
Jagdeep Dhankhar always defended farmers, was enthusiastic about judicial reforms
One of his first speeches as Vice-President on judicial accountability was made in December 2022 at the 8th Dr. L.M. Singhvi Memorial Lecture on 'Universal Adult Franchise: Translating India's Political Transformation Into A Social Transformation'. Citing a Supreme Court verdict that repealed the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC), Mr. Dhankhar, in the presence of then Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, said: 'Please find out a parallel in the world where a Constitutional provision can be undone. Our Indian Constitution provides in explicit terms Art 145 (3). Interpretation of the Constitution when a substantial question of law is involved can be done by the court. Nowhere does it say that a provision can be run down,' he said, adding, 'I am startled that after this verdict, there was no whispering in the Parliament. It was taken as such. This is too serious an issue'.
LIVE: Vice-President Dhankhar resigns
Later, when the Opposition criticised him for such a speech, Mr. Dhankhar said in Rajya Sabha that Parliament is eminently positioned to take affirmative steps to bring out congeniality amongst wings of governance. 'Delegitimising the Judiciary is beyond my contemplation. It is a pillar of democracy. I would urge and expect leaders across the political spectrum to bear in mind not to subject high Constitutional offices to partisan stances,' the Chairman of Rajya Sabha said.
Jagdeep Dhankhar resigns as Vice-President: why is it unprecedented?
On another occasion, he proposed a revisit to the K. Veeraswami Judgement — the 1991 Supreme Court judgement that dealt with the issue whether the Prevention of Corruption Act is applicable to higher court judges. Terming the 1991 judgement a 'judicial legerdemain', Mr. Dhankhar said the genesis of the problem of corruption in the judiciary is the K. Veeraswami case judgement. 'Time for us now to change. And I have full trust and confidence in the present Supreme Court, which is of eminent people, people of integrity. In a short time, the present Chief Justice has shown that things are soothing for people at large,' Mr. Dhankhar said, citing the example ofthe Supreme Court's actions on the issue of recovering cash from a Delhi High Court judge's official residence.
Mr. Dhankhar reminded the MPs that the Constitution has given privileges to MPs, but this privilege is not unqualified. 'This privilege comes with very heavy responsibility and that responsibility is that every word spoken in the parliament must be after due thought, after due consideration. It can't be based on unverified situations. House cannot be made a wrestling ground of free fall of information,' Mr. Dhankhar had said.
Warning against arrogance in public life
Very recently, addressing the inaugural programme for the eighth batch of participants of the Rajya Sabha Internship Programme (RSIP), Mr. Dhakhar warned against arrogance in public life. 'We must be resilient. We must believe in our point of view. But we must also have respect for the other point of view. If we believe in our point of view and think, 'I am the only one who is right, and everyone else is wrong' — that is not democracy. That is not our culture. That is ego. That is arrogance. We must control our ego. We must control our arrogance. We must try to understand why the other person holds a different point of view — that is our culture. What has India historically been known for? Discourse, dialogue, debate, deliberation. These days, we do not see all this happening in Parliament,' he said.
Championing farmers' rights
Since December 2024, he has made several speeches in defence of the rights of farmers. At a function in Mumbai, in the presence of Union Agriculture Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan, he urged the Centre to talk to farmers who were protesting at the borders of Punjab and Haryana. 'Agriculture Minister Sir, every moment is critical for you. I urge you, and as the person holding the second-highest constitutional position in India, I request you to please tell me, was any promise made to the farmer, and why has it not been fulfilled? What are we doing to fulfil the promise? There was an agitation last year, and there is one this year as well, and time is passing, but we are doing nothing,' he said.
Mr. Dhankhar had asked Mr. Chouhan to consider the dialogue with the farmers as a challenge, which should not be considered any less than the unity of India. 'We cannot fight with our own people; we cannot put them in this situation where they are left to fight on their own. We cannot hold the ideology that their struggle will be limited, and they will eventually tire out. We should not disturb the soul of India; we should not hurt its heart. Can we create a boundary between the farmer and the government? Those whom we need to embrace cannot be pushed away,' Mr. Dhankhar said.
On the demand for statutory Minimum Support Price (MSP), the Vice President said he fails to understand why a formula cannot be worked out in consultation with economists and think tanks that will reward the farmers. 'Whatever price we give to the farmer, the nation will benefit five times over; there is no doubt about it. I have heard people say inflation will rise. I will say one simple thing. Wheat makes bread, and the disparity is immense! Milk makes ice cream, and again, the disparity is immense. Who are those people who say that if we give our farmers a fair price for their produce, I do not understand why that would cause a disaster,' he said.
Sanatana debate
The Vice President had also joined the debate on Sanatana, which was started by DMK leader Udayanidhi Stalin. The Vice President said we are one of the oldest civilisations. 'Ironically and painfully, in this country, reference to sanatan, reference to Hindu, evokes baffling reaction beyond comprehension rather than understanding the depth of these words, their deep meaning, people tend to be in reaction mode, at a drop of a hat... Can ignorance be more in extremity? Can the enormity of their lapse be countenanced? These are souls that have misguided themselves, driven by a dangerous ecosystem that is a threat not only to the society but to themselves,' he said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Hindu
5 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Constitution under siege, BJP doing ideological coup to replace republic with theocratic state: Sonia
Congress Parliamentary Party chairperson Sonia Gandhi on Saturday (August 2, 2025) alleged that the Constitution is 'under siege' as the ruling BJP is using its power to dismantle the very framework it long opposed. She alleged that the BJP is seeking to bring an 'ideological coup' by replacing our democratic republic with a theocratic corporate state serving the powerful few. In her special message read out at the day-long national legal conclave on 'Constitutional Challenges - Perspectives and Pathways', Ms. Gandhi said the Congress would oppose every attempt to undermine the Constitution in Parliament, in courts and on the streets, asserting that it is not just a political but an ideological commitment to defend every Indian's dignity. 'Today, the Constitution is under siege. The BJP-RSS, which never fought for freedom or upheld equality, now uses its power to dismantle the very framework it long opposed,' she said. 'Their ideological forebears glorified Manusmriti, rejected the tricolour, and envisioned a Hindu rashtra, where democracy is hollow and discrimination is the law. In power, they've eroded institutions, criminalised dissent, targeted minorities and betrayed Dalits, Adivasis, OBCs and the working poor. 'Now they seek to erase socialism and secularism, pillars of Ambedkar's vision of equal citizenship. This is not reform, but an ideological coup replacing our democratic republic with a theocratic corporate state serving the powerful few,' the former Congress chief alleged. She stressed that India yearns for the inclusive, just and democratic nation envisaged by our freedom fighters and Constitution makers. 'That is what the Congress party stands and fights for. We will oppose every attempt to undermine the Constitution, in Parliament, in courts, and on the streets. This is not just political, it is our ideological commitment to defend every Indian's dignity. I commend Abhishek Manu Singhvi and his team for reigniting this vital conversation. Our mission is clear - to reclaim the republic and protect the rights of each and every person,' she said in her message. Ms. Gandhi said the Constitution is more than a legal charter and claimed that it is the moral foundation of our democracy, built on justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity. Noting that the Constitution was shaped through the sacrifices and vision of the Indian National Congress, she said even before independence, the Congress imagined a constitution, 'by Indians, for Indians'. From the Nehru Report in 1928 to the demand for a Constituent Assembly in 1934, Mahatma Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru laid the groundwork and B.R. Ambedkar, as chairman of the Drafting Committee, gave form to these ideals. 'He warned that without social and economic justice, political democracy would be just a top dressing,' she said. 'The Congress recognised this and acted on it, expanding rights, strengthening institutions, and upholding dignity and inclusion,' she said.
.jpg%3Fw%3D1200%26ar%3D40%253A21%26auto%3Dformat%252Ccompress%26ogImage%3Dtrue%26mode%3Dcrop%26enlarge%3Dtrue%26overlay%3Dfalse%26overlay_position%3Dbottom%26overlay_width%3D100&w=3840&q=100)

New Indian Express
5 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Constitution under siege, BJP doing ideological coup to replace republic with theocratic state: Sonia
NEW DELHI: Congress Parliamentary Party chairperson Sonia Gandhi on Saturday alleged that the Constitution is "under siege" as the ruling BJP is using its power to dismantle the very framework it long opposed. She alleged that the BJP is seeking to bring an "ideological coup" by replacing our democratic republic with a theocratic corporate state serving the powerful few. In her special message read out at the day-long national legal conclave on 'Constitutional Challenges - Perspectives and Pathways', Gandhi said the Congress would oppose every attempt to undermine the Constitution in Parliament, in courts and on the streets, asserting that it is not just a political but an ideological commitment to defend every Indian's dignity. "Today, the Constitution is under siege. The BJP-RSS, which never fought for freedom or upheld equality, now uses its power to dismantle the very framework it long opposed," she said. "Their ideological forebears glorified Manusmriti, rejected the tricolour, and envisioned a Hindu rashtra, where democracy is hollow and discrimination is the law. In power, they've eroded institutions, criminalised dissent, targeted minorities and betrayed Dalits, Adivasis, OBCs and the working poor." "Now they seek to erase socialism and secularism, pillars of Ambedkar's vision of equal citizenship. This is not reform, but an ideological coup replacing our democratic republic with a theocratic corporate state serving the powerful few," the former Congress chief alleged.


Economic Times
5 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Constitution under siege, BJP doing ideological coup to replace republic with theocratic state: Sonia Gandhi
PTI Congress MPs Sonia Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, Samajwadi Party (SP) MP Ram Gopal Yadav and other parliamentarians hold placards as they protest against the Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar, during the Monsoon session of Parliament, in New Delhi. Congress Parliamentary Party chairperson Sonia Gandhi on Saturday alleged that the Constitution is "under siege" as the ruling BJP is using its power to dismantle the very framework it long opposed. She alleged that the BJP is seeking to bring an "ideological coup" by replacing our democratic republic with a theocratic corporate state serving the powerful few. In her special message read out at the day-long national legal conclave on 'Constitutional Challenges - Perspectives and Pathways', Gandhi said the Congress would oppose every attempt to undermine the Constitution in Parliament, in courts and on the streets, asserting that it is not just a political but an ideological commitment to defend every Indian's dignity."Today, the Constitution is under siege. The BJP-RSS, which never fought for freedom or upheld equality, now uses its power to dismantle the very framework it long opposed," she said."Their ideological forebears glorified Manusmriti, rejected the tricolour, and envisioned a Hindu rashtra, where democracy is hollow and discrimination is the law. In power, they've eroded institutions, criminalised dissent, targeted minorities and betrayed Dalits, Adivasis, OBCs and the working poor. "Now they seek to erase socialism and secularism, pillars of Ambedkar's vision of equal citizenship. This is not reform, but an ideological coup replacing our democratic republic with a theocratic corporate state serving the powerful few," the former Congress chief stressed that India yearns for the inclusive, just and democratic nation envisaged by our freedom fighters and Constitution makers."That is what the Congress party stands and fights for. We will oppose every attempt to undermine the Constitution, in Parliament, in courts, and on the streets. This is not just political, it is our ideological commitment to defend every Indian's dignity. I commend Abhishek Manu Singhvi and his team for reigniting this vital conversation. Our mission is clear - to reclaim the republic and protect the rights of each and every person," she said in her said the Constitution is more than a legal charter and claimed that it is the moral foundation of our democracy, built on justice, liberty, equality, and that the Constitution was shaped through the sacrifices and vision of the Indian National Congress, she said even before independence, the Congress imagined a Constitution "by Indians, for Indians". From the Nehru Report in 1928 to the demand for a Constituent Assembly in 1934, Mahatma Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru laid the groundwork and B R Ambedkar, as chairman of the Drafting Committee, gave form to these ideals. She said he warned that without social and economic justice, political democracy would be just a top dressing. "The Congress recognised this and acted on it, expanding rights, strengthening institutions, and upholding dignity and inclusion," she said.