' he said. He said that Dr Mookerjee's sole objective was to move forward with the idea of 'Nation First', and today, the seed he planted has grown into a banyan tree in the form of the Bharatiya Janata Party — the world's largest political party. Delhi BJP Media Head Praveen Shankar Kapoor said that the BJP was in politics not just for politics but for principles, and this theatrical performance on the life of Dr Mookerjee served as a medium to present those very principles. Delhi BJP Morcha in-charge Sumit Bhasin and spokesperson Nitin Tyagi were also present at the conference. On Dr Mookerjee's 125th birth anniversary on Sunday, Nadda digitally inaugurated six district offices of Delhi and Haryana. Stating that Dr Mookerjee's birth anniversary carried both moral responsibility and emotional significance for the BJP, Nadda said that he was a man of multifaceted talent. He became a professor at Kolkata University at the age of 33 and entered the legislative Assembly by the age of 36. Nadda emphasised that Dr Mookerjee never clung to positions of power but remained unwavering in his commitment to ideology, even sacrificing his life for it. He never compromised on his beliefs, and India will always remain indebted to him, especially for his role in ensuring that West Bengal remained a part of the country. Nadda recalled that the seeds of Indian politics' divisive appeasement were sown soon after Independence, and Dr Mookerjee resigned from the Nehru cabinet in protest, laying the foundation of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh, which evolved into today's Bharatiya Janata Party.

Turkey's deepening role in Bangladesh adds a new layer to India's security calculus
Turkey's deepening role in Bangladesh adds a new layer to India's security calculus

Time of India

time10 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Turkey's deepening role in Bangladesh adds a new layer to India's security calculus

Turkey's entry point into India's backyard Live Events India raises alarm over Turkish links to Islamist groups Ankara's pan-Islamist narrative is India-focused Erdogan's divergence from NATO Turkey's quiet push into the Bay of Bengal Trade persists but under a cloud (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel As Turkey deepens itsTurkey South Asia strategy, India Turkey rivalry India rare earth security , Ankara Islamist influence Bangladeshmilitary, ideological and economic footprint in South Asia, particularly in Bangladesh, it is opening a new and under-reported front in its long-simmering rivalry with not a direct military adversary, Ankara's convergence with Pakistan and increasing engagement in India's eastern neighbourhood is beginning to look like a coherent anti-India strategy, built on shared ideological sympathies, defence cooperation and soft-power the centre of India's concern is a subtle but strategic shift in Turkey's foreign policy posture under President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, one that now pairs military-industrial ambition with pan-Islamist ideology and is actively shaping alignments in South Defence Industry Agency chief Haluk Görgün is scheduled to visit Dhaka on July 8, according to The Economic Times.Görgün will meet the Chief Adviser of the interim government, Muhammad Yunus, and all three service chiefs of the Bangladeshi armed forces. The visit is intended to finalise plans for setting up two Turkish-backed defence industrial zones in Chittagong and Narayanganj, bringing Ankara closer to India's eastern flank than ever groundwork for this collaboration has already been per ET, Bangladesh Investment Development Authority (BIDA) chief Chowdhury Ashik Mahmud Bin Harun visited Turkey earlier this year, followed by Foreign Affairs Adviser Md Touhid Hossain's trip to the Antalya Diplomacy Forum in April, where he described aerospace cooperation with Turkey as a "win-win" Turkey has no historical stake in the Bay of Bengal region, this defence-industrial engagement marks its first substantive hard-power play in India's immediate makes Turkey's growing presence more alarming for India is its reported support for Islamist outfits in Bangladesh, particularly Jamaat-e-Islami. Indian intelligence agencies, as reported by Firstpost and News18, believe that Turkish entities, some with links to its intelligence apparatus, have funded the renovation of Jamaat offices in Dhaka and facilitated visits by Islamist leaders to Turkish arms activities go beyond soft diplomacy. Indian officials say Ankara's strategy is a fusion of ideological influence and covert defence networking, especially through intermediaries affiliated with banned or radicalised officials told News18 that such visits are designed not just for exposure, but potentially to facilitate procurement of Turkish defence tech, possibly including drones and surveillance convergence of ideology and capability has raised red flags in Indian intelligence circles, as per the core of the deepening India–Turkey estrangement lies President Recep Tayyip Erdogan's increasingly assertive pan-Islamist foreign policy, which has frequently taken aim at India, especially over the Kashmir per TOI, between 2019 and 2022, India–Turkey relations hit their lowest point, marked by an intense phase of diplomatic hostility and media warfare. The downturn was triggered by India's revocation of Jammu and Kashmir's special constitutional status, a move that drew sharp criticism from response, both countries engaged in sustained narrative offensives, with official statements and media outlets on each side amplifying opposing positions on Kashmir and regional has consistently aligned itself with Pakistan's position on Jammu and Kashmir, raising the matter at the United Nations and the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), and positioning itself as a rhetorical and ideological ally of Turkey's challenge is no longer limited to political to Hindustan Times, multiple drones used in cross-border attacks on Indian territory have been traced to Turkish origin, a development that has forced Indian defence planners to reassess Ankara's evolving role in the regional security signature drone exports, once celebrated as battlefield game-changers from Ukraine to Libya, suffered a dramatic setback during India's Operation Sindoor in May 2025. According to The Times of India, Indian air defences intercepted every Turkish-origin drone launched by Pakistan during the offensive. This included Bayraktar TB2s, Byker YIHA III kamikaze drones, and Songatri and eYatri its indigenously developed Akashteer air defence system, India neutralised 300–400 drones mid-air, many of them before they even breached Indian airspace.A Pakistani source told Reuters that these drones were intended to 'provide cover for manned aircraft and artillery strikes,' but the mission collapsed as India's layered defences, from legacy L70 guns to modern Akashteer radar and missile systems, activated with full efforts to export its drone diplomacy to South Asia, coupled with its ideological posturing, hihglight a hybrid threat: one that mixes religious soft power with technological hard power and increasingly positions Ankara as an active disruptor of India's regional security military adventurism and embrace of non-Western alliances are not only reshaping its relationship with India, but also with NATO. As The Diplomat reported, Ankara's 2019 decision to acquire Russia's S-400 missile system triggered its suspension from the US-led F-35 fighter jet deepened Turkey's strategic isolation from the West while nudging it closer to states like Pakistan and per Eurasian Times, India has used this window to build counterbalances. Following Turkey and Pakistan's open support for Azerbaijan in the Nagorno-Karabakh war, India supplied Armenia with Akash missile systems and ramped up defence ties with Iran, Greece, and Cyprus, states long at odds with another such instance, Prime Minister Narendra Modi's stop in Cyprus, the first by an Indian PM in over two decades, may appear routine en route to the G7 Summit, but it carries strategic weeks after heightened tensions with Pakistan, the visit subtly realigns India in the eastern Mediterranean and sends a clear message to Ankara over its growing closeness to divided since Turkey's 1974 military intervention, remains a geopolitical flashpoint. While the northern third is under Turkish control and claims independence as the TRNC, it is recognised only by Turkey. The Republic of Cyprus, a full EU member, governs the internationally recognised southern two-thirds of the per ET, India has long supported Cyprus's territorial integrity, placing it at odds with Ankara, especially as Turkey continues to back Pakistan on Kashmir. During India's Operation Sindoor, Turkey sided swiftly with contrast, Cyprus condemned the April 22 Pahalgam terror attack and offered to raise the issue of cross-border terrorism at the EU level, reinforcing its alignment with India on key security a development that caught India off guard, Hindustan Times reported sightings of Turkish drones, possibly Bayraktars, along the India–Bangladesh border near unconfirmed, Indian defence officials believe these overflights may have been part of reconnaissance or technology demonstrations to Bangladeshi fuel to the fire, Muhammad Yunus, Chief Adviser of Bangladesh's interim government, stirred a diplomatic storm during his four-day visit to Beijing by referring to the region as 'landlocked' and positioning Bangladesh as its 'only guardian of the ocean.''The seven states of India, the eastern part of India, are called the seven sisters... They have no way to reach out to the ocean. For Bangladesh, as the only guardian of the ocean in the region, this could be a huge opportunity and an extension of the Chinese economy,' Yunus said, implying that Bangladesh could serve as a strategic gateway for China into India's northeast.'From Bangladesh, you can go anywhere you want. The ocean is our backyard,' he sees this as part of a larger pattern of Turkey embedding itself into the China–Pakistan–Bangladesh framework, operating as a wildcard player that leverages soft power, drones, and ideological platforms to punch above its regional rising geopolitical tensions, India–Turkey trade has remained steady, though modest in scale. According to The Economic Times, India exported goods worth USD 5.2 billion to Turkey during April–February 2024–25, down from USD 6.65 billion in FY 2023– trade accounts for just 1.5% of India's total exports of USD 437 main exports to Turkey include mineral fuels and petroleum products (worth around USD 960 million), electrical machinery, auto parts, organic chemicals, pharmaceuticals, plastics, rubber, cotton, synthetic fibres, and iron and the import side, India imported goods worth USD 2.84 billion from Turkey during April–February 2024–25, a decline from USD 3.78 billion in FY 2023–24, and representing only 0.5% of India's total imports of USD 720 imports include marble (blocks and slabs), gold, fresh apples (valued at about USD 10 million), vegetables, lime, cement, chemicals, mineral oils (USD 1.81 billion), pearls, and iron and continues to maintain a trade surplus with people-to-people ties with Turkey remain active. More than 300,000 Indian tourists visited Turkey in 2023, and around 3,000 Indian nationals, including students, currently reside there as of 2024.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store