Trade bodies advocate restoration of final tax regime
They suggested tax rates of 1.5% for FY25, 1.75% for FY26 and 2% from FY27 onwards, adding that this approach would ensure the required increase in revenue without the need for complex tax filings or audits.
A high-level delegation comprising representatives from the Sialkot Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Pakistan Readymade Garments Manufacturers and Exporters Association and Pakistan Hosiery Manufacturers Association met with Special Assistant to Prime Minister (SAPM) on Industries and Production Haroon Akhtar Khan on Monday.
They discussed crucial matters including the final tax regime versus the normal tax regime, industrial policy and measures to improve the ease of doing business. A major worry was the emerging practice of tax officers, who were demanding an additional 0.5% advance tax from exporters to meet revenue targets. This raises the effective tax burden by 150%, a level that is utterly unsustainable for the value-added export sectors, especially those dominated by small and medium enterprises (SMEs), the representatives of trade bodies said.
The final tax regime was introduced in fiscal year 1991-92 with a 0.5% fixed tax on exports. It was a remarkable success as tax collection rose from Rs343 million in 1990-91 (pre-final tax regime) to Rs855 million in 1991-92, reflecting a staggering 149% growth.
They stressed that it not only boosted government revenue with minimal administrative cost but also paved the way for exponential growth in exports, particularly from regions like Sialkot, while significantly reducing corruption and discretionary interventions.
Over the decades, the final tax regime provided exporters with a simple, transparent and harassment-free taxation model, but the imposition of the normal tax regime increased the burden, they said. The new policy allows a 2% deduction at source on export proceeds (a 100% increase), an unprecedented move that undermines export viability.
They pointed out that there was 1% minimum tax and 1% advance tax (total 2%) at source, and 29% tax on companies and 45% on individuals/Association of Persons (AOPs) after assessment.
The trade representatives also raised the issue of 10% surcharge on income exceeding Rs10 million for AOPs/individuals and super tax of 1-10% for income exceeding Rs150 million.
They were of the view that the shift to the normal tax regime would have significant implications with the potential for unfair practices. The introduction of refunds and complex tax assessments may incentivise exporters to manipulate financial statements to maximise refunds.
The normal tax regime could also reduce the inflow of export proceeds as businesses may seek to avoid higher tax burdens by resorting to under-invoicing. Exporters may deliberately declare lower values for goods or services to reduce the taxable income, leading to minimum tax liabilities and parking of funds abroad.
Addressing the concerns, SAPM Haroon Akhtar assured the delegation that the government was fully aware of the challenges faced by the business community. "We are committed to taking all possible measures to resolve these issues," he stated.
He revealed that a proposal would be drawn up to include a comprehensive and standardised definition of SMEs in the new industrial policy.
"A stable and predictable policy framework is essential for attracting investment and ensuring sustainable industrial growth," the PM aide remarked.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
COAS Munir instructs FBR to have dialogue with businessmen over arrest powers, penalties: FPCCI
While focusing on the recently enacted expansions of the Federal Board of Revenue's (FBR) powers, Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) President Atif Ikram Sheikh with the trade and industry's delegation met Chief of Army Staff (COAS) Field Marshal Syed Asim Munir, NI (M). who assured them of his full support for the economic growth of the country, according to a FPCCI statement on Tuesday. The development comes days after Pakistan's two largest cities - Karachi and Lahore - faced partial and complete market closures over a strike call by traders against what they called 'anti-business' tax measures introduced in the Finance Act 2025. Karachi, Lahore hit by strike against 'anti-business' tax measures In the Finance Act, the government expanded the FBR powers with Sections 37A and 37B, which empower the tax authority officials with arbitrary arrests; Section 21(S), which imposes harsh penalties on cash transactions of Rs200,000 or more; mandatory digital invoicing under SRO 709; and the imposition of e-Bilty under Section 40(C). 'Mr Atif Ikram Sheikh maintained that the business community is immensely thankful to Field Marshal Asim Munir for immediately directing that the new provisions; particularly those added under Sections 37A and 37B of the Sales Tax Act 1990, pertaining to arrest and detention; be held in abeyance; and, for instructing the FBR to enter meaningful and solution-oriented dialogue with stakeholders and address their concerns,' the FPCCI statement read. The statement further said the delegation had presented a comprehensive overview of the challenges faced by the industrial sector – with particular emphasis on the recently enacted expansions of the FBR's powers. 'Additionally, the GHQ will support economic activities in the country through the platform of Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC); fostering an environment of collaboration and trust.' The business community's delegation also called for interest rates to be brought down in line with inflation to stimulate businesses and economic activities. It also highlighted the delay in notification of the Export Facilitation Scheme (EFS) amendments relating to exclusion of cotton and cotton yarn from the scheme; and, imposition of an 18% sales tax on their imports, according to FPCCI statement.
Business Recorder
14 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan's textile manufacturer approves revival strategy, eyes entry into IT sector
The Board of Directors of Bilal Fibres Limited, a textile manufacturer, has approved a business plan to launch an IT Division, anchored by a substantial Rs10 million investment. The listed company, which continues to face operational suspension, disclosed its revival strategy in a notice to the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) on Monday. The company shared that its IT Division would target small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in Pakistan and the Middle East, with potential for global expansion. The division would offer a broad suite of services, including website and e-commerce platform development, mobile app development and MVP builds, IT support services, SaaS and subscription-based platforms and custom enterprise software for SMEs. The company aims to 'deliver cost-effective, high-quality IT solutions, capitalising on Pakistan's skilled workforce and strategic industry partnerships' with organisations such as P@SHA and PITB. Sharing the financial projections, the company anticipates annual revenue ranging from Rs12 million to Rs70 million, with breakeven targeted within 18 months and strong profitability expected within two years. Earlier this month, Bilal Fibres informed that it is now actively engaging with stakeholders, technical experts, and consultants to finalise a comprehensive business plan for its proposed entry into IT, health tech, and Electric Vehicle (EV) sectors. 'During the quarter ended 30th June 2025, the company's operations remained suspended, and no business activities were undertaken. However, as a first step towards revival, the Board of Directors (BOD) have approved the proposal to establish IT/health tech/EV division as a potential secondary line of business,' the Lahore-based company said in its notice back then. Established in 1987, Bilal Fibres Limited engages in the manufacture and sale of yarn in Pakistan. It offers poly/cotton, poly/viscose, CVC, viscose, and cotton yarns for weaving or knitting applications. The company also exports its products to Europe, the Far East, and the Middle East.
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
Trade bodies advocate restoration of final tax regime
Trade bodies have expressed concern over the imposition of the normal tax regime under the Finance Act and proposed several measures to resolve their pressing problems. They have advocated that the final tax regime for the export sector should be reinstated and under this mechanism the tax rate can be increased gradually. They suggested tax rates of 1.5% for FY25, 1.75% for FY26 and 2% from FY27 onwards, adding that this approach would ensure the required increase in revenue without the need for complex tax filings or audits. A high-level delegation comprising representatives from the Sialkot Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Pakistan Readymade Garments Manufacturers and Exporters Association and Pakistan Hosiery Manufacturers Association met with Special Assistant to Prime Minister (SAPM) on Industries and Production Haroon Akhtar Khan on Monday. They discussed crucial matters including the final tax regime versus the normal tax regime, industrial policy and measures to improve the ease of doing business. A major worry was the emerging practice of tax officers, who were demanding an additional 0.5% advance tax from exporters to meet revenue targets. This raises the effective tax burden by 150%, a level that is utterly unsustainable for the value-added export sectors, especially those dominated by small and medium enterprises (SMEs), the representatives of trade bodies said. The final tax regime was introduced in fiscal year 1991-92 with a 0.5% fixed tax on exports. It was a remarkable success as tax collection rose from Rs343 million in 1990-91 (pre-final tax regime) to Rs855 million in 1991-92, reflecting a staggering 149% growth. They stressed that it not only boosted government revenue with minimal administrative cost but also paved the way for exponential growth in exports, particularly from regions like Sialkot, while significantly reducing corruption and discretionary interventions. Over the decades, the final tax regime provided exporters with a simple, transparent and harassment-free taxation model, but the imposition of the normal tax regime increased the burden, they said. The new policy allows a 2% deduction at source on export proceeds (a 100% increase), an unprecedented move that undermines export viability. They pointed out that there was 1% minimum tax and 1% advance tax (total 2%) at source, and 29% tax on companies and 45% on individuals/Association of Persons (AOPs) after assessment. The trade representatives also raised the issue of 10% surcharge on income exceeding Rs10 million for AOPs/individuals and super tax of 1-10% for income exceeding Rs150 million. They were of the view that the shift to the normal tax regime would have significant implications with the potential for unfair practices. The introduction of refunds and complex tax assessments may incentivise exporters to manipulate financial statements to maximise refunds. The normal tax regime could also reduce the inflow of export proceeds as businesses may seek to avoid higher tax burdens by resorting to under-invoicing. Exporters may deliberately declare lower values for goods or services to reduce the taxable income, leading to minimum tax liabilities and parking of funds abroad. Addressing the concerns, SAPM Haroon Akhtar assured the delegation that the government was fully aware of the challenges faced by the business community. "We are committed to taking all possible measures to resolve these issues," he stated. He revealed that a proposal would be drawn up to include a comprehensive and standardised definition of SMEs in the new industrial policy. "A stable and predictable policy framework is essential for attracting investment and ensuring sustainable industrial growth," the PM aide remarked.
