‘How dare you': Former minister Alan Shatter criticised in committee on Israeli settlements bill
Former justice minister Alan Shatter has been criticised for comparing a ban on trade with Israeli settlements to TV sitcom Father Ted, with one TD asking 'how dare you' use that description.
Ex-Fine Gael TD Mr Shatter opposes the Irish Government's draft law banning trade with Israeli settlements on Palestinian lands that have been deemed illegal by the UN's top court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
25 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Tánaiste holds talks over Lebanon peacekeeping renewal
Tánaiste Simon Harris has held talks with UN and EU counterparts about the vital need to renew the mandate of the UN peacekeeping force in southern Lebanon. Next month at the UN headquarters in New York, the mandate of the UN Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL) will be up for discussion at the Security Council. There is concern that the 12-month roll-over of the UNIFIL mandate could be in jeopardy given strong criticism of the blue helmet operation by Israel and the fact that its ally, the United States, could pull support from the mission. The Tánaiste spoke with his counterparts in Italy and Lebanon, as well as the UN peacekeeping chief Jean-Pierre LaCroix. The discussion with Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani is particularly important given the recent appointment of an Italian Major General as the UNIFIL Force Commander. Later Mr Harris will hold further talks, including with the French foreign minister whose country is leading the bid to ensure the UNIFIL mandate continues. Earlier this week, Poland gave its full backing to the renewal of the UNIFIL mission - a country that works hand-in-hand with Irish peacekeepers in southern Lebanon. The Tánaiste also told Cabinet on Tuesday that the UNIFIL mission is vital for the morale of Irish troops, and most importantly, Ireland's unwavering commitment to international peace and security. In his call with Lebanese foreign minister, Mr Harris also raised the case of Private Seán Rooney, who was killed while out on patrol in southern Lebanon in December 2022. The Irish Government has expressed concern at the length of time it is taking for a trial to proceed and continues to liaise with the late Private Rooney's family.
Irish Examiner
25 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Amnesty International chief slams 'fearmongering' after Ibec comments on Occupied Territories Bill
There has been 'fearmongering' in attempts by some bodies to 'derail' the introduction of the Occupied Territories Bill, the head of Amnesty International has said. The organisation's secretary general, Agnès Callamard, has praised the Irish Government for its plans to ban trade with Israeli settlements in the occupied Palestinian territories. Ms Callamard said the EU has 'betrayed its principles through its shameful decision not to suspend the EU-Israel Association Agreement'. 'The EU's refusal to take action to hold Israel accountable highlights the need for Ireland and other likeminded member states to urgently take unilateral or concerted steps to bring their actions in line with international law, which takes precedence over both EU and national law,' Ms Callamard said. 'Despite the fearmongering and efforts by certain parties to derail the bill, Ireland must stay firm in its convictions and commitment to justice." It comes after comments from the director general of Ibec, Danny McCoy, criticising the Government for introducing the bill, warning it is damaging Irish interests in countries like the US. 'We're not talking about millions here,' Mr McCoy said. 'This is not about actually helping in any material way. It's symbolism and moral positioning, and so on. However, with moral positions, you can also reveal hypocrisy.' Ms Callamard said passing the legislation would 'set a strong example' to other EU countries to unilaterally suspend co-operation with Israel. Ms Callamard said: It cannot be 'business as usual' while Palestinians are starved and slaughtered while seeking aid or under relentless Israeli attacks in Gaza, or killed and forcibly displaced by state-backed Israeli settler violence, devastating military operations and suffocating movement restrictions in the West Bank. 'From its own experiences of colonization, famine and conflict to its leading role in international efforts to end apartheid in South Africa, Ireland has repeatedly shown that it can stand up to bullies and consistently punched above its weight in global diplomacy.' The Oireachtas Justice Committee is currently undertaking pre-legislative scrutiny of the Occupied Territories Bill, with witnesses appearing in recent weeks to discuss the proposed laws. There has been some criticism of the legislation for not going far enough, as it only deals with trade and not services. Read More
Irish Daily Mirror
25 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Taoiseach says Ireland will not be punished by US over Occupied Territories Bill
Taoiseach Michéal Martin has rejected claims that Ireland will be punished by the US over the Occupied Territories bill and said the country will not 'suffer unduly'. After US President Donald Trump threatened 30% tariffs on imports from the EU earlier this week, US politicians have suggested that the bill will not bode well for Ireland. US Republican Senator Lindsey Graham said the bill - which will prohibit trade between the State and Israel's illegal settlements- would not be received well in the US and it 'would not go unnoticed'. Speaking in Cork on Friday, the Taoiseach refuted claims that the bill will harm Ireland economically. He said: 'There are efforts abroad to undermine the integrity of Ireland's position, to misrepresent Ireland's position. We are conscious of that. We will always work to protect our economic interests and the national interest 'We don't want in any way to undermine Ireland. The purpose of the exercise is not that Ireland would suffer unduly in respect of this.' The Taoiseach added that the bill 'has not been mooted' and there is a broader negotiation ongoing between the EU and US on tariffs. He added: "Those negotiations are tough and as you know we have until August 1 to resolve it. That is the context on which tariffs will be discussed and now an individual member state basis." This comes as former minister for justice Alan Shatter heavily criticised the bill as it was given consideration at the Joint Committee on Foreign Affairs on Tuesday. As a member of the Ireland Israel Alliance, the former Fine Gael TD repeatedly referred to the bill as a 'Father Ted' measure. He also compared it to how the Jews were targeted during the Second World War. Responding to this, the Taoiseach said: 'What I would reject very strongly is any suggestion that there is any hint of antisemitism in terms of the Irish position. I think that was wrongly presented by former Minister (Alan) Shatter in his presentation to the Oireachtas committee. "I was dismayed at the language he used. It was false language and it was a very false presentation.' The Taoiseach said the focus needs to be on the thousands of people who have died in Gaza and the ongoing loss. He continued: 'The Irish people are appalled by what is happening in Gaza and indeed across the West Bank. People I meet cannot understand the continued slaughter of children. "Only in the last 48 hours a church was attacked, a Catholic Church was attacked and innocent people were killed. The war needs to stop. Hostages need to be released and the political process and a massive surge in humanitarian aid needs to be facilitated.' Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
