MP's 'we are Palestine Action' comment edited out of Hansard
The debate, which took place on June 2, saw Sultana speak against the proscription.
Video of the debate shows she said: 'We have to recognise that this will go down as a dark day in our country's history and one that will be remembered: people will ask, 'Which side were you on?' and I stand with the millions of people who oppose genocide, because I am one of them.
'I oppose the blood-soaked hands of this Government trying to silence us. So I say this loudly and proudly on Wednesday 2 July 2025: We are all Palestine Action.'
READ MORE: I'm an SNP MP. Here's why we abstained on proscribing Palestine Action
Hansard initially recorded that, before being cut off, Sultana had said: 'So I say this loudly and proudly on Wednesday 2 July 2025: We are all Palestine –'.
However, it has since been edited and now instead reports that Sultana said: 'So I say this loudly and proudly on Wednesday 2 July 2025 –".
After the group was proscribed, supporting or being a member of Palestine Action became punishable with up to 14 years in jail.
However, MP's statements in the Commons are protected by 'absolute privilege' – which ensures full legal immunity for comments made in Parliament. 'Qualified privilege' then allows fair and accurate media reports on Westminster proceedings based on those statements.
Screenshot of the official Hansard report, which has had Zarah Sultana's 'we are all Palestine Action' comment edited out (Image: UK Parliament) Responding to the edit on social media, Sultana said: 'Parliament and Hansard have removed 'We are all Palestine Action' from my speech on Wednesday 2 July 2025 – despite me saying it.
'This is a blatant attempt to censor me and rewrite the record. This is not how a democracy behaves.
'We will not be silenced.'
Sultana further shared a video of her speech from July 2, in which she can be clearly heard to say: 'So I say this loudly and proudly on Wednesday 2 July 2025: We are all Palestine Action.'
The UK Parliament has been asked why the change has been made, and whether it will correct Hansard to record what was actually said by the MP.
Police officers remove 83-year-old Reverend Sue Parfitt from a protest in support of Palestine Action (Image: PA) The proscription of Palestine Action led to 29 people being arrested on suspicion of terror offences in London last weekend, including an 83-year-old reverend.
Metropolitan Police circled around dozens of protesters standing quietly beneath a statue of Mahatma Gandhi, with placards that said: 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action'.
The move to ban the organisation was announced after two Voyager aircraft were damaged at RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire on June 20, an incident claimed by Palestine Action, which police said caused around £7 million of damage.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Macron presses for recognition of Palestine as ‘only path to peace'
Emmanuel Macron pressed for recognition of Palestinian statehood in an address to the UK's Parliament, saying it was the 'only path to peace'. The French president said a ceasefire was a matter of 'absolute urgency' and that a two-state solution would bring security to the region. He said: 'We are aware that a political way out is crucial, and I believe in the future of the two-state solution as a basis for regional security architecture which will enable Israel to live in peace and security alongside its neighbours. 'But I want to be clear, calling today for a ceasefire in Gaza without any condition, is just telling to the rest of the world that for us as Europeans, there is no double standard, and as we are attached to human lives, as we are attached to territorial integrity, we want the ceasefire, no discussion. 'And today, working together in order to recognise the state of Palestine and to initiate this political momentum is the only path to peace.' David Lammy had earlier refused to set a time frame for when the UK would recognise Palestinian statehood. The Foreign Secretary was asked at the Commons Foreign Affairs Committee when the timing would be right to recognise statehood. He said: 'I'm not going to set it to a set time frame, because I've explained that this is a moving, live situation. 'There are delicate ceasefire negotiations under way. I've explained the issues that sit within that, and whether we will get a… ceasefire. I'm hopeful that we will.' Mr Lammy said he was in talks with French and Saudi colleagues on recognition, but that he wanted to see change on the ground. He said that 'despite the recognition movement, actually what we've seen is further annexation on the West Bank' and 'it has not led to get us getting closer to a process, it's led to further annexation'. Mr Lammy said he 'would prefer it was part of the process' and that he believed 'our French colleagues are also waiting to see if there is, in fact, a ceasefire in the next few days' to kickstart a process and that the UK Government remained 'completely committed' to recognition.
Telegraph
25 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Macron: UK and France risk growing apart
Emmanuel Macron has warned there is a risk of French and British societies 'growing apart'. In an address to members from both houses of Parliament during his state visit, the French president voiced concerns that the English Channel could 'grow wider' after Brexit. Mr Macron argued for new exchange programs for students, researchers and artists, saying: 'Let's allow our children to have the same opportunities as the one we had.' That section of the speech, which was listened to by hundreds of MPs and peers, received one of the largest rounds of applause of his 30-minute address. The intervention puts pressure on Sir Keir, who was watching from the front row of the audience, to sign off details for a new youth free movement agreement with the European Union. The Prime Minister agreed to one in principle in his 'reset' summit with the EU in May after strong lobbying from European capitals but has not agreed on the timings or numbers. Elsewhere in the speech, Mr Macron took a swipe at Brexit, calling it 'deeply regrettable', and urged the UK not to diverge from the bloc's rules and regulations. He issued a plea for the UK and France to join forces to cut the 'dependence' on America – which is waging a trade war under Donald Trump – and China. Mr Macron also confirmed that the Bayeux Tapestry will return to England for the first time in 900 years. The treasures of Sutton Hoo will in turn be displayed in France. The address to Parliament came on day one of his three-day UK state visit – the first by a French president since the British public voted to leave the EU in June 2016. Mr Macron said: 'As Channel Tunnel is celebrating its 30th anniversary this year, let's make a wish here today. Let's not allow the Channel to grow wider. 'Although there are 300,000 French people living in the United Kingdom and 150,000 British people living in France, there has been a decrease in movement in recent years when it comes to school, university, professional and researcher exchanges. 'And today there is a risk that our societies are growing apart, that our young people do not know each other as well and may end up strangers at a time when international current events remind us on a daily basis of our common future. 'Let's face it, let's work together, in order to facilitate the exchange of students, researchers, intellectuals, artists. This is so important. Let's allow our children to have the same opportunities as the one we had.' Elsewhere in the speech, there were nods to Brexit, a decision that Mr Macron fiercely opposed and has since been involved in shaping via numerous signed agreements. The French President called Brexit 'a decision we respect, even if we found it deeply regrettable'. He also joked about how long post-Brexit negotiations had taken. At one point Mr Macron said that 'the point is not to diverge and to move forward side by side on these strategic choices we are facing'. The message is in stark contrast to Brexiteers who have long argued that the UK could prosper most by diverging from European rules and regulations. Sir Keir recently struck an agreement on agricultural products to copy EU requirements in return for lowering barriers to trade. Mr Macron notably welcomed the Prime Minister's re-engagement. There were also calls to action in the international arena. In recent weeks there have been tensions between London and Paris about exactly when and how to recognise Palestinian statehood, as revealed in The Telegraph this weekend. British ministers have been resisting Mr Macron's push to make the declaration that would drive forward a two-state solution, instead wishing to attach more conditions on Hamas in return for the move. Mr Macron used the speech to argue his case: 'Today, working together in order to recognise a state of Palestine and to initiate this political momentum is the only path to peace.' He also condemned what is happening in Gaza, as he said: 'A war without end and without a strategic objective poses a huge threat to the region and our collective security. Today, dehumanisation is occurring there that can never be justified.' There was a call for both nations to work together to counter not just the threats from China but the challenges from the US under Mr Trump's second presidency. Mr Macron said: 'If we still depend on both China and the US I think we have a clear view of our future and the future of our children. 'On one side, over-capacities and over-subsidies are a clear threat to fair trade and they are destabilising a lot of value chains and creating new dependencies. 'On the other side, the trade war is clearly an explicit decision not to be compliant any more with WTO and this due commerce we loved until now.' Mr Macron said 'we have no other choice' but for Europe to become more self-reliant, adding: 'We want an open world. We want to co-operate, but not to depend.' The French President also singled out the influences of algorithms made in America and China which are impacting the lives of children in Europe, including via social media addiction. He warned: 'What is at stake as well today in Europe is the defence of democratic models amid foreign interference, information manipulation, domination of minds by negative emotions and addictions to social media. These are the big other risks.' 'Finally, we meet again' The address was wrapped up with an emotional reference to the shared history between France and Britain from two world wars, via a nod to singer Vera Lynn. Mr Macron said: 'I came here today to renew the French people's message of friendship and fraternity. 'Yes, finally, we meet again. And let's be sure that we will meet again for years and decades. 'Because we are linked by our geography, by our past, but we are linked by our common future. And the only way to overcome the challenges we have, the challenges for our times, will be to go together, hand in hand, shoulder to shoulder. This is our common destiny. 'Long live our French-United Kingdom friendship. Long live the United Kingdom. Long live France.'
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
Can PM turn diplomatic work with Macron into concrete action on migration?
Emmanuel Macron addressing parliament in the Palace of Westminster's Royal Gallery was a highly anticipated moment in the long history of our two nations. That story - the conflict and a historic Anglo-French agreement that ended centuries of feuding, the Entente Cordiale - adorn the walls of this great hall. Looming over the hundreds of MPs and peers who had gathered in the heat to hear the French president speak, hang two monumental paintings depicting British victories in the Napoleonic wars, while the glass stand in the room commemorates the 408 Lords who lost their lives fighting for Europe in two world wars. The French president came to parliament as the first European leader to be honoured with a state visit since Brexit. It was the first address of a French president to parliament since 2008, and Mr Macron used it to mark what he called a new era in Anglo-Franco relations. 7:22 Peers and MPs cheered with delight when he confirmed France would loan the Bayeux Tapestry to the UK in the run-up to the anniversary of William the Conqueror's birthday. "I have to say, it took properly more years to deliver that project than all the Brexit texts," he joked as former prime minister Theresa May watched on from the front row From Brexit to migration, European security, to a two-state solution and the recognition of Palestine, Mr Macron did not shy away from thorny issues, as he turned the page on Brexit tensions woven through Anglo-French relations in recent years, in what one peer described to me as a "very political speech rather than just the usual warm words". He also used this address to praise Sir Keir Starmer, sitting in the audience, for his leadership on security and Ukraine, and his commitment to the international order and alliances forged from the ashes of the Second World War. For that, he received a loud ovation from the gathered parliamentarians. 3:28 The test now for Sir Keir is whether he can turn his deft diplomatic work in recent months with Mr Macron into concrete action to give him a much-needed win on the domestic front, particularly after his torrid week on welfare. The government hopes that France's aim for "cooperation and tangible results" at the upcoming political summit as part of this state visit, will give Starmer a much-needed boost. The PM is attempting to drive-down crossings by negotiating a one-in one-out return treaty with France. Under this plan, those crossing the Channel illegally will be sent back to France in exchange for Britain taking in an asylum seeker with a family connection in the UK. But as I understand it, the deal is still in the balance, with some EU countries unhappy about France and the UK agreeing on a bilateral deal.
