Why India needs a Genomic Protection Act now
The recent implosion of 23andMe, a once-celebrated pioneer of direct-to-consumer genetic testing, should not merely be viewed as a Silicon Valley story gone wrong. It is a powerful cautionary tale for India, which now stands on the threshold of a genomic revolution.As someone deeply involved in precision medicine and longevity care, it is time for India to go beyond fragmented data protection frameworks and enact a dedicated Genomic Protection Act, one that prioritises clinical oversight, ethical stewardship, and individual rights.advertisementIndia is a genetic mosaic. With more than 4,000 distinct ethno-linguistic communities, centuries of endogamy, and a vast reservoir of rare variants, our population represents both a treasure trove for research and a potential minefield for exploitation. The collapse of 23andMe was not simply about a business model failing. It was about trust being eroded.
It showed what happens when data privacy becomes an afterthought and genetic results are served without medical interpretation, leading not to empowerment, but anxiety. We must not repeat these mistakes.Genomic data is not like browsing history. It cannot be deleted or changed. It holds information not just about the individual, but about their children, communities, and future generations.Once it's leaked or misused, the consequences are irreversible. In India, where public awareness about data rights is still evolving and health literacy varies greatly, the risks of commodifying DNA are enormous.advertisementYes, the Digital Personal Data Protection Act is a step forward. But it lacks the nuance and granularity required to govern genomic data, which is fundamentally different from other forms of personal information.We urgently need legislation that defines who owns your genetic data, sets limits on how it can be shared, and ensures consent that is layered and ongoing, not broad and one-time.FOUR PILLARS OF A GENOMIC PROTECTION ACTClinician-Led Testing: Genomic insights must be contextualised within clinical frameworks. Raw data leads to confusion; interpreted data leads to care. Imagine a longevity screen that integrates a patient's APOE status with cholesterol levels, cognitive assessments, and family history—offering a prevention roadmap, not just a risk percentage. That's precision medicine.Ethical Data Stewardship: Any storage, transfer, or analysis of genomic data should be governed by ethical boards and protected under encrypted, India-based servers. Data sanctity must not be compromised for commercial gains.Granular Consent and Opt-Out Rights: Individuals should be able to choose what portions of their data are used, for how long, and by whom. Consent should be revocable. An individual must have the right to know who accessed their genome and for what purpose.Population-Scale Governance: As India moves into population genomics and public-private collaborations, our policies must ensure that innovation does not outpace regulation. Genomic information must never become a tool for discrimination, be it in insurance, employment, or marriage.advertisementIndia has the opportunity to construct a gold-standard genomic ecosystem, one that learns from global missteps and roots itself in trust, transparency, and scientific integrity. The collapse of 23andMe is not the end of consumer genomics. It is a wake-up call. We must lead with care, not just curiosity.It's not a question of whether India will embrace genomics. The question is whether we will do it responsibly. A Genomic Protection Act is no longer optional. It is essential, for science, for ethics, and for the future of every Indian genome.(Disclaimer: This is an authored article. The views and opinions expressed by the doctors are their independent professional judgement, and we do not take any responsibility for the accuracy of their views. This should not be considered as a substitute for physician's advice.)- Ends
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Duncan Hines parent Conagra Brands says it will phase out artificial colors
HighlightsConagra Brands, the parent company of Duncan Hines and Slim Jim, announced it will discontinue the use of artificial colors in its frozen foods by the end of this year and across its entire portfolio by the end of 2027. The company will not offer products containing artificial colors to K-12 schools starting from the 2026-2027 school year, aligning with similar commitments made by Kraft Heinz and General Mills. The federal government has increased scrutiny on artificial colors, with a recent ban on the dye Red 3 and plans to eliminate synthetic dyes by the end of 2026, relying on voluntary efforts from the food industry. Conagra Brands , the parent company of Duncan Hines , Slim Jim and other brands, is the latest big food company to say it's discontinuing the use of artificial dyes. In a statement released Wednesday - the same day as a similar statement from Nestle - Chicago-based Conagra said it will remove artificial colors from its frozen foods by the end of this year. Conagra's frozen brands include Marie Callender's, Healthy Choice and Birds Eye. Conagra said it won't offer products containing artificial colors to K-12 schools by the beginning of the 2026-2027 school year, and it will work to discontinue artificial dyes across its entire portfolio by the end of 2027. Kraft Heinz and General Mills made similar pledges earlier this month. The federal government has stepped up its scrutiny of artificial colors in recent months. In January, days before President Donald Trump took office, the U.S. regulators banned the dye called Red 3 from the nation's food supply, nearly 35 years after it was barred from cosmetics because of potential cancer risk. In April, Trump's Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and FDA Commissioner Marty Makary said the agency would take steps to eliminate synthetic dyes by the end of 2026, largely by relying on voluntary efforts from the food industry . Many of Conagra's products already make a point of using natural dyes . On a jar of Vlasic kosher pickle spears, Conagra notes that they're colored with turmeric, not the synthetic Yellow 5. For the cheesy color in its frozen vegetable sides or its Orville Redenbacher popcorn, Conagra uses annatto, a plant extract. But some of Conagra's products still rely on synthetic colors. Duncan Hines' Comstock County Cherry pie filling uses Red 40, for example, while its Creamy Strawberries n' Cream Frosting uses both Red 40 and Yellow 5. Conagra's Swiss Miss Butterscotch pudding contains Yellow 6, Red 40 and Blue 1.
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
New AI tool to revolutionise personalised cancer treatment
New Delhi: An international team of scientists has developed an artificial intelligence (AI) tool that could revolutionise cancer treatment by mapping cellular diversity within tumours. The innovation tackles tumour heterogeneity in oncology, where varied cell populations cause treatment resistance and recurrence, Xinhua news agency reported. The AAnet AI tool, developed by the Sydney-based Garvan Institute of Medical Research in collaboration with the Yale School of Medicine in the US, uses deep learning to study gene activity in single cancer cells. It finds five different cell types within tumours, each with its own behaviour and risk of spreading. This helps doctors understand cancer better than older methods, which treated all tumour cells the same, said the multinational research team. 'Heterogeneity is a problem because currently, we treat tumors as if they are made up of the same cell. This means we give one therapy that kills most cells in the tumor by targeting a particular mechanism. But not all cancer cells may share that mechanism,' said the study's co-senior author, Associate Professor Christine Chaffer from the Garvan Institute. As a result, some cancer cells survive, and the disease can return, Chaffer said. She added that AAnet provides a way to biologically characterise tumour diversity, enabling the design of combination therapies that target all cell groups at once. Associate Professor Smita Krishnaswamy of Yale University, a co-developer of the AI, indicated that this is the first method to distill cellular complexity into practical archetypes, potentially transforming precision oncology. The technology is ready for clinical use, with plans to combine AI analysis and traditional diagnostics to create treatments tailored to each tumour's cell type. Validated in breast cancer, it also shows promise for other cancers and autoimmune diseases, marking a shift toward personalised medicine, revealed the study published in the journal Cancer Discovery.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Neglected and forgotten: Psychiatric patients face systemic apathy in Hyderabad; implement Mental Health Act fully, say experts
A food poisoning incident at Institute of Mental Health, Erragadda, exposed the plight of psychiatric patients HYDERABAD: The food poisoning incident at the govt-run Institute of Mental Health (IMH), Erragadda, earlier this month highlighted the condition of psychiatric patients in the state. Although a state mental health authority (SMHA) has been established, mental health experts say that it is yet to completely implement the provisions of the Mental Health Act, 2017, across Telangana. The act was introduced to ensure that such individuals receive quality mental healthcare and are treated with dignity. You Can Also Check: Hyderabad AQI | Weather in Hyderabad | Bank Holidays in Hyderabad | Public Holidays in Hyderabad The state mental health authority's role includes creating awareness about mental health and illness to reduce the stigma associated with mental illness, as well as providing legal aid. M Srinivas, president of the Hyderabad-based Network of Persons with Disabled Organisation (NPdO), claimed the SMHA is only working towards the physical well-being of psychiatric patients, neglecting their societal reintegration. "Many patients have been abandoned by their families, and their rehabilitation is happening only for the namesake. As per the act, rehabilitation services should be closer to the patient's residence, but most are forced to travel to Hyderabad. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 'They Want This Joint Relief Gummy Gone—Here's Why Seniors Love It' Joint Fuel 360 Click Here Undo The properties of several of these patients are in dispute owing to their conditions, but legal services are not up to the mark. There is no standardisation as the act mandates. I doubt the authorities even know the exact number of psychiatric patients in the state," he explained. A junior doctor at the IMH, speaking on condition of anonymity, said, "Awareness programmes were supposed to make people aware of the symptoms so that they would recognise the problem first and then take steps for proper treatment. But that has hardly happened. District committees, which are required under the act, have not been formed." 'Infrastructure woes' While IMH serves as the nodal institution for mental healthcare policies and regulations in Telangana, services are also provided at community mental healthcare centres (CMHCs) and govt hospitals in the state. IMH currently houses nearly 200 patients in the three wards - discharge, non-discharge, and open - of whom around 100 are ready to be discharged. However, their families are reluctant to take them back owing to post-discharge chronic mental illness. Patients in all these wards were affected during the recent food poisoning incident that claimed the life of a destitute person and left 92 others ill. In a report on June 11, TOI pointed out how IMH is grappling with infrastructure woes and staff shortages, thereby impacting patient care. While estimates say there are around eight lakh Psychiatric patients in Telangana, there are only about 600 mental health professionals, which is insufficient to meet growing needs. Officials refute claims A 2023 report by the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Health and Family Welfare highlighted that Telangana has only 50 to 60 accredited clinical psychologists, out of the total 2,840 in India. A senior official at the IMH, however, refuted the claims. "The state mental health authority (SMHA) is functioning smoothly and is regularly taking care of patients' rehabilitation through services of an NGO. Furthermore, awareness activities and other provisions of the act will be implemented soon."
