Ex-Labour minister says winter fuel U-turn smacks of incompetence
The former Pontypridd MP told BBC Radio Wales Breakfast: "The problem… is it smacks of incompetence. These U-turns don't look good, they never look good."This seemed to be kind of rudderless, floating around, not knowing which way to turn, and now they face this kind of humiliation, and really there was no need for it."It's true that people like me on a decent pension don't need it, but there are millions and millions who do need it."For a Labour government to be doing this just seems daft really."I'm afraid that this, along with a number of other decisions, has allowed people quite validly to level really very significant criticism at the government."
Howells had a series of ministerial jobs under Tony Blair, including in the Foreign Office, before he was reshuffled out by Gordon Brown in 2008. He left Parliament in 2010.In the radio interview Howells criticised the communication style of the prime minister."I don't understand anything Sir Keir Starmer says."It's this kind of London techno speak, which nobody understands."It's a mist instead of a clear policy, and that's what we need really. People need something to aim at, they need a hope, they need a future."
He said Welsh Labour would "undoubtedly" pay the price for the UK government's actions - but Howells also criticised the Welsh government's performance.The former minister said devolution was designed "to make Wales better, but our health service is even worse than in England"."Welcome to Wales means you get all those tunnels in Newport," he said, referring to the 2019 scrapping of plans for an M4 relief road by former Labour first minister Mark Drakeford."We have to do much more than we have done at the moment."Howells complained about what he saw as the "curse of the Welsh Assembly" in calling for subsidies, using the original name for the Cardiff Bay legislature which was changed to the Welsh Parliament in 2020."It's not been about encouraging entrepreneurships and getting people to start their own businesses. It's been constantly about the old politics of 'we haven't had our share, we must get our share'."Asked about the row over whether Wales would benefit from funding for the Oxford to Cambridge railway line, he said: "Sure, that public investment is very important."But I don't think that's going to sort out transport problems in Wales or the future of Wales."It needs this outfit in Cardiff, it needs Keir Starmer's government in London, to realise that the world is changing at a fantastic pace and we've got to change with it."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
33 minutes ago
- The Sun
Britain on verge of signing returns deal with Iraq to thwart small boats crisis
BRITAIN is on the verge of signing a returns deal with Iraq to thwart the small boats crisis. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper is understood to be in the final stages of negotiations to help break up people smuggling gangs. 1 Iraqi Kurds have been one of the biggest obstacles to tackling the problem which has seen numbers continuously ramp up since 2018. The proposed deal comes after Sir Keir Starmer struck a ' one in, one out ' deal with France last week to help reduce numbers. But more than 22,000 migrants have already made the perilous journey this year. The deal will help return the number of migrants making the C hannel crossings and failed asylum seekers back to Baghdad. It had been hoped that the deal could have been signed off this month but an Iraqi delegation has delayed their visit, the Sunday Times said. The agreement, expected to be finalised at the end of the summer, would allow UK authorities to detain and then send migrants back to Iraq more easily. The National Crime Agency has been drafted in to try and stop the bosses of the smuggling gangs from bringing migrants to Britain. Bosses from Britain's so-called FBI are understood to have established a presence with the Kurdish authorities. Boats and engines are also been closely monitored with sniffer dogs from the UK being deployed between Turkey and Bulgaria to find rubber dinghies being used in the crossings. Rob Jones, the NCA boss head of operations, said he was targeting areas where kingpins thought they were 'untouchable'. But Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp told Sky News that it was 'absolutely ludicrous' to think the deal with France would have any impact. He said: "This deal will only see about 6% of illegal immigrants who arrive in the UK getting returned to France, and the idea that therefore 94% can stay here is going to have any effect is absolutely ludicrous.' "Of course, if 94% of illegal immigrants who cross can stay in the UK, that is no deterrent whatsoever.' The Prime Minister will hold talks this week with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz as he called illegal migration "a global problem".
Metro
2 hours ago
- Metro
Three in five Brits 'wouldn't even trust Starmer or Farage to watch their bag'
The UK is 'shattered' into different ideological factions, a report has found, with each holding distinct ideas about what's wrong with the country and how to fix it. Politicians face a serious challenge winning back the trust of Brits too, with almost nine in ten having little or no faith in them, according to the findings. A major new poll at the centre of the report lays bare just how disillusioned we are with the current system, and the depth of pessimism over whether things will get better. Three in five Brits say they wouldn't trust Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Leader of the Opposition Kemi Badenoch or Reform leader Nigel Farage to even watch their bags – with similar levels of distrust for all three. And the one word used most to describe the state of the country is 'broken', followed by 'mess', 'struggling', 'divided' and 'expensive'. According to More in Common, the pollsters behind the 'Shattered Britain' report, most people in the UK can fit into one of seven segments that show their attitude to the nation's issues. Craig Munro breaks down Westminster chaos into easy to follow insight, walking you through what the latest policies mean to you. Sent every Wednesday. Sign up here. They are: Progressive Activists : Highly engaged in politics but feeling alienated, they are concerned with social justice and issues like climate change. Make up 12% of the population. : Highly engaged in politics but feeling alienated, they are concerned with social justice and issues like climate change. Make up of the population. Incrementalist Left : Generally left-of-centre but preferring gradual change over revolutionary reform, with high levels of trust in experts. Make up 21% of the population. : Generally left-of-centre but preferring gradual change over revolutionary reform, with high levels of trust in experts. Make up of the population. Established Liberals : Believe the system broadly works as it currently is and have faith in the UK's institutions to deliver continued progress. Make up 9% of the population. : Believe the system broadly works as it currently is and have faith in the UK's institutions to deliver continued progress. Make up of the population. Sceptical Scrollers : Seek alternative sources of truth online due to loss of faith in traditional institutions, and are drawn to conspiracies. Make up 10% of the population. : Seek alternative sources of truth online due to loss of faith in traditional institutions, and are drawn to conspiracies. Make up of the population. Rooted Patriots : Feel abandoned and overlooked by political elites, but not keen to overthrow the system as a whole. Concerned about community decline and migration. Make up 20% of the population. : Feel abandoned and overlooked by political elites, but not keen to overthrow the system as a whole. Concerned about community decline and migration. Make up of the population. Traditional Conservatives : Respectful of authority and nostalgic for the past, believe in established norms. Make up 8% of the population. : Respectful of authority and nostalgic for the past, believe in established norms. Make up of the population. Dissenting Disruptors: Drawn to dramatic change and strong leadership that will overthrow the status quo, feel disconnected from society and opposed to multiculturalism. Make up 20% of the population. The report was based on a survey of 20,000 and dozens of focus groups which took place across the UK. It found a lot of concern about money among the British public, too, with more than half saying they don't think the cost of living crisis will ever end and 43% citing money as their biggest source of stress. Meanwhile, a majority of Brits – 53% – said they thought those in their children's generation would have a worse life than those in their parents' generation. Two-thirds of people also said they're not sure politics will ever return to normal after saying it had become more chaotic over the past ten years. Dianne from Bridgwater, described as a 'Rooted Patriot' in the report, told the pollsters: 'I think our government's the worst ones actually. 'They don't respect the people that vote for them, and if they were to do that then it would be a lot better, but they don't. You try to get the best for everybody and the government just laugh at you.' Maddie, a 'Progressive Activist' from East Dulwich in London, said: 'You notice a difference, you notice everything going up, that transport and we're all sort of living on top of each other as well. 'And the rich are richer and the poor are poorer.' It's not all bad news, though – the survey found people are largely very positive about the area in which they live. While 'broken' was the most common word to describe the UK as a whole, people mostly said the place where they live is 'quiet', followed by 'nice', 'rural', 'safe' and 'peaceful'. And in stark contrast to their attitude towards politicians, a majority Brits from all seven of the 'segments' included in the report said they trusted their neighbours. Luke Tryl, Director of More in Common, said the research shows the country is 'exhausted, increasingly fragmented, and yearning for change – but deeply divided on what that change should look like'. He added: 'Britain has seen difficult times before, and the purpose of this research is to help leaders navigate these new fault lines to find a way out of the current era of malaise. 'If political leaders want to rebuild trust and build a broad coalition to fix a Britain that increasingly feels broken, they will have to navigate the new political map of Britain.' Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Until I had one, I was ignorant about the reality of miscarriages MORE: Map reveals Nato's maritime security challenges – from Russia to terrorism MORE: Delays and diplomacy: Inside Starmer's migrant deal announcement with Macron
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Wales' news Sustainable Farming Scheme absolutely right, minister says
A new flagship farming policy is "absolutely the right scheme", according to Wales' agriculture ahead of its launch, Huw Irranca-Davies said he was "hopeful it will land to a good reception", even though he conceded "there will be the odd person" who wished it had been done second iteration of the Sustainable Farming Scheme (SFS) and the rate of payment farmers can expect for joining it is due to be announced next week, after unions and farmers rejected the original scheme, staging plans included a requirement for farmers to plant trees on 10% of their land to qualify for subsidies, but they claimed that could lead to huge job cuts. Farming union NFU Cymru want "at least the same level of stability to farm business, rural communities and supply chains" as the current scheme, known as the Basic Payment Welsh government has been holding roundtable discussions with farming leaders, as well as environmental and nature campaigners, to revise the plan which it hopes will make farming businesses sustainable and help to reach its 2030 climate and nature targets. Irranca-Davies, Wales' deputy first minister and secretary for rural affairs and the environment, said the final scheme was "the result of more than 12 months of intense work" involving farming unions, meat, livestock and dairy sectors as well as environmental groups "to get the balance".Although he would not give any detail about the scheme, he told BBC Politics Wales it was "going to be unlike anything else that's been delivered in the UK"."It'll be a whole farm approach and a whole nation approach that delivers for the people of Wales," he said."They want to see farming that produces good food to high animal welfare standards and also does the right thing for the environment."The minister would not commit to publishing an impact assessment of the final iteration as he said work was assessment of the first iteration of the scheme predicted 5,500 jobs would be lost and livestock numbers would be the government is also under pressure from environmentalists to ensure that the plan is 80% of Wales' landscape is under the care of farmers, it is also argued they have a key role to play in helping the effort to tackle climate change and the losses in nature. NFU Cymru president Aled Jones said it was "imperative that the revised scheme and budget attached to the SFS avoids such a shocking impact on one of Wales' iconic sectors". "The SFS must work for all farming sectors and areas of Wales and help ensure that Welsh farming can continue to underpin the £9.3bn food and farming supply chain," he about the impact assessment, Irranca-Davies said his "feeling was that it'll be better" for both "viable farm businesses and environmental benefits as well".Again refusing to pre-empt the announcement, he said there would be mitigations in order to ensure those in agriculture would not be left behind as Wales moves towards a greener economy with "real subtleties" within the scheme that would be Cymru's Delyth Jewell MS said: "I think there has been frustrations for a long time that lots of people in the farming community feel they haven't been heard. "We have to make sure - these are people who sustain our lives - we need to make sure their lives are made sustainable too."Conservative Senedd leader Darren Millar MS said he wanted to see the policy voted on by politicians to ensure "democratic legitimacy" for the plan."We've got to make sure that the new scheme has food security at its heart, and that it will actually deliver the sustainable future for our farmers that they need," he said.
